10 Video Games That Punished You For Saving

Save points don't always save you.

Alien Isolation
Sega

It's hard to believe there was a time when saving in a video game wasn't an option. When you ran out of lives, you had to start from scratch.

Nowadays, saving is part and parcel with almost any modern title. In recent years, you don't have to worry about manual saving, since auto-saves are the norm. The younger generation probably can't comprehend the dread that veteran gamers experienced, running around to find a save point to avoid losing hours of progress.

We may have widely different opinions on what defines a good game, but you'd assume we could all agree save files are a universally positive feature.

And yet, saving can have its drawbacks. Certain games make it so inconvenient to find save points, you'll die long before reaching them. Other times, you have to pay a price to prevent your progress from being lost. If you save after running out of guns and ammo, you might have to start all over again. Even though save points should be a blessing, the games on this list made it feel more like a punishment.

10. Ni No Kuni: Wrath Of The White Witch

Ni No Kuni Drippy
Level 5

Ni No Kuni isn't one of those RPGs where you can take it easy once you reach a certain level. At any point in your playthrough, even the lowest enemies can take you out. If you're not monitoring your party's HP, you'll be looking at the Game Over screen before you know it.

When this occurs, you'd assume you have to restart from the last save point. But that's not always the case, since the game allows you to save at the exact moment you died, so you don't lose any progress.

But there's a cost. To utilise this feature, you have to fork over 10% of your coins. Now, 10% of anything doesn't sound like much. If that's the price to avoid losing an hour of progress, it seems reasonable.

But this "to save or not to save" dilemma is a problem, since equipment in Ni No Kuni is REALLY expensive. There are times where you have to grind for an hour and sell dozens of items just to afford one flippin' sword! If you're hoping to fill up your wallet, it might be better to restart from the last save point after you die, rather than accepting this costly compromise.


9. The Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask

legend of zelda majora's mask
Nintendo

In The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask, Link is tasked with saving Termina, which is destined to be destroyed by the moon within three days. Any time the moon is about to collide into the world, Link can play his Ocarina to reverse time, giving him an extra 72 hours to complete his mission. Because Link can perform this action indefinitely, he literally has all the time in the world.

Although Majora's Mask didn't match the success of its predecessor, it's now regarded as one of the most underrated titles in the series. But no matter how much you adore this entry, Majora's Mask suffers from a major problem: saving.

There are two methods to save: reverse time on the Ocarina or by speaking to the owl statues. But if you choose to save on an owl statue, you'll be forced to quit.

Um... why? Have you ever heard of a game that wouldn't let you save UNLESS you quit playing? Although you don't have to quit when you reverse time, you will lose all your items and money in the process. Whatever method you use to save, you get screwed over.


8. Metroid Prime 2: Echoes

Metroid Prime 2
Nintendo

We're all familiar with no-win scenarios. In chess, it's called zugzwang. In Star Trek, it's known as the Kobayashi Maru simulation. And in the world of gaming, it's referred to as softlocking. If you save in a game after skipping required actions or items, you might find yourself trapped in an area, without the means to escape.

Although this issue has occurred in many games, one of the worst offenders is the GameCube title, Metroid Prime 2: Echoes. After finding the Echo Visor in Sanctuary Fortress, you'll gain the ability to detect sonic devices. After you blast the three sonic interfaces nearby, the central door will deactivate, allowing you to leave.

At least, that's the idea. If you blast one or two of the sonic locks, leave the room to save, and then return, the remaining lock(s) will not appear, meaning the exit door will stay shut. Although you can perform the Kip Dash or the Roll Ball Jump to escape, these techniques are so hard to pull off, most players don't bother.

Thankfully, this glitch was remedied when Echoes was ported for the Wii. But if this happened to you while playing the GameCube version, you had no choice but to start all over again.


7. Assassin's Creed: Odyssey

Assassins Creed Odyssey
Ubisoft

In Assassin's Creed: Odyssey, you can trade with the merchant at Oikos of the Olympus for armour, weapons, and ship paraphernalia. If you're feeling lucky, you can try out the merchant's Olympian Gift, which allows you to purchase a random Epic or Legendary item for a reasonable price.

To get the best deal possible, some players will a perform a technique that's highly illegal. Just before you buy this unique loot box, you can save your progress. If The Olympian Gift you received doesn't tickle your fancy, you can reset your progress and try again. By using this technique repeatedly, a player can quickly attain the best loot possible. This sly tactic, known as savescumming, gives the player an unfair advantage, since they can avoid suffering any negative outcome.

However, the developers created a failsafe to prevent players from performing this trick. If you savescum at this point, you'll lose the item you purchased. On top of that, the money you spent will be gone and The Olympian Gift will become unavailable. Although this is a harsh punishment, it discouraged players from trying this scam again.


6. Final Fantasy XII: The Zodiac Age

Final Fantasy XII
Square Enix

While playing Final Fantasy XII, you feel great relief after you come across a Save Crystal, especially after making your way past a slew of enemies and booby traps. By coming into contact with this glowing jewel, you can save your progress and regenerate your party's HP and MP.

But sometimes, your eyes deceive you. Occasionally, the Save Crystal is not a Save Crystal at all, but a duplicitous enemy called Crystal bug. Sadly, you won't know whether these save points are real until you try to use them!

Although fake save points have appeared in games like Hollow Knight and Undertale, these crystallised critters are infamous for deceiving players, since they can literally kill you.

