10 Video Games Where Everyone Can Die

Games that let you end things with a bloodbath.

Until Dawn
Supermassive Games

One of the things that makes video games such a unique art form is the element of player choice. It's something that every dev team must take into account and ask themselves how long a leash they want the player to be on. Whether the game is a single straight path that the player has no influence over or a multi-branching path storyline where the player can influence every detail of the world.

In both categories, player agency must be considered, and as such, the natural conclusion of this is asking if you want to craft a game that looks at the player and asks "aren't you tired of being nice? Don't you just wanna go ape-sh*t?"

It's amazing how many games out there really do let you just kill everyone in the story. From choice-based games to straightforward narratives, there are a lot of game stories that can end in such a bloodbath that Hamlet would look at it and go "you know in hindsight, I got off pretty easy".

10. Ultima V

Ultima V
Origin Systems

Ultima V is one of the best examples of a true blue, old-school CRPG where one screw-up at the wrong point really can mess you up forever. Case in point, the infiltration into Lord Blackthorn's castle.

With Blackthorn having taken over all of Britannia and NOT being a total idiot about it, you learn that Blackthorn is keeping some vital McGuffins in his personal castle. First-time players proceed to then learn that getting caught is the absolute last thing they want to happen.

Blackthorn, you see, needs your character alive to learn some very powerful and dangerous magical mantras, but that doesn't mean he needs your friends. So, one by one, he places each of them beneath a guillotine and gives you every chance in the world to give him the mantra. And if you think that if you hold out just a bit longer, someone will save you? Sorry, that ain't how Ultima V plays.

One by one, if you don't hand over the mantras, all of your friends die forever. So maybe take off the hard-soled boots when infiltrating the dark lord's castle, yeah?


9. Final Fantasy Tactics

final fantasy tactics advance
Square Enix

With most games that include a permadeath system, usually, if the health bar hits zero, that character is DEAD, no ifs ands or buts. But Final Fantasy Tactics went in a more lenient direction. Not VERY lenient, granted, but lenient all the same.

Final Fantasy Tactics' permadeath works on a timer system. If a unit goes down, they're out of the fight. If you manage to get a phoenix down to them within three turns, that unit returns. If you don't, well, away that character goes.

This one is lower on the list due to the decent amount of time the player is given to undo the damage done, but suffice to say, if you aren't very good at turn-based strategy games, then you may end up losing all of your units, because this game WILL hold your feet to the fire on that one.


8. Majora's Mask

legend of zelda majora's mask
Nintendo

The "Bad Ending" has been a concept teasing at the back of the industry's mind ever since its inception. Sure there were text adventure games that had you die if you made the wrong decision, but one of the first examples of the player screwing up or sitting around twiddling their thumbs meaning the worst possible ending for everyone involved was Legend Of Zelda: Majora's Mask.

Majora's Mask tells you that in three days, the moon will fall on Clock Town, killing everyone there and, ya know, presumably everyone else because it's the bloody MOON. And the game lets you call its bluff on that one, running out the time until the final few hours when the moon finally comes down on everyone's heads and kills them all.

The most interesting part is how the mood of the townsfolk changes depending on how close to landfall the moon is. You wander around Clock Town, seeing the townsfolk all either go mad from terror at their inevitable doom, find some solace at the end, or remain in denial right up until impact.


7. Persona 4

persona 4
Atlus

Because of its time-based nature, where every dungeon is on a set time limit for when you can complete it before you get a bad ending, there are a lot of points in these games where a certain number of named characters die who were otherwise meant to live.

But the title of this list isn't "video games where SOME people die and other people play, I dunno, boggle or something" so that leaves just one bad ending out of the bunch: Persona 4's Fog Ending.

This is the ending you get when you take way too long with the second to last dungeon, where Adachi is bringing the fog down on Inaba and soon the rest of the planet. Failing to stop him in time means the TV and real worlds merge permanently and everyone dies.

And just in case you think the game is joking around with you on how bad this situation is, monsters will actually start appearing in Inaba as the days wind down. You even get to hear Naoto die a horrible, horrible death to the shadows over the phone in the final few days before everything ends. So that's nice.


6. Dragon Age: Origins

dragon age origins
Bioware

Dragon Age: Origins tells you on the back of the box that it's a dark fantasy story, and then spends the next 100 or so hours backing itself up.

This game is chock full of myriad different ways to screw over everyone you meet on your journey, including the poor sods who decided to travel with you. To the point where killing them can seem like a kindness. Don't get Zevran and Sten's friendship levels high enough, they'll straight up turn on you at the first opportunity. Try to poison the urn that holds the ashes of the nation's messiah figure, well you'll have to kill Leliana first. You can even side with the main human villain and chop off your best buddy Alistair's head.

