10 Ways Video Games Keep Lying To You

Video game marketing says the darndest things.

Witcher 3 Downgrade
CD Projekt Red

Ever since E3 blew up to be the extravagant and, more importantly, expensive spectacle it's become, game developers and publishers have been, to put it nicely, finding creative ways to hype up their games.

After all, games today are incredibly expensive to make, averaging a cost of about 80 million dollars. Time and space at E3 isn't cheap, not to mention the many other video game conventions that have popped up over the years.

When you combine booth space, press conferences, employee wages, special game demos and trailers, paying celebrities and models, construction - the list goes on and on, and can easily reach hundreds of thousands of dollars.

And publishers want to see that money back.

Unfortunately, building hype is the best way to do that. And the easiest way to build hype is to wow people. Developers are under a ton of pressure from publishers to hype their games, which often aren't ready to even be seen.

So we get trailers intended for internal use pushed out as marketing, or narrow, curated gameplay demos made exclusively for the show, or games running on significantly higher hardware specs than they will in the real world.

So whether it's blatant false advertising, little white lies, or seemingly harmless enthusiasm pushed too far, these are the lies the industry just can't stop telling.

10. Hyperbolic Statements That Make No Sense

Fable combat
Lionhead

During Xbox's recent Summer 2022 showcase, the developers of the "all-new", brand-rebooted Forza Motorsport touted a whopping 48 times improvement in the fidelity of their physics simulation.

Just let that sink in for a second. That's their previous physics fidelity - whatever that means - multiplied by 48! It's such a brazenly outrageous claim that it's hilarious. How is it even possible to measure something like that as one number? And what is that number? Not only does this sound ridiculous, but we also have no idea what it even means.

Of course, this is nothing new.

Some of us are old enough to remember Peter Molyneux - the king of hyperbole - claiming that the original Fable would be a full, evolving simulation. One famous claim was that you could plant an acorn and watch it grow into a tree over the course of the game - a ridiculous statement for an original Xbox game.

And we have to mention the grandfather of all marketing hyperbole: "John Romero's going to make you his b*tch." Whatever that was supposed to mean.

He did not. Not even close.


9. "Big" Games... With Nothing To Do

Matthew's Animal Husbandry Fallout 3
Bethesda

Let's consider the announcement of the famously (or infamously) troubled Fallout 76 where Todd Howard claimed it was "four times bigger" than Fallout 4. Of course, what he forgot to specify was that, while the amount of land in the game may be four times more, there wasn't a whole lot of anything to do in it.

Abstract concepts like size and amount of play time are bandied about in video game marketing all the time, despite the fact that your mileage will obviously vary wildly.

Is a game really bigger or longer just because the map is bigger?

What they don't tell you is what that includes. How much of that is repetitive tasks like collecting 100 feathers; how much is boring side quests; how much of the map is auto-generated, copied and pasted assets that make all the dungeons basically the same? (I'm looking at you, The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion.)

Is a game really bigger or longer just because there's more space to do more repetitive activities?


8. Mobile Game Ads

Evony Advert
Evony

Mobile game ads are a real exercise in cynicism for everyone involved. The majority of them are brazenly fake, showcasing elements not found in the game, or, often times, footage of something that isn't even what's being sold to you.

You know what I mean: The strangely prolific "pull the pins in the right order to get the guy across the screen to the treasure" genre - a genre that, for a long time, only existed in those fake trailers.

And the worst part is, we all know it. We know what we're seeing isn't actually the game at all. And they know we know it. How many people could there possibly be falling for these trailers, downloading a game that in no way resembles what they were expecting, and then, presumably, paying for more microtransactions?

Sadly, like most scams, when you think about it long enough the answer is obvious: Likely the elderly, or people otherwise uneducated in gaming as an industry. Not only are these false advertising, but they're predatory to boot.

... How is this legal??


7. Loot Boxes That Aren't Pay To Win (Technically)

Middle-earth: Shadow of War
Monolith Productions

Surprisingly, it seems like we're gradually settling into a reasonable space with microtransactions and loot boxes. And to think, all it took was video game publishers pushing the concept to breaking point, where multiple world governments had to either intervene or at least warn them they would.

Until recently though, microtransactions were a jungle of publishers trying everything they could to wring every last penny out of consumers. The concept of "pay-to-win" just didn't last long amidst player outrage.

Or, at least, not openly. If you want to spend dozens of hours grinding and praying to the RNG gods, then you absolutely don't need to spend money.

One of the worst of these was Middle-Earth: Shadow Of War. The game was totally beatable without paying for loot boxes. Unless you wanted to see the game's "true" ending, which required you to replay lengthy fortress sieges over and over, gaining and losing followers, levelling them up, etc., etc.

Of course, you could buy a loot box and hope you get some overpowered orcs to use instead. If not, try again! Eventually you'll get something to alleviate this very intentional chore.


6. "Vertical Slice" Trailers

The Division downgrade
Ubisoft

Not to be too dramatic, but the E3 2005 "gameplay" trailer for Killzone 2 kinda broke the industry. We were more naive then, so as we watched what looked like a staggering leap forward in technology, we were also skeptical. Like they say, if something looks too good to be true, it probably is.

And boy was it. As we suspected all along, the alleged gameplay trailer was entirely, in industry terms, "bullshot" - pre-made imagery sold to viewers as the game itself. Essentially, it was a cutscene that depicted what next-gen shooters at the time could, hypothetically, look like.

Completely fake. An indisputable lie.

