10 Video Games You Gave Up On (That Are Actually Great)
Dead Island 2 is a lot better than anyone could've hoped for.
The hype cycle is important to keep gamers engaged, both pre-release and post-release.
For one thing, studios have entire marketing teams to make sure that their title is in the public eye, in the best possible light and - most importantly - at the right time. If a title keeps stumbling and falling behind, any initial interest for it is bound to simmer off as other games come along to divert attention. Games can release and be decent fun but there might not be anyone who has stuck around to find out!
This can also happen after a game hits store shelves, in fact. If a release doesn't grab you in the first few hours, it can be all too easy to simply go find your fun elsewhere. This is magnified many times over if the game feels like it's broken or unfinished. Even if a title redeems itself eventually, most people move on without a second thought.
The entries in this list fall into either category but what unites them is that their potential audience largely disappeared. Though, looking at them now, they're frankly decent games at the very least and, in some cases, underappreciated classics.
10. The Last Guardian
Shadow of the Colossus is one of the most celebrated titles in gaming history. It's approach to both gameplay and story - and what ties them together - has influenced so many games in it's wake.
As such, Japan Studio's follow-up The Last Guardian seemed like it had the potential to be just as huge. Originally revealed as a PS3 title in 2009, the game took seven years before it hit store shelves.
By this time, any hype from the initial reveals had absolutely died down to a simmer. Everything was exacerbated by the departure from Sony of lead developer Fumito Ueda. Despite Sony reassuring consumers that the auteur was still lead on the project, Ueda had described his departure as coming from feeling a "sense of crisis" which made players uneasy.
Whilst it's hard to argue that parts of The Last Guardian didn't already feel outdated on release, it doesn't mean that the game was bad by any means. In fact, 2016 was a year of solid action-packed FPS titles (Overwatch, Battlefield 1 and the Doom reboot to name a few) so The Last Guardian still manged to find it's space as a slower-paced, more thoughtful experience.
The game holds favourable reviews on MetaCritic from both critics and consumers, it's just that it simply undersold terribly.
9. No Man's Sky
We all love a good redemption story and in recent years in gaming they've become not uncommon.
Now, there are strong arguments to be made about false advertising and not patting developers on the back for eventually getting their games where they needed to be on release. Still, the fact of the matter is that No Man's Sky has clawed it's way back from certain doom.
HelloGames' space-faring adventure title promised some pretty hefty things including a massive universe littered with an unthinkable number of procedurally generated planets that could be explored alongside friends. However, the planets were all pretty uniform, the ships you could pilot were boring and the promised multiplayer seemed to be removed right at the last moment. There was simply very little to do.
And yet, No Man's Sky may be the poster child for games being supported long after their release. In the seven years since, the game has had multiple free patches every year that have included hosts of new content; bringing it in line with the original vision for the title and beyond that by several milestones.
To really hit home, the game was tagged on Steam with "mostly negative reviews" on its debut in 2016. By September 2021, the developers had turned this around to 70% positive reviews.
8. Advance Wars 1+2: Re-Boot Camp
Advance Wars came to the West in 2003 and brought a puzzling little military strategy concept to the GameBoy Advance. Being one of Nintendo's most niche franchises, standing in the shadows of Mario and Link, ultimately led to the last game in the series being 2008's Days of Ruin (or Dark Conflict in Europe).
As such, fans were relieved to see the two original GBA titles announced for Switch in July 2021 as the awkwardly titled Advance Wars 1+2 ReBoot Camp. Unfortunately, it was pushed back to April 2022. Just a month before release however Nintendo decided to put the game on ice indefinitely due to the 2022 Russian invasion of Ukraine.
Fans, even the most understanding ones, got a little impatient as the delay for a surely completed game took over a year to pass by. Thankfully, ReBoot Camp was well received due to it's abundance of content that has been reinvograted and polished to perfection. The package never loses sight of what made the originals great, retaining both its charm and level of challenged.
