10 Video Games That Take Multiple Playthroughs For The TRUE EXPERIENCE
Saving the real rewards for the most committed players.
Generally speaking, once you’ve rolled credits on a game, it’s safe to close the thing down and move on with your life, but there are certainly glaring exceptions to that rule.
Some games pack so much worthwhile, even "necessary" content into their New Game Plus modes that you’re only massively depriving yourself of the - wait for it - true experience if you don't bother sticking around for another few playthroughs.
Though we’ve all got busy lives and a backlog of games we haven’t got a hope in hell of ever clearing, these games absolutely begged you to come back for more to glean the full picture.
On repeat playthroughs these games unfurled the full extent of the story, presented it from a wholly different perspective, and perhaps even went full meta by playing around with parallel universes and alternate timelines.
If you dropped these games like a bad habit the moment you saw the dev credits, you’ve only seen a fraction of what they actually had to offer, and in most cases you’ve robbed yourself of something far more meaningful…
10. Nier: Automata
Let's kick things off with perhaps the gold standard of games which outright need you to play through them numerous times.
Rolling credits once on Nier: Automata just won't cut it, as players require a minimum of three playthroughs to experience every sliver of story it has to offer.
Once you've "beaten" the game as android protagonist 2B, you'll be able to witness the same events from the perspective of fellow android 9S, which given that the duo are separated for large chunks of the story, ensures a wealth of new content, with 9S also playing quite differently to 2B.
And then there's the third playthrough, which picks up after 2B and 9S's stories have concluded for an entirely new mini-campaign of sorts, with players now controlling yet another android character, A2.
Playing through all this is necessary to unlock Nier: Automata's true ending, Ending E, ensuring that those who jump off after 2B's initial campaign are really only seeing a third of the story play out.
9. Ico
Team Ico's aptly-titled debut Ico is a gorgeous adventure game in which players take control of the titular young boy who is trapped inside an abandoned castle.
Ico spends the game attempting to escape alongside a captive girl, Yorda, and due to Yorda's limited physical abilities, players must help her traverse the castle by providing boosts and manipulating the environment.
Shadow creatures will also attempt to drag Yorda away if you leave her unaccompanied for any amount of time, so you need to be constantly watching and assisting - or if you want to be a bit mean, babysitting - the poor girl.
Yet the ultimate expression of Ico's gameplay is only unfurled once the game has actually been completed, when the European and Japanese versions of the game will unlock a co-op mode, allowing a second player to take control of Yorda.
Granted, she's still subject to all of the physical limitations that her CPU counterpart is, but allowing another human to take control of her adds an undeniable visceral quality to gameplay, especially if playing with a loved one or perhaps even someone who isn't terribly experienced with video games.
8. Final Fantasy VII Remake
As terrifically entertaining as Final Fantasy VII Remake is on any difficulty, it becomes something truly special once you beat it and unlock Hard Mode, which is unequivocally the way to get the most out of the game.
Hard Mode isn't just the base game but more challenging, it inherently reshapes the way in which you play, in turn delivering an experience more akin to classic, old-school Final Fantasy.
Beyond enemies simply being more difficult, they've also got new attack patterns, but most crucially, you're not allowed to use items, and rest points can only be used to replenish HP, not MP.
Basically, Hard Mode makes magic feel like a truly vital commodity rather than something you can always rely upon to get you out of a tough spot no matter what. It forces players to be strategic and thoughtful about when they use it, saving the big guns for tricky bosses.
In comparison to the more casual-friendly lower difficulties, Hard Mode absolutely feels like the way Square Enix wants you to play the game.
7. The Quiet Man
Because it'd be a little too easy to just include actual good games on this list, here's an absolute clanger.
The Quiet Man is a cinematic beat 'em up game with an intriguing albeit poorly executed hook - to immerse players in the world of its deaf protagonist, both the gameplay and FMV cutscenes have minimal audio with no subtitles.
Yet this ultimately resulted in an experience more confusing than entertaining for most.
Even if you could forgive the frankly atrocious combat, figuring out what the hell was going on was an absolute chore, and something that few were compelled to commit much thought to.
A week after the game's release, however, developer Human Head Studios released a New Game Plus update called "Answered," which restored the removed audio and allowed players to at least understand what was happening.
Yet let's be honest, that initial playthrough is such a miserable, head-scratching experience that few likely bothered to dive back in for a more illuminating second go-around.
6. Resident Evil 2
There's perhaps only one thing which the original version of Resident Evil 2 did better than Capcom's fantastic remake, and that's its A/B scenario system.
The survival horror masterpiece allows players to take control of either Leon Kennedy or Claire Redfield, but beating the game with one character is really only seeing half the story - or if you're a strident completionist, a quarter.
