10 Worst Xbox One Games With Gold Releases So Far

While these games may have been given away for free, they still left gamers feeling ripped off.

Microsoft has been offering its Games with Gold program for just over two and a half years now. As it stands, members get two free games a month on both the Xbox One and the Xbox 360, but of course that's not how it always was. It wasn't until a full year after initiation that the program was brought to the Xbox One and a full year after that that two games a month were offered on the One. At this point in time members have been offered over 100 games with the Games with Gold program. With over 100 games having been offered, of course there's going to be some duds, and unfortunately for Microsoft, the duds dramatically outweigh the gems. Over the period, gamers have complained about the games they've been receiving and questioning if the Games with Gold program is even worth it. The argument could be made as to the program just being an added incentive as your Gold subscription covers the ability to use party chats, play multiplayer games and so on. However, with the evolution of the Gold subscription on Xbox Live, it has come to include things such as Deals with Gold on a weekly basis as well as the Games with Gold program. Without the subscription, those two features are gated away. So yes the Games with Gold feature is something we as Xbox users pay for, albeit the value we get back overshadows the price we pay by a large margin. While it seems obnoxious to complain over "free" games, most members just want games that can be considered fun, have good story or good gameplay. Members aren't expecting to get a six month old AAA title, but a little bang for our buck could be a nice change of pace. That's not to say we haven't received exceptional titles with the program, because we most certainly have, they are just so rare and buried under the bad games it's often forgotten. As a matter of fact it was a damn challenge in itself to narrow it down to only 10 games that were bad inclusions in the program. But here's the 10 games that genuinely made Xbox users question if Games with Gold was even worth it.


10. Halo: Spartan Assault

The first Games with Gold released on the Xbox One and the first game Xbox One users were surely disappointing with. Halo: Spartan Assault sees you take control of Edward Davis and Sarah Palmer in the fight against the covenant in the time between Halo 3 and Halo 4. That's about all the story you're going to get out of the game because frankly there truly is barely a story to get invested into. The game takes a top-down perspective, something very different from the usual first-person shooter aspect of Halo games (Halo: Wars being ignored because we like to forget about that game). See, this game started off as a mobile and PC game but mainly it plays like a mobile game. Remember Dead Ops Arcade from Call of Duty: Black Ops? That's essentially what this entire game is. Repetitive game play and missions all backed up by annoying and unnecessary microtransactions. In order to bring any type of new loadout into a mission you have to acquire certain amounts of XP. Don't have enough XP? Well looks like you're going to have to buy it then. Really, the game only holds any type of excitement for a mission or two before it starts to feel extremely repetitive and feels like nothing short of a grind. Halo: Spartan Assault never felt like anything more than a mobile game pushed onto the Xbox One because Microsoft was trying to flood the barren Xbox game market at the time. The game may have kept the Halo lore inside it with it's use of weapons and enemies but that's about it. It truly was just a game for the sake of being a game. It felt like more of a cash grab by Microsoft in the terms of "let's give it away for free and hook them in on microtransactions." It's a game that simply exists, many fans have since forgotten about it or deleted it.

9. Magic: The Gathering - Duels Of The Planeswalkers 2013

Despite the popularity of Magic: The Gathering, the mass market of Xbox users don't share this dedication to the game both in the physical table-top form and simulated arcade games. All-in-all this game is simply a card game with seemingly complicated rules most casual gamers will not care to want to learn, and that's absolutely it. At first glance Magic: The Gathering has a complex set of rules, even more complex exceptions to these rules and a unique terminology that take a lot of getting used to. It's understandable that not every single gamer would enjoy every single game that's given away, but Magic: The Gathering simply targets too narrow a group of gamers. With that being said though, of the Magic: The Gathering games, this one is the most friendly to new users as a lot of the features have been dumbed-down. Pre-built decks make up most of the selection (mostly in a monochrome fashion which makes learning and playing even easier), and the deck builder feature was not nearly as in depth as it would be in more recent games. The Magic: The Gathering fanbase was more than likely thrilled to see this game as an inclusion in the Games with Gold program, but only because their loyalty runs with the game. At its surface the game is nothing more than a table-top arcade game, where new players are forced to sit and learn the ins and outs of a sometimes complicated set of rules. To the average gamer this was nothing more than an easy pass and another disappointment.

