10 Worshipped Video Games No One Understands

If you think you understand it... you don't.

mortal kombat baraka
NetherRealm

When it comes to video games, story isn't as crucial as the gameplay. But it's no coincidence that some of the greatest titles to grace our consoles happen to have a compelling and heart-wrenching plot. Although Final Fantasy VII and The Last of Us have astounding mechanics, characters, and music, it's the beautiful writing that trumps everything else.

However, there are certain games that are utterly adored, even though they're incomprehensible. Now, this isn't suggesting they have poorly structured narratives. In fact, many of them make perfect sense, if you put in the time and effort to understand them. But if the plot is too long, complex, or deliberately vague, you can't expect to follow it.

Bizarrely, some games have had no trouble finding success, despite being indecipherable. Everybody loves Final Fantasy and The Legend of Zelda, even if they don't know what's going on. Castlevania and Mortal Kombat have so many entries, you'll need an encyclopaedia and a few wiki pages handy to grasp the overarching story. You may worship the games on this list, but that doesn't mean you understand them.

10. Diablo

Diablo II Resurrected
Blizzard

When you're looking at a series with nearly a dozen instalments like Metal Gear Solid or Tekken, you can understand why it's tricky to condense the overarching narrative. Of course, you'd assume Diablo wouldn't have this problem, since there are only three instalments. (Diablo Immortal doesn't count and never will.)

But Diablo's plot leaves most players stumped. The first game is simple enough, with our hero venturing to Hell to destroy The Lord of Terror, Diablo. There's a lot of lore, but it's laid out clearly, so it's easy to follow.

However, the sequels don't expand the plot - they retcon it. The Worldstone, which was a crucial MacGuffin in the original, isn't mentioned in the sequel at all.

The Worldstone was brought back in Diablo III, but its lore was rewritten, so the artefact's destruction endowed Sanctuary's inhabitants with divine power. Even though Sanctuary was originally written as the underdog caught in the crossfire between Heaven and Hell, this change-up turned them into a force who could contend with gods. Not only does this contradict the original story, it makes Heaven and Hell's action seem non-sensical. Why would they leave Sanctuary alone, if its people pose a serious threat?

Because each instalment gives different explanations to characters' motivations, history, and power levels, you're constantly left scratching your head.


9. Bayonetta 2

Bayonetta 2
Platinum Games

It goes without saying that nobody on the planet bought Bayonetta for the plot. Because PlatinumGames' hack-and-slash focuses on the most OTT action possible, we would lap it up, even if the narrative had the same complexity as Tetris' story.

And yet, the developers stuffed each instalment with an overly bloated plot, especially Bayonetta 2. In this sequel, our gun-toting heroine teams up with a child called Loki to defeat the evil personification of himself called Loptr, who's the reborn version of the God of Chaos. (If you found that summary confusing, it gets worse.)

During your quest, Bayonetta travels 500 years in the past, where she learns Loptr killed her mother, (which contradicts a big portion of the first game.) Loptr then retrieves the Sovereign Power, which is a.... something... turning himself into a deity.

Bayonetta 2 isn't just gibberish - it's long gibberish. Every now and again, your demon-smashing antics will be interrupted by a cut-scene, detailing everything that's happened... ever. Disruptions like this can be a good way to condense dangling plot-threads. But here, they simply add to the player's confusion.

Also, some of these exposition dumps go on for ten minutes!! If you can't follow what's happening within the first 30 seconds, you'll be totally lost by the end of it.


8. Chrono Cross

chrono cross serge
Square Enix

In Chrono Trigger, the player can take control of seven different characters, each with their own unique attacks and mechanics. Not only was this a great way to diversify the gameplay, it benefits the story. Because we're looking at the narrative from the eyes of many, we understand and appreciate it a lot more.

However, discerning the sequel, Chrono Cross, is much harder. This time around, there aren't seven characters to play as... there's 45!! Because this saga centres around parallel worlds, time-travel, and a time-eating entity, it's already a challenge to take it all in.

And when you're playing as nearly four dozen characters, each with their own backstories and personalties, you don't have any chance of following what's going on half the time. Even though a lot of your teammates are well-written and fleshed out, you stop paying attention to their dialogue after a certain point, since there's too much information to process.

And when Chrono Cross tries to tie into the complicated plot of its predecessor during the climax, it's safe to assume every player completely checked out.


7. Inside

inside game
Playdead

The most common reason why a video game's plot is hard to understand is because it's too complex. But Inside has the opposite problem, since it doesn't explain anything.

In this indie platformer, you play as a boy who's on the run from a group of mysterious guards. During the chase, our hero stumbles upon a laboratory, where scientists are performing mind-control experiments.

In the third act, the child discovers a chamber, which houses a grotesque homunculus called The Huddle. After our protagonist releases it, he becomes one with The Huddle, using its body to escape from the facility.

Because Inside has no dialogue, everything you see and experience is left to interpretation. Who is the boy? Are the guards the bad guys because they're hunting him? Or are they the good guys because they're trying to stop the boy from releasing The Huddle? Was The Huddle using mind-control to lure the child to the facility to free it? Is The Huddle a victim or a monster? Were the scientists using mind-control to take over the world or save it from an impending disaster?

After all these years, these simple questions still cannot be answered.


6. Mortal Kombat

Mortal Kombat 11
NetherRealm

Because Mortal Kombat puts so much emphasis on creative ways to gore your victims, it's easy to forget the bloody beat 'em up has a plot. Basically, the game centres around an interdimensional fighting tournament called Mortal Kombat. If the fighters from one world defeat the fighters from another world in ten consecutive tournaments, the losing realm will merge against the victorious one.

After Outworld's forces defeated Earthrealm's contenders nine times in a row, they assumed victory was at hand. But after Outworld had their collective asses handed to them, they declared war on Earthrealm.

If you think that story is complicated., that only covers the events... of the first game. If you want to unpack all the stuff introduced into the sequels, we'll be here forever talking about other realms, the kamidogu, time-travel, parallel universes, Robocop showing up for some reason, and the fact all the dimensions used to be fused into one super-universe, who was alive (somehow).

Because Mortal Kombat constantly retcons plot-threads and then retcons those retcons, the story is a mess. And with MK11 wiping the slate clean yet again, we've no idea what's canon anymore.


5. Final Fantasy X

Final Fantasy X Ending
Square Enix

Okay, we could've selected any Final Fantasy game, since every instalment leaves the player with more questions than answers. Where did Necron from Final Fantasy IX come from? What did the ending of Final Fantasy VIII mean? Why is Final Fantasy XIII very, very bad?

But if we had to pick one, it's gotta be Final Fantasy X. This entry kicks off with the hero, Tidus, playing a game of blitzball. Suddenly, the city of Zanarkand is destroyed by the monstrous Sin, causing Tidus to be transported to the world of Spira.

Okay, that's not too confusing. (At least, by Final Fantasy standards.) But every hour or so, another bombshell drops, which drastically alters the story.

Over time, you discover Sin is Tidus' father. Shortly after, a maester called Seymour tries to become the new Sin and marry Tidus' friend, Yuna, but he's killed (multiple times, might I add). After that, Tidus and Yuna awkwardly laugh in the hopes of becoming a meme (which works). Tidus' team then learn Sin cannot be permanently destroyed unless they defeat Yu Yevon, who created an eternal cycle of rebirth for the creature. Tidus also finds out everyone in the Zanarkand attack is slightly dead (including him), and his spirit will pass on after Yu Yevon is destroyed.

Even if you understand FFX's plot, it's hard to explain, since the story by the end bares no resemblance to how it started.


4. The Legend Of Zelda

The Legend Of Zelda Breath Of The Wild
Nintendo

The Legend of Zelda is composed of 20 main games, not including spin-offs, crossovers, or the abominable Philips-CDi instalments. So, it's no surprise it's difficult to follow the story.

But it's not just difficult - it's impossible. There are so many tales set in the distance future, the distant past, other dimensions, and alternative timelines, it's enough to befuddle anyone.

However, Nintendo had the chance to put these concerns to rest when they released a Legend of Zelda encyclopaedia called Hyrule Historia. Because this compendium detailed the franchise's timeline, fans believed they could finally follow the chronology of the franchise.

