10 Video Games That Sold MILLIONS (Despite Being Terrible)

It's not what you do, it's how you market it.

Grand Theft Auto Definitive Edition
Rockstar

The history of gaming is littered with cult classics - brilliant diamonds left to shine in the darkness by the general public.

This list is not about them.

Instead, we're taking a look at some of gaming's most notorious overachievers - towering edifices of mediocrity whose staggering commercial success belied the deficiencies of their design. Whether through name recognition or launching on the right console at the right time, these games managed to fail upwards into millions of gamers homes.

Each game on this list contains a multitude of sins, from general woes (slapping a license on a clearly unfinished product and calling it a day) to more specific failings (cha-cha dancing aliens).

Yet no matter how deeply flawed they were, they all managed to sell over a million copies, and in doing so provided yet more evidence of the amoral, uncaring nature of the universe.

And on that cheerful note, let's get started!

10. Wii Music

Wii Music
Nintendo

The mid-to-late noughties was a golden period for rhythm games. The likes of Guitar Hero and Rock Band saw gamers across the world strutting their stuff and living out their rock star fantasies in the comfort of their living rooms.

Naturally, Nintendo wanted to get in on the action in their own idiosyncratic way. Unfortunately, this particular brand of idiosyncratic genius was less The Beatles and more John & Yoko.

Wii Music suffered from two problems. One was its inescapable air of cheapness, from the lo-tech graphics to the public domain songs that made up the majority of its tracklist. The other was a total lack of immersion.

Guitar Hero and its ilk succeeded because playing on their peripherals created a genuine sense of engagement with the music. Wii Music, on the other hand, simply asked players to half-heartedly swing the Wii controller about in a vague approximation of whichever instrument you were tasked with playing.

This had all the immersion of waving a baguette at home and pretending you were conducting the London Symphony Orchaestra, with the downside that you couldn't eat the Wiimote afterwards.


9. Shadow The Hedgehog

Shadow The Hedgehog
Sega

There is no greater indicator of emo's power in the mid-noughties than the fact that Shadow the Hedgehog managed to sell millions of copies.

Shadow The Hedgehog may not be the worst Sonic game ever made - the glitch-filled, bestiality-promoting Sonic 06 holds that dubious distinction - but it's definitely located somewhere near the bottom of the Sonic barrel.

As well as its posturing, try-too-hard attitude (just look at the state of the above picture), Shadow suffers from the same bugbears that affect all the worst Sonic games. Chiefly, a camera that actively avoids showing you important information and overly-sensitive controls that make the protagonist move like a meth-soaked pinball.

Unfortunately, Shadow also adds its own bitter twist to the toxic Sonic formula - guns. The gunplay in Shadow is utterly hopeless, as the lock-on constantly fails to distinguish between friend and foe and the aforementioned camera problems see the player having to constantly fire at off-screen targets.

It says something that Shadow The Hedgehog never received a sequel despite selling millions. SEGA knew they got lucky with the ebony hedgehog's first (and last) game, and wisely quit while they were ahead.


8. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens Colonial Marines
Gearbox

We weren't kidding about the dancing aliens in the article intro.

The above .gif tells you everything you need to know about the state Aliens: Colonial Marines launched in. The millions of people who had the misfortune to purchase the game may have expected a nerve-shredding Aliens experience, but what they got were insterstellar improv routines.

The AI of the eponymous Aliens was utterly broken, leading to scenes like the one above. Our personal favourite was a chase scene where the Alien abandoned pursuit to wander back and forth down the same hallway, looking for all the world like a stoned cosplayer at Comic-Con.

Incredibly, the xenomorphs' wonky AI was later discovered to be the result of a single typo in the game's code, with a renegade "a" completely breaking Colonial Marines' artificial intelligence systems. Six years and millions of dollars in development costs flushed down the drain because of poor spell-checking.

Now that's a waste of resources even Weyland-Yutani would balk at.


7. Hey You, Pikachu!

Hey You, Pikachu - Pokemon
Nintendo

How far can you stretch the definition of "game"?

It's a question Nintendo has often asked itself, to varying degrees of success. Sometimes it leads to greatness, like the beguiling charms of Animal Crossing. Other times...

Other times, it winds up with players yelling futile commands at a yellow rat determined to ignore them.

Hey You, Pikachu! was a voice-recognition game for the N64 that successfully rode the Pokemon hype train to the tune of around 2 million sales. Pretty impressive for an $80 game that contained maybe two hours of content.

HYP tasked players with instructing Pikachu to complete simple puzzles through the microphone that came bundled with the game (and led to its vastly inflated price tag). Unfortunately, Pikachu's limited vocabulary (he could only recognise 200 words) and the mic's limitations meant the yellow mascot was as likely to zap you with a thunderbolt as he was to follow your commands.

Combined with the game's lack of content, Hey You, Pikachu! was an overpriced novelty that signalled the death-knell for Nintendo's foray into voice-recognition gaming.


6. Homefront

Homefront 2011
THQ

A blatant attempt at jumping on the Call of Duty bandwagon, Homefront didn't just miss the mark - it stumbled, fell in front of the wagon and got trampled to death by the horses. Who then used its remains as a toilet.

Homefront makes the classic mistake of any pale imitation, in that it chooses the wrong things to copy from its inspiration. In this case it means that Homefront is overly scripted, to the point you feel like the designers are only begrudgingly letting you play it.

Every single action is narrated out loud for you by your squad of tropes- sorry, "team-mates" - while the camera points you exactly where you need to go and a button prompt details exactly what you have to do. It's like the developers don't trust you, and feel the need to force you into having the exact experience they envisioned.