8. CastleStorm

A game so nice we received it twice. Xbox One users got it first back in May 2015, then it would be available again on the Xbox 360 in December of the same year. It was the first time a game had been given away on both consoles (excluding backwards compatibility) and it certainly wouldn't be the last. CastleStorm, unlike the other more notable games like Tomb Raider and Assassin's Creed IV: Black Flag, was not a game fans were asking for once, let alone twice. Most notably the fact the definitive edition was given away first with the original and "not-so-definitive-edition" being given away second. The game is nothing more than a Angry Birds clone with a few minor tweaks. You can send forth your own army (and by army it's 10 or so soldiers) to fight the impeding army from the enemy castle. The story is far from interesting and offers essentially nothing other than being a springboard to unlock new weapons and upgrades - with over half the weapons being outclassed by one or two specifics. The game has a decent amount of customization but nothing groundbreaking, and gameplay is extremely repetitive, as it's essentially just "destroy the opposing castle before they destroy yours" over and over again. CastleStorm never really feels like anything more than a browser based flash game. There's a strong possibility it may even be based off of a combination of flash games Age of War and Bowmaster: Prelude as much of the same exact music and gameplay shows up in CastleStorm. Truly if this is the case, the flash games did it better.

7. A World Of Keflings

A city-building, resource management game that centers around the use of your Xbox Live Avatar as your character. Could there be a more uninteresting premise of a game possible? This arcade game was given away in November 2013, and from the start was set up for failure because of the game users had gotten the month prior - Halo 3. Granted at the time Halo 3 was six years old, but A World of Keflings was three. Anything given away after Halo 3 was bound to be met with a universal groan of despair, but to make it A World of Keflings (along side Iron Brigade) almost seemed unfair. It was as if Microsoft had understood it had given away one of its prized possessions and the only way to follow it up was to put members back in their place with a mediocre at best arcade game. At its core, nothing stands out in this game. I struggled to make it past twenty minutes and after I could take no more, was bored and knew there was no saving the game for me, I deleted it and never went back. All the basic aspects of a city-building, resource managing game are there and they don't delve much deeper than the basics. Gameplay is boring, repetitive and tedious. The cutesy design, with help from your Xbox Live Avatar make the game seem like it was made for children, which it might certainly have been.

6. Strike Suit Zero

Oh how the beginning months of Games with Gold struggled on the Xbox One. Being the fifth game given away, with entirely lackluster games preceding it, that collective groan from the Xbox community was starting to grow louder. Strike Suit Zero is a space flight combat game with a story that's a struggle to follow and make any sense of. The story is one of the only game modes to this incredibly shallow game as there aren't many features nor missions in the story. Flying around in a ship that transforms and blowing up other ships while protecting your own is about all you'll be able to take away from this game. Now the game would be forgivable to a point if the controls or gameplay made up for it in any way, which of course they do not. Once you figure out what is even happening, the gameplay becomes a cakewalk, as the only real challenge is trying to fulfill certain mission objectives. Almost all guns lock on and you're never really in real danger of failing. The worst, however, comes from the flight controls and camera control. The game is entirely disorienting. Too often you'll end up in the wrong direction, turned upside-down with no idea where you are in respect to an objective. Flying the ship, no matter how your settings are, always feels like it's going the exact opposite way of where you want to go. Everything feels inverted even if it isn't inverted. Truthfully the game controls make it hard to even want to get past the tutorial let alone finish the thing to the end credits.

5. Knight Squad

There's just something about top-down and/or cartoonish games Microsoft loves to include in its selections for Games with Gold. A very select few of them can be good, but Knight Squad wasn't one that fell into that category. Knight Squad is a sort of Bomberman hybrid that can be played with friends or alone, however being played with friends is really the only way anyone could get enjoyment out of this. This is unfortunately just another game that feels like a flash game with a little bit more depth than one would have. That depth doesn't run very deep, as after about 20 to 30 minutes of playing the game you've run through every game mode already. Yeah, there's a challenge mode with maybe eight challenges with only one being remotely difficult. The game is not meant to be played alone, which is understandable, but you'd be hard pressed to find a group that will pick this game to play over any other co-op or competitive game out there right now. Even if you found that group, the chances they played it for more than 20 minutes would be even slimmer. After getting Tomb Raider: Definitive Edition, Valiant Hearts: The Great War and The Walking Dead: The Complete First Season all consecutively on the Xbox One, it was hard to swallow the pill of no longer being spoiled that was, Knight Squad.

