10 Video Games We Still Can't Believe Got Cancelled

Sadly, cancel culture isn't just for celebrity Twitter.

True Crime hong kong
United Front

Nowadays, when we hear about something being cancelled, we expect a story about a celebrity who had the audacity to write a drunken, edgy Tweet twelve years ago, only for it to ruin their career forever. Unfortunately, cancellations don’t just happen to these no-good scoundrels; they happen to our beloved video games as well.

It’s unlikely that a video game’s cancellation will be a result of it using the wrong pronouns in 2008, but there are still a variety of issues that can plague a game’s production. Lack of funding, publisher interference, poor receptions to early marketing and prolonged periods in Development Hell can all lead to a game’s eventual demise.

Regardless of the reason, video game cancellations are devastating for fans on the hype train. This is especially true when a game passes the ideas phase and enters into some stage of production. Arguably the most painful is when developers go as far as releasing a trailer for a soon-to-be-cancelled title.

Much like the time you told your partner you’d been working on your stamina and were ready for a long night of unforgettable passion, the announcements of these games were setting up nothing but disappointment.

10. InSane

Insane Del Toro Game
THQ

Famed director Guillermo del Toro was working on a survival-horror game with Volition and THQ back in 2010. This title was to be called inSane and made it far enough to have a 30 second teaser released before its cancellation in 2012.

According to del Toro, the game would be something new in terms of format and would leave players questioning their reality throughout. This could suggest that we were headed for a title similar to Amnesia, but with his weird and wonderful mind putting its own spin on it. Surely, this would have been enough to catch the attention of survival-horror fans worldwide?

There’s not a huge amount of information on why this game was cancelled, other than a brief statement from THQ, advising they were no longer supporting the product and had returned the rights to del Toro. However, given that THQ was liquidated the following year, it could be speculated that they were cutting any costs that weren’t absolutely essential at this time.

Guillermo del Toro does still own the IP for inSane, so the particularly optimistic of us could argue that it’s in Development Hell. The realists, however, will acknowledge that it’s been ten years now and it’s probably time to give up hope on this one.


9. True Crime: Hong Kong

True Crime Kick
Activision

Before you jump down our collective throats - yes, we know about Sleeping Dogs and yes, it’s a superb game.

With that out of the way, the disbelief when it comes to this entry is aimed toward Activision cancelling True Crime: Hong Kong in the first place. According to the game’s executive producer, True Crime was “playable from start to finish and virtually complete in terms of content” when Activision canned the project in 2011.

Although not the massive commercial success that similar games like GTA were at the time, True Crime still sold reasonably well and had garnered a cult following. The second title, True Crime: New York City, was criminally underrated (pun intended) and left committed fans yearning for more.

If Activision didn’t believe there was enough demand, they wouldn’t have agreed to publish a third game in the first place. Therefore, it’s odd that so far into production, the game was tossed out due to quality issues. Had developers been allowed the time to work out any kinks, using the True Crime title would likely have helped ship more units than Sleeping Dogs eventually did.

That said, the nine of us who did pick up Sleeping Dogs are eternally grateful to Square Enix for putting this awesome game out.


8. Fez II

Fez II
Polytron

The original Fez is nothing short of an incredible indie title. Somehow managing to revolutionise platforming games as late as 2012, its seamless transitioning between 2D and 3D, innovative gameplay mechanics and beautiful art style gained it many well-deserved rave reviews. The achievements made by such a small and low-budget studio like Polytron cannot be overstated.

So, with such a monumental success, Fez II was a guarantee, right?

Well, it was in production, but controversial designer of the original game, Phil Fish, just straight up rage-quit and cancelled the title after a series of public Twitter spats. Fish had a reputation for being vocal, angry at the industry, and difficult to work with. Shortly after an awkward podcast appearance and a Twitter argument with GameTrailers host, Marcus Beer, Fish Tweeted the following:

“im done. FEZ II is canceled. Goodbye”

Fish then proceeded to lock his account.

It’s a real shame that this happened, because Fish and his whole team had done a phenomenal job with their first title. It may have been wise to have someone more charismatic and with thicker skin be the face of Fez, whilst Fish remained doing what he did best and designing great titles. Unfortunately, it seems it’s too late for the Fez franchise.


