10 Worst Ever FIFA Games - Ranked

The not-so-beautiful games.

FIFA Fail
EA Sports

FIFA is bang in form this season, but they can’t all be beautiful games.

We’ve all heard how sublime FIFA 17 is with those fluid Frostbite-powered visuals, refined gameplay and packed team roster, and yet, not unlike Manchester City, its history is a story of ups and downs.

Beginning life as FIFA International Soccer in 1993, the EA Sports series has since appeared on everything with a screen and its annual refresh is the only thing in life more inevitable than death and taxes.  

The footballing powerhouse may be a regular fixture in the upper reaches of the software charts, but Pro Evo’s bitter rival has scored more than a few own goals during its playing career, from ugly handheld instalments to ropey ports that should never have even made the subs bench.

Looking back, it all seems like a stark reminder that the series didn’t always deliver the winning formula fans now take for granted.

10. FIFA 16 (Multi)

fifa 16 shielding tackle
EA Sports

FIFA was on a roll for the best part of a decade, but with last season’s instalment EA Sports had grown complacent.

No matter what your system of choice happened to be, FIFA 16 was the version where legacy issues which had plague the series for a number of years caught up with it.

The match engine was in need of a drastic overhaul by this point (which it was mercifully given in the Frostbite-powered FIFA 17) and the gameplay felt imbalanced - defenders were overly powerful and forwards lacked fluidity in the final third. And tactics? What are they?

Perhaps we wouldn’t have been so harsh on FIFA 16 had it not been released in the same year as a cracking edition of Pro Evolution Soccer, which returned to form with a shiny new match engine and retooled gameplay.


9. FIFA 15 (PC)

Fifa 15 Sad
EA Sports

EA Sports missed an open goal with the PC edition of FIFA 15.

Any game bearing the branding of football’s governing body is a sure-fire success, but this home computer edition almost wasn’t due to a buggy launch.

Upon release, gremlins in the machine threw a spanner in the works of player AI and the result was your team members trotting aimlessly towards the centre circle, regardless of whether you were staging an attack or on back foot.

Other glitches included imbalanced shooting mechanics and poor lighting, but EA had the chance to bang one in on the rebound when they issued a patch for the game.

Fortunately, this rectified the issues and brought the PC edition of FIFA 15 in line with its home console teammates.


8. FIFA Street 3 (Multi)

Fifa Street 3
EA Sports

EA Sports’ urban-flavoured spinoff series FIFA Street never did quite find its feet, and its third iteration was perhaps the biggest bottler in front of goal.

Flash trailers and a fanfare-heavy launch promised much, leading us to believe the grittier alternative to regular FIFA had finally arrived, but the end result was all style and little substance.

Repetitive challenges, inconsistent AI and a lack of game modes were just a few of the problems that brought FIFA Street 3 crashing down to earth, a lot like Liverpool’s title challenge this season.


7. FIFA World Cup South Africa 2010 (Multi)

FIFA World Cup South Africa 2010
EA Sports

Releasing two versions of FIFA in the same year just because there happened to be a World Cup on reeked of cash-in, but the stench becomes unbearable when FIFA World Cup South Africa 2010’s feature set is scrutinised.

We’re talking updated players skins, tweaked stats and new lines of commentary dialogue. Oh, and let’s not forget official team mascots, Money well spent or what?

Still, it could have been worse. EA Sports might have included blaring Vuvuzelas during matches - not that they sound any worse than the menu screen music on the Game Boy versions of FIFA, which we'll get to shortly.


6. FIFA 14 (Wii)

FIFA 14 (Wii)
EA Sports

FIFA 14 for Wii is another port that makes the list for a criminal lack of innovation.

The old ‘if it’s not broke, don’t fix it’ adage doesn’t quite cut it when we’re talking about blockbuster video games which cost full whack, so this lazy rehash of FIFA 13 was another scandal worthy of Sepp Blatter.

On the plus side, FIFA 13 for Wii wasn’t all bad, but even the most avid fans of the series expect more than a few updated squad lists for their hard-earned cash.


