10 Video Games That Were Killed By Executive Meddling

Brutal Legend didn't deserve to be gutted and mis-sold to the public.

Brutal Legend
Double Fine

A lot of things can go wrong during the development of a game. Creatives can be over-ambitious, under-skilled, or just plain negligent. However, more often than not, the thing that truly kills a game can be the overbearing interference of executives, publishers and companies that aren't directly involved.

Games are expensive, so the people behind funding often want to make sure their investment is as "safe" as possible, which results in the compromising of artistic integrity or general shady business practices that would otherwise produce an enjoyable game.

It is perhaps one of the most frustrating aspects of the gaming industry, as these faceless businesspeople appear to lack any awareness or understanding of gamers, resulting in crippling decisions that completely baffle the general populace.

Games are often rushed out to meet deadlines, toned back in response to focus groups, and completely butchered in order to fit bankable trends. Instead of trusting developers, the people who actually relate to the modern gamer and understand the marketplace, execs decide that the popularity of Fortnite means the next plaformer needs a battle royale mode.

10. Sea Of Thieves

Sea Of Thieves
Rare

Sea of Thieves was No Man's Sky 2.0. It intended to be the ultimate online pirate game, with ships, plunder and endless open seas fun. It promised a lot and developed very little. Unlike No Man's Sky, however, the game's release state was not a result of a lack of talent but a lack of time.

Following the E3 2016, Microsoft was under a lot of pressure to deliver more titles for the Xbox, prompting their somewhat humorous display of "exclusive" games the following year.

One of the actual exclusives was Sea of Thieves, and upon the launch of the game, it was incredibly clear that production had been ramped up in order to meet the exclusive title demands.

The game was unfinished. It barely had enough content to satisfy a closed beta, and as it released it became clear that it was full of a whole load of nothing. All because it was rushed to the shelves and the talent behind the game didn't have the chance to make something decent.

At least it had the multiplayer it promised... *cough cough* 'No Man's Sky' *cough cough*


9. Ratchet & Clank: Quest For Booty/Into The Nexus

Ratchet And Clank Into The Nexus
Insomniac

Insomniac originally intended these standalone games to be DLC for 'Tools of Destruction' and 'A Crack In Time' respectively. However, somewhere along the line they were chopped off and segregated into standalone titles, thus being ridiculously overpriced.

Containing diddly-squat, they doubled down on the recent trend of reducing overall content in the series, making minuscule games that would've barely registered as DLC anyway. Not to mention the fact that the confusing way they were marketed alienated audiences who simply didn't understand what the games were meant to be.

Worst of all, those who DID buy them were disappointed when the credits rolled midway through what should have been a first act.


8. Brutal Legend

Brutal Legend
Double Fine

The story of Brutal Legend could be turned into a Peter Jackson trilogy. Firstly, when the game was under the control of Activision, the developers were in a constant struggle to realise their vision, with Activision knocking back idea after idea.

The rumours were that the game felt reminiscent of Guitar Hero in style and tone, and Activision wanted to refrain from compromising the brand integrity of their franchise. Thus the game was butchered into releasing as a third of its initial proposed state.

Said was release had a marketing campaign handled by EA, who marketed it as a combat game with driving elements - completely glossing over the Real Time Strategy that made up the bulk of the experience, resulting in Brutal Legend reviewing poorly and being received very negatively by people expecting something completely different.


7. Fuse

Fuse game
Insomniac

Insomniac is one of the most stylistic developers out there. You need only look at Ratchet and Clank, Sunset Overdrive and even Resistance to see some of the most impressive and unique looking titles out there.

So, what did EA decide was the smart move when it came to Insomniac's cartoon-style first-person shooter? Let's remove all the stylistic intent from the game because of focus groups, and make the game look more realistic, resulting in Call of Duty Knockoff #453.

It is probably one of the most forgettable games out there, to the extent that people are liable to have never even heard of it. It's simply just meh... And all because of a focus group... And EA's lack of faith in one of the most established developers around.


6. Metal Gear Survive

Metal Gear Survive
Konami

Konami didn't give this game a chance. The background squabbling and further firing of Hideo Kojima, their main man and the creative mind behind their two most popular franchises, killed the franchise instantaneously.