At the time of writing, the game hasn't been out long enough to know how it's fared sales-wise. Unfortunately, for a C-tier franchise it was already fighting an uphill battle but over a year of delays can certainly hurt potential interest.
7. Sea Of Thieves
Under Nintendo's contracts, Rare were one of the most respected developers in the industry. After signing with Microsoft, that reputation began to slip fast.
Around 2009, Microsoft put the team to work exclusively on Kinect titles. The legendary Rare working on games for a failing gimmicky peripheral just felt like a total waste and key staff members left the company fast.
As such, Sea of Thieves was Rare's real comeback. This high-sea exploring pirate adventure looked at the state of multiplayer online titles and saw to inject the genre with something unique.
After a delay the game finally released in 2018 and, as an always-online world, Sea of Thieves encountered the common but no less dreaded server issues. Furthermore, when players did finally get into the game many of them found themselves eventually asking "well, what is there to do?" and began to move onto something else.
A thoughtful roadmap kept the core audience engaged and convinced players to return in a year's time when the content and progression system was much deeper. Since then, Sea of Thieves has only gone from strength to strength. Now, if a player was to jump in, they'd find a game fit to burst with experiences from random encounters with ghost-ships to story-driven adventures, as well as pretty impressive crossovers with the likes of Pirates of the Caribbean.
6. Shenmue III
Shenmue holds an interesting place in history as a niche gem touchstone that has had an understated impact on storytelling in gaming, as well helping to popularise quick time events. After nearly two decades since the second game, a third title finally arrived partially by way of a crowdfunding project.
So not only did Shenmue III have to contend with an 18 year wait and the grand expectations associated with it but also unfortunately mixed reviews upon release.
Some outlets called the release samey and outdated but, in a way, this was the entire point. How does one update a series so rooted in gaming's DNA at the turn of the millennium to modern standards? And is that what fans really want? Instead of teething its way through something new, Shenmue III is a loving, nostalgic call-back to the Dreamcast classics in a way that almost feels like no time has passed at all.
Sure, despite all that time, the threequel doesn't actually wrap up all the loose plot threads and even has the gall to end on a cliff-hanger. Still, taken at face value, there's a lot to like about Shenmue III.
The series is somewhat divisive and has a reputation for being obtuse in it's slow and relaxed nature, but if you enjoyed Shenmue's past there was no reason to write off the follow-up.
5. Fallout 76
The concept of exploring the post-apocalyptic wasteland and coming into contact with other players doing the same was strong enough that Fallout 76 made too much sense not to do. However, the game infamously had one of the most negative reactions within the last decade. On launch it had infinitely more bugs than it had things to actually do. There weren't even NPCs or really much in the way of quests.
With that in mind, many players expected Fallout 76 to become a game that Bethesda washed their hands of quickly but that's not what happened at all. The team maintained their commitment to updating and improving the experience: completely overhauling the levelling system, fleshing out the world and supplying story-driven content, and peppering in tonnes of quality of life improvements, all for free.
Not only is Fallout 76 still online five years later against most expectations, it's kind of thriving as an underappreciated gem.
The numbers don't lie. At the end of last year, the company revealed that Fallout 76 had climbed to 13.5 million players lifetime total, meaning new people are continuously trying it out. The game currently holds a sturdy average of 8000 concurrent players who enjoy what it's become. Sure, that number is never going to set the world on fire but it's a lot better than the game becoming the empty wasteland most predicted at launch.
4. Prey (2006)
3D Realms were once a key figure in the first-person shooter genre, having published id Software's Wolfenstein 3D and developed their own Duke Nukem 3D. As such, they were a name to watch and their next foray into the FPS was sure to push the genre forwards yet again.
Early looks at Prey during the late 1990s repeatedly impressed. It had a strong sense of style and some eye-watering visuals for the time, especially in regards to its portal feature that rendered two areas and stitched them together seamlessly.