5. FIFA 07 (Game Boy Advance)

FIFA 07 (Game Boy Advance)
EA Sports

It took a while before handheld hardware was advanced enough to handle anything resembling the full-fat version of FIFA, but that never stopped Electronic Arts from churning them out over the years.

Although the Game Boy Advance was obviously better equipped for the series than its monochrome predecessor, two face buttons and a pair of shoulder buttons still proved inadequate for football games any more complex than Sensible Soccer.

EA did manage to cram 510 teams and a rudimentary career mode onto one of the handheld’s cartridges, but control issues coupled with graphics blockier than Minecraft earned this edition of FIFA 07 a deserved red card.


4. FIFA 09 (N-Gage)

FIFA 09 N Gage
EA Sports

Developing a mobile version of FIFA once technology allowed it was a smart move by EA, but releasing it through Nokia’s ill-fated N-Gage service in 2008 was not.

Not only was the N-Gage platform flagging at this point, with the mobile phone brand’s disastrous foray into gaming hardware fresh in everyone’s mind, this version of FIFA 09 was more sluggish than the Leicester City squad the morning after a Vardy Party.

While it wasn’t too shabby on the visual front, resembling a previous-gen PC game, users on devices like the Nokia N96 came away with sore digits after a few matches, providing the inability to move faster than jogging pace didn’t put them off first.


3. FIFA International Soccer (Game Gear)

FIFA International Soccer Game Gear
EA Sports

FIFA endured a troubled start to handheld life and its fortunes on Sega Game Gear were proof that colour visuals wouldn't have absolved the early Game Boy editions.

This FIFA International Soccer port did its best to mimic the isometric viewpoint of the 16-bit Mega Drive version, but the developers missed a few sitters along the way.

For starters, the camera was stuck in close-up mode, giving us a clear view of the player in possession but little else on the field of play. Half the time you were forced to blindly hoist the ball beyond the confines of the screen and hope for the best.

With only two action buttons, controls were limited and that meant no sprint command, slowing the action to a crawl.

Obviously concessions were unavoidable due to the hardware restraints, but did EA really have to jettison the on-screen timer? The only way to tell whether you were in Fergie Time was to track each half on your watch like a glorified fourth official.


2. FIFA International Soccer (Game Boy)

FIFA International Soccer Game Boy
EA Sports

Two years on from the original FIFA International Soccer’s release, EA Sports managed to scale down the formula and cram it onto a Game Boy cartridge.

It sounds like quite the development feat, except the end results were uglier than the tackle that ended David Busst’s career. And if that name means nothing to you, don't Google him if you're planning on keeping your breakfast down.

Ropey animation saw the player sprites flicker like an old-school LCD handheld device and the hideous menu screen music made your ears want to vomit.

Those issues may have been overlooked if the game played well, but with only two buttons at their disposal, the developers were forced to tie virtually every command to the A button, while B was used to switch player.

Most of the time you were blindly hammering A, not knowing whether your player was going to pass, shoot, cross, tackle or whip up a batch of margaritas.

EA Sports proved that porting FIFA to humble handhelds was possible with this 1995 release, but whether they should have bothered is another matter entirely.


1. FIFA Soccer 64 (Nintendo 64)

FIFA Soccer 64 Nintendo 64
EA Sports

With ball control that denied the laws of physics, godawful controls and hideous frame rate issues, FIFA 64 just wasn't cricket... it wasn't even football, for that matter.

Everything about the series' Nintendo 64 debut felt rushed, except the sluggish pace at which the players moved around the pitch. The graphics were half-baked and gameplay was cumbersome and horribly imbalanced.

EA Sports kicked this one out of the gates to get FIFA onto the N64 shortly after the console's launch, and in its haste, produced a title which was deservedly clobbered by Konami's International Super Star Soccer in every single respect.

Which do you think was the worst ever FIFA? Share your choices below in the comments thread.


In this post: 
FIFA 17
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Been prattling on about gaming, movies, TV, football and technology across the web for as long as I can remember. Find me on Twitter @MarkLangshaw