But instead of letting the series die, Konami dug it up out of the dirt, brushed it off, propped it up with tent-poles, slapped zombies on it and charged £60 for it. There was no way this game would succeed. The industry had already turned against Konami, so even if the game was the second coming of Christ, everyone would have hated.

The game is a mediocre one at best, but that wasn't what turned people away. Even the least industry savvy gamer knew how badly Konami screwed Kojima, so there was no way it would even stagger out the starting gate.


5. E.T. The Extra Terrestrial

e t game atari 2600
Atari

This is what happens when you give a development team two months to make a game. You almost single-handedly destroy the entire western gaming industry and cripple the medium of gaming for years to come.

E.T. was an absolute mess. To this day, it remains one of the most baffling and outright intriguing games around. And not in a good way. It's impossible to know whether or not the game would have been good if it had more time, but as it stood, the developers are at no fault for the state of the game.

If anything they deserve props for not shipping the box with nothing more than a drawing of E.T. inside.

The game wasn't killed by the executives, it never even got a chance to live.


4. SimCity (2013)

SimCity 2013
EA

Always online. Remember when that was the popular trend for games. And remember how it pretty much killed every single game that had it featured in it. There was the whole Kinect debacle, but perhaps the most cataclysmic of examples is that of SimCity

EA (Yes, don't worry. This is the second last time they are mentioned.) forced the game to be played always online in a vain attempt to tack on some meagre online features. Not only did the game not need online, but the online support for the game was simply shocking.

No money had been spent on the servers, and as result, the connection was apocalyptic at launch. The game was pretty much unplayable for several weeks, during which point most people jumped ship to competitors in the city building marketplace.


3. Star Wars Battlefront 2

Star Wars Battlefront 2
EA

Let's dig up this dead horse one last time to truly look at just how shocking Battlefront 2's launch was. Of course, there was the issue of loot boxes and the absolutely despicable implementation of them throughout the game, but the issues of executive meddling go far deeper than that.

The game was gorgeous and was technically brilliant, but it had no time. It was another example of a game being pushed out before it was ready and being disastrously underfunded. The servers barely had any money put into them so the game was buggy and choppy on day one release.

EA paraded around how they had learnt their lesson with the first game, and they had. The DLC was all free. However, they learnt one lesson, whilst firing four more bullets into their own leg. DICE did such a good job but were held back at every point by EA's meddling.


2. Hitman (2016)

Hitman Marrakesh
IO Interactive

Whilst the episodic nature of the game wasn't exactly a bad thing on paper, with most of the levels actually benefiting from this structure, the marketing of the game and explanation of how it worked was pitifully poor.

People were scared off by the episodic nature of the game as Hitman: Absolution was hardly noteworthy for its excessive replayability. So, paying a hefty sum for a single Hitman level was pretty daunting. It was just a poor implementation and poor marketing of a decent idea.

Not to mention the way in which the levels were divvied up was done purely for monetary gain. Originally packaged in two segments, the game was then split in three, ruining the flow of the gameplay and making it an even more confusing mess for fans to buy into.

If you need further convincing, IO Interactive ditched Square Enix as a publisher for the upcoming sequel. If that doesn't speak to the state of background meddling in the first game, then nothing will.


1. Prey

Prey Gloo Cannon
Bethesda

Prey was a pretty decent game. Functionally, it was outstanding and it had a decent story to boot. So, what made it disappear under the rug?

Unfortunately, Bethesda had a hand in that.

Refusing to give out review copies and restricting critical feedback on the game until a day before launch caused Prey to just... disappear. The controversy around the review copy embargo was enough to burden its reputation, and the lack of day one reviews scared off most cautious buyers.

That, and the fact that it was burdened with the title purely for a marketing perspective. Playing through the game, you can't help but think that this was an Arkane title that got slapped with the title 'Prey', simply because of Bethesda not knowing what to do with the property. It has nothing to do with the original or even the sequel's trailer, causing fans to just be confused.

All this resulted in a game that still reviewed well... there was just no one around to listen.


Contributor

I like video games, writing and writing about video games. Expect sarcasm and the dry wit of a Brit. And the occasional rant of a unhappy Scot. You know... the usual.