But Prey was trapped in development hell for years, constantly stopping and starting and even being restarted. The issue here is that in all of the time 3D Realms agonised over Prey, the FPS genre was evolving with games like Medal of Honour and Call of Duty came and made their mark.
When Prey finally released in 2006, it was considered a financial success but it's sales figures were dwarfed by it's contemporaries. Simply put, the industry had moved on.
That being said, Prey still offered a lot of its own flavour with its unique portal and gravity-defying features, stellar level design and gorgeous worldbuilding. When other shooters were starting to fight over who has the bigger and grandest, Prey offered a lowkey atmospheric tale that has seen it become a cult classic.
3. Star Wars Battlefront II
One way to make waves throughout the gaming industry to simply release a product of unanimously agreed high quality. Another, of course, is to do something so controversial that you are all the news cycles can talk about.
When the beta for Star Wars Battlefront II released in 2017, it gave a startling insight into the loot-box heavy systems of the game. Players, even those who had shelled out for deluxe editions, would have to make the choice between spending even more money or grinding for 40 hours to unlock a single hero character.
Even as EA disabled microtransactions days before release, Battlefront II had a pretty strong stink about it for a long time.
But somehow, despite this, when the publisher announced the game's support would be ending in 2020, some diehard fans even took to making petitions to ask for more. That is a head-spinning turnaround.
And, in all fairness, it wasn't like Battlefront II wasn't fun from the get-go. Over the years, EA tweaked the game's rewards systems away from being totally contemptuous whilst adding tonnes of maps, skins and content that celebrated different eras of the space opera saga. It took the longest, bumpiest road possible to get there but Battlefront II wound up being a pretty good celebration of Star Wars.
2. Dead Island 2
2011's Dead Island was a decent enough mindless, multiplayer zombie killing romp. It showed promise at least, and so it was given spin-offs and a sequel was greenlit the following year.
Dead Island 2's existence became so much of a meme that others, like Goat Simulator 3, began parodying the long wait for it. Not only did development stretch across eleven years, it also spent time in the hands of three different teams. Yager Studio were dropped in 2015, Sumo Digital had the product taken out of their hands in 2019 and finally the game released as developed by Dambuster Studios.
That is the development equivalent of a project being raked over hot coals and glass. There was almost no way Dead Island 2 was going to be good. And yet...
Both critical and consumer response to the sequel was one of pleasant surprise, with the game scoring around the 70% mark. Players complimented the game's stylish aesthetic, memorable locations and high quality gore. The level of polish is surprising considering the majority of long-delayed titles tend to suffer in this regard.
Most players who assumed that Dead Island 2, if it ever came, was going to be a disaster were well within their rights but it wound up being surprisingly enjoyable.
1. Cyberpunk 2077
With no question, Cyberpunk 2077 is remembered as the most disastrous video game launch of all time. Whilst the game was originally announced in 2012, it went through a protracted development. Nearing the end of the decade, the interest in Cyberpunk's sci-fi world was high, never more so than when beloved actor Keanu Reeves announced he would be playing a lead character.
But then the game released... and you likely don't need to be reminded in what state. Without a high-end PC, there was no way to enjoy Cyberpunk 2077 through the haze of graphical, collision and performance issues and crashes that became a mainstream controversy.
Because of this, not many people actually talked about the game's actual content. Cyberpunk lost 200,000 players in it's first month as most wrote it off forever. However, as CDPR rolled out patches over the following year, the actual game could eventually be seen underneath the grime.
It's a real shame that Cyberpunk 2077's legacy will be the utterly awful launch because had this not been the case players could've enjoyed it on its wealth of merits. The game has a strong sense of identity thanks to an instantly believable world and a story filled with memorable characters. It rewards exploration and immersion and has an instantly recognisable visual aesthetic.
And, whilst it still has it's issues (what open world game doesn't?), it's now a brilliant addition to the western action-RPG genre.