The nadir comes when Homefront - and this actually happens - demands you "Press X To Jump Into A Mass Grave". It's exactly as crass, tone-deaf and moronic as that sounds, and an insult to the intelligence of the player. The only QTE this game needed was "Press Refund to Get Money Back".


5. Call of Duty: Ghosts

Call of Duty Ghosts
Activision

Speaking of Call of Duty, here's the franchise nadir!

A jumbled mess of a game, CoD: Ghosts had no idea what it wanted to be. The game's marketing promised a campaign focused on guerrila warfare and stealth (hence the "Ghosts" of the title), as you sneaked around America to thwart the bad guys du jour.

So naturally the first mission ends with more explosions than a Michael Bay movie, and the finale involves flying into outer space and the firing of a sci-fi doomsday weapon.

Ghosts just feels like a game made in a hurry - a hodgepodge of different half-baked ideas and themes all thrown together in the hope something stuck. Take Extinction as an example. A twist on the traditional CoD Zombies mode, Extinction replaced the undead with extraterrestrials for no adequate reason. It was change for the sake of change, and CoD quickly went back to zombies in all future installments.

Which rather sums up Ghost's lack of impact on the franchise. Although it sold tens of millions and ended on a massive cliffhanger, CoD's publishers have made no sign that Ghosts 2 will ever be forthcoming.


4. Resident Evil 6

Resident Evil 6
Capcom

Speaking of franchise low-points, here's Resident Evil 6!

Thinking about it, RE6 and CoD: Ghosts have a lot in common. They're both regarded as the worst games in their series, they both suffer from overstuffed, messy campaigns, and they both somehow sold in the tens of millions.

Playing Resident Evil 6, the first thing that strikes you is the weightlessness of the combat. Enemies take far too many bullets to go down, and there's no sense of impact in any of your weapons. Every battle feels like a childhood playfight with that one friend who refused to admit they were dead, and the end result is a series of tedious brawls that go on long past the point of being enjoyable.

The second thing you'll notice is that RE6 would have benefitted enormously from being cut in half. The four-campaign single-player is easily two campaigns too long, as Chris and Jake's stories contain the worst gameplay in Resi history. Chris' story is a dull slog alongside the most boring character to grace a Resi game, and Jake's is so badly designed it will actively piss you off and have you rooting for the little s**t's untimely demise.

A mid-life crisis in video game form, Resident Evil 6 saw Capcom embarrass itself by trying to ape the trends of the time. It didn't work, and Capcom thankfully took the series back to its roots for the stellar Resident Evil 7.


3. Kinect Adventures

Kinect Adventures
Good Science Studio

In video games, as is the case in so much of life, timing is everything.

For a golden minute Microsoft's Kinect looked like it would be the next big thing in gaming. A body-tracking device that promised a shining future of controller-free gaming, Kinect turned out to be a buggy, barely responsive novelty item that was quickly discarded when the depths of its flaws became apparent.

Unfortunately millions of people fell for the the hype, resulting in the woeful Kinect Adventures making its way onto this list.

A pack-in game bundled with the Kinect itself, Kinect Adventures was clearly meant to be seen as the next Wii Sports - a minigame compilation designed to show off the possibilities of the new hardware. Unfortunately, whatever magic pixie dust Nintendo used on Wii Sports was clearly in short supply in Microsoft HQ.

Like the aforementioned Hey You, Pikachu!, Kinect Adventures is less a game and more of a showcase for a semi-functioning piece of tech. And much like that title, KA suffers from a serious lack of content.

Two hours of limb-flailing let most gamers see everything it had to offer, at which point the game began gathering dust alongside the Kinect itself.


2. Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy

GTA Definitive Edition WTF
Rockstar

Next game on the (s)hit list is Grand Theft Auto: The Trilogy - Definitive Edition. Or, as it's also known "The Cyberpunk 2077 of 2021".

Much like 2020 saw CD Projekt's infamous RPG become the biggest piƱata in the games industry, November 2021 saw gaming outlets far and wide absolutely batter Take Two's disastrous revival of the PS2-era Grand Theft Autos.

And with good reason. Far from being the definitive editions promised in the title, the remasters made each game actively worse. Characters were given hideously ugly redesigns, iconic songs from the soundtracks were cut for licensing reasons and the game's remastered weather effects were legitimately worse than the 2004 originals. And that's not even mentioning the bizarre glitches or the genuinely insulting Switch port.

Yet despite all that, Take Two reported that the remasters "exceeded sales projections", with up to 10 million copies reportedly having been sold.

GTA games have always held a dim view on humanity, and if that many people wilfully parted money for this dumpster fire of a collection then you can see why. (Dollars to donuts there'll be a mission in GTA 6 where a corrupt executive gloats over fleecing the public with shoddy, effort-free remasters).


1. FIFA: Legacy Editions

FIFA Nintendo Switch
Nintendo

True story - if you look up FIFA 22 on the Nintendo eshop, this is the only picture available in the preview gallery. Which begs the question: What are EA trying to hide?

Is it the mannequin-like character models? The lack of modes? Or the fact that EA have been releasing the exact same game for five years?

That's not hyperbole, by the way. The FIFA: Legacy Editions use the same engine that powered FIFA 2017, with only the team rosters and outfits changing every year. While other consoles get engine updates and new modes every year, Switch players get a reskinned version of a five year old game.

The FIFA Legacy Editions are endemic of everything wrong with the games industry. A cynical, effort-free cashgrab that nevertheless makes millions every year, the only way the Legacy Editions could be more insulting is if EA started bundling them with NFTs showing their shareholders laughing all the way to the bank.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Hello! My name's Iain Tayor. I write about video games, wrestling and comic books, and I apparently can't figure out how to set my profile picture correctly.