10 Video Games That Punish You For Caring

Keep your heart strings taut, lest they be torn out for caring too much about these games.

Metal Gear Solid V
Konami

It's an understatement to call gamers "passionate" about their pass-time of choice. Unfortunately, that passion can range widely on a spectrum that goes from just a strong emotional investment in a story and its characters all the way to sending developers death threats because they changed Peter Parker's face.

But the majority of us fall somewhere in between. We form attachments with our favorite games because those games feel like being invited into another world. And when you spend enough time there, having your expectations subverted carries a lot of weight. Sometimes it's because of something you do and sometimes it's because of something the developers or publishers do to you, especially in a medium as expensive as the game industry, where business decisions will almost always outweigh creative ones.

Whether it's by your own agency as a player, choices made by the developers, or just misplaced hopes, some form of disappointment is inevitable. But there aren't many games that can escalate that disappointment to full-blown heartbreak and betrayal.

The best fiction draws you in so deeply and thoroughly that you care about its world and characters. However, there's also a lot to be said for not caring TOO much and managing your expectations. With that said, here are ten games where you did care too much - and were punished for it, you nostalgic sap.

10. The Witcher III

the witcher 3
CD Projekt RED

CD Project Red's games based on the popular Witcher franchise were notable for making player choice a matter of actions and consequences, rather than good or evil. And that's exactly why it's best to go into any situation in this series with no expectations because chances are, whatever you do will blow up in your face one way or another.

Choosing the seemingly good or compassionate choice in The Witcher rarely works out the way you want it to. Cure a severely wounded woman with one of your potions, she becomes catatonic due to its toxicity; save a deserting soldier from a lynch mob, he forms a group of bandits who rob refugees; show mercy to a spirit and return her bones to her lover for a proper burial, she kills him and goes on to terrorize the region. And the severity of ways your ward, Ciri, can be screwed over as a result of your best nature is staggering.

At times the game can be a little too edgy in how many choices result in tragedy no matter what you do, but you'll often find that cold, sometimes cruel logic will yield better results than a bleeding heart.


9. DmC: Devil May Cry

DmC: Devil May Cry
Capcom

When Capcom decided to reboot their beloved Devil May Cry series, they also chose to hand the reigns over to western developer Ninja Theory. It seemed like a good move at the time, as Ninja Theory had brought us well-received action games like Heavenly Sword and beloved cult classics like Enslaved: Odyssey To The West. There was no reason to think they wouldn't knock it out of the park - but, depending on whom you ask, they did. Still, while DmC was a very well crafted action game, it was also something of a middle finger (pictured) to series devotees.

Dante was an established and popular protagonist after four games, with his bleach-white mop of hair, red coat, and signature weapons. He was heavily inspired by anime - the aloof, silver-haired badass with a big sword - a style Capcom is famous for.

However, Ninja Theory made it a mission to "subvert" this overall tone. Dante now looked like Morrissey and provoked fans by briefly donning a white wig before mocking his appearance and casting it off.

From there onward the story gradually became a satire of American politics and media, turning DmC's major lore into more of an undercurrent supporting the game's messaging, souring many established fans and newcomers alike.


8. The Last Of Us Part II

The Last Of Us Part II Abby
Sony Interactive Entertainment

The Last Of Us: Part II is either one of the best games ever made or one of the worst games ever made, depending on how you took its heart-stomping first act twist. After spending the entirety of the first game developing a relationship with protagonists Joel and Ellie, and becoming so emotionally invested in their relationship to each other, killing off Joel in the most brutal, agonizing, graphic way possible left pretty much everyone in a state of shock.

What differs for a lot of players is how they felt after the shock wore off. Many appreciated the significance of Joel receiving his karmic punishment for the choice he made at the end of Part I to save Ellie from her unwitting sacrifice to save the human race. Others, like Joel himself, were too angry to let go of the loss, and carried that bitterness throughout the entirety of the experience.

And just to kick you when you were down, they made Joel's killer the secondary protagonist, challenging you to empathize with the character you hate more than anyone. But regardless of what side you fell on, there's no denying that everyone paid the price for caring so much about Joel and Ellie.


7. Rage 2

Rage 2 Rocket
Bethesda

Id Software's original Rage wasn't anything to write home about. Its graphics were spectacular for the time, but other than that it was a generic shooter that ended abruptly with zero resolution to an admittedly forgettable story. So who is Rage 2 punishing if not those who played the original?

Everyone who played and loved the criminally underrated Mad Max game.

Both developed by Avalanche Studios, 2015's Mad Max was a surprising cult hit. Despite some derivative mechanics, it blended a fast and weighty driving with brutal, improvised combat and survival elements in an open world that felt like a Mad Max-themed amusement park.

Unfortunately it bombed and Avalanche was put in charge of making Rage 2, a sequel nobody asked for. What's frustrating is that Rage 2 feels so close to the Mad Max 2 that could have been. Driving still feels fun and satisfying and the gunplay is extremely well-made - but gets old very fast in a huge open-world game.

But it looks so much like Mad Max, and at times, plays so much like Mad Max that it's impossible not to be distracted and deflated by thoughts of what could have been.


6. Chrono Cross

Chrono Cross
Square Enix

Square Enix's Chrono Cross is a fantastic game featuring a unique battle system, a complex story, and one of the best damn soundtracks of all time. Unfortunately, it's also a sequel to one of the SNES's most beloved games - Chrono Trigger.

The world and characters of Chrono Trigger made an indelible impact on young gamers, so when the sequel featured an entirely new cast - with seemingly no direct connection to the original game - things were off to a bad start.

