14 Most Overrated Video Games Of 2015

Bad optimisation broke the Bat...

There's a prevailing attitude among many gamers that video game critics are simply too generous. Contributing towards a culture where many games have their worth blown wildly out of proportion, resulting in them becoming "overrated". In the gaming world, a 7/10 is rather peculiarly seen as an "average" score - compared to a 5/10 in film criticism - and so a 70 on MetaCritic is pretty much the minimum score that most developers would want to rack up. Even that's pretty disappointing to most publishers, though, and with incentive bonuses being paid to developers whose titles achieve certain scores, it's safe to say that there's a lot invested in the word of these critics (not to imply any untoward conduct on their part). Now, 2015 saw plenty of games release with suitable scores: Star Wars Battlefront was an enjoyable if piecemeal shooter and hence scored in the early-to-mid 70s, Splatoon was a fun new IP and racked up 81, and Undertale, one of the most imaginative games of the last few years, rightly scored an impressive 92. These 14 games, however, had their true value misrepresented by overzealous critics, who for one reason or another, decided to take it easy on them despite the presence of huge flaws. Here are the 14 most overrated video games of 2015...

14. Halo 5: Guardians

MetaCritic Score: 84 What It Deserved: 69 Everyone wanted the first Halo game on the Xbox One to be a home run, but in honesty it ended up feeling like the weakest, laziest and least "necessary" of the Halo games to date. To start, the campaign is for the most part a tedious affair, with the much-hyped Locke vs. Chief showdown ultimately amounting to very little, while you're forced to fight the same boss enemy countless times, it clocks in at just five-ish hours in length, and you probably won't remember much about it a few weeks after playing. Yes, the foundational gameplay is as excellent as ever, but it's wrapped around repetitive objectives (so...many...elevators) and a dull plot. The multiplayer fares much better, thankfully: though many objected to the eye-gougingly ugly use of primary colours in too many of the maps, this is really where the game got to shine, and accounts for the vast majority of the effusively positive reviews. The requisition points system, however, is a wildly unnecessary way of forcing microtransactions into the game, and most depressingly of all, they've apparently been a huge hit for Microsoft. Halo 5 is a sequel that falls far short of all that hype, and though it's still fun to play, the addictive quality just wasn't there, due to some of the series' most underwhelming maps and the general player feeling that this isn't a package worth the full retail price.

13. Evolve

MetaCritic Score: 74-77 What It Deserved: 60 Evolve was massively hyped as the Next Big Thing ahead of release, but Turtle Rock Studios' follow-up to their superb Left 4 Dead was in fact a colossal let-down, a tedious multiplayer excursion that used up most of its goodwill after no more than a few hours. The concept is admittedly superb: four human hunters take on a monster who continually evolves throughout the battle, but sadly there's not much beyond that premise to sustain a full-price retail title. The maps are far too similar, there's too much grinding, and your level of fun will vary wildly depending on the skill of the people you're playing with. If you can find four pals to consistently play it with, then you'll benefit substantially, but this just isn't very realistic for the vast majority of players. It looks nice and it has some solid ideas, but it's ultimately all about the execution, and Evolve falls down hard with an intermittently enjoyable experience at best.

12. Until Dawn

MetaCritic Score: 79 What It Deserved: 68 There's no point arguing with the fact that Until Dawn is a fun game, but there was a far better way to execute the concept. You see, Until Dawn is essentially a 7-hour interactive horror movie, and though it spends much of that time reveling in the cliches of the genre, it's not nearly witty or subversive enough to do much more than merely emphasise the absurdity of these tropes. As such, this gets rather tiresome over the length of the campaign, which players are pretty much encouraged to blast through in one sitting, preferably with enough pals so that you can assume the role of one character each. The abundance of cliches feels draining over such a run-time without sufficient satirical content, and so it becomes apparent after a few hours of play that the game would've been much more entertaining if the 7 hours were split into 3 or 4 "movies" with different takes on various horror film scenarios. After all, would you really want to watch a 7-hour film about a bunch of horny, idiotic teens trapped in the woods? Probably not: variety is the spice of life, and had we seen more in the way of diversity, Until Dawn perhaps could have lived up to those lofty reviews. Also, the game's insanely low frame-rate, often hitting the early 20s, is enough to knock it down a few points.

11. Game Of Thrones

MetaCritic Score: 64-69 What It Deserved: 55 Telltale have enjoyed tremendous success with their The Walking Dead episodic series, and they've proven with the likes of The Wolf Among Us and Tales from the Borderlands that they're no one trick pony...but sadly not everything they make is quite up to the same standard. Game of Thrones is all the more disappointing because it seems like such a rich universe to translate into the episodic video game medium. Sadly, it's hampered by atrocious graphics (even for the fairly forgiving standards of these games), forced cameos from the series' characters, more transparent choices, and a narrative that's far more difficult to get invested in than Telltale's usual fare. Perhaps it's because the TV show is so well-written compared to something like The Walking Dead that our expectations are automatically higher, but even the fairly mixed reviews for this game ultimately felt like they let it off lightly. From the presentation to the slack narrative, it just didn't excite and intrigue in the same way that the studio's very best series have so far. Strictly for die-hard Thrones fans, but even then, you probably won't get that much out of it.

10. Assassin's Creed Syndicate

MetaCritic Score: 74-78 What It Deserved: 62 While Ubisoft do deserve a small measure of credit for learning from Unity's horrendous launch and releasing the latest Assassin's Creed title in a playable state on all platforms, it's still largely business as usual for the franchise: a few inconsequential additions, a shiny new locale...and tons of repetitive, dispassionate missions. That's right: it's the same old story with a different lick of paint, and it's fascinating that so many entries deep, critics are still willing to give it a 70+ average for what's largely cut-and-paste game design. For all but the most hardcore fans, the formula feels ready to collapse spectacularly under its own lack of imagination and ambition. Smartly, 2016 sees no new core Creed games hitting the market, as Ubisoft reportedly plan to ditch the tired annualised format, which will hopefully up the series' quality at least a little.

9. Battlefield Hardline

MetaCritic Score: 71-73 What It Deserved: 61 There was plenty of worry that this Battlefield spin-off would end up being a glorified DLC update...and that happened to be exactly on the money, but charged at a full retail price. Though more effort has been put into fashioning a longer campaign this time, it ironically is brutally boring for the most part, suffering from terrible AI and relying massively on stealth in a way that's neither fun nor particularly smart. Though the multiplayer combat is as decent as usual in the franchise and the Cops 'n' Robbers gameplay is a solid sideways niche for the series, it just doesn't do enough to justify actually being a full-price game. This was worth £20 at best upon release, because it's not as fun as Battlefield 4 and not much more than a mildly interesting diversion for an hour or so every now and then. Not a terrible game as such, but it shouldn't really be a game in its own right at all...

8. Everybody's Gone To The Rapture

MetaCritic Score: 78 What It Deserved: 65 Walking simulators are always going to prove divisive, especially with players compared to critics, but even as someone who typically enjoys meditative experiences of this sort (including developer The Chinese Room's own Dear Esther), Everybody's Gone to the Rapture is a painfully dull effort. Now, the game certainly looks nice and the voice acting is superb...but that's pretty much all there is. It forces you to walk at a snail's pace (and even holding the "sprint" button is only a marginal improvement), a lot of the dialogue is tedious and repetitive, navigating using golden orbs is more awkward than intuitive, and just when it seems to be getting a little bit interesting...it abruptly ends. Some might find the artful beauty in it, and good for them, but in an age where there's a desperate desire to push video games as artistic experiences, this feels like one that's trying too hard and not enough all at the same time.

7. Call Of Duty: Black Ops III

MetaCritic Score: 73-81 What It Deserved: 70 To be fair, critics have been fairly generous with the Call of Duty series for some time now, and though Black Ops III is indeed one of the better CoD titles of recent years, it still doesn't really do enough to be a truly great game. Yes, the campaign is longer and more involved, and the multiplayer boasts some fantastic new abilities and killer maps...but the campaign's story is pretty much nonsensical, the verticality isn't taken advantage of particularly well, and the graphics still feel several years behind the times. It's a rock solid FPS, and so a score of around 70 feels apt. An enjoyable game but not one that most players will keep returning to once they've beaten the campaign and Prestiged online.

6. Forza Motorsport 6

MetaCritic Score: 87 What It Deserved: 67 There's no point arguing with Forza 6 from a visual perspective: it is a gorgeous-looking racer, but sadly invites mostly boredom during its uninspired career mode, which largely consists of sluggish, overlong races ad nauseum. Still, at least the rewind feature means you won't need to tirelessly repeat races just to get a suitable finish, The depth of customisation is certainly appreciated and the higher-speed vehicles add some break-neck fun, but the majority of the time spent in serious competition will ultimately be a fairly joyless sprint where, more often than not, you'll leave your opponents effortlessly in the dust. Real petrolheads might find it more engaging than casual players, but there's the distinct feeling that the "simulator" genre is sorely in need of a title that manages to be technical and massively fun all at the same time. Forza 6 is a well-designed racing game where, hilariously, the worst thing about it is the racing.

