10 Video Games That Were Basically One Big Apology
Sorry you didn't like our game!
Sometimes game developers get it wrong. Horribly wrong. To be fair to them, most of the time they have a herculean task on their hands: to be able to satiate fans, who, with advances in technology and increasing demands of excellence, have ever growing expectations on what they expect from their favourite franchises.
The weight of expectation (I'm looking at you Cyberpunk 2077), tight deadlines, or a complete misreading of what the fans actually want, can leave people feeling p*ssed off and frustrated with the final product.
You only have to look at the disastrous re-release of XIII and the developers PlayMagic's subsequent grovelling apology to fans, who said, "In its present state, XIII does not meet our quality standards and we fully understand players' frustrations."
Therefore, when working on a follow up game, it is up to the developers to give fans what they want, whilst still maintaining their creative integrity.
Here we discuss the many ways in which developers, fresh off of the 'must do better' feeling on one of their games, have strived, with mixed results, to give more of what the fans actually want with follow up games.
10. Wolfenstein: The New Order
Whilst the majority of Wolfenstein titles have been a byword for quality, and is some of the most fun that can be had in video games, this gaming juggernaut ground to a halt with the release of Wolfenstein in 2009.
It received middling reviews, predominantly being criticised for being dull, and having promising features not expanded upon. A prime example is its open world setting, which on first glance seems expansive, but in reality was linear (and not in a good way) and extremely limited in scope and size.
The game performed poorly in sales, resulting in MachineGames being given the franchise in 2010.
The new developers took a fresh approach to the direction of the franchise, which mostly succeeded. The game went back to a more 'on the rails' style, which was accentuated with intense gunplay and hedonistic, gory visuals.
The narrative was a particular highlight, Wolfenstein's trademark alternate history of World War 2 taking BJ Blazkowicz on a tour of Nazi occupied earth.
It is no surprise then, buoyed by the success of the game, that the template for The New Order was almost certainly used as inspiration for id Software to create Doom (2016) , one of the best shooters of its generation.
9. GTA V
GTA IV is one of the least celebrated games in Rockstar's mighty franchise, despite receiving enormous critical and commercial acclaim at the time. Some of the criticism levelled at it was for its overly serious and realistic tone. The city was drab and grey, and the story had a much darker tone than previous installments.
As a response, Rockstar made their craziest open world game ever with GTA V. Gone was the 'bland' protagonist, and was replaced by an upcoming gangster, a washed up actor and an unhinged psychopath. Although a comedic element has always been present in all GTAs, Rockstar went overboard on this element for GTA V.
Rockstar introduced an ambitious three character narrative, which was woven seamlessly into the gameplay mechanics. This departure from GTA IV was perhaps personified the most with playable character Trevor, who was a politically incorrect, depraved, unhinged maniac. Crucially, the game made no apology for his behaviour, and rather revelled in it.
Whilst the impact of GTA V has arguably been the biggest of any Rockstar game, let's hope we get a proper sequel soon, and not just a re - pre - expansion remastered edition... again.
8. Resident Evil 7: Biohazard
Sometimes, in order to create something great, you have to create something terrible. And while you could argue Resident Evil 6 isn't terrible, it certainly isn't good compared to the other mainline entries in the franchise.
Resident Evil 6 went off the rails by being action focused, set piece heavy, and almost entirely lacking in scares. Fans did not appreciate this action-based gameplay, and Capcom sold a million fewer copies than projected as a result.
Subsequently, Capcom has had a long, hard look at what made the series great, and went back to basics with Resident Evil 7. Considered a soft reboot of the series, it took tonal inspiration from the original Resident Evil, as well as from classic horror movies such as The Texas Chainsaw Massacre.
Featuring a stripped down setting of a dilapidated Southern plantation house, it focused more on atmosphere and genuinely unsettling jump scares - Jack Baker bursting out of the wall will always make your heart skip a beat.
The switch to a first person perspective showed Capcom weren't willing to rest on their laurels, and were looking for new and exciting ways the fans could enjoy their game. Clearly it worked, as it was met with great acclaim upon release.
7. Assassin's Creed Origins
Even the most ardent Assassin's Creed fan can pinpoint the low point of the franchise. Assassin's Creed Syndicate encapsulated everything bad about the series.
Not a year had passed following Assassin's Creed Unity's release before the next instalment, Syndicate, came out. There were numerous glitches and bugs; some being hilarious and odd, and others being game breaking and downright frustrating.
Although many of these glitches were eradicated soon after, it mystified gamers, who wondered why a game was being released despite being nowhere near finished. Although Syndicate shone a light on Ubisoft's corner cutting, in reality it had been endemic of Assassin's Creed games for years.
With Assassin's Creed Origins, Ubisoft tore up the rulebook and went back to basics. The Animus, considered a pace destroying plot device in previous titles, was toned down massively, immersing players more successfully in the historical world.
The action was taken away from Europe to the ancient theatre of Egypt. The combat system was completely revamped, meaning the action elements were much more accessible to players, becoming a legitimate alternative to stealth.
This game has set the blueprint for two well received sequels, and showed that Ubisoft is prepared to listen to its fans.
6. Every Sonic Game Over The Past Decade (2015)
So far in this list we've shown how developers have mainly apologised for individual titles. Sega, not to be outdone, decided to cover all bases by apologising for EVERY bad Sonic game from the past decade.