Basically, Resident Evil 2 has four playable core scenarios - beating the "A" campaign for one character unlocks a paired "B" campaign for the other.
If you start the game by playing through Leon A, you'll then unlock Claire B, which depicts the game's events from Claire's unique perspective.
More to the point, actions made by the player in scenario A will be reflected in B, such as any enemies you left alive still being there.
And if you really want to get the most out of it, you can then play the scenarios flipped, making for a grand total of four playable campaigns to see everything Resident Evil 2 has to offer.
5. Astro Boy: Omega Factor
Much like Nier: Automata, Astro Boy: Omega Factor's second playthrough is so gosh-darn vital that it scarcely feels right to even call it a New Game Plus at all.
After defeating the "final" boss, players are met with a sudden bummer of an ending, where Astro is killed by a device known as the Death Mask, allowing villain Sharaku to conquer Earth.
But after this, players are revived by an entity known as Phoenix, presenting Astro with the ability to time travel back to the start of the game and get another chance at victory.
This back-half of the game, called "Rebirth", allows you to play through all the levels again in the pursuit of a more fortuitous outcome against Death Mask, in turn unlocking the real happy ending.
Basically, if you just call it a day when Astro dies and the initial end credits roll, you're depriving yourself of a whole half of the experience.
4. Bastion
Supergiant Games' terrific action-RPG Bastion concludes with an epic choice - players can either use the Bastion to rewind time in an attempt to prevent the apocalyptic Calamity, or use it to evacuate the survivors and head somewhere safe.
The player is warned that there's no guarantee that rewinding time will actually prevent the Calamity as there's no way to test it, leaving players to decide for themselves whether the "Restoration" ending is worth it.
This is absolutely the ending that makes sense, though, given that beating Bastion will unlock a New Game Plus where you can play through the game again with much of your progress retained.
The New Game Plus contains new dialogue hinting that the protagonist has experienced these events before, including an opening narration which echoes the final words of the Restoration ending.
By its nature, the New Game Plus rather grimly implies that the Restoration ending didn't prevent the Calamity, in turn encouraging players to select the Evacuation ending the second time around, knowing that rewinding time is simply delaying the inevitable.
3. Starfield
Starfield may be one of 2023's most polarising games to date, but Bethesda deserves a measure of credit for coming up with a New Game Plus which ties directly into the story itself in an amusingly meta way.
At the end of the game, players are given a choice - to continue exploring the universe, or become a Starborn, leaving their universe behind forever and entering another one, allowing them to basically restart the game in a parallel universe.
Those who become a Starborn will retain their level, powers, and skills, but items, side mission progress, and character relationships will all be wiped, giving you the opportunity to approach the game from a whole new perspective.
These universes also include intriguing variations on your original run, such as allowing your to recruit yourself as a companion and replacing the members of Constellation with children, ensuring that you're not really seeing the full extent of Bethesda's vision if you just quit after a single playthrough.
2. Dishonored 2
About a month after Dishonored 2 hit stores, Bethesda put out a New Game Plus update which offered the unequivocally definitive iteration of the game.
Your first run through Dishonored 2 forces you to choose between two characters - either Empress Emily Kaldwin or her father (and protagonist of the original game) Corvo Attano, meaning that you're locked out of accessing the other player's bespoke powers.
But New Game Plus goes absolutely hog wild by not only carrying over your bonecharm traits, runes, and blueprints, but also allowing you access to all of both Emily and Corvo's powers, no matter which of the two characters you decide to play as.
Unsurprisingly this absolutely rips, granting players an almost overwhelming array of options as it pertains to both combat and stealth.
Once you've had a taste of New Game Plus and all it has to offer, it's honestly tough to even consider going back to the restrictive "vanilla" iteration. This is the game.
1. Chrono Trigger
And finally, we come to the legendary RPG which popularised the very idea of New Game Plus, and perhaps remains the ultimate expression of its potential brilliance.
Chrono Trigger contains a stonking thirteen endings of varying complexity, and are unlocked depending on choices made throughout the game and especially how the player reaches the game's final boss, Lavos.
After beating the game once - and most likely being stomped by Lavos - you'll unlock New Game Plus, where you'll be able to restart the game with your levels and equipment carrying over to take another pop at the alien parasite.
The real kicker, though? This time, you can fight Lavos whenever you want, allowing you to unlock each of the additional endings and see all the distinct possible permutations of the story - namely, how the timeline is affected by defeating Lavos at different junctures.
Beating the game once and moving on is denying yourself the joy of hoovering up all the different endings - some genuinely great, some totally jokey.
Chrono Trigger pioneered the very idea of repeat playthroughs being integral to the fabric of the story, rather than simply something for the most obsessive fans to do.