10 Ways Red Dead Redemption 2 Will Be Infinitely Better Than GTA V
The Old West is making a comeback.

Six long, very Revolver-less years later, E3 has come and gone, yet we still have nothing new to report. Fans were optimistic following a leaked map back in April, but alas, it wasn't meant to be. Rockstar have stayed quiet, and the wait for a new Red Dead continues.
Demand for a RDR sequel is feverish, and for good reason: Redemption offered a gripping story, a sympathetic and interesting main character, and concluded with a heart-wrenching ending that sealed its status as a true masterpiece.
Although GTA V was certainly great in many different respects, Redemption remains Rockstar's defining piece of work. A sequel could take the strong foundation of RDR, and build on it into ambitious and unique ways, leads to an experience on-par - and maybe even superior to - a game many feel is already a landmark achievement.
Even with rumours and speculations being the only form of information regarding a Red Dead sequel, there are plenty of ways (10 to be exact) that a RDR sequel would be superior to GTA V. These are the 10 Ways Red Dead Redemption 2 Will Be Better Than GTA V!
10. An Online Experience That Lives Up To Expectations

With GTA Online, it was always going to be tough to live up to the immense hype it brought upon itself. Although it turned out to still be a fun experience, the repetitive missions, overly-long loading times, and expensive in-game items left some gamers disappointed.
Red Dead's online, however, was received with glowing praise and was much beloved by fans who've always wanted to get into a Mexican standoff with fellow players online. RDR delivered on that, along with giving players the ability to free roam, form posses, and take part in shootouts.
In a sequel, Rockstar could take the concept of player-organised heists from GTA and bring it into a Wild West setting. Take the mission structure and increase the variety so that players no longer feel they're playing the same mission twice.
Online train heists and robberies could prove to be even more of a game-changer, as it's both wish-fulfilment for Western fans and gamers who are looking for that next step above GTA V's heists. Rockstar can make that sensational feeling of pulling off a successful heist once again, but do it in a way that maintains originality and player enjoyment.
9. A Massive Map (That You WANT To Explore)

As enticing as it is to salivate whenever a developer states how extensive their in-game map is, it's important to remember that bigger isn't always better. GTA V's map was impressively spread out, with mountainous regions and plenty of urban city streets to drive through. However, with a massive world, comes a massive need to fill that world with both inhabitants and things to do. Although there were a number of fun easter eggs and random events throughout the map, there simply needed to be more.
It was with Red Dead that random events, like saving someone from being hanged or helping an officer hunt down an escaping prisoner, would take place to make exploration more interesting. Red Dead had these random events, as well as treasure hunting and various challenges. Even with stretches of wide open areas and no buildings or towns in sight, these events helped make the world feel alive and full of fellow inhabitants, even if they weren't always good Samaritans.
With rumours speculating that RD3's protagonist will be able to swim, the landscape could see some major changes to exploration and to the open environments, leading to more than just an exploration of the sandy Old West. There are certainly going to be more random events, with increasingly unique circumstances so that exploration continues to feel both intriguing and worthwhile.
8. More Interactivity Between You And The World

If there was one design flaw in GTA V that stood out too much, it was the lack of interiors and opportunities to interact with NPC's, with the strip clubs allowing the most interaction (press X to make it rain). In RDR, every saloon and town offered a means to interact with the citizens, even if that interaction boils down to a fist fight with a local gang member.
Thieves Landing gave you a lawless and chaotic town, filled with men willing to shoot you the instant you start causing trouble. These distinct towns filled with plenty of minigames like Blackjack, Poker, Liar's Dice, even the 1v1 shootouts that allowed these NPC's to be more than background decoration. GTA V lacked this, even with a plethora of minigames to take part in, and that was due to a lack of interaction with the citizens of Los Santos outside of stopping an occasional mugging.
RD3 can continue to add even more minigames and activities, similar to the bounties and parlour games that take advantage of the game's time period. Red Dead showed the importance of letting NPC's stand out rather than simply forcing them to blend in with the scenery. RD3 is sure to continue this trend.
7. Memorable Side-Characters

A good story feels hollow without strong characters to fill it. Thankfully, RDR has plenty of engaging characters, with the grave digger Seth and smooth-talking Abraham Reyes being two standouts. Throw in characters like the old gunman, Landon Ricketts, and the snake oil merchant, Nigel Dickens, and you've got a small sample of the many personalities present throughout the campaign.
These memorable characters are what made RDR so special, giving each story mission a feeling of purpose and entertainment, regardless of whether the mission is particularly action-packed. You know the characters are great when you knowingly take part in their cow-herding missions just so that they can be happy.
The story was certainly heightened due to these three-dimensional characters, thus in turn making the story in-depth and interesting throughout the campaign. GTA V, due to its satirical nature, have purposely one-dimensional side characters that serve to represent certain aspects of society. It's because of this less-serious tone that the side characters aren't as fleshed out, which is why RDR's follow a different path.
A sequel to RDR would hopefully continue this trend, as morally gray characters stand out the most, and RDR had plenty of them.
6. Side Missions That Don't Feel Superfluous