Once considered a genuine rival to Mario, the blue speedster had a dramatic fall from grace during the noughties. So much so that Sega felt they had to come out and explain themselves. “Sega has publicly apologized to the fans as the quality of console games in the Sonic franchise hasn’t been acceptable over recent years,” said Jon Rooke, Segas Europe Marketing Director.
The transition between 2D and 3D had been inconsistent at best, so Sega looked to start from scratch with future titles to try and get the fans back on board.
This apology was issued a couple of years after Sonic Lost World, which received a lukewarm reception at best. But when we consider sub par Sonic games such as Sonic Forces, Sonic Unleashed and Sonic Boom: Rise of Lyric, perhaps the apology was warranted!
A bold move, considering you are effectively telling your fan base that most games based on your most iconic character over the last ten years have been rubbish, but hopefully one that will pay off.
5. Doom (2016)
Doom 3, released in 2004, was the first Doom game to mix up the formula. Gone was the fast paced, high octane action, and in came dark, claustrophobic corridors and frighteningly realistic monsters.
The pace was slowed to a crawl, and incorporated many survival horror elements, such as players not being able to hold their weapons and a torch at the same time and predictable jump scares.
Perhaps the biggest change was a shift to more narrative gameplay, and the iconic Doom Guy was replaced by an unnamed generic soldier.
Although well received, there was dismay from fans that the classic Doom recipe was almost completely missing from the game. People didn't want to creep around corridors, they wanted to go into hell and shoot the ever loving s**t out of everything.
Doom 2016 took all the elements that made the original Doom so successful, and turned them up to eleven. Guided by a heavy metal soundtrack which almost seemed to sync with your actions, it turned the series' staple violence and headlong aggression into an art form, introducing glory kills to name but one.
Doom was a triumphant return to form, and id Software have continued in this vein with the much lauded Doom Eternal.
4. Call Of Duty: Modern Warfare
Previous installments of Call of Duty were mainly focused on futuristic conflicts, which had more in common with running up walls than breaching them. Fans made it clear after Infinite Warfare released, that futuristic combat was not the direction the franchise should focus on.
Interestingly, Infinity Ward started working on a remaster of Modern Warfare soon after the release of Infinite Warfare.
By revisiting Modern Warfare, they were also revelling in the high point in the series, where the developers had achieved the almost perfect medium of a gripping single player campaign, twinned with an enjoyable and long lasting multiplayer.
The campaign was considered one of the best ever, and helped satiate fans who thought too much emphasis was placed on the multiplayer modes in previous games.
The tone and combat was more grounded in realism, with moral choices a refreshing addition, helping players ponder their actions rather than crashing through buildings and killing everything that moved.
Some aspects of the story were criticised, such as a section where you control a child soldier, but this could be construed as an attempt by developers Infinity Ward to add more complex layers to the story, which in previous titles had sometimes verged into parody.
3. Red Steel 2
There is no greater contrast in gaming than a game being one of the worst releases on a console, to its sequel fully utilising everything that console has to offer.
The first Red Steel game, a launch title for the Wii, was notable for being a first person game that used the Wiimote controller, as well as a Red Steel specific Nunchuk attachment which was used to control the katana and gunplay simultaneously.
If Wii Sports was the watermark of a game that realised the Wiimote's potential, then Red Steel showed what it was like to fall short of the mark.
While some commended the game for its innovative and unique controls, many reviewers slammed the control scheme for being unresponsive and inconsistent.
The sequel Red Steel 2 managed to get it right. The once derided motion controls had a complete overhaul, and as a result were more responsive and effortless to use, making you truly feel like a gun slinging ninja. It was felt with Red Steel 2 that the Wiimote controller seemed purpose built for it.
A great example of taking something the first game fell short on, and then realising its potential to become one of the best games on the console.
2. Silent Hill: Shattered Memories
Silent Hill Homecoming, the sixth entry in the Silent Hill franchise, had a very muted reception upon release. Although it was an admirable attempt to reboot the franchise, it just didn't feel like a Silent Hill game, and was more of a throwback to better games.
Step up Silent Hill: Shattered Memories. It went the bold direction of reimagining the first game, which was a fan favourite, albeit set in an alternate universe.
The game asks the player to reveal their deepest fears and desires, which directly influences the gameplay, and even the appearance of some creatures.
With Shattered Memories, gone was the repetitive hack 'n' slash combat, and back to the creeping, existential horror that made the first three Silent Hill games such a landmark in the genre.
This was a marked improvement from earlier titles, which had slowly been eroding the franchise over time with confusing plot threads and bland combat.
Whilst it isn't a classic Silent Hill game, it not only revisited one of the high points in the series, but also to took the franchise in a bold, new direction.
1. Saints Row 2
The first Saints Row was, perhaps unfairly, dismissed as a Grand Theft Auto clone. When a game dominates the industry like GTA has, Saints Row developers Volition had to do something to make their franchise stand out from the crowd.
Whilst the first game did have individual moments of tongue-in-cheek humour, it still had a fairly serious tone. With Saints Row 2, they decided to ramp up the levels of craziness.
Activities included killing a mob boss in a destruction derby, taking on a shady villainous corporation with a sewage spreading truck and taking part in parodies of American cop shows.
The storyline was utterly bonkers, involving your character having major plastic surgery and setting up a HQ in a building destroyed by an earthquake.
The franchise went from being a GTA clone to a parody of serious sandbox games, and a great game in its own right. After all, can you really call a game a GTA clone if you can zap pedestrians to death with shock paddles? Probably not.
In a way, then, this game was less of an apology, and more of a 'if that's what the people want then that's what they'll get'.