Bizarrely, the Hyrule Historia made things worse. According to the official synopsis, Link exists in three branching timelines - one as a child, one as an adult, and one as a fallen hero. Because of this, many defining entries like A Link to the Past, Majora's Mask, and The Wind Waker do not occur in the same reality.

In hindsight, it would've been better to suggest, much like Final Fantasy, that most The Legend of Zelda games are self-contained stories, since it's too much trouble to connect them all.


3. Castlevania

Castlevania Anniversary Collection (Ultimate Edition)
Konami

Castlevania follows a vampire hunting family called the Belmonts. Every century, Dracula rises from his grave, compelling the Belmont of that period to storm his castle and destroy him.

Now, understanding the story of a single Castlevania title is a piece of cake. Understanding the Castlevania saga collectively is unfathomable. Konami's iconic franchise consists of 26 mainline entries, which spans 22 timelines over a thousand years.

Just to add the confusion, the games weren't released chronologically. If you thought you could follow the story by putting the games in the right order, that won't help, since some of them are no longer canon! Several titles, including one of the best entries, Circle of the Moon, have been retconned out of existence.

Also, we only learned of Dracula's backstory and how he keeps resurrecting himself in one of the latest instalments, Lament of Innocence. If you never played this entry, you missed out on the largest part of Castlevania lore.

Although it's always exciting when a new Castlevania game is announced, fans feel a great sense of dread, knowing the continuity is about to muddled up again.


2. Kingdom Hearts

Kingdom Hearts Riku
Square Enix

Even though JRPGs are infamous for their convoluted storylines, you'd think SquareEnix would tone it down for Kingdom Hearts. Because this Disney property has tons of appeal for kids, it would be sensible for the plot to be straightforward.

Instead, the developers crafted a narrative that makes Tenet look comprehensible by comparison. As Kingdom Hearts opens, Sora heads off with his friends to explore new worlds. After Sora's friends are captured by the Heartless, he comes into possession of the Keyblade. Teaming up with Donald Duck and Goofy, Sora travels to various Disney worlds to defeat the Heartless.

Now, that premise is totally fine. However, things go bonkers when the antagonist, Ansem, is brought into the picture. You see, Ansem is the Heartless of Xehanort, who stole the identity of his master (the real Ansem) after he placed his heart into Terra, who was tasked with defeating Xehanort. This entity, known as Terra-Xehanort, is composed of the bodies of Ansem (the second one) and his Nobody, Xemnas. A Nobody is created when a body and soul is... you know what... at what point did the developers realise no gamer is going to understand any of this?

It's like Square forgot Kingdom Hearts' target audience is children. If adults can't grasp the story, kids have no chance.


1. Dark Souls

Dark Souls Remastered
FromSoftware

Many gamers have played Dark Souls from start to finish without having an inkling what's it about. Although it's possible to comprehend the story, it's not easy.

Key characters are unnamed. Backstories are incomplete. Objectives are unclear. The narrative is mostly hidden, meaning you must go out of your way to make sense of anything. By not picking up one trinket or not speaking to a specific NPC, you may miss out on crucial information on our hero, the world you roam, your mission, or the antagonist. Since many plot elements are ambiguous, you never get a straight answer.

Despite the fact most FromSoftware titles have this issue, Dark Souls is the biggest offender. At first, you'd think this would be the easiest Soulslike to comprehend, since it has two follow-ups that expand the lore.

But all the sequels did was offer more unanswered questions. In fact, they contradicted questions we thought the original answered! While playing Dark Souls 3, many players were bewildered to see Ornstein and Gwyndolin were alive despite... you know... dying. Even though plot-points like this make sense canonically (I think), you can understand why fans have debated over Dark Soul's narrative and timeline, even after a decade.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Mortal Kombat
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor

James Egan has been with Whatculture for five years and prominently works on Horror, Film, and Video Games. He's written over 80 books including 1000 Facts about Horror Movies Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about The Greatest Films Ever Made Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts about Video Games Vol. 1-3 1000 Facts About James Bond 1000 Facts About TV Shows