7. Mega Man Universe

Mega Man Universe
Capcom

Capcom’s superstar, Mega Man, is a character with plenty of titles under his belt. Of course, being on this list, not all of his games have made it to the shelves. Mega Man Universe was an ambitious project that never got to see the light of day.

This innovative platformer was planned to follow the storyline of Mega Man 2, missing out any of the protagonist’s special abilities that we saw in more recent titles. The twist on this release was centred on level design and aesthetic, with a new 2.5D design and rendered graphics. The biggest change, however, was that players could now edit the existing levels as well as creating their own.

This game was also expected to include character customisation, with a variety of interchangeable skins and abilities. Much like with the massively popular Super Mario Maker series, players would be able to upload their levels to an online community, as well as playing through other user-made levels online.

Sadly, in late 2010, news around Mega Man Universe went dark, with Capcom releasing a statement confirming the cancellation in March of 2011 due to “various circumstances.” We can only assume they’re kicking themselves over this decision, given the success of Super Mario Maker four years later.


6. Aliens: Crucible

Aliens: Crucible
Obsidian

Despite having a name close enough to Aliens: Colonial Marines to make even the most hardened fans shudder, Aliens: Crucible had the potential to be a ground-breaking game for its time. Originally pitched by SEGA in 2006, the license was given to Obsidian Entertainment to create an RPG based in the Alien universe.

Obsidian are made up of the minds behind Fallout 1, 2, New Vegas and, most recently, The Outer Worlds. The point you should take from this is that they know how to make a great RPG. This particular project would have seen a crew of customisable characters attempting to survive a Xenomorph infestation on a large space colony.

Planned features included unique skills and abilities for different characters, a necessity for teamwork, multiple possible outcomes and endings, as well as perma-death for any unlucky crew members. The game would also feature a companion system, similar to a Fallout or Mass Effect title.

In early 2009, SEGA announced an indefinite suspension of Aliens: Crucible’s development, then officially announced its cancellation in June of the same year. Whilst no official reason was given, there was speculation that executives weren’t happy with the finished product.

Maybe there weren’t enough loot-boxes or surprise mechanics.


5. Metallica: The Game

Metallica Game Concept
Black Label Games

The title alone for Metallica: The Game should have been enough to make a massive profit. It’s a Metallica video game! Whilst the band did indeed get their own Guitar Hero title, alongside some of their music appearing in a Rock Band DLC, this particular game was a completely different idea.

Rather than being a rhythm game for you and your mates to shred some plastic guitars to, Metallica: The Game would be an open-world, driving and shooting based title that incorporated music and themes from the band’s catalogue. Beta gameplay footage of the planned 2005 title suggested we’d be getting something that resembled a Mad Max and Metallica crossover. (Again- HOW do you not release this game?!)

The game, also sometimes referred to as Damage Inc, was cancelled for unclear reasons near the end of 2004, after releasing a trailer and some early concept art. At one point, frontman James Hetfield suggested that it was being revisited for a PSP release, but this never came to fruition either.

How a concept like this, with the ability to rival a proper Half-Life 3 when it comes to hype, could still be doing a stint in Development Hell, is genuinely mind-boggling. Perhaps Slipknot could release a horror title to soften the blow?


4. Gotham By Gaslight

Batman Gotham By Gaslight
Warner Bros. Home Entertainment

Before Rocksteady blew everyone’s minds with their fantastic Arkham series, Batman had made an appearance in a multitude of different video games; some better than others. These ranged from platformers, to third-person action titles, to side-scrolling brawlers, to driving games, and even the odd Lego tie-in.

One game that astonishingly never saw the light of day was Gotham by Gaslight. Taking its story from the 1989 graphic novel of the same name, Gotham by Gaslight would have seen the Caped Crusader featuring in a detective story set in a steampunk version of Gotham in 1889.

Early footage showed the title to be another third-person action game with a focus on stealth, a slow-motion mechanic and numerous, not necessarily period-appropriate, gadgets at Batman’s disposal. Whilst basic, this footage was aesthetically pleasing, suggesting that the finished product would have been a beautiful game.

