10 Video Games With The Biggest Downgrade From Reveal To Launch
Downgrades are commonplace, and these are the worst offenders.
E3 is always a magical time of year. At some point during the week-long event, we're guaranteed to see a brand new game shown off for the first time. It will look absolutely glorious with realistic lighting, dynamic weather, mind-blowing animations, and graphics that look so good and crisp, you'd think they weren't real.
And that's just the problem - they're not.
At this point in development, what's being shown off is more of a "vertical slice" of the full release. However, that slice gets polished to the nth degree, and the team can't recreate that for the entire game within the release window.
Now, to be fair to the developers, this issue usually doesn't come from a place of deception, but more the want to put together a demo or trailer for E3 that aims to represent the final product.
Should developers stop doing this? 100%. But you can't blame them for wanting to make the best possible version of the game they're creating. There's also the rare occasion where we can celebrate titles like God of War, Spider-Man or Red Dead Redemption 2 that end up looking even better than what we saw first.
With all that out of the way though, let's take a look at the worst offenders.
10. Anthem
Anthem has been dragged across the coals for a lot of reasons since it launched, from a dearth of content to long loading screens, but graphics have not been one of the issues.
That is, until you go back to the E3 2017 reveal trailer.
Bioware showcased a bustling Fort Tarsis with incredible lighting and lots of NPCs. Those NPC's were moving around, talking to each other... living, essentially. In the final product, Fort Tarsis is a dull, uninspired hub area with a handful of NPC's that only spring to life when you hit a button to interact.
Then there's the open world; massive and jaw-droppingly gorgeous with giant AT-AT-like machines, hordes of creatures, striking landscapes, and vast underwater areas worth exploring. What we actually got was a good looking game with a less alive world, no active mechs, downsized landscapes, and no underwater areas worth talking about.
And that's not even taking into account things like animated load screens that were removed, more dynamic monsters, and a larger landmass. Anthem has a lot of gameplay issues that absolutely warrant the criticisms thrown at it, but that shouldn't mean its big graphical downgrade gets a pass.
9. Rainbow Six Siege
Siege's reveal at E3 was one that showcased an incredible, tense multiplayer shooter in claustrophobic environments. It looked remarkably cinematic with realistic player movements, and environments with spectacular lighting and destructive environments. The released version of the game though, was a lot less impressive.
Rainbow Six: Siege is pretty much just another first-person shooter but inside confined environments with more tactics and a handful of unique gameplay mechanics. Gone were the lifelike player movements, the realistic lighting and the eye-catching effects.
There was also downgrades in regards to the intro to each map, with the trailer showcasing an exciting helicopter drop-in sequence that never made it to the final game, and the enemies boarding up windows that are automatically boarded up at the start of each level.
Initially, the game tasked one set of players as playing as terrorists, with the other are a special forces unit. The retail version scrapped the terrorist angle, seemingly to avoid any minimal controversy. Also gone are the interactive hostages who were well designed, the dynamic smoke, debris and spark effects, and more.
The current retail version of the game looks and plays fine but lest we forget the very noticeable downgrades between reveal and release.
8. The Witcher 3
This is the one game on this list that is sure to ruffle some feathers. And that's because the released version of The Witcher 3 looked amazing. However, there's no denying that it was a far cry from the epic trailers we saw before launch.
If we take a walk back in history to 2013, we'll find the first gameplay trailer for The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt. We know now that trailer was a mixture of CGI and gameplay because it looks infinitely better than the final product.
We see Geralt riding Roach between trees with jaw-dropping weather effects, a more action-oriented camera angle, a burning village with vastly more realistic fire effects. And then there's CGI made to look like gameplay, and cinematic fights scenes with more animated monsters.
There's plenty of downgraded effects in The Witcher 3, from textures to weather to combat, but the biggest downgrade appears to be in the overall cinematic nature of the game. The way Geralt moves in the actual game is borderline janky, while the trailers make him look smooth and lifelike. And honestly, there are worst example of this than the reveal trailer, as you'll see in the video above.
Good as the game may be, there's no denying the big downgrades between that pre-release trailers and the product that released in 2015.
7. Watch Dogs
Often the poster-child for graphical downgrades; Watch Dogs was actually the first game we ever seen for PS4 and Xbox One and we knew something was a little fishy. The game suffered a substantial graphical downgrade from reveal to release, but it's far from the worst offender - even from Ubisoft!
The 2012 reveal trailer showed Aiden Pearce walking down a beautiful Chicago street with mesmerising clothing, wind, and lighting effects. While the released version had virtually no wind, overtly downgraded lighting, and less impressive clothing; ; sure Aiden's coat still sways while he runs, but it lacked the same oomph.
We also saw Pearce in a firefight between cars and use a focus-mode slowdown that evoked The Matrix. While the final product had the focus mode slowdown, its visual effects were entirely altered.
There are several more examples like this in Watch Dogs, with overall lighting being a big issue, and NPC's looking much less life-like. The resulting product was one that obviously had been downgraded, but probably less so than you remember.
Watch Dogs was a good game that was rightfully criticised for its bland protagonist and unexciting world, but in 2013 it still looked pretty damn good.
6. The Divsion
The Division released in 2016 and was Ubisoft's first real attempt to jump on the games-as-a-service bandwagon. While it suffered the usual rocky launch and went through plenty of growing pains, the team managed to turn it into one of the better live services games around.
Let's go back to when the game was revealed, to a 2013 trailer that borderline blew minds.
The reveal began with a CGI trailer of a snowy, desolate New York City, then transitioned into gameplay of a Division agent who opened up a unique map that, rather than going to a menu screen, actually sprawled around the player within the game. The agent then met-up with a couple more players and went to an NYPD precinct for a mission.