We can agree that there were a little bit too many herding missions in RDR. However, we can also agree that if there's a mission type that GTA V had too much of, it's the tow-truck stuff.
For every memorable side mission in GTA, there was another towing job for Tonya or hunting mission for Cletus. Red Dead certainly had missions that were less action-packed than others, but they would then lead into ones like 'I Know You' that offer an entirely unique set of circumstances.
Missions like 'I Know You' helped give side missions in RDR challenging themes and additional depth that would be absent otherwise. These side missions offer questions of morality in which no 'right answer' is given to the player, as well as an examination on the dangers of choosing religious faith over practicality.
Red Dead had many challenging themes, and the side missions were the showcases for the 'discussion' of said themes. With GTA, you have side missions that offer variety and entertaining characters outside of the main story. In RDR, side missions offer tough questions and crushing realism at certain moments. The effectiveness of those moments makes these side missions feel every bit as essential to the player as the main story, which will surely continue in the sequel.
5. Rewarding Exploration

The most important part of designing an open world is giving players a reason to explore that open world. In Red Dead, you had hunting and survival challenges, random events, buried treasure, many forms of interesting wildlife, and new side missions discovered as you travel. In GTA, there were a couple collectibles and Easter eggs to be found, like the No Country For Old Men recreation or the many alien teases.
However, other than those fun secrets, as well as a few heist members you can discover and recruit, there's not a whole lot that occurs when you explore GTA's world. This is an issue RDR didn't have as much, although Rockstar HAD to fill up the world outside of the many towns with some form of activity, or else exploring the open desert could have become tedious.
What's important with RDR2 is how they structure this open world with the towns and settlements. It's important that the open world feels just as populated as the towns do. With RDR showing how unpredictable and engaging the desert can be, RDR2 would only heighten the experience. More interactions during travels, and more incentives to leave town and brave the Wild West.
4. The Score

GTA V's 80's-influenced score greatly accompanied the many set pieces throughout the campaign and combat situations. This, alongside the game's many licensed songs, solidified Rockstar's reputation of having amazing soundtracks. However, it was with RDR that Rockstar hit their peak. The time period was emulated perfectly, and the authenticity and quality of the music was second to none .
Every combat situation, every quiet moment out in the wild, even walks through town have musical accompaniment that furthers immersion and player enjoyment. Unlike GTA, which typically only has the score playing during story missions (due to the option of radios outside of missions), RDR's music is always present, and it perfectly encapsulates each gameplay situation.
There are very few licensed songs in RDR, but when present, they are utter perfection. The entrance into Mexico, the ride back to John's family, both heightened moments due to the flawless song choices.
We have Bill Elm and Woody Jackson to thank for both the scores of Red Dead, and as long as they're back for the sequel, there's little doubt the next soundtrack will be anything but outstanding.
3. Memorable Villains

As unlikable as Devin Weston and Steve Haines were, they were NOTHING compared to the pure hatred players felt towards Edgar Ross. There was simply no comparison, as the man who holds John's family hostage for most of the game is undoubtedly pure evil.
His boastful and cruel nature is felt with every interaction, and the hatred felt by players only increases with every line of dialogue. John's former gang members are notably good too, with Dutch van der Linde establishing a three-dimensional character in the span of four missions. When comparing these two with GTA's antagonists, there's no contest.
Depending on if Rockstar chooses a prequel or a completely new story, some additional background information could be given to further the characters of Ross and Dutch as we see their past selves. If it's a new story, RDR2 could have a conflicting villain, much like Dutch, who has both good and bad in him. Either way, Rockstar will surely not disappoint.
2. A Sympathetic Main Protagonist That You Can Root For

When you first meet John Marston, he seems like the typical no-nonsense cowboy. However, after his first encounter with Bill and his conversations with Bonnie, you see the very human and intelligent side of him that cares and just wants to see his wife and son again. It is with this clear goal that we can both sympathise with John's situation AND be more than willing to help him reunite with his family.
In GTA V, each protagonist isn't exactly lovable, with Michael being mostly unlikable. We're supposed to root for him to get his family back, but due to his mainly cynical nature, it's hard to really sympathize with his struggles being a father/husband.
Franklin isn't really sympathetic either, as he does whatever is asked of him with little remorse. Trevor is by far the most three-dimensional, with moments of both regret and glee after violent acts, but still doesn't really have any character traits that make him sympathetic (which obviously was the intention of the writers). This is why RDR's selection of a character working to better himself allowed for a far more likeable and engaging protagonist overall.
Once again, if Rockstar opts for a prequel, we can witness a pre-family John Marston that didn't exactly make many unselfish decisions. This would allow the player to see John's transition from hell-raiser to family man, thus giving his character the complete arc that he deserves.
1. An Emotionally-Engaging Story

THIS is where GTA V definitely faltered: failing to offer a story that players could truly get invested in. The tone for the game certainly wasn't of the Last Of Us variety, but it simply didn't offer enough within the plot to keep players hooked outside of the fun gameplay and sharp writing. RDR offered a thoroughly-engaging plot, with a conclusion that was absolutely bitter, and an epilogue that was amazingly sweet.
Red Dead ensured that each part of the story had plenty of twists and turns in which you felt just as John felt. The emotion and depth packed into the story were through the game's challenging themes and multi-layered characters, each with their own struggles and desires.
Moments like Dutch's monologue, John reuniting with his family, Ross angering players whenever he speaks; all moments in which the player had a strong reaction because of how the game engaged them.
Hopefully, regardless of whether the story is new or a prequel to Redemption, let's hope that Rockstar ensures that the emotional side of RDR doesn't leave its sequel. Who knows, maybe there'll be a happy ending this time?
--
What do you hope to see in the sequel to Red Dead Redemption? Let us know in the comments!