And if you think the dastardly, manipulative mage Morrigan is exempt from this, check out the expansion pack Witch Hunt and you can stab her with a knife if you so choose. Or if you think this doesn't quite cover "everyone" to your liking, another expansion to this game lets you play as the darkspawn and overwhelm Ferelden completely.


5. Fire Emblem: Awakening

fire emblem awakening
Nintendo

Frankly, I could've put any of the Fire Emblem games here, I could even have put them in every slot on this list, seeing as how permadeath has always been both the series' defining gimmick and the millstone around its neck. But Awakening serves as a good representation of the series, so it gets the spotlight.

Fire Emblem is a tactics-based RPG where your "party" can consist of dozens upon dozens of different characters. To make things interesting, then, the series implemented a system that would attract a dedicated hardcore fanbase and scare off literally everyone else: unforgiving permadeath. If a character dies, that's the end of it. No matter how important they are, if you screw up, the story continues without them.

Awakening and games after it gained fame by giving players the option to turn permadeath off, but just looking at the ridiculous number of characters on standby in the easy mode serves as a constant reminder that the game had planned for you to have lost a lot of people by then.


4. Fallout: New Vegas

Fallout New Vegas
Obsidian

Bethesda games let you get away with killing a lot of people, but in Fallout 3, if you kill someone too important - the game will let you - but it will tell you that you are now playing a dead save file that can't progress anymore. Other characters - like the Brotherhood of Steel members - just shrug bullets off and get back up.

By contrast, when you kill someone too important in Fallout: New Vegas, it tells you nothing. Because the game doesn't care.

You wanna sneak into Caesar's camp and assassinate the main villain the second you're able to? Go right ahead. You wanna do the same for the leader of the NCR? Have fun. You wanna do both AND kill Mr. House, the Brotherhood of Steel, the Followers of the Apocalypse, and every person stupid enough to get in your way? God speed you bloody psychopath!

Fallout: New Vegas drops you into this world with nothing but the clothes on your back and whatever ridiculous mods you loaded in with you, and tells you to have fun. And if that means reducing this already barren wasteland to a somehow even more barren crater? All the more power to you.


3. Until Dawn

Until Dawn Emily Wendigo
Supermassive

It's honestly shocking to me that Telltale-style games had been around for almost a decade before someone finally decided to say "hey this would make for a sick as hell slasher game!"

Until Dawn centers on a group of friends being trapped up in the mountains with a pack of angry and VERY hungry Wendigos. It's up to the player to decide how many, if indeed, any of our helpless victims make it out alive.

Until Dawn is very much not kidding with this aspect, ANYONE can die in this story, and there are multiple death flags for each character that the player needs to watch out for. There are no do-overs if a character dies, you just gotta keep moving and hope you save the next one that's in danger.

This merciless attitude towards the peril its characters are in makes the game all the more harrowing to play, and every screw up feels all the more painful because of it.


2. Mass Effect 2

Mass effect 2
Bioware

When you have a game whose final mission is literally named The Suicide Mission, you had better have the stones to back that up.

Mass Effect 2 starts with Shepard being brought back to life after the bad guys shoot him into the cold vacuum of space, with the sole purpose of defeating the Reapers' latest cronies, The Collectors. This requires going into a section of the galaxy that no one has ever gone to before, with one ship and no backup, and take on - presumably - an entire race of highly effective killing machines.

Yeah, if you don't get your squad shaped up, get the right upgrades to your ship, and choose your tactics wisely when the time comes, you can get every member of one of the best RPG casts ever created killed. Some of them dying in the most horrifying ways imaginable.

Mass Effect 2 is one of the best RPGs ever made, due almost entirely to its willingness to hold the players' feet to the fire.


1. I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream

I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream Bad Ending
Cyberdreams

One would struggle to craft something optimistic out of anything Harlan Ellison wrote, let alone his best know work, one of - if not the bleakest work in science fiction: I Have No Mouth And I Must Scream. So the makers of the game adaptation decided to, well, not even try.

In this game, we meet AM - The Allied Mastercomputer, which has wiped out pretty much all of the human race - and his favorite playthings, the five remaining members of the human race. AM has been viciously torturing them for the past several hundred years but decides to switch things up. He tells them that if they pass a trial carefully made for each of them, he will grant them that greatest mercy of all: the right to finally kill themselves. If they fail, he gets to subject them to a fate somehow worse than either death or the torture he had subjected them to for his own amusement.

No matter how this game ends, it always has the characters dying. Whether by their own hands, finally getting to put AM on ice and set the stage for the human race to repopulate Earth, or being malformed by AM into an ungodly abomination of pain and misery for all eternity. This isn't just a game where everyone CAN die, this is a game where everyone WILL die.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

John Tibbetts is a novelist in theory, a Whatculture contributor in practice, and a nerd all around who loves talking about movies, TV, anime, and video games more than he loves breathing. Which might be a problem in the long term, but eh, who can think that far ahead?