Although Crystalbugs aren't too hard to defeat, you let your guard down while approaching one, since you're under the false impression there are no enemies nearby. As such, it's unlikely you'll have your defences up, giving the treacherous beast an opportunity to overpower you.

What's worse is you can't just avoid the Crystalbug, since he turns into a real Save Crystal when he's defeated. If there's no other Crystals in the area, you have no choice but to fight him to maintain your progress.


5. Golden Sun

Golden Sun
Camelot

After winning an RPG, many players continue to explore the world map, hoping to complete every side-quest and obtain every hidden artefact.

If you played Golden Sun, you had more incentive to find everything, since your data could be carried over to the sequel, Golden Sun: The Lost Age. The most crucial items to locate were the Djinn - elemental creatures that give your party additional powers and allow them to summon godlike monsters. After you beat the game, you'll want to collect all of these enchanted critters, so you can transfer them over to The Lost Age.

But if you save at the wrong time, this becomes an impossibility. When you defeat the Fusion Dragon, your team will be transported to Lalivero. After speaking to Babi, you can head towards the Lemurian Ship, which will cause the credits to roll.

Here's the problem - You're unable to leave Lalivero after you kill the Fusion Dragon. So, if you saved your progress after arriving in this town, you can't complete any unfinished side-quests. If you still had a few Djinns to get, you missed your chance to use them in the follow-up.


4. Alien Isolation

Alien Isolation
Sega

In Alien: Isolation, our heroine, Amanda Ripley, is constantly being hunted by psychopaths, androids, and a Xenomorph. Because you're going to die A LOT, Isolation is the kind of game you'd expect to have an auto-save feature.

But it doesn't. Since Isolation focuses on its eerie atmosphere, it wouldn't be particular scary if you could save whenever you wanted. To ensure every moment is dripping with tension, the emergency phones, which serve as save stations, are as spread out as far as possible. They are often separated by multiple slow-opening doors, which is the last thing you want when you have an enemy on your tail.

Even when you find these phones, you're not out of the woods yet. You see, games like Eternal Darkness and Resident Evil only let you save while there are no threats nearby. Alien Isolation doesn't give you this option. When you try to save, there could be a killer robot, a gun-toting bandit, or an acid-spitting extra-terrestrial right behind you.

But what's worse is it takes FOREVER to save. After picking up the phone, you have to wait ten seconds for the save point to be created. While you wait, you're forced to face a wall, meaning you're not allowed to look around to see if there's a Xenomorph beside you, ready to rip your face off.


3. Resident Evil

Resident Evil 1 Original
Capcom

Resident Evil is directly responsible for putting survival horror on the map. But it wasn't just the zombies that spooked us - it was the limited opportunities to save. To maintain your progress, you had to use an Ink Ribbon on one of the typewriters strewn around the mansion. Because there were a finite amount of Ribbons, the player had to be careful how often they saved.

But that wasn't the only issue. In the original Resident Evil, you can play as Chris Redfield or Jill Valentine. Chris can hold six items in his inventory, while Jill can hold eight. Because you have limited slots to hold weapons, ammo, health supplies, and key items, carrying a ribbon was as inconvenient as not having one!

It might sound counter-intuitive, but it's sensible to keep saving to a minimum. If you haven't used a typewriter in a while, it's sometimes better to plow ahead rather than backtrack. Trust me. Every Resident Evil player has lost count the amount of times they died, while making their way back to a previously visited typewriter room.


2. Doki Doki Literature Club!

Doki Doki Literature Club
Team Salvato

Doki Doki Literature Club! doesn't necessarily punish you for saving - instead, it makes your save files feel inconsequential. As your adventure begins, our protagonist is invited by his childhood friend, Sayori to her school book club. Over time, Sayori confides in you how she suffers from depression, giving you a choice on how to comfort her.

Sadly, whatever decision you make is irrelevant, since Sayori hangs herself either way. Naturally, your first instinct will be to open an old save file and try to stop Sayori from taking her life.

However, you'll be surprised to learn your save files have been deleted. When you restart, you'll notice Sayori has disappeared. Stranger still, the other characters don't acknowledge her, as if she never existed. Every time you save after this point, you have to accept nothing in the game is set in stone. Even if you load your "save file," it might not be the save file you remember.

Late in the game, your classmate, Monika, will actually disable your ability to load or save your progress. Only after you manually enters the game's directory and deletes her character will everything reset, allowing you to access the save options.


1. Undertale

Undertale Flowey
Toby Fox

A save file doesn't just secure your progress - it symbolises the player's ability to erase their mistakes. No matter how many times you lose, you can return to the last save point as if nothing happened.

Unless of course you are playing Undertale. You see, Toby Fox's indie RPG has a unique way to retain data. If you kill Toriel during the tutorial, Flowey will mention you can undo this mistake by reloading your save file. To spare Toriel's life, many players will take Flowey up on his offer.

But during the climax, the insidious flower reminds you how "you murdered her, and then you went back because you regretted it," proving your supposedly deleted save file still exists in the game's memory.

Sans makes a similar observation while you perform the Genocide run. After Sans kills you, you will return to your most recent save point, where you can face him again. Just before the battle, your skeletal antagonist states he's already beaten you in your previous run.

You can't help freaking out during moments like this, since it feels like your ability to save is compromised. Even if you win the game, you can't help feeling bad, since the characters bring up your save file to remind you of your failures.


Watch Next


Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows