10 Video Games That Totally Crushed Our Dreams

They butter you up, only to sucker punch you down.

Like the world of movies, video games are all about wish fulfillment, about allowing us to play out those fantasies that we can't in real life, to live the dream. If we want to be a secret agent, a bank robber or even a God of War, games are there for us, yet sometimes, as hard as they might try, it's just not enough, and our dreams are still mercilessly crushed before our very eyes. This can materialise through broken promises from video game developers, a game that didn't quite live up to our expectations, or a particularly harrowing character death that totally broke our hearts. These games, though on the whole actually pretty great, still dashed our hopes and dreams in one fell swoop, failing to deliver in one key area, or playing with our emotions to the extent that we could barely cope anymore. Every idea we had about the future of the game and its characters was uprooted by missing game modes, games that never hit their stride, weird endings and deaths we really could have done without. How devastated were you by these gaming mishaps and moments? Did we miss any classically dream-crushing video games? Let us know in the comments!

10. Still No Heists - Grand Theft Auto V

The Dream: Grand Theft Auto V would release on September 17th 2013, and two weeks later on October 1st, GTA Online would launch, bringing to fruition the much-advertised and hugely-hyped Heist mode, which would allow up to 16 players to play together to carry out or stop a daring theft of money. The mode, like pretty much everything Rockstar puts their hand to, would go down a storm, and we'd be so glued to our consoles we'd forget that next-gen consoles were even a thing. The Reality: When GTA Online launched, Rockstar stated that Heists had been delayed for a brief period, which was disappointing enough. During late 2013, the developers remained curiously quiet about setting a definite release date for the update, though they were widely expected to drop long before Christmas. Still, 2014 rolled on and Heists were still nowhere to be seen, and when Rockstar finally gave them a vague "spring" dating, gamers became infuriated as that window passed by without a mention. It's August 2014, and a whole 11 months later, Heists still haven't materialised. It's widely expected that they're being held back for the next-gen and PC versions of GTA V, apparently due for release in November, but we'll have to wait and see. The tragedy, of course, is that we've pretty much lost interest in Heists now anyway: we've moved onto other games, and don't particularly care to reward stalling tactics like this. We love Rockstar as much as anyone, and this is one of their rare screw-ups, but it's one that really stings. Perhaps if they'd communicated with gamers a little better, we might be more understanding.

9. Battle Borefest - PlayStation All-Stars Battle Royale

The Dream: Super Smash Bros. for the PlayStation? Haven't we wanted this ever since the original 1999 N64 game? Now we'll finally get to have Solid Snake taking on Crash Bandicoot, Nathan Drake, and Lara Croft in a grueling fatal four-way fight to the death, right? Right!? The Reality: Even ignoring the surprisingly complex battle system, Sony's answer to Smash Bros. flopped because it just didn't have the household names worthy of its namesake: where on Earth were Solid Snake, Lara Croft, Crash Bandicoot, Spyro, Cloud and other unmistakably crucial icons of the PlayStation? Instead of Snake, we get...Raiden (who we'll talk about more later), and the game features near-anonymous characters such as "Fat Princess" who we just couldn't give a hoot about. This could have been a fantastic retort to Super Smash Bros., but instead it's a misguided, poorly thought-out failure. If Sony couldn't put their cream of the crop in the game for some sort of licensing issue, then they shouldn't have made the game in the first place.

8. It's...Just A Good Game - Watch Dogs

The Dream: After serving up that incredible E3 2012 trailer and enduring several unfortunate delays, Watch Dogs would prove to be worth the wait, hitting stores to universal critical acclaim and taking its rightful place in the pantheon of the very greatest video games ever made. The next-generation of gaming had arrived, and you wouldn't even need a next-gen console to usher it in... The Reality: Watch Dogs finally hit stores in May of this year, and...it's just a good game. Far from the Earth-shatteringly unique sandbox title many were expecting, Ubisoft's latest was a curiously familiar action game that did enough to distinguish itself from the glut of GTA clones on the market, but suffered from a generic, even cliched storyline, woefully repetitive missions, and the general feeling that the game was never capable of living up to its tremendous hype. Was Watch Dogs a fun game to blast through? Sure, but from that first E3 trailer, we were expecting so much more, and the end result was a game we're in absolutely no rush to return to.

7. No Sequel For John - Red Dead Redemption

The Dream: John Marston, the steely outlaw protagonist of Rockstar's ridiculously entertaining wild-west romp, would get the Bureau of Investigation off his back, somehow take care of Edgar Ross and any other loose ends, and live to fight another day, because legends this awesome can't die, can they? The Reality: It appears they can. Red Dead Redemption ends with Marston sending his family away from the ranch moments before the BOI shows up for one final showdown with him. Though John takes as many of Ross' goons with him as he can, he's ultimately cut down by the sheer numbers game, and dies a brutal death. Sure, the epilogue sequence allows players to get revenge on Ross by playing as John's aged son Jack, but we spent the course of the game growing attached to John, only for any franchise potential to be completely wiped out at the end of the game. Of course, we'd play a sequel featuring a fully-grown Jack Marston, or even a prequel starring John himself, but it's a shame one of Rockstar's most bada** protagonists to date had to take a bullet (well, lots of them) at the eleventh hour.

6. The Joker Dies - Batman: Arkham City

The Dream: As The Joker told Batman in The Dark Knight, "I think you and I are destined to do this forever." The yin-and-yang hero-villain pairing are a perfectly opposed match, and as the Caped Crusader's most infamous and potent villain, Rocksteady will just keep bringing him back for a special appearance in every game, even if it's not as the main antagonist. The Joker is just too awesome to kill off. The Reality: We learn early on in Arkham City that the Titan formula is slowly killing The Joker, but we didn't for a second actually believe that he'd be killed off by it. After Batman cures himself at the end of the game and prepares to also cure The Joker, Jokes seals his own fate by attacking Batman, causing the antidote vial to smash, confining him to an unpleasant death as the sickness overcomes him. We get an awesome scene in which Bats carries The Joker's body out of Arkham City, but was it really worth killing the series' cash cow over? Smartly, the follow-up game (which wasn't created by Rocksteady, mind), Arkham Origins, was a prequel, so the Clown Prince of Crime was still able to make an appearance, yet with the impending Arkham Knight, a direct sequel to Arkham City, Rocksteady won't have the same luxury.

5. A Step Back - Grand Theft Auto IV

The Dream: Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas was a landmark title for the PS2, one that completely pushed the console to its limit, and so, imagine the possibilities of a GTA game on the new, shiny next-gen platforms. Given how huge, sprawling and absurdly time-consuming San Andreas was, Liberty City on the PS3 and Xbox 360 is surely going to be even bigger and better. The only way forward is up. The Reality: Though GTA IV released in 2008 to overwhelming critical acclaim, the gamer response was a little more mixed. Sure, the game boasted awesome graphics and arguably the best storyline of any GTA game up to that point, but didn't Liberty City just feel a little...empty? San Andreas had such a ridiculous amount of activities to take part in that GTA IV's more limited offerings stuck out like a sore thumb, and on top of this, the game's more serious tone just made it seem a lot less silly and fun compared to the mania of the previous title. At least, to their credit, Rockstar listened to gamers and delivered a significant improvement with last year's GTA V (even with the lack of Heists).

4. Three Colours Ending - Mass Effect 3

The Dream: After two incredible Mass Effect games, the third is going to tie together all of our crucial decisions throughout the game, delivering a unique, individual climax depending on the choices we as players made. BioWare have promised it, and there's no way they'd lie about such a huge selling point, surely? The Reality: Well, BioWare lied. In 2012, gamers everywhere smashed their keyboards to pieces after realising they'd been had. The end of Mass Effect 3 came down to picking one of three colours and crossing your fingers, leading to worldwide outrage online, to the point that BioWare released an Extended Cut ending in order to try and pacify p***ed off gamers everywhere. Though BioWare did to their credit try to fix the mess they'd made, it really wasn't good enough, as to implement their promises properly would have required a substantial re-build of the final hour of the game. Still, the mass anger towards BioWare has at least made it clear to them and other developers that they can't just phone it in and make false promises: they will be called out on it and suffer huge embarrassment as a result.

