12 Most Replayable Video Games Of 2015

The games that'll tide you over until 2016 truly kicks in.

Given how expensive video games can be and how frequently developers attempt to gouge players for DLC that should be in the original game, value for money is a major concern to the discerning gamer now more than ever, because as anyone who bought The Order: 1886 knows, £40 for a five hour game is a pretty damn terrible deal. To cite some other recent examples, there's Evolve, which died a death rather quickly due to the lack of content, and Star Wars Battlefront, which is fitfully enjoyable if frustrating as most of the good stuff has blatantly been held back for DLC (which will cost almost as much as the "full" game). But what about the games that didn't cut corners and weren't trying to take players for a ride? The games from 2015 that ate up 50, 100, 200 or even close to 500 hours of your life depending on how much time you can actually physically devote to these damn things. Each of these 12 games served up an insane amount of action for your hard-earned cash, and should set an example for other developers to follow, that if you're not making a game worth a full retail asking price, then don't make that the asking price. Here are the titles we kept dragging ourselves back to time and time again this past year, the 12 most replayable games of 2015...

12. Splatoon

Who knew that a game about paintball on crack would end up being one of the year's most enthralling and fiendishly addictive multiplayer offerings? Splatoon was by far the Wii U's most intriguing new IP this past year, and a perfect example of a simple idea executed superbly: two teams face off over a sprawling map and attempt to paint as much of the map in their chosen colour as possible. The mechanics are easy to pick up and play, but with a steady stream of unlocks as you level up and a high level cap, there was plenty reason to stay glued to your Wii U over the second half of the year. Credit to Nintendo for also releasing a steady stream of new maps and weapons as free DLC: this is the sort of content rollout AAA franchises across the board should take note of. Splatoon is the sort of game you'll be dipping into for a quick 20 minutes for years, but at the same time, every so often you'll want a marathon session when you get the itch.

11. Guitar Hero Live

Guitar Hero Live completely smoked Rock Band 4 and reinvented the rhythm game at the same time, moving the goalposts for the genre while blowing the previously accepted limitations out of the water. Though the game has a fairly unremarkable campaign, the real value for money comes from GHTV mode, a free streaming service where players can strum along to hundreds of music videos. This adds literally 20+ hours of gameplay to the usual Guitar Hero formula (and that's if you only play each song once), and with songs constantly being added on a near-weekly basis, there's continued incentive to keep returning and see what's been added. If you were justifiably worried pre-release that the game wouldn't be continually supported, so far Activision have proven that they're going all in. Simply, no game in the genre comes even close to Live in terms of replay value.

10. Until Dawn

You might be thinking that Until Dawn's replayability comes from the differing outcomes of the various scenarios that you can have, but in fact, what truly makes the game worth replaying is its status as an absurdly entertaining party game. That's right. The game has 8 main characters, so find 8 buddies, pick names out of a hat and each player controls one of the characters throughout the adventure. This adds an extra layer of tension to gameplay as players will literally kill their friends off in order to save themselves, though as anyone who has played the game will know, this can often go sideways for the player in question. The actual core game doesn't have as much storyline variety as you might expect and picking up collectibles isn't especially interesting or fun, but the game goes down great at parties, and you can easily get at least three or four playthroughs from it by just showing it off to your buddies.

9. Halo 5: Guardians

Though Halo 5's single player campaign may have been a crushing disappointment, the series' value for money has always stemmed from the multiplayer component, and while there's sadly no split-screen multiplayer this time, the online offering is still as vibrant and entertaining as ever. It doesn't reinvent the wheel, but then, does it need to? The addictive quality of previous Halo games is out in full form here, and the addition of the insane Warzone mode adds even more chaos to the established online Halo formula. Even though the maps arguably aren't as good as the best games in the series and the Requisition points system has been contentious at best, it's still hard to pull yourself away because the core gameplay is so water-tight.

8. Rare Replay

Rare Replay is an extremely impressive collection of 30 classic Rare titles, ranging from the company's earliest efforts like Jetpac to solid gold classics such as Battletoads, Perfect Dark and Conker's Bad Fur Day. Even ignoring the insane value for money this collection presents, you'll likely never return to your original versions of these games again, aided by the superb addition of a rewind feature, allowing you to quickly correct a mistake in certain games without needing to start all over again (given the punishing difficulty of older titles in particular). Yes, it's missing Rare's best game (Goldeneye), but there are still at least half a dozen classics (if not many more) that you're likely going to return to time and time again, and with so much content, it's practically impossible to get bored.