Sadly for fans of the bat, Day 1 Studios and THQ failed to secure the relevant rights from Warner Bros to release the game and the project was eventually abandoned. Much like with other games that THQ cancelled during this period, it wouldn’t be unreasonable to speculate that the company’s financial problems would have had an impact on this.


3. Silent Hills

Silent Hills
Konami

By now, most people know the infamous story behind the cancellation of Silent Hills, but that doesn’t make it any less painful.

Hideo Kojima and the previously mentioned Guillermo del Toro had been working on this ninth main-game instalment to the Silent Hill franchise, with Norman Reedus to be the face and voice of the protagonist. However, after a very public dispute with Konami, Kojima and a number of his staff left the company, with Konami cancelling the game in 2015.

The only remnants we have of Silent Hills is the stellar Playable Teaser (or PT) demo that was released for PlayStation 4 in 2014. The demo, in which you would repeatedly walk around a corridor in a creepy and subtly changing environment, had players sh*tting themselves world-over as they tried to avoid being stumbled upon by the house’s terrifying tenant, Lisa.

Konami even went as far as to take this demo off the PlayStation Store, meaning that, unless you downloaded it in 2014 and haven’t deleted it since, you cannot play PT. That is, unless you plan on scouring eBay for a console with the demo on its hard drive and price-tag scarier than the game itself.

Thanks for that one, Konami. We’re super stoked that Silent Hill is now a pachinko machine franchise instead.


2. Star Wars 1313

Star Wars 1313
LucasArts

Star Wars 1313 looked like it was going to be superb. LucasArts had planned for this to be a story-centric, third-person action game, based on the career of fan-favourite bounty hunter, Boba Fett. The title was originally announced at E3 2012, much to the glee of Star Wars fans everywhere.

This was yet another game on this list that made it far enough through development to tease us with trailers before its cancellation.

One of the most intriguing aspects of this potential game was the plan to give it a Mature rating. Given the plethora of family-friendly Star Wars products already in circulation at the time, a darker and more violent take on the source material was a hugely appealing prospect.

However, once Disney acquired the Star Wars franchise in 2013, production was frozen, with the final nail in the coffin being EA taking over the video game production helm from LucasArts. It was likely a mixture of Disney’s distaste for Mature ratings, alongside EA’s preference for continuously monetizable multi-player games that spelled the end for 1313.

That being said, with the recent successes of both Jedi: Fallen Order and The Mandalorian, maybe the project could be revisited… Please?


1. Agent

Rockstar Agent
Rockstar

Rockstar’s proposed title, Agent, was undoubtedly destined to be a smash hit. The concept sounded phenomenal. We’d take on the role of a secret intelligence agent, during the 1970s Cold War era, with Rockstar describing the story as “a paranoid journey into the world of counter-intelligence, espionage and political assassinations.”

Rockstar were also advertising the game as being developed by the people who brought us Grand Theft Auto. It’s a genuine struggle to think of who on earth wouldn’t want to play this. Spies? Check. The '70s? Check. Fantastic writers? Check.

So, what happened to this sure-fire winner? Probably Grand Theft Auto V, in the end.

Whilst Agent first began development in 2007, numerous issues around development of other titles, IP disputes, and lack of confidence from executives caused the PlayStation 3 exclusive to be delayed repeatedly. The real killer, however, would have been when team members were taken off the project to work on GTAV.

Between Grand Theft Auto IV and V, Rockstar developed two DLCs for IV, Chinatown Wars, Red Dead Redemption, LA Noire (with Team Bondi) and Max Payne 3. Since GTA V, we’ve only had Red Dead Redemption 2.

As the scale and popularity of these IPs increases, so does the workload required for developing them. This means that, for titles like Agent, they've probably been silently assassinated in a dark room.


Contributor
Contributor

Lvl 10 Maker of pro-gamer moves. Lvl 4 TV & Film critic. Lvl 69420 Sh*tposter. Lvl 1 Knowledge of Comics. Fantasy Football Extraordinaire. I don't know anything about wrestling. Please @ me- I have no friends.