10 Video Games You Won't Believe Got REJECTED
We lost so many good Star Wars games.
Video game cancellations are a rare event in the industry these days. This is because so many projects, be them in the format of ideas or as far as post-production, have become more salvageable as the industry has progressed. For example, if an independent studio is unsure of the prospect of their title, they can choose to publish the game themselves. This way, they're able to hold onto their baby and stay away from publishing traps.
However, not all studios have had this luxury in the past. Whether in development for years or shown to the world at E3, any handful of circumstances can lead to a game's cancellation in an instant. Time constraints, a growing lack of faith in the project or even the untimely merging of companies are just some of them.
Some of these cancelled titles live on in infamy, as what ifs of the industry. Others have the drawing power to be adapted into something else, with many Star Wars games acting as an example of this. While missed, gamers will always adore a chance at that sweet speculation, being able to hang on to the possibilities of what could have been.
Still, a cancelled game is sad sight to behold and we’ll be using this list to mourn 10 games you won’t believe got rejected.
10. Gotham By Gaslight
Back in 2012, test footage of a secret, well hidden Batman video game adaptation, Gotham By Gaslight, was leaked. This footage was fairly shallow, showing an extremely hench Batman walking through the Victorian streets of London, shrouded by fog.
This alone looked to be a moody, pretty unique take on Batman. Not just for comic books, but all of his appearances.
The intrigue only increases as we unravel what little we know about the cancelled project. Developed by Day 1 Studios and backed by THQ. Gotham By Gaslight was inspired by the comic of the same name. The story would focus on a Batman in the midst of investigating Jack The Ripper through a Victorian, steampunk London.
Allegedly action, this adaptation of Batman looked to be far more artistically stylised than that of the Arkham games. Dark, eerie environments set in England would utilise a grayscale filter with an almost horror-like direction.
The reason for its cancellation was simple: THQ couldn’t get the rights they needed.
9. Silent Hills
Arguably the biggest what if in video game history. Silent Hills is the infamous casualty of Hideo Kojima’s messy departure from Konami. Even today, almost five years later, it’s still hazy as to why Kojima Productions, as well as the man himself, disbanded from Konami. You have to imagine it was something huge considering Hideo had his baby, Metal Gear Solid, pried from his hands as he was pushed out the door.
Konami also held the rights to Silent Hills and pulled all content, including the playable teaser. PT was the demo that had everyone in awe of its simplicity and truly terrifying gameplay. Players walked through an L shaped corridor with few rooms to explore. Each time they exited, they started over. However, instead of being dull, it was gripping, possessing an atmosphere more intense than any other horror game.
All of that meant nothing to Konami, though, kicking Kojima out as soon as The Phantom Pain was shipped. Silent Hills was off the table, as well as the collaborative efforts of Guillermo Del Toro. Norman Reedus did, however, make his way over to Kojima’s first project free from Konami, Death Stranding.
8. The Flash
Back in 2008, just before Batman: Arkham Asylum released, Bottlerocket Entertainment, under Brash Entertainment, were extremely close to releasing a similar styled video game focusing on The Flash. It was said to be an origin story, set in both Keystone and Central City. Even the gameplay sounded great, with combos, various speed-based moves and the obvious health bar to account for Flash’s vulnerabilities.
Other rumours were alleged about the type of bosses you would face. This would include villains such as Mirror Master, Captain Cold and Weather Wizard. Some of these villains were said to be simple fights but others would require a more creative approach, using Flash's superpowers to a more creative end.
As well as a line-up of villains, the developers were hoping to get Ryan Reynolds’ voice talent on board. It sounds like an all-round fun, unique title that could have stood side-by-side with that of Arkham Asylum.
In the end, though, it all came down to money. The company backing the developers, Brash Entertainment, went bankrupt and with that, all projects were cancelled.
7. Battle Of The Sith Lords
The first of two Star Wars cancellations on our list as a result of Disney’s acquisition of Lucasfilm. Battle of the Sith Lords,
often referred to as simply Darth Maul, has some… strange history. Developers Red Fly were generally thrown in the air and spun around by various LucasArts employees. Even George himself had brainstorming sessions with them about what
Darth Maul could be like and how he should “be friends” with Darth Talon,
despite the historical time difference.
They were given encouragement to prototype, working with any ideas involving Darth Maul after his death in Episode 1. Beyond giving Maul some robotic legs, Red Fly floundered, trying to produce action-based content with stealth sprinkled on the top. With footage showing the game wasn’t too far from The Force Unleashed or Arkham Asylum, including a double-edged lightsaber, force powers and the heavy involvement of Sith lore.
However, out of nowhere, LucasArts informed Red Fly they would no longer be required to work on the project. They gave no detailed explanation and used the Disney acquisition as the reason for the cancellation.
6. Star Wars 1313
The second of our Star Wars cancellations is that of the infamous Star Wars 1313. It’s been over seven years since the E3 gameplay trailer was released and it legitimately still holds up. Players would take control of a younger Boba Fett who worked dangerous missions in Coruscant’s level 1313. Though, it wasn't just another Star Wars game. Of the many, many cancelled or otherwise MIA Star Wars video game projects, Star Wars 1313 was the big one.