7. Undertale

Undertale has become one of the year's most acclaimed games for numerous reasons: its ferociously original combat, its terrific sense of wit, its unique tone, and of course, the fact that despite running in at a fairly short 6 hours, there are a ton of ways to play through it. That's right, every Undertale experience is a new one: there's immense replay value to be had in deciding whether to spare enemies or kill them, and this will have reverberations for future playthroughs, as enemies will either talk to you differently or possibly not even appear at all. In addition there are several branching storylines and alternate endings, so plenty to keep you coming back for multiple playthroughs.

6. Call Of Duty: Black Ops 3

When you think of Call of Duty, do you ever really think "replay value?" The campaigns are usually a "one and done" deal, and most players likely begin to move onto other games once they've hit Prestige mode in the multiplayer suite. You get your 20-or-so hours in and then never touch them again, right? That said, Black Ops 3 served up easily the strongest value for money of any CoD game to date, as in addition to all the above and the usual Zombies mode, there's a special mode called Nightmares, which is unlocked after the original campaign is completed, remixing it with a zombie invasion premise. It's actually a lot more entertaining than the regular campaign (which is, to be kind, a mess) and gives a greater incentive to keep coming back than any previous title in the franchise.

5. Super Mario Maker

As if getting the opportunity to build your own Super Mario maps didn't promise enough replayability, Super Mario Maker will also keep players coming back for more as extra editing tools are unlocked over time, and best of all, you're able to download maps made by other players, essentially making the replay value potentially infinite. Sure, it's a simple game and not one you'll be likely to cling to for hours at a time, but the fact that there's always a new batch of absurdly inventive maps to test out ensures the game won't be feeling stale any time soon, and is extremely good value for money. Don't believe us? See for yourself just how creative and insane things can get.

4. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

Arguably the best thing about MGS V is the sheer wealth of options you have when deciding how to tackle a mission, and though a lot of the objectives are disappointingly samey, it's in choosing how to approach a given goal that the game's ridiculous variety becomes apparent. Are you going to snipe the target? Use a bombardment? Tranq the entire base and fulton everything in sight? Replaying missions is terrifically entertaining, especially as you begin to amass a more impressive arsenal of gadgets and weapons later in the game, and hoovering up even more GMP as you go is disgustingly addictive. Though the story did feel fairly lacking in MGS V and replaying missions will likely only enhance that feeling, The Phantom Pain is a prime example of gameplay helping to craft its own narrative. With the insane freedom the player has to weave their own unique mid-mission scenarios, it's hard to feel that mad about the toned down storytelling.

3. The Witcher 3: Wild Hunt

In case you somehow didn't get enough out of The Witcher 3 during your first playthrough, CD Projekt RED patched in a New Game+ mode over the summer, allowing players to start the game again while being bumped up to level 30 (assuming you weren't there already) and retaining everything that made them a bada** the first time around. First things first: New Game+ is not for the faint of stomach, it's a much more difficult version of the game from the outset (though there are difficulty settings still), but offers an experience distinct enough that Witcher fanatics probably won't be able to stop themselves from playing through it. Is it necessary? No. Does it reinvent the wheel? No. But if you own the game, you owe it to yourself to give it a whirl regardless.

2. Fallout 4

Bethesda have boasted in the past that you can spend 400 hours playing Fallout 4 and still not experience everything, but would you really want to? Though the game's visuals are disappointing and it doesn't move the franchise forward as far as it should, it's hard to argue with the bang for your buck in terms of content: the world is so huge that it's practically impossible to catch everything on one playthrough, and you're definitely going to want to return to take on some side-quests or just investigate the wasteland further. Also, as the number of mods released for the game increases, so too does the incentive to dive back in. There are already a ton of great mods out there, and by the end of 2016, the sheer possibilities the game will invite are going to be mind-boggling. If anything, Fallout 4 has too much content, or at least more than most human beings can reasonably fit into a regular, functioning existence.

1. Rocket League

Rocket League is the game that came completely out of nowhere and pretty much blew everyone away, because who can resist car football? The mechanics are simple but extremely fine-tuned, hence why even the base game can easily eat up 50 or 100 hours of your life before you know it. That's without even discussing the array of free DLC content, adding a bunch of wacky mutators into the game as well as a hilarious winter-themed ice hockey mode, and much, much more. There's not much more to it than a basic sports game, and yet more so than any other game over the past 12 months, it's had us coming back time and time again even when bigger and more ambitious games have come and gone. More than a silly indie you'll play feverishly for a month and then forget about, this is a title with true staying power. Which 2015 video games have you got the most mileage out of? Shout them out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.