10 Video Games With Incredible Stories But Terrible Gameplay
It's worth suffering through The Last Guardian's infuriating gameplay for its beautiful story.
Though video games are the result of numerous artistic disciplines working in glorious tandem, it's fair to say that most players put a premium on two things above most others: story and gameplay.
Given that games are still a relatively "immature" medium compared to books, movies, and TV, it's little surprise that players are used to forgiving games for having less-than-stellar stories if the core gameplay is a blast.
But less-common is the opposite, where a game's story is so wonderfully engaging even while the gameplay itself isn't really fun at all.
Yet it certainly happens, typically where a developer has a keen eye for atmosphere and narrative yet lacks the follow-through to wrap a satisfying gameplay loop around it.
Sometimes the story is fantastic enough to carry the game to success regardless, while in other cases the gameplay is such a damn trainwreck that the title hasn't ever risen above cult classic status.
While these games all featured unappealing gameplay defined by glitches, repetition, and jank, their stories were so damn thrilling, emotional, and overall entertaining that it was (mostly) worth going along for the ride...
10. To The Moon
2011's adventure-drama To the Moon is often held up as boasting one of the most creative and emotionally impactful stories in the history of video games.
And while the particulars are best left unspoiled, the spine of the story involves two doctors who administer "wish fulfilment" to dying people by creating artificial memories in their minds.
Across just four hours, To the Moon tells a devastating, one-of-a-kind tale of love, mortality, memory, and regret with a level of maturity and psychological plausibility rarely seen in games.
It's just a shame that, as a traditional game, To the Moon isn't really up to much at all. In fact, at times it feels less like a video game than a visual novel, albeit without any major sense of choice.
Gameplay is largely limited to walking around and interacting with people, and even the few puzzles are so hilariously easy as to be completely trivial.
But what qualifies To the Moon's gameplay as terrible is the frustrating abundance of glitches throughout: it's possible to get stuck in the game's geometry at various points, enough that you may not even be able to continue playing.
As such, it's a relief that the game's play-time is so short. If To the Moon were, say, 10 or 20 hours long, players might be decidedly less forgiving of its leaden, clunky gameplay.
9. Uncharted: Drake's Fortune
This one's bound to ruffle some feathers alright.
Though the Uncharted sequels are all renowned for both their compelling stories and slickly cinematic gameplay, the original game is considerably more uneven.
Naughty Dog's franchise starter certainly offers up a thrillingly Indiana Jones-inspired story and instantly endears us to the pairing of Nate and Sully, but the gameplay? Not that great. Not that good, even.
Even upon release in 2007, many criticised the wonky shooting, imprecise platforming, uninteresting puzzles, and worst of all, those horrendous jet-ski sequences.
While some labelled the original Uncharted a generic yet entertaining romp, considering the massive strides the sequels all made, it seems considerably worse in retrospect.
The tedious, relentless gunfights and just generally not-good feel of controlling Nate got the franchise off to a dodgy start - a boring yet good-looking game that was fortuitously tethered to great characters and a riveting story.
8. Persona 2: Innocent Sin
The Persona 2 duology - consisting of Innocent Sin and Eternal Punishment - are a rather unsung pair of games compared to their more feted sequels.
Eternal Punishment was however broadly praised for improving upon Innocent Sin's flaws, the most glaring of which is that it's just a damn tedious chore to get through.
Everything in the game - especially the combat - takes far too long to do, and for anyone coming to the game today after having played the later entries in the series, there's no way for it to not seem excruciatingly quaint.
It's a shame, though, as Innocent Sin's story is one of the series' best and most original, abetted by a bevy of delicious twists and a memorable, likeable cast of characters. It's just heightened enough to be unforgettable and interesting, yet not enough that it goes totally off the rails.
But alas, the core gameplay is so freaking mundane you couldn't be blamed for watching a Let's Play like a visual novel and scrubbing past the dishwater-dull combat.
7. Soma
Soma is an extremely moody survival horror game best remembered for its deeply unnerving, mysterious narrative, in which protagonist Simon Jarrett slowly comes to learn the jaw-dropping nature of his presence at an underwater, remote research facility.
The story packs quite the visceral punch, especially once all the cards have been played at game's haunting end, yet the narrative is wrapped around a perfunctory, low-effort gameplay loop.
Exploring the facility to gradually uncover clues about your predicament is fine enough, but developers Frictional Games decided to pad things out with tedious enemy encounters.
The hide-and-seek stealth gameplay manages to be both boring and frustrating, as though Frictional felt they had to include these mechanics to make the game more appealing to those who would otherwise dismiss it as a "walking simulator."
In fact, the pushback against the enemy design was prominent enough that Frictional eventually released a "Safe Mode" update, which stopped the game's monsters from killing the player, allowing them to just focus on the infinitely more compelling story.
6. Mass Effect
The series went to bigger and better places in later entries, but there's no denying the brilliance of the original Mass Effect.
BioWare's sci-fi RPG pulled off the daunting task of introducing us to a galaxy's worth of instantly fascinating characters while weaving a rich story tapestry that was genuinely gripping, heartfelt, and at times even hilarious.
There's certainly an argument to be made that the original Mass Effect has the best, tidiest story of the four mainline games, focused more explicitly on world-building and character, and letting its plot unfold in a more organic way than any of its successors. Plus, Saren is just an awesome villain.
Yet the original Mass Effect falls down hard where gameplay is concerned, and is undoubtedly the franchise-worst in this regard.