It was something we hadn’t seen before in a game based on the franchise, mixing the likes of Uncharted’s action and set-pieces with the look and feel of a Mass Effect game. Almost released, 1313 would have been the first ever full blown, full budget narrative experience Star Wars fans had been waiting for.
As with Battle of the Sith Lords, the mouse scooped up the remains of LucasFilm and made their sequels. This left plenty of projects to die in their wake. Though, in fairness, we did eventually get Jedi: Fallen Order to fill the gap 1313 left.
5. Scalebound
In regards to scale, this entry takes the cake for our list. Scalebound looked to gain inspiration from the likes of the Monster Hunter series, with an added twist. Instead of man vs. monster, it would be man and fellow dragon companion, vs. other monsters.
Originally scheduled for a 2016 release as an Xbox One exclusive, Platinum Games, developers of Nier and Bayonetta, delayed it a year to offer the best experience possible. This makes the entry sting that much more considering it was only a year away from release. That is, assuming the delay wasn't market speak for, we’re not sure it’s going to be ready.
After almost three years of hype, alongside dragon-filled and combat-heavy trailers, the project came to an abrupt end. Microsoft released a statement severing ties with Platinum Games, also announcing the cancellation of Scalebound.
When asked for further details they remained tight lipped and refused to reveal which of the companies owned the Scalebound IP. Unfortunately, it was later revealed that Microsoft own the rights. An absolute tragedy.
4. LMNO
Created by legendary director, Steven Spielberg, LMNO was said to be a more emotional attempt at narrative through the means of video games. It had players on the run with an alien named Eve who was trying to escape an organisation chasing her down. Most rumours of the game allege it to be in the more avant-garde, artsy realm of video games, with a heavy focus on interactivity. Spielberg specifically stated he wanted to create the type of product he felt the industry was lacking, presumably more akin to film.
This emphasis on interactivity made it possibly comparable to Heavy Rain or Life Is Strange. Considering it had Spielberg at the wheel, you know it wouldn’t be lacking in substance, similar to whatever venture Hideo Kojima wanted to dive into next.
Ultimately, publisher EA deemed it too ambitious. Imagine that: you get Spielberg on board to work on a game and and then shut him down.
3. Prey 2
The original Prey was an amazingly unique experience, one possibly sullied by the 2017 reboot. Now, whatever opinions you may have of one or the other, it’s mere speculation that the reboot had anything to do with Prey 2’s cancellation. In fact, it’s arguable that the cancelled sequel vaguely morphed into the 2017 version.
Focusing on Prey 2, the story was to be loosely tied to the events of the original. A plane crash into The Sphere would lead to combat and unconsciousness for Killian Samuels. He would then wake up on an alien planet as a bounty hunter. Running into protagonist of the first game, Killian tries to continue his bounty hunter life, post-amnesia.
The issue here is that the rights to the game switched hands. From 3D Realms to Bethesda, who handed development to Human Head Studios. Rumours then suggest that Arkane Studios, who later released the 2017 reboot, had a hand in trying to salvage Prey 2, to no good end. Then, in 2014, after almost a decade of development, Bethesda announced Prey 2’s cancellation, only to release the reboot a few years later.
2. Sadness
A game which had stylistic flair and the potential to become a classic for the Wii, squandered by a development studio with a big mouth and slow hands. A really big mouth, mind you. Nibris made lots of promises and told us about all kinds of awesome premises that any horror fan would jump at the sight of.
From released content and statements, we know that Sadness would use a black and white graphical style and focus on gothic, psychological horror. It would also have capitalised on the scary nature of medical conditions such as fear of the dark, schizophrenia and paranoia. These all make up for a great foundation of a horror game. Not to mention, this was way before the release of either Amnesia: The Dark Descent or Outlast.
Sure, it was on the Wii but that’s more reason that it could have shaken things up. However, due to the only footage being a teaser trailer and developer Nibris’ inability to meet deadlines or produce any other content, fans were concerned. Was this project cancelled, or did its production only go as far as the developer's hollow claims?
1. Fez II
Fez II features the weirdest reason for ending a game's development: Cancelling the sequel to your critically acclaimed, universally praised indie darling video game, simply out of spite for the industry itself.
Really, Phil Fish is, or was, a unique gem of the business, and that cancellation is no exaggeration.
Fez II was well into production, with Fish once again heading the charge. Unfortunately, he was always coming under fire from some direction or another within the industry, with remarks from critics, reviewers, pundits or whoever else he heard in his head. This all blew out when Marcus Beer, The Annoyed Gamer, complained about Fish not giving info about something or other. Beer ended his rant with insults at the indie dev.
Fish responded via Twitter. It then went back and forth and eventually, Fish peaced the scene, literally. He threw his hands up, done with it all. Bye bye, video game industry.
Underneath that fiasco though, we lost a lovely looking game that could only give us more of what we wanted. Mind-bending, well thought out puzzles based around perspective with a pretty art style to go along with it. Some people love drama. Nothing more, nothing less.