10 Video Games With The Worst Enemy A.I.

When the enemy is somehow dumber than a brick.

aliens colonial marines
Gearbox

AI is one of those things in video games you probably won't pay much attention to unless it's done incredibly or, more likely, horribly.

Simulating the behaviours of an actual, living thing is an extremely challenging task for video game developers, such that games that make strident leaps in AI programming - such as Halo: Combat Evolved, F.E.A.R., and Alien: Isolation - are desperately few-and-far-between.

And while there's an argument to be made that excessively smart AI enemies actually aren't very fun to play against, some games simply dumb-down the player's adversaries to the point that it comes across as lazy.

These 10 video games, from critically acclaimed blockbusters to more low-key budget titles, all offered up antagonist AI that didn't cut the mustard.

In some cases the developers promised state-of-the-art AI that they just couldn't deliver, while elsewhere it's clear that believably sentient, self-preserving meat shields weren't on the team's priority list.

In some cases it ruins the combat by rendering enemies trivial and boring to fight, while in a select few instances the game is still enjoyable enough to overcome its obvious developmental shortcomings...

10. Crysis 2

Crysis 2
Crytek

Nothing will put critics and players alike on the back foot more than a game that over-promises and under-delivers, and at least in the AI department, that's Crysis 2 in a nutshell.

In the lead-up to the sci-fi shooter's 2011 release, Crytek promised that Crysis 2 would feature "the most advanced AI system" seen in any video game, with enemy combatants being "truly intelligent, thinking, fair enemies" who would continually adapt to player behaviour.

Despite these lofty claims, Crysis 2's AI is arguably even worse than the original game's widely-ridiculed enemy programming, largely because it's so maddeningly erratic and inconsistent.

Enemies will often fail to put up any sort of meaningful fight against you, running out of cover directly into your gunfire and getting stuck on walls.

Yet in ranged combat they'll often be able to detect you with a jarringly pin-sharp accuracy, and on occasion you might even get shot through a wall for no apparent reason. It all makes for a wildly frustrating and uneven experience.

Sadly the recent Crysis 2 remaster failed to fix the garbage AI, which is infinitely more irritating because the developer was so confident in their own brilliance, and it somehow regressed back past the previous game.


9. Anthem

Anthem Game
BioWare

Bad AI was certainly the least of Anthem's problems on launch, though considering that the janky enemy AI had been flagged by players in beta tests, it was a shame to see so few improvements made for the full release.

It's bizarrely common to see enemies, particularly the Scars, simply standing around and doing nothing while you fire upon them.

And even when they do spot you they don't reliably seek cover or fight back, and can even run right past the player who is standing in plain sight.

It'd be hilarious were Anthem not a massively expensive AAA project that spent years and years in development. For it to tout such elementary, at times scarcely existent AI was merely another addition to its long list of embarrassing misfires.

BioWare clearly tried to compensate for their vegetative AI by simply throwing a sheer mass of enemies at you instead, but it's a laughably obvious tactic that doesn't distract at all from the glaring AI programming issues.

Bullet sponge enemies in looter-shooter games are nothing new, but it's reasonable for players to expect much more from mega-budget games employing hundreds of talented people.


8. Far Cry

Far Cry 4
Ubisoft

Far Cry may be one of the most popular open-world FPS franchises on the market, and yet, some six mainline games and almost 20 years into the franchise Ubisoft still hasn't figured out how to produce even remotely believable AI.

The original game infamously featured a glitch which allowed enemy soldiers to shoot through tents, a glitch that wasn't officially fixed for an entire 13 years.

Yet even as the sequels have become more advanced and expansive, the AI has remained largely braindead, with enemy combatants standing out in the open and freely allowing you to take pot shots at them, like movie goons waiting for their cue to fall down.

Even in the more recent fifth and sixth games, your opponents won't take cover or employ basic expected flanking manoeuvres.

It's entirely possible to kill a soldier's friend without them noticing or reacting, and even if they do spot you, they'll give up the hunt in record time.

For a series that's endured so impressively over nearly two decades, it's shocking how few improvements its AI has made.


7. Days Gone

Days Gone
Sony Bend

Days Gone is very far from being a perfect game, but it at least captures the pulse-quickening thrill of taking on voluminous fleets of the zombie-like Freakers.

Though the Freaker AI is relatively decent for the most part, the game stumbles hard where its human enemies are concerned.

The human adversaries you'll encounter are usually supernaturally oblivious to your presence, such that unless you cause a major disturbance they won't see your attacks coming. Hell, they might even walk past the corpses of their friends without kicking up a fuss at all.

And even when they spot you, it's hilariously easy to hide in the environment and avoid their horribly-aimed gunfire, especially at night where they can't see you three feet in front of their face.

At least the Freakers have an excuse, being mutant cannibals and all, but most of the human combatants only fare marginally better during combat. At least it's funny, but in a game that's trying to create a genuinely tense atmosphere that's unfortunate.


6. Aliens: Colonial Marines

Aliens Colonial Marines
Gearbox

Almost a decade after its release, we're still harping on about how crushingly disappointing Aliens: Colonial Marines was - a game that should've been the definitive video game embodiment of James Cameron's Aliens, but instead felt more like a straight-to-VOD knock-off.

Players could've forgiven the light story and underwhelming visuals if it nailed the atmosphere of the Alien movies, and in particular the sweaty-palmed fear of facing off against the Xenomorphs.

Instead, the Xeno AI was by far the most common complaint about the entire game, that these digital approximations of the iconic aliens didn't behave anything like the Xenomorphs from the movies.

Rather than cunningly stalking players and their squad-mates, the aliens would just rush blindly into firefights, ensuring they could be easily melted by your vast array of weaponry.

That wasn't all, though: sometimes the Xenos wouldn't respond to you at all, immediately annihilating the player's entire sense of immersion.

Hilariously, a modder discovered in 2018 that the janky AI was actually due a typo in the game's code. Upon fixing the mistake, the AI was significantly improved, with the Xenomorphs actually flanking the player and deploying some manner of defensive capability.

Still, 2018 was many, many years after most everybody had written Colonial Marines off and basically forgotten it ever existed, so it was certainly too little, too late.


5. Mario Kart

Mario Kart 8 Blue Shell
Nintendo

As fun as playing any Mario Kart game with friends is, it's a whole other ball game taking on human rivals.

The series uses rubber-banding mechanics to both close the gap between you and PCU racers, and also give those near the back of the pack a greater likelihood of receiving an advantageous item.

As such, it's no coincidence that the CPU racers have an over-the-odds tendency to pick up blue shells whenever you, the human player, slides into first place.

The intent is obviously to ensure the player can't just relentlessly thrash the competition and sail through every race, but it can often result in players basically being excessively punished for, you know, being really good at the game.

Over the years there have been countless deep-dive investigations into Mario Kart's infuriatingly lopsided "cheating" AI, which while arguably embodying the random chaos of life itself, actually makes the game a lot less fun and chill.


4. Daikatana

Daikatana game
Ion Storm

Much like Crysis 2, Daikatana catches more flak because the game was released on a platform of such unflappable confidence, what with its infamously audacious marketing claiming, "John Romero's about to make you his b*tch."

But Daikatana was a big 'ol dud from first moment to last, pilloried by critics for its outdated graphics, boring repetitive gameplay, and yes, its execrable, unforgiveable AI for both sidekicks and enemies alike.

Enemy combatants will generally just Leeroy Jenkins themselves towards the player while firing wildly and praying for the best.

It'd be hilarious if it didn't make the game such a chore to push through - though let's face it, how many of us ever actually bothered to finish Daikatana?

Countless fan-made patches have been released to mend the game's AI - and other things - over the years, but as with Aliens: Colonial Marines, it's basically like putting a bandage on a trauma patient who bled out, oh, 20 years ago.


3. Hotline Miami

Hotline Miami 2
Dennaton

There's little denying how awesome the Hotline Miami games are: the ultra-violent top-down shooters occupy that small, liminal space between infuriatingly difficult and just-challenging-enough.

The objective is simple throughout: use stealth, your weapons, and your sheer guile to murder your way through a stage full of enemies, with even the simplest mistake often resulting in the player's instant death.

It's tremendously entertaining, in spite of the fact that the game's AI is basically one atrocious crapshoot. On the flip of a coin, the AI might hold in place and wait for you to emerge, or wander off and randomly shoot you when you're preoccupied somewhere else.

As with so many games on this list, it's the inconsistency that's most annoying. Some enemies won't even flinch when one of their fellow goons gets brutally murdered mere feet away, which proves especially annoying if you're trying to lure enemies into a doorway to mow them down.

The AI behaviour is "eccentric" to be kind, often acting as though suffering from a major neurological disorder: it's not uncommon for them to just give up shooting at you or walk into a room and then walk right back out of it for no reason at all.

In a game that's all about split-second timing where even simple mistakes are brutally punished, the rules of the enemy behaviour need to be clear. That the game is still so much fun in spite of all this is frankly miraculous.


2. The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct

The Walking Dead Survival Instinct
Activision

The Walking Dead: Survival Instinct is a textbook example of how not to adapt a beloved IP into a video game, and while every single aspect of its gameplay and presentation flat-out sucks, there's perhaps nothing more demonstrably awful than the AI of the undead Walkers.

Seriously, how hard can it be to program a convincing zombie? All they need to do is track the player's movements in a way that doesn't seem completely robotic, and yet developers Terminal Reality couldn't even get that right.

Walkers will often hunt the player down only to find themselves randomly turning around and walking in another direction, or even getting stuck in the environment. You can also avoid a horde with hilarious ease by simply breaking their line of sight - that's dumb even for a zombie (sorry, Walker).

The game's marketing spiel promised "dynamic Walker AI," though the only dynamism on display here lies in how erratic it is. On seemingly the roll of a dice, Walkers might notice you from a football field away or fail to clock you unloading rounds into their torso.

Zombies aren't supposed to be smart, sure, but this is just ridiculous.


1. The Legend Of Zelda: The Wind Waker

Legend Of Zelda Wind Waker
Nintendo

And finally, we have The Legend of Zelda: The Wind Waker, which while controversial upon release due to its cel-shaded art style is today accepted to be one of the series' finest entries.

If you can forgive the garbo AI, that is.

The Wind Waker is one of the easier games in the Zelda franchise, for sure, and that's in large part because the enemies are rendered so hilariously trivial through their stupidity.

The game's array of foes are programmed without any awareness of their surrounding environments, such that even when they do spot you, they'll clumsily saunter around, often bumping into objects and in the case of the Moblins and Darknuts even hitting each other while pursuing you.

It ensures The Wind Waker is a great introductory Zelda game for younger players, and generates some sure laughs, but for a franchise renowned for its peerlessly meticulous craft, the AI does feel rather sloppy and low-effort.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.