4.The Raven: Legacy Of A Master Thief

An episodic point-and-click adventure game that's not made by Telltale Games surely doesn't sound very appealing in the first place. While Telltale isn't the only company out there with the ability to make these games, they surely have had the most success. But the qualm with this giveaway doesn't lay much with the game itself (while it's most certainly not that good) but in the fact that it's episodic and only episode one was given away. That's right, only one third of the game was given away. That would be like only getting the first chapter of The Walking Dead for free, and if you wanted to find out what else happened, you'd have to shell out for the rest of the game. Not to mention the fact that The Raven's first episode ends in a cliffhanger, so not only are you left unsatisfied but felling as if it was all just a ploy to get you to buy the rest of the episodes. The gameplay itself doesn't save this game either. The story is simply not that interesting and it feels sluggish. For a detective game, nothing in it really screams detective work either. No puzzle in the game is hard to figure out, nor do they even require you to think at all. You're required to interact with people multiple times to even figure out if they are worth your time or not because you only find out after the third or fourth continuous interaction. The user interface isn't helpful either as items you need to interact with on screen show no sign of being remotely intractable until you manage to place your cursor over them. Such a tedious game, that wasn't even fully given away is most certainly something that left gamers annoyed.

3. Sacred 3

Boy did the fans of the Sacred series hate this game with a burning passion or what? Sacred 3 departed from everything fans of the series had come to love - action RPGs similar in tune to the Diablo series. What they were given in this game however, was a four player hack-and-slash, beat-em-up style game with a heavy departure from its RPG elements - there's not even a loot system in the game. The game currently has a 51 out of 100 from critics and a 4.1 out of 10 from fans on Metacritic. A game so widely panned by critics and gamers alike seemed like such a great game to give away right? A former developer even went so far as to openly apologize to fans for the game they received. While this disappointment may have hit home with a lot of Sacred series fans, the casual gamer probably hadn't heard of the series before. Even as this game was a fresh experience for some players, the gameplay itself just once again let down everyone who touched it. It was nothing more than a repetitive beat-em-up with watered down features. There's a lot of people who more than likely didn't even download the game, seeing it as only an "RPG" with little to nothing to offer. It's shocking that a game so widely hated was given away as a gift. While the game certainly isn't worth much currency it may have been the only way to get people playing it. Regardless, it left nothing but a sour taste in everyone's mouth.

2. Pool Nation FX

A pool simulator where the best part about it is its graphics - yikes. There's no way to deny that this game does look nice, as it's running on Unreal Engine 4. However, it's safe to say that absolutely everything for this game went into the graphics. A pool simulator with poor physics is just something that can't happen if people are supposed to take it seriously. The game has a decent amount of customization in the lines of the table, pool cue and balls, but the amount of time needed to play to actually unlock these customization options is staggering. Not only was this game simply unappealing to most, it's one of two games (the other being Crimson Dragon) that's been offered for the most months consecutively under Games with Gold. Pool Nation FX was given away for three full months from April 2015 to July 2015. While of course users still received the new monthly game along side Pool Nation FX. It seemed as almost a trick by Microsoft to say, "well you guys are technically getting two games this month," until in July 2015 (coincidentally right when this game was taken away from the Games with Gold program) two games were actually offered monthly.

1. D4: Dark Dreams Don't Die

D4: Dark Dreams Don't Die - the game with absolutely zero redeeming qualities going for it. Simply put, not a single thing about this game is good. It's an episodic video game, where the ending is a cliffhanger. Strike one. The controls are so bad it's one of the few times playing a game with the Kinect might actually be a better experience. Strike two. The story is so god awful, and nothing but in-your-face quirkiness it gets unbearable within the first 10 minutes. Strike three. This game is most certainly meant to be played with the Kinect because the controls are so bad it's inexcusable. Forcing users without the Kinect to use a slow cursor shaped like a hand (see how hard they're trying to get this Kinect thing across) to interact with so many senseless objects that do nothing. Quick time events are scattered throughout, coming out of seemingly nowhere, where you have to move both thumbsticks in certain directions and hit button prompts. The gamplay is BAD. The story however might be even worse. You're trying to solve the murder of your wife, whom your character calls "Little Peggy" in the creepiest way possible almost any single time he ever gets a chance to. You can time travel to solve this murder in something called "dives". An old detective friend comes over and cooks you food that you must search out and eat or else you run out of stamina and can no longer interact with anything. Oh, and your cat has turned into some woman who wears bikinis around your apartment, because why not. Nothing, absolutely nothing about this game is fun nor funny, as hard as it may try to be and truly is the worst game we've ever received. Which other poor XBox Games With Gold releases belong on this list? Share your picks below.

Contributor
Contributor

Just a gamer with an unhealthy addiction to achievements, fantasy booking WWE events and watching 90's teen comedies.