10 Video Games You Didn't Realise Were VERY Successful

Star Wars: Battlefront II made a profit??

Kinect adventures
Xbox

We all know a product doesn't need to be good to sell. There are an avalanche of crappy movies which have earned over a billion dollars. The Pet Rock toy sold millions despite the fact it's... literally a rock.

But in the gaming world, consumers are a bit more cautious. A new video games can cost £50 and is expected to keep us entertained for at least 20-30 hours. If the game in question is utter dreck, we can't invest our time and money in it, can we? When word got out that Duke Nukem Forever, Fallout 76, and Superman 64 stunk to high heaven, it was no surprise when sales dried up. Even if a dud is an AAA title or is from a recognised brand, we naturally assume it bombed.

But there are exceptions. There is some utter tripe that somehow earned mega-bucks. And we're not talking about a decent profit. We're talking Scrooge McDuck money. These titles are infamous for sucking and yet, customers bought them in droves.

Now, that's not suggesting every game on this list is garbage. In fact, some entries are pretty solid. But since you've heard so little about them, you never suspected they amassed a fortune in the billions.

10. Enter The Matrix

Enter The Matrix
Shiny Entertainment

The Matrix Reloaded had its moments, but it failed to recapture the magic of the original. Although there are plenty who still enjoyed the maligned sequel, the same cannot be said about the video game, Enter the Matrix, which was released at the same time.

This abominable movie tie-in was so rushed and unfinished, it couldn't win over the most die-hard Matrix fan. Due to its imprecise controls and shoddy camera, Enter the Matrix failed to emulate the bullet-time or the badass fight choreography - the two most iconic elements of the Wachowski's creation.

Despite being a mess, no one could fault Enter the Matrix's marketing. Hype for The Matrix Reloaded was through the roof, so it was no surprise its video game counterpart was advertised just as much. Because the game gave further insight on certain subplots in The Matrix Reloaded (supposedly), gamers had further incentive to check it out.

Within a month, Enter The Matrix sold 2.5 million units, making it the fastest-selling game in Atari's history. Selling five million units in total, Enter the Matrix did pretty well for itself, considering it's total crap.


9. Mortal Kombat Vs DC Universe

Mortal Kombat Vs DC Universe
Midway Games

Fans were elated when Mortal Kombat Vs DC Universe was announced. Having Scorpion fighting Batman or Liu Kang squaring off against the Joker sounded like a dream come true.

But because a lot of DC Comics are geared towards kids, the crossover had to drastically tone down the violence which Mortal Kombat is known for. After all, it couldn't depict Sub-Zero ripping out Wonder Woman's spine or Superman executing his opponents with his laser eyes, could it?

Naturally, gamers were up in arms. Bloodshed is the bread and butter of the franchise. Mortal Kombat without gore is like Mario without jumping or an EA title without the disappointment.

Considering Mortal Kombat Vs DC Universe was the last game Midway released before filing for bankruptcy, many assumed this stinker bombed spectacularly.

However, MKVSDCU sold over two million units, and was the most pre-ordered MK game ever at the time. According to GameStop, this fighting title made up 55% of the company's sales during the first week of its release. According to Renthrak, it was one of the most popular Xbox 360 games in 2009 to rent.

Midway didn't go bankrupt because of Mortal Kombat vs DC Universe, but in spite of it. It went bust literally the same week this crossover was released, so it had no baring on the company staying afloat.


8. Shadow The Hedgehog

Shadow The Hedgehog
Sega

After the Sonic antihero, Shadow, became hugely popular (for some reason), the rebellious hedgehog got his own spin-off. In 2005, Shadow the Hedgehog hit shelves, and BY GOD, it was terrible. The dark themes and gun violence feel totally out of place in this Sonic title. Even if you were onboard with the edgy style and Shadow's too-cool-for-school attitude, every other aspect of the game is woeful. The level design is barren. You'll careen to your death more times than you can count, thanks to the unpredictable controls. The music, baddies, bosses, and the plot are utterly forgettable.

