12 Worst Superhero Video Games Of All Time
Superheroes! Don't bother assembling, please?
Superheroes are almost tailor-made for video games. These larger-than-life characters with their interesting backstories, cool abilities and diverse rosters of villains and allies should all go hand-in-hand with the gaming medium, but that begs the question: why on earth have there been so many truly godawful superhero video games?
Long before Rocksteady perfected Batman's gameplay in the Arkham series, and long before Insomniac nailed every nuance of Spider-Man's web swinging abilities, both of these poor superheroes have suffered throughout the years in some true horrors.
It's not limited to them either. Good old Aquaman, the Watchmen, Catwoman and various others have all starred in games that sullied their reputation and made anyone who played them want to go cry in a corner somewhere. From terrible movie tie-ins to games that had their creative direction controlled - and ruined - by a superhero's creators, there's plenty of examples of these terrible super-powered adventures to choose from.
In honour of these truly atrocious pieces of gaming history, it's time to somehow wander through the long, dark and scary quagmire that is terrible superhero games, and find the ones which can truly claim to be the best of the worst...
12. Superman 64
You can't write about the worst of superhero games without the most infamous of the lot - Superman 64.
Good old Supes hasn't had the best of luck in video games. Despite being seemingly ripe for the picking as a game character, there's never really been a fantastic Superman game. Superman 64 is definitely not a good Superman game. In fact, it's barely even passable as a game in general.
In Superman 64, you roam around a virtual recreation of Metropolis where the bulk of the gameplay revolves around navigating Superman through a terribly-rendered city full of fog, usually flying through rings and occasionally stopping to pick up an object.
That's basically it for the game. It plays terribly, nothing is fun, and it's incredibly deserving of all the ire that gets thrown towards it.
It's easy to point the blame at the developers, Titus Interactive for releasing a title in this state, but in a 2011 interview, Eric Caen, the game's producer, revealed that the game ended up as it was because Warner Bros and DC Comics heavily controlled what happened in the game. They didn't want Superman to fight real people - hence the virtual world - and around 10% of the original design made it into the final product.
A PlayStation version was also due for release after the huge failure of the N64 title, but the license expired and it never got off the ground.
11. Batman Forever
Ascending a ledge in a game shouldn't be particularly difficult, but Batman Forever somehow managed to make it so.
A tie-in for the movie of the same name, Batman Forever is a 2D, side-scrolling beat-em-up where you, or you and a friend, can play as Batman or Robin and punch, kick and attempt to use incredibly complicated combos to use gadgets to beat enemies.
It's an extremely weird game that uses very similar technology to the original Mortal Kombat titles, where Batman/Robin and the enemies are rendered in realistic fashion. Unfortunately they also tried to use a control scheme similar for Mortal Kombat to make a side-scrolling game, and the results are absolutely atrocious.
There's no in-game direction to tell you what to do, so it's literally a case of guessing for the most part. The aforementioned ledges are particularly bizarre; turns out you need to press up and Y to use a grapple to get up there, but the game doesn't tell you this at all.
10. Catwoman
To the surprise of nobody who has seen the terrible 2004 Catwoman movie staring Halle Berry, the game based on the movie is equally as dire.
Firstly, there's the camera. You'll probably spend most of the game trying to wrestle it into place, as it has a real tendency of looking at everything except what you need to. It's controlled by the D-pad, as for some bizarre reason, the games' combat controls are mapped to the right analogue stick. This is obviously a strange way to fight, and it really makes it difficult to pull moves off.
Outside of combat, you'll be completing acrobatic moves like the Prince of Persia games of the same area. Unfortunately Catwoman is janky as hell, and actually doing these is an exercise in frustration too. Combine it together with the terrible camera and you've got a real recipe for disaster.
Even more hilariously, on the title screen, Catwoman asks the player "do you want to play my game?" After playing it, Catwoman, probably not. Thank you.
9. Amazing Spider-Man 2
Spidey doesn't do half-bad in gaming. In fact, the web-slinger's transition to the gaming market has been pretty good overall. There's been more than a few really good Spider-Man games over the years, topped off nicely by the fantastic PS4 game released by Insomniac.
Unfortunately, however, there've been some duds too. The worst of the bunch is probably the Amazing Spider-Man 2, a tie-in with the movie of the same name.
Everything about Amazing Spider-Man 2 screams "rush job". Unfinished textures, janky character models, terrible pop-in and awful textures plague this game. Then there's the actual gameplay too - it's all very finicky and clumsy, with weird swinging mechanics (the left and right shoulder buttons control Spidey's left/right hands respectively), a combat system that tries to copy the Arkham games and fails, and some shockingly bad stealth sections thrown in for good measure too.
8. Watchmen: The End Is Nigh
Watchmen isn't your typical superhero story. It's a commentary on superheroes in general - a mature take on the genre that pushes boundaries and expanded on what a comic story could actually be.
Surely a tie-in video game should also push the envelope a bit, right? It should be a game that's memorable and makes the most of Watchmen's cast of weird and wonderful characters, yeah? Well, in the case of Watchmen: The End is Nigh, that's a categorical nope.
This is a Watchmen game in only that the characters from the franchise appear in it, and the name is slapped on the box. It's basically just a very shallow beat-em-up - inexplicably, released in two parts - which is set ten years before the original comic story. You play as either Rorschach or Nite Owl, making your way through scores of enemies with atrocious AI, smashing their faces in again and again and again. That's pretty much it.
Despite this, the game itself is presented well, with some excellent cinematics and decent character models. Unfortunately it's all a case of style with no substance, as the game attached to the visual spectacle is definitely not worth a glance, never mind an extended watch.
7. Aquaman: Battle For Atlantis
Aquaman gets a lot of flack already for being that fella who talks to fish, but he really deserves all the negativity coming his way if you've ever played Aquaman: Battle for Atlantis.
Panned upon its release in 2003, Aquaman is full of genuinely atrocious gameplay. The vast majority of the experience will have you swimming around a really poorly rendered version of Atlantis, following your radar to find small groups of enemies. Once you've found them, you engage them in almost-completely-broken combat scenes where our fishy friend can punch, kick, do a couple of special moves, and even call in sea-life for help too. There's no need to do so though; mashing the attack button is generally more than sufficient for getting through this, thanks to the terrible AI.
Ever played a game where the camera perspective changes, and suddenly down is up? Aquaman perfects this technique with a completely erratic camera that moves wherever it wants, routinely swapping out your controller direction so before you know it, you're pressing up to go left.
Then there's the fuzzy textures, terrible draw distance, lack of variety of things to do, and the fact that all the enemies have the same basic attacks and animations.
6. Batman: Gotham City Racer
Think the Riddler in Arkham Knight was the first one to give Batman racing challenges? Well, you're probably right, as Gotham City Racer is barely a racing game.
Released in 2001 for the original PlayStation, Gotham City Racer is based off the television series The New Batman Adventures. That's the main hook of the game - it includes some nice cutscenes based around the show, but that's about the only redeeming quality this one has.
The game looks and plays really badly. All you do is drive the Batmobile to a location, stop a crime, throw some Batarangs, and then rinse and repeat.
Traversal isn't fun either. During your driving escapades, Gotham City Racer will routinely pause the game and throw a loading screen at you as it can't handle rendering the environments. This happens a lot.
It almost plays very similarly to Driver 2; you're against the clock trying to get to a location and then there's a bit of traversal thrown in for good measure. Unfortunately the Batmobile handles like it's not a car at all, with stiff steering and rubbish cornering.
Oh and try not to hit anything in the environment - items have a tendency to throw your Batmobile into a massive, catastrophic spin and force you to restart the mission.
5. Silver Surfer
Love yourself a bit of difficulty in your games? Excellent - this is the perfect one for you: Silver Surfer on the NES.
Widely regarded as one of the hardest games ever created, Silver Surfer, is, unfortunately, also one of the worst examples of a superhero game out there. It takes an existing property, loosely makes a game around it, and throws up difficulty spike after difficulty spike all the way through.
Silver Surfer is both a side-scrolling and top-down shooter. You'll guide your character (who has a massive surfboard, making it really hard to dodge stuff) through unfairly-constructed levels where ONE hit means you die instantly and have to restart the stage all over again. There's no health, no armour and no power-ups. You touch something, you're dead.
Technically you can complete Silver Surfer in around an hour, but doing so probably means you are the ultimate deity of gaming and should be worshipped as such. For us mere mortals, it's probably better that you don't try Silver Surfer at all, as you can almost guarantee you'll be flinging your controller across your room in disgust within minutes.
4. Spawn: The Eternal
What do you get if you cross the battle system of Tekken with the 3D adventure gameplay of something like the original Tomb Raider games, then blend them together in a big vat with a pile of steaming horse dung? Well, you'd get Spawn: The Eternal.
Barely playable as an actual game, Spawn plays horribly, has a dreadful camera and - somehow - the game manages to make even the simple task of walking through a doorway incredibly difficult thanks to controls that don't respond quick enough to button prompts.
That's just the 3D exploration sections too! In combat, the game adopts a similar style to fighters such as Tekken, but instead makes sure that hits aren't registered correctly, the moves are poorly animated and the titular character feels less like a badass, and more like a hopeless lunatic swimming through treacle.
Then there's the graphics. Hoo boy - this game, even for its age, is really scraping the bottom of the barrel here. It's a blurry, pixellated mess all the way through.
3. The Uncanny X-Men (NES)
Created by an unknown developer - probably after they realised what they'd done and didn't want their name on the box - Uncanny X-Men is not only one of the worst superhero games of all time, but also one of the very worst games in the NES's library.
On paper, it sounds like it could be alright. You can play as six different X-Men - Wolverine, Cyclops, Storm, Colossus, Nightcrawler and Iceman - and that's a tantalising prospect for any X-Men fan. They all try to navigate through a 2D realm from a top-down perspective.
Unfortunately the execution leaves a lot to be desired. Despite there being a mixed cast of characters, the game is clearly made for characters who can shoot, and playing as one who can't is nigh on impossible due to poor collision when trying to punch things.
Then there's the AI - this game forces you to either play with a friend or be saddled with a terrible, computer-controlled character. They'll routinely get in the way, get stuck on objects and even commit suicide by falling to their death regularly down pits.
Even for a NES game this one looks awful too, with an uninspired colour palette, bland level design, and simple re-skins of the same model for every character.
2. Iron Man
Hey, they managed to get Robert Downey Jr. to actually voice Iron Man! That's neat - surely the game will be alright too?
NOPE.
Iron Man is the quintessential movie tie-in game. Rushed out to coincide with the very first film in the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Iron Man is exactly what you've come to expect from a licensed game - rubbish.
The game is generally experienced like this. You'll go from a really bad cutscene straight into a mission where Iron Man must complete various objectives, constantly dogged at all times by respawning enemies who employ every underhanded tactic in the book to kill you pretty much instantly.
It fails on actually making a gamer feel like Iron Man too, as the enemies are so ridiculously overpowered, you have to almost play the game like a coward. Instead of swooping around dealing out the hurt like Iron Man should, you'll pop out whenever and wherever you can to do minimal amounts of damage, before retreating back down your crate/mountain/other usefully-placed object.
If these weren't in place, the game probably could have been passable. Flying is alright and there's some cool upgrades to have. That in no way redeems the rest of it though. If you play this, you'll only find frustration rather than enjoyment.
1. Batman: Dark Tomorrow (Xbox/GameCube)
To be quite honest, there's no better way to sum up Batman: Dark Tomorrow than how IGN put it in their original review. They said: "There is no polite way to say this, so I'll forgo civility for honesty: This game is crap."
Batman's appeared a lot on this list already, and it's quite amazing that the Caped Crusader has such a bad history with video games. We're spoiled now with things like the Arkham Trilogy, but it seems as if Batman game development previously was more of a 'throw crud at the wall and see what sticks' kind of approach, rather than actually thinking about it.
Where to begin with Dark Tomorrow? Well, one of the worst things about it is the combat system. There's no way to block, the controls are weird, and - as Batman doesn't like to kill people - you must arrest every enemy you knock unconscious. Only problem is that you get about five seconds to do so, and there are usually more than one enemy present at that moment. You'll also be treat to the exact same cutscene every single time you arrest an enemy.
Then there's the rest: a terrible camera where you'll end up fighting with it more than the enemies? Check. Grapple swinging mechanics where you'll routinely fall to your death through no fault of your own? You betcha. Load screens basically every 30 seconds that constantly break up the action? You got it!
Batman should immediately return to Wayne Manor and think about what he's done for putting out something like this.
Watch Next
You'll Never Get 100% On This Batman: Arkham Quiz!