3. Still No Sign Of It - Half-Life 3

The Dream: After the brilliantly devastating cliffhanger of Half-Life: Episode Two, Valve would ultimately decide to forego an Episode Three and make Half-Life 3 a direct sequel to the game. After a lengthy 5-year wait, the game finally dropped in 2012 to universal critical acclaim, easily wiping the floor with every previous game in the series. The Reality: Not quite. It's almost 7 years since the devastating cliffhanger ending of Episode Two shocked us all, and we're still no closer to knowing a) when Half-Life 3 is being released and b) if it's even in development. Pretty much a month doesn't go by without some Internet trickster creating a hoax that, through sheer desperation, we all haplessly buy into, but in typical Valve fashion, they've kept their lips mostly zipped on the matter, and will presumably continue to do so until the game, assuming it's being made, is anywhere near ready. On one hand, at least Valve's approach won't keep continually letting us down with delay after delay, but would it kill Gabe Newell to just tell us that the game's being made or isn't? Knowing that it's a thing and it's happening would be enough, but instead, we're left totally in the dark, and as a huge fan of the series, it's painful. Either deliver the death blow or give us something to get excited about!

2. Aeris Dies - Final Fantasy VII

The Dream: Remember Aeris, that lovely young flower girl you meet early on in Final Fantasy VII? She's totally destined to fall in love with Cloud and marry him and have his babies for sure, right? Who needs that hussy Tifa? It's all about Aeris. The Reality: Of course, Aeris doesn't survive the events of Final Fantasy VII, taking a blade from Sephiroth in the game's most heartbreaking moment. It wasn't just that so many gamers foresaw Cloud and Aeris as lovers, but that Aeris was one of the game's most well-liked and innocent characters, and to see her cut down so brutally gave us all the motivation we needed to bring Sephie to his knees. We're not ashamed to say that of all the gaming deaths we've experienced over the years, this is the one that cuts the deepest. So desperate have gamers been to prevent Aeris' death that some have even used a Gameshark and other cheat devices to resurrect her into their party, though she only appears during battles and on the party screen. Rumours have persisted over the years that there's a legitimate way to revive her in the game, though these all appear to be wishful thinking.

1. Not Playing As Solid Snake - Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons Of Liberty

The Dream: The wait is over. Metal Gear Solid 2: Sons of Liberty is finally here, and we get to play as our favourite bada**, Solid Snake, once again. Gee, that Tanker section was really awesome...I can't wait to see what else Hideo Kojima has in store for Snake. It's going to rule. The Reality: After playing through the thrilling Tanker section of Sons of Liberty as Solid Snake, it seemed like MGS2 might truly be an action extravaganza capable of topping the brilliant original game, that is, until we realised we were going to spend the rest of the game playing as the white-haired, effeminate punk Raiden. Over a decade on, it still baffles gamers why Kojima would make such a counter-intuitive creative decision: players want to be Solid Snake, so let them be Solid Snake! That's why people bought the game, and pulling such a fast one on gamers by keeping the Raiden reveal so secret totally left us feeling deflated. Had Kojima at least done the honest thing and advertised Raiden's appearance, we wouldn't have felt quite so crushed, but of course, it's all about marketing and money, so why not just patently lie to your customers, right? Snake does admittedly appear throughout the game in not-so-subtle disguise as Raiden's buddy Iroquois Pliskin, but considering he's an unplayable character, it did little to soothe our wounds. Which video games totally crushed your dreams without mercy or compassion? Let us know in the comments!

In this post: 
Watch Dogs
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.