The combat feels clunky and unrefined compared to what came later, the Mako sections are a bore, the UI and controls are a mess, and it's packed to the gills with frustrating glitches.
Pretty much everything about its gameplay was improved upon in the sequels, and though last year's Legendary Edition certainly made revisiting the first Mass Effect more appealing, the gameplay framework still feels rather dated.
5. Deadly Premonition
Depending on who you ask, Deadly Premonition is either an amazing game or an absolute, fiery trainwreck. But consider this - what if it's both?
Released in 2010, this open world survival horror game channels the same manic, anything-goes energy of Twin Peaks, similarly following an FBI Agent as he investigates the murder of a young woman.
As a piece of pure storytelling, Deadly Premonition is wonderfully campy and bizarre: a willfully heightened slice of throw-everything-at-the-wall insanity packed with gut-bustingly funny dialogue.
It is, in all of its eccentricity, infinitely more memorable and entertaining than the generic narratives of a dozen considerably more polished AAA games.
But let's be clear - the gameplay surrounding the story makes for a miserable experience. Even if you can forgive the muddy graphics and terrible soundtrack, the tank-like controls are agonising, the combat sucks, and the open world design makes it a frequent slog.
Thankfully a large portion of the game's play-time is comprised of story-driven cutscenes, which are far and away the real reason to play Deadly Premonition.
If any video game can be compared to The Room in the so-bad-it's-good stakes, Deadly Premonition is it, even if the story is genuinely engaging and enjoyable in its own right.
4. Silent Hill 4: The Room
Silent Hill 4: The Room is in many respects the black sheep of the mainline series, because it opted to deviate from the firmly cemented style of the original survival horror trilogy for something markedly different.
For starters, it literally moved away from Silent Hill and was set primarily in the city of Ashfield, with protagonist Henry Townshend's apartment serving as a hub (and the game's only save point) which players could explore from a first-person perspective.
The series' iconic, often infamously challenging puzzles were also massively toned down in favour of a greater emphasis on combat, and many fans and critics were vocally critical of the game's second half, defined by repeated environments and a prolonged escort mission.
None of this is wrong at all - indeed, Silent Hill 4's gameplay pales vastly compared to the first three games, enough that even many hardcore fans struggled to get through it.
But the story gets much closer to the all-timer quality of Silent Hill 2 than most will freely admit. It's certainly more disturbing, in large part due to the unexpectedly fleshed-out characterisation of the game's antagonist, undead serial killer Walter Sullivan.
Combined with the series' typically first-rate atmospheric design, Silent Hill 4 is a mesmerising experience albeit one constantly at odds with its lackluster, often exasperating gameplay.
3. Planescape: Torment
Planescape: Torment is in many respects the poster child of "great story, trash gameplay."
Black Isle Studios' legendary RPG is renowned for its extremely intricate, well-written story courtesy of the brilliant Chris Avellone, whereby practically every named character you encounter in the world is worth talking to.
The ambition and detail of its narrative is totally unmatched by its thoroughly staid gameplay, then, where combat is trivial to the point of tedium, and the only gameplay aspect that fully engages is the actual dialogue itself (which, it can be argued, scarcely passes for gameplay in the traditional sense).
Even at the time of its 1999 release, Planescape: Torment's gameplay was considered half-baked at best, yet propped up by a story that remains one of the most expertly crafted in the history of the medium.
Though 2017's enhanced version made the eyesore of a UI more appealing to look at, the gameplay was left largely unchanged, drawing only further attention to how horribly dated it is. Again, though, killer storytelling.
2. The Last Guardian
The Last Guardian was finally, finally released in 2016 after countless agonising delays, and though in many respects it's a beautiful game with a tender, minimalist story about the bond between a boy and his gigantic, bird-like companion, the gameplay sure is like pulling teeth.
Even those who harbour a real love for the game will freely admit that the gameplay is clunky at best. In attempting to make the focal creature, Trico, behave like a "realistic" animal, his AI routines are infuriatingly unpredictable for anyone trying to, you know, beat the game.
If you've played the game, you'll likely remember struggling to direct Trico to do what you need him to in order to complete a puzzle. This often results in seemingly simple sequences taking far longer than they should to complete.
It's like wading through treacle at the worst of times - you go nowhere fast, and it's all because the game's "fluid" AI is fundamentally busted.
Though the developers deserve praise for the game's richly crafted world and wonderful low-key narrative, the frustrating, undercooked gameplay is a major step down from predecessor Shadow of the Colossus.
1. Rule Of Rose
Even die-hard fans of cult classic survival horror game Rule of Rose won't say much to defend its core gameplay, because players and critics alike are pretty much united in praising its story and atmosphere while dog-piling on its clumsy, uninvolving gameplay.
Rule of Rose is set in 1930s England and follows 19-year-old Jennifer, who becomes trapped in a strange world ruled by young girls and attempts to recover the memories from her forgotten past.
From a narrative perspective, it's absolutely riveting - as a study of trauma and abuse, it felt years ahead of most other genre entries when it released in 2006.
Yet the mainstream media of the time predictably latched onto its mature, boundary-pushing content and made outlandish claims that it contained underage eroticism.
Beyond its story, though, Rule of Rose is a much rougher ride: the melee-based combat is a janky, unwieldy mess and there's an egregious amount of backtracking, with both issues being further exacerbated by rancid controls and unhelpful camera angles.
It is a quintessential game worth experiencing even if you might not actually want to play it. Considering that director Shuji Ishikawa himself called it "essentially an interactive movie," he probably wouldn't mind all that much if you just watched a Let's Play on YouTube.