Worse, however, was the reveal that those connections actually did exist - insofar as those iconic characters mostly having met tragic, mundane ends. Except one: Schala - a major character whose actions directly contributed to setting the entire saga in motion. At the end of Trigger she's lost in time and team badass Magus - her brother - leaves to find her.

So... where is he? Magus was meant to appear in Cross, but was cut in favor of the game's other party members, many of whom are insignificant to the story. Most would argue that it's impossible to continue Schala's story without Magus - and they'd be right. His absence undercuts the entire idea of a Chrono Trigger sequel.


5. Mass Effect 3

Mass Effect 3 Javik
Bioware

To be honest, there is no world where Mass Effect 3 doesn't end up being some degree of disappointing. BioWare set an extraordinarily high bar with Mass Effect 2 and the promise of all of your choices culminating in any number of ways for the final game was simply an unrealistic goal for the time. But the forgettable cast deflates the entire journey, not just the ending.

ME2's cast is one of the best in RPG history. There aren't many games with more iconic characters in one neat package. And the idea of the game's final "suicide mission" potentially killing any or all of them drove the emotional stakes through the roof.

It also made it really hard, if not impossible, to include them all as potential crew mates in ME3 - there are just too many variables. But those connections were so strong that a new cast felt like an attempt to replace the friends you lived and died for previously.

However, between the bland muscle-head, the sexy robot who looks like she came from another game, and one of two of the first game's least popular characters, it's hard to imagine a bigger swing and miss.


4. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Metal Gear Solid V The Phantom Pain
Konami

In most senses, Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is an amazing game - perhaps the best stealth/action game of all time. From the large, well-crafted maps offering tons of creative freedom for the player to complete objectives to stealing equipment and personnel with the silly but satisfying fulton recovery system - and that killer soundtrack.

However, one thing Hideo Kojima's swan song for former employer Konami notably lacks is its central protagonist, Snake/Big Boss.

By casting Kiefer Sutherland in place of series mainstay David Hayter, Kojima blew up the game's already overinflated budget by god knows how much. As a result, the likely expensive Sutherland is used excruciatingly sparingly, resulting in a usually verbose character being closer to a silent protagonist.

Even worse is that this is, technically, justified in the story, as it's revealed at the end that all along you've been playing as a Big Boss decoy, retroactively justifying the character's contrasting personalities in his early and later appearances.

All of this is driven home by the fact that this version of Snake is also known as Punished Snake. So Kojima put it right in front of our faces the entire game. That's some top tier trolling. Hats off, sir.


3. Assassin's Creed III

Assassins Creed Iii 3
Ubisoft

After building up the modern day story of Desmond, explored through the genetic memories of his ancestors, designer Patrice Desilets unceremoniously departed developer Ubisoft for unclear reasons. This left them in the position of having to finish a story that was only 2/3 of the way done, without its author.

Over multiple games we saw many questions raised: Desmond's destiny, scheming god Minerva, closest ally Lucy's betrayal... and what about the whole thing with Adam and Eve we glimpsed in ACII? Never answered.

Without Disilets, Ubisoft seemed uninterested in tying any of these threads together. Instead we got a very cliche story about Desmond sacrificing himself to prevent a solar flare from destroying the world - an Assassin Messiah whose growth and importance to the overarching plot of the ancients is simply dropped along with his body.

And the so-called "Apple" artefact at the center of the story was quickly reduced to one of many similar magical artefacts - probably the worst one, thanks to power creep that has grown over so many games.

The ending of AC: Valhalla finally gets back to this story, albeit in a convoluted way. Hopefully they stick with it this time.


2. The Banner Saga III

Banner Saga
Stoic

Stoic's The Banner Saga really puts you through the wringer over the course of its three entires. But it isn't until the third game that you truly feel the weight of the difficult choices you've made thus far.

The biggest punch to the gut is the slow realization there will be no "good" ending or "bad" ending - no reward. Many will be sacrificed and the world will never be the same. You'll have to find a way to carry the weight of your actions.

The games have a robust and well-written cast of companions. Having already lost many along the way, the desperation to keep the ones who remain alive at the end is a stress felt throughout the game. And with a city besieged, food scarce, and a journey into an apocalyptic wasteland while being hounded by one of your former allies gone mad, every choice you make carries the weight of finality.

No other game makes you want to reload old saves to make new choices as badly as the Banner Saga. Unfortunately, that would require you to start the trilogy over again from scratch, as the butterfly effect of your choices carry through the entire series.


1. Frostpunk

frostpunk game
11 Bit Studios

In the new ice age of 11 Bit Studios' Frostpunk, suffering, hunger, and illness are the new baseline for living. Your one and only goal is survival - at any cost. Caring about your citizens will likely just get everyone killed.

One of the most brutal and unforgiving survival games ever made, Frostpunk is nothing but a constant stream of bitterly tough decisions. Trying to save everyone is impossible. Before you know it, one compassionate act can snowball into a series of catastrophic failures - keeping everyone warm drains your power and fuel faster than it can be replaced; keeping everyone well-fed will deplete your food stores and result in starvation; providing children with an education will halve your potential workforce; compensating the crippled and sick will engender violent envy in your workforce.

To simply keep your restless populace working as a well-oiled machine is to ensure mankind's survival at their own expense, rallying them under oppressive fascism or theocracy - essentially gaslighting, coercing, or forcing them into working to death for an ideal.

If you aren't prepared to bear the guilt of sacrificing men, women, and even children for the greater good - you aren't ready to play Frostpunk.


Watch Next


Contributor

At 34 years of age, I am both older and wiser than Splinter.