5. Rock Band 4

MetaCritic Score: 78-79 What It Deserved: 66 Is Rock Band 4 fun? Absolutely. But should it have been released as a retail game? Absolutely not. Following the downturn of the rhythm game genre around five years ago, Harmonix attempted to resurrect it with a new Rock Band game, which would abandon the over-the-top guitar-teaching shtick of the previous title and get back to plastic instrument basics. While that is successful to an extent, Rock Band 4 basically just feels like a glorified DLC update: the 65 on-disc songs are a decent if not massively remarkable collection, and the removal of online multiplayer is nothing short of criminal. That Harmonix felt comfortable charging up to £50 for such a meager amount of content is ridiculous, as this really should've been a £20 DLC. There's a feeling that many critics gave the game a free pass because of the compatibility with legacy content, that you could play most of your DLC and songs from previous games within the new game, but in essence that gets away from what this new release is actually offering you, and seems disingenuous. After the vastly superior Guitar Hero Live released a few weeks later, this one was all-but forgotten, even though Live inexplicably only scored a few points higher than RB4 on most platforms.

4. Soma

MetaCritic Score: 79-84 What It Deserved: 70 Frictional Games' long-awaited follow-up to Amnesia: The Dark Descent is a solidly enjoyable, atmospheric sci-fi horror game, though those expecting something on the nerve-shreddingly intense level of Amnesia may find themselves a tad underwhelmed Yes, the mood is there and the game certainly looks great, but Soma is also undone somewhat by its irksome pacing (vague mission objectives will often make fairly mundane tasks last longer than they need to) and the fact that it's just not very scary: the enemies don't instill that same sense of fear and anxiety that made Amnesia such a tough experience. The narrative is an ambitious step up, but the execution settles for being good rather than great, sadly.

3. Batman: Arkham Knight (PC)

MetaCritic Score: 70 What It Deserved: 53 Batman: Arkham Knight may have been a decent game on consoles, but the PC version was an unmitigated disaster right out of the gate. Thanks to performance issues which resulted in a dreadfully low frame-rate whenever the player entered the Batmobile, even on high-end systems. The port was so universally criticised that its PC release was pulled the day after initial release, with a major patch being released in late September and the game going back on sale in late October. It was also revealed during this time that Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment were aware of the technical issues ahead of release, but decided to put it out anyway. Even with the new patch, the game still doesn't work properly for many players, causing WBIE to offer refunds to all players who requested one until the end of 2015. It's disgraceful that a seemingly AAA title can release in such a poor state, and that the game still scored a solid 70 is proof perfect that critics went pretty easy on it. For the sake of comparison, the Xbox One and PS4 versions scored 85 and 87 respectively, but even so, Arkham Knight's intermittent PC performance really only makes it feel like half a good game, hence the proposed score of 53.

2. Fallout 4

MetaCritic Score: 84-88 What It Deserved: 74 Fallout 4 was one of 2015's most-hyped games... and one of its most disappointing. Most critics accepted many of the game's flaws, that the engine feels ridiculously out of date, the graphics aren't very good and there are tons of glitches, but nevertheless threw 9s and 10s at it for its addictive gameplay, customisation options and compelling story. This is a fine example of a good game that really needs polish to push it into the 80+ mark: it feels so un-refined, and to boot also features shockingly repetitive missions, not to mention a fairly down-the-line, familiar story. Is it a fun game? Yes, but it doesn't feel sufficiently evolved from Fallout 3 and New Vegas given its hefty development time and release on current-gen platforms. Even so, it's still not the year's most overrated game...

1. Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain

MetaCritic Score: 91-95 What It Deserved: 76 Can a video game be at once one of the best games of the year and almost the most crushingly disappointing? There's little arguing that Metal Gear Solid V served up some of the most expertly-layered, intuitive and straight-up addictive gameplay of 2015: Snake has never played with more fluidity and freedom, but at the same time, the game still left so many MGS fans scratching their heads. For one, the lack of cut-scenes is a shame, albeit not a deal-breaker if the game still managed to convey a tightly-woven, appropriately insane story. Sadly not, though: the narrative took a major backseat to the gameplay here, with morsels being drip-fed to the player throughout, and then the game ending on an incomplete note, with major portions of the story blatantly being left unfinished due to time constraints. Then there's the depressingly samey missions, the eye-rollingly sexist depiction of Quiet, the fact that most of the boss battles are non-events that can be sidestepped entirely in some cases, and the insane plot twist that enraged as many as it satisfied. It's all the more disappointing considering that Kojima and Konami have now parted ways, so this is likely how the MGS story ends...at least until Konami tries to milk it without Kojima's presence. Tragic. Which 2015 video games did you find the most overrated? Shout them out in the comments!

Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.