You'd assume Shadow the Hedgehog would fail for two reasons. Firstly, it's very, very bad. Secondly, it was the first Sonic-based title to receive an E10+ rating, limiting its potential audience. Also, to reiterate - very, very bad.

And yet, Shadow the Hedgehog sold 2.06 million units, outperforming Sonic Adventure 2, which is considered the last great Sonic title devised by Sega. Although the Sonic brand is widely inconsistent, Shadow the Hedgehog is among the most successful entries in the franchise over the last 20 years despite being... y'know... absolutely terrible.


7. Star Wars: Battlefront II

Star Wars Battlefront 2 Anakin
EA

Although video game controversies usually make a mountain out of a mole hill, the concerns surrounding Star Wars: Battlefront II couldn't be overstated.

Due to the micro-transactions and unfair loot box progression system, players were given a widely unfair advantage if they spent real money. When government officials got involved to determine whether the loot boxes constitute as unlicensed gambling, the creators knew they screwed up big-time.

This scandal got so out of hand, EA's share prices plummet, resulting in the loss of $3 billion in stock value. Because Battlefront II didn't make as much as its predecessor and missed its sales target, the infamous Star Wars follow-up has been branded as a failure.

But one should never underestimate the power of branding. Any product, no matter how bad, is sure to attract a massive audience, if it's based on George Lucas' sci-fi epic. Star Wars: Battlefront II was met with strife since Day 1, but it still managed to sell nine million copies. Because of the stock drop, the game didn't make a profit, but that doesn't change the fact Battlefront II sold extremely well.


6. Dr. Mario

Dr. Mario
Nintendo

The Tetris craze was in full-swing during the early 90s, inspiring gaming studios to forge their own Tetris clones, hoping to generate a ton of cash. Over the years, we've had many rip-offs of the iconic Game Boy title, such as Columns, Dr. Robotnik's Mean Bean Machine, and Super Puzzle Fighter.

Of course, the most well-known Tetris doppelgänger has to be Dr. Mario. Throughout this puzzle game, the Italian plumber tosses vitamin capsules into a bottle to align the same colours, in order to destroy the nasty viruses.

Although Dr. Mario is addictive and has incredibly catchy tunes, it's surprising to see Nintendo plagiarise another property so flagrantly. (C'mon, guys. You wrote the book on innovation.) Because Dr. Mario was blatantly created to piggyback off the success of Tetris, you'd assume gamers would see through it and stick to the original.

But that wasn't the case. Dr. Mario was a blinding success, selling ten million units. In fact, it outdid some mainstream Mario titles by a considerable amount. It sold double the amount of Super Mario Sunshine and Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island. Even though Super Mario Galaxy 2 is hailed as a masterpiece, Dr. Mario has it beat by three million copies.


5. Resident Evil 5

sheva resident evil 5
Capcom

Even though Resident Evil 5 was decent, it didn't come close to matching the standards of the previous instalment. Resident Evil 6 may be the nadir of the zombie saga, but we can see the same issues nesting in the entry that came before. Cheesy dialogue. Focusing on bombastic action, rather than survival horror. And, of course, rock-punching.

Fortunately, things course-corrected with Resident Evil VII: Biohazard, and the undead series has been on the straight and narrow since. Due to the success of the recent remakes and Resident Evil: Village, you'd assume these entries made a killing in sales.

And yet, Resident Evil 5 is still the most successful entry, selling 13.4 million units. It was also the the most successful Capcom release for nearly nine years, until it was surpassed by Monster Hunter: World.

With Village and Resident Evil 4 Remake still raking it in, it's only a matter of time before either game catches up. Nevertheless, it's still a remarkable (and perplexing) achievement how Resident Evil 5 has maintained this record for well over a decade, despite being perceived as a disappointment.


4. Nintendogs

Nintendogs game
Nintendo

Because of its simple gameplay and adorable characters, Nintendogs is one of the most delightful gaming experiences any animal-lover can imagine.

Despite receiving positive reviews, you wouldn't expect a pet simulator to fly off the shelves. Not only does it sound like a niche market, Nintendogs doesn't have the same level of recognition as Mario or The Legend of Zelda, does it?