Here we see a shootout that leaves reactive holes in police cars, gorgeous lighting effects, and the agent using a wrist watch as his menu. The agents work their way inside the precinct where we see more jaw-dropping lighting, none of which was in the final product.
The Division launched 3 years after that trailer and was missing several features, much of the dynamic lighting, and featured a less detailed New York. Without doubt one of Ubisoft's worst downgrades.
5. Mass Effect: Andromeda
Prior to release, we saw precious little footage of Mass Effect: Andromeda in action. From the initial reveal in an E3 dev diary, to the first CGI trailer in 2015, to the gameplay reveal a year later; we should have realised there was an issue. We assumed EA was simply taking a new approach of staying tight-lipped and holding its cards close. The reality, however, was that Mass Effect: Andromeda was a hot, steaming mess and EA was hiding it.
The reveal trailer showed off multiple planets with insane geographies, ecosystems, and bustling societies. What we got however were rather lifeless, mundane planets, that were not so much exciting as they were flat-out boring. It also showed some beautiful character models that ended up being far less expressive in the actual game, except for when their rubber faces were breaking.
There's so much wrong with Mass Effect: Andromeda that one could pick it apart all day. We all know the trials and tribulations the game went through, both during development and post-release, and the result was a permanent stain on the BioWare name.
That's beating the proverbial dead horse, especially when it's much more hip to be beating on Anthem's weary corpse right now. Oh BioWare, how the mighty has fallen.
4. Dark Souls II
Dark Souls II is, without doubt, the red-headed step-child of the Souls series. It lacked the punch any sequel should have, both in a lack of innovation and a graphical downgrade that was impossible not to notice.
The first trailers for Dark Souls II showed a game that looked next-gen with its evocative lighting, both in the open world and in the castle environments. However, what were atmospheric locales with shadows and dynamic fire lighting in trailers, were dull ones with jagged edges, poor textures, and virtually lifeless lighting effects in the released game.
Dark Souls II went from looking like a next-gen game to a very average PS3/360 one. Even the enhanced version of Dark Souls II on PS4 and Xbox One, released a year later, didn't feature anywhere near the visuals of the original trailer. Something clearly happened during development that forced FromSoftware's hand to rush the product. All of this is compounded when compared to the still-gorgeous Bloodborne that came out just two years later.
FromSoftware got something of a pass with this hiccup, but some companies wouldn't be so lucky. Everyone knows the Dark Souls series is renowned for being painstaking in its difficulty, but this instalment was also pretty painful to look at.
3. No Man's Sky
No Man's Sky deserves credit for turning around a ship that many deemed a lost cause. However the reason that was ship was deemed so, was the failure to deliver the gargantuan promises made by the trailers prior to release.
Infamously promising a universe of infinite planets with diverse geography, fauna, life and everything in between, we were shown a beautiful planet, lots of organisms, including a giant lockneck dinosaur and a rhino rampaging and knocking down trees. The player then hopped in their jet, shot off into space and engaged in a dog fight with other ships, before chasing them down onto a new planet and blasting them into pieces.
In case you're unaware, the game that released two years later was pretty much nothing like that. Sure there were planets with fauna and dinosaurs...but the dinosaurs looked janky af; the planets were far less alive; you couldn't engage in random faction wars in space; you couldn't continue that fight onto a new planet; etc., etc.
The promise of infinite planets became meaningless because those planets were essentially palette swaps of one and other. There was no reason to explore and that was kinda the point. Oh well, it's pretty good now.
2. Aliens: Colonial Marines
Aliens: Colonial Marines was, arguably, the first mis-step in the long, drawn-out downfall of Gearbox Software. The game looked incredibly scary and atmospheric in trailers, but upon release it was a buggy mess that turned out more funny than it was scary.
To be fair to Gearbox, development on Colonial Marines was conducted by several different studios between 2007 and its 2013 release, so blame cannot solely fall on the shoulders of Randy Pitchford and co. That said, Gearbox is to blame for the misleading reveal trailers that resulted in lawsuits for false advertising.
As is seemingly customary with game downgrades, the lighting was a major factor in Colonial Marines. The initial trailer showed a gorgeous space station with shadows that added to the atmosphere and tension. It showed action scenes with far more emphatic effects and cinematic gameplay than those of the actual release.
There are dozens of examples of poor lighting, awful AI, missing features, untextured environments, and laughable character models. The funniest thing about Colonial Marines however is that all of the broken AI was down to one spelling error in the code. That wouldn't have saved the game or made up for the misleading graphics, but it sure makes for one great anecdote.
1. Killzone 2
Killzone 2 is still the most ludicrous example of graphical downgrading, however it wasn't even really downgraded at all.
You see, Killzone 2 was shown-off at E3 2005 as a PS3 game, and yet its animations are beyond even current possibilities. That's not hyperbole, the trailer was a gross exaggeration of graphics, animations, and gameplay that wouldn't even be possible for many years to come.
The trailer showed impressive character models heading into a battle with Helghan soldiers that is incredibly explosive and chaotic, with truly lifelike character animations. The trailer suggested lots of squad-based and cinematic gameplay, unlike anything ever seen at the time. The released product was much more of a streamlined FPS with standard mechanics, no squads, and nothing even close to the same animations.
It was clear the trailer featured no actual gameplay at all, therefore no actual downgrade occurred. It was a CGI trailer portrayed as actual gameplay, and that's really not OK.
Guerrilla Games studio founder Herman Hulst said that the team put together the trailer as a proof of concept, based on the capabilities of the PS3. The concept was never meant to be shown to the public but ended up there anyhow. At least the same mistake was not made with Horizon: Zero Dawn.