Since then, the term "vertical slice" has been used to justify a similar practice: showing a pre-made demo of an actual game, but rendering only what's on camera, often on a mighty PC dev kit. Technically it is a peek at real gameplay, just not an accurate representation of the whole product.

Worse, making these demos takes time from developers who could be working to make the actual game better. All for a brief demo reel that we've become too jaded to ever take seriously.


5. Selling Ambition, Not The Product

Spore No Man's Sky
Maxis & Hello Games

As we learned time and again with Peter Molyneux, Will Wright and Sean Murray, it's usually not best to let the artist lead the marketing of a game.

Developers - especially the ones in charge - are extremely passionate about what they do. And that's a good thing, obviously. We know what happens to big games when things like passion and morale just aren't there - Mass Effect: Andromeda, for one.

But it's always a bad idea to sell a game based on the developer's vision alone. A passionate creative will pursue their vision relentlessly if given the chance, but too often that ambition exceeds reality. When certain figures get excited they aren't considering things like budgets, deadlines or how much of the game is yet to be coded - they're just stoked to be talking about this thing they're so in love with.

Fortunately, when given the time and space necessary, some developers can, eventually, deliver on all those ambitions, No Man's Sky being arguably the most famous example, but not the only one.

Games like Final Fantasy XIV, The Elder Scrolls Online and Destiny are just a few others showing what can happen when developers have the freedom to eventually reach their potential.

All the same, stop trying to sell us on hypothetical concepts and be FAR clearer about the reality of production.


4. Threadbare Content At Launch

Anthem game
Bioware

You know when a friend is telling you about some prestige TV series you haven't seen? And inevitably, at some point in the conversation, they'll say something like, "The first season isn't great but if you can grit your teeth through it then the rest is so worth it?"

Have you noticed that the same kind of thing has been happening with games?

As developers get more ambitious, their games end up feeling more like a proof of concept for a sequel. Or that the first game is the foundation and the sequel is the entire rest of the house.

Obviously, you hope a sequel builds upon an original, but this disparity feels like it has become intentional. Destiny, Anthem, Marvel's Avengers - all games that were released in a state that felt more like a pitch than a complete product - a very expensive pitch that needed to make its money back before the rest of the game could be implemented.

To put it more succinctly, too many games today are hyped relentlessly and then released as glorified "early access" titles, without the label.


3. Glorified Tech Demos At Launch

The Order 1886
Ready at Dawn

It used to be standard for new game consoles to launch alongside great and now iconic games. Numerous Mario titles, Altered Beast, F-Zero, Tekken, Halo - all, to varying degrees, games that could potentially sell a console.

As game development got more complex, the quality of launch titles slowly diminished. Games like Genji: Days Of The Blade or Kameo: Elements Of Power were fine, but were primarily built around showing off what their respective new consoles could do. Launch games started feeling more targeted; more an extension of marketing.

By the Xbox One/PS4 era, that concept had become standard. The Order: 1886 was shown off early in the PS4's hype cycle, and rightfully so - it was an astonishing jump in graphics. But when the actual game came out, there just wasn't much to it. Ready at Dawn's console title was a generic shooter that... looked really good. It was basically a tech demo meant to show off the PS4's capabilities first, and be a game second.

So far this generation we've mostly got upgraded versions of games we just recently played. Yes, the visual upgrades were significant, but imagine if the Nintendo 64 launched with a 2.5D version of Super Mario World. Kind of underwhelming.


2. E3 Is Not For The Fans

Todd Howard E3 Be3 2019
Bethesda/E3

E3 has lived a lot of lives. What started as a business conference for the video game industry and press gradually grew into gaming's Super Bowl.

All year we'd wait to see what games would be announced, what games would be demoed, what weird crap Ubisoft would do. Over time it even became a question of what celebrities might show up. And it became an exorbitantly expensive spectacle.

Several years ago parent company the ESA tried to rein it in and gamers revolted - then they brought the glitz and glamour back, but drastically limited the required credentials to attend. Now, despite some cancellations recently, E3 has been opened up as a free-for-all if you can get a ticket.

In all that time, fans were never truly the priority. It has always been a press and business event first and foremost, which is the reason why you see things like "vertical slice" demos or trailers that just show a hint of what the game might, maybe be like. These things were primarily made with industry use in mind - to satisfy publishers, appeal to investors, or wow the press.

E3 being for the fans at all is really just a way to recoup those massive expenses.


1. Announcing Games Way Too Early

Beyond Good And Evil 2 57569
Ubisoft

This one has been happening more and more lately - a company will announce a game to hype fans, even though that game is just entering development.

This practice usually goes one of two ways:

In the case of the Elder Scrolls VI, that the game would eventually come out was never in question. It's a hugely successful franchise, Skyrim continues to perform well ten years after its original release - a new entry in the TES series was a foregone conclusion. So for Bethesda to announce that TESVI was beginning production - a process that will take years - simply as weak mea culpa for Fallout 76's troubled launch was just a needless tease.

On the other side of things, the poster child for this particular lie: Beyond Good And Evil 2. Announced first all the way back in 2008, the game is approaching Duke Nukem Forever-levels of uncertainty.

Since that original trailer, Ubisoft has never officially cancelled the game. For over ten years now they've insisted it's still in active development, leading to a full gameplay trailer in 2019, followed by an almost immediate return to total radio silence.

If I didn't know better, I'd say Ubisoft is trolling us.


Watch Next


Contributor

At 34 years of age, I am both older and wiser than Splinter.