Although Nintendo were probably expecting a reasonable profit, nobody thought this Tamagotchi-inspired title would blow up. Nintendogs was the most successful game on the DS at the time, apart from New Super Mario Bros. (It even outsold Mario Kart DS!) We know customers bought a DS just to play with this digital pet, since sales for the handheld system quadrupled the same week Nintendogs was released. On top of that, it was the top-selling Nintendo game on any system in 2005.

But it doesn't stop there. Nintendogs sold almost 24 million units, making it among the most successful games of all time. Let's say that again - Of All Time. It outperformed gigantic titles, including Red Dead Redemption, Pokemon Ruby/Sapphire and 2018's God of War. The fact it sold almost as much as Super Mario Bros. 3 and Sonic the Hedgehog is bewildering.


3. Pac-Man (Atari Version)

pac man atari 2600
Atari

E.T. - The Extra-Terrestrial often gets sole blame for The Video Game Crash of 1983. Yes, it's true this failed movie tie-in nearly burned the gaming industry to the ground. However, it was the Atari port of Pac-Man that lit the match.

When the original blew up at arcades, gaming companies were desperate to port Pac-Man to every console imaginable.

Here's the problem. Despite's Pac-Man rudimentary design, it took 18 months to develop. Because of this, recreating it was no easy task, especially for Atari developer, Tod Frye, who was expected to create a port in six months. Worse still, Frye wasn't provided with any design specifications, meaning he had to guess how Pac-Man was programmed by playing it.

Despite Frye's best efforts, his Frankensteined Pac-Man was a glitchy travesty, with little resemblance to the original.

Considering this abomination played a hand at nearly collapsing the world of gaming, you would have every reason to believe it tanked.

Ironically, Pac-Man is the best-selling game on the Atari 2600. Selling eight million units, this utter crapfest (I can't believe I'm saying this), was the most successful game ever at the time.


2. Kinect Adventures!

Kinect Adventures
Good Science Studio

The Kinect was supposed to be the Xbox 360's secret weapon. Rather than relying on a peripheral like the Wii Remote or the PlayStation Move, Microsoft's motion camera would read the player's movements, effectively turning them into the controller. If this technology was precise, the Kinect's tentpole title, Kinect Adventures!, would become a literal game-changer.

Unfortunately, the gadget's ability to read movements is so inadequate, you safely assume the developers released Kinect Adventures! to hit a deadline, not because they believed in the product.

If the motion sensors worked flawlessly, this sports title is still not worth getting, since it only contains five mini-games! Worse still, only two of them are fun. Recognising how atrocious Kinect Adventures! was, the developers must've been 100% certain it would tank.

But somehow this hunk of junk sold 24 million units, making it the most successful game on the Xbox 360.

Not Minecraft. Not Halo. Not frickin' Grand Theft Auto V. This glitchy disaster outsold them all. The whole situation was quite informative because it proved that, even after all these years, the majority of gamers still don't read reviews before making their purchase.


1. Human: Fall Flat

Human Fall Flat
No Brakes Games

Human: Fall Flat is a pretty straightforward game which utilises a real-life physics engine. As you traverse around the open-ended arenas, you must solve puzzles, climb platforms, and most importantly, not fall to your death.

Curve Digital's little title was originally released on the PC back in 2016. Due to its success, it was ported to Steam, PS4, and Xbox One the following year. After a multiplayer was incorporated, Human: Fall Flat's popularity soared, allowing it to be ported onto almost every system and mobile device.

Even if you're a fan of this cute puzzler, you probably don't comprehend how profitable it's become. Human: Fall Flat has sold a whopping 40 million units. It has outsold Breath of the Wild and Skyrim... by 10 million! Humans: Fall Flat came out less than a decade ago, and its sales are almost on par with Pac-Man and Tetris!

Do you know what makes this accomplishment more unbelievable? Human: Fall Flat isn't very good. The Xbox One port received the highest Metacritic rating, which was an underwhelming 73%. This means the best version of this platformer is just... okay. And yet, Human: Fall Flat has become one of the most successful video games in history.


Watch Next


In this post: 
GTA V
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows