14 Most Surprising Metacritic Scores Of 2017

RIP Mass Effect?

Mass Effect Andromeda Metacritic
EA

While terrible movies can often fend off poor reviews and release to gangbusters box office results, gamers tend to be a far more conscientious bunch where money is concerned, because of course, games generally cost much more than a trip to the cinema.

As such, critical reception to a game is far more important, to the extent that many publishers will dole out financial bonuses to developers if their new game scores over, say, 85 on Metacritic. That magic aggregate number means a lot, to the extent that many gamers won't even touch a game below 80.

Like any year in gaming, 2017 served up its share of surprise hits, shock flops and, perhaps most frustratingly of all, middling disappointments, reflected in these Metacritic scores just about nobody saw coming. Awesome franchises fell from grace, others rose from the embers, and some games just did...OK?

Nobody was surprised that the likes of Zelda: Breath of the Wild and Super Mario Odyssey made critics go giddy, nor that something like Troll and I was a critical punching bag, but as we get to thinking how 2018's biggest games will fare with the gaming press, these are big critical shocks that undeniably caught everyone off-guard.

Note: Metacritic scores are taken from the most-reviewed version of the game unless specified...


14. WWE 2K18 - Nintendo Switch (35)

WWE 2K18 Brock Lesnar Paul Heyman
2K Games

Now, it's fair to say that critical expectations for the WWE 2K franchise are always middling at best, but considering that the PS4, Xbox One and PC versions of WWE 2K18 scored 66-67 - a score consistent enough with the last few entries - few could've expected the Nintendo Switch port to score barely half that.

While 2K's stealth release of 2K18 on the Switch definitely raised a few eyebrows, it was nevertheless reasonable to expect the game to score around 50. However, the few critics who even bothered to review the game (which wasn't even given to most outlets for review) savaged the title for its myriad technical issues, calling it "painful to play" and "a terrible port".

The company responsible for the port, Blind Squirrel, has insisted that they will patch WWE 2K18 into shape in the future, but it's hard to imagine any reviewers going back to give it a second chance. It's toast.


13. Need For Speed: Payback (60)

Need For Speed Payback
EA

After 2015's Need for Speed reboot scored middling critical reviews (60), 2017's new entry was marketed as a pulsing return to form for the franchise, taking clear influence from the Fast and the Furious movies and intending to take the series in a cinematic new direction.

Though Payback was praised for ditching the widely-reviled always-online gameplay of previous titles, it nevertheless introduced a whole new means of actively annoying players, with an over-abundance of micro-transactions causing most critics to knock the game down a few notches.

Less-surprising was the criticism of the cinematic story mode and linear campaign gameplay, but even so, just about everyone expected Payback to be a decent improvement on the 2015 game, right? Instead of racking up a decent 70-ish score, it scored exactly the same as its maligned predecessor. Oops.


12. Friday The 13th (61)

friday the 13th
Gun Media

Friday the 13th is a fun game...to a point, but as anyone who has played it will know, it's also horrendously janky, cheaply thrown-together and basically a mechanical mess.

The joy of playing as Jason Voorhees is undeniable, but this is constantly played-off against repetitive central gameplay that gets old fast, the lack of a single-player campaign, the abundance of bugs and general feeling that this could be so, so much better.

Again, it's not a bad game, and it deserves a little slack for clearly being created on a small budget by people with a passion for the franchise, but 61? Really?

That's not to say 61's a good score, because it absolutely isn't, but given the game's litany of technical issues, it really shouldn't be scoring north of 50.


11. Super Bomberman R (62)

super bomberman r
Konami

It hurts to admit it, but Super Bomberman R on the Nintendo Switch absolutely stinks. This is a great property that's a fantastic fit for the Switch on paper, especially when it pertains to multiplayer mayhem, but this low-fi, slapdash effort falls far short of its awesome potential.

Where to begin? The single-player "story" mode is boring and full of obnoxious cut-scenes, the online multiplayer is cursed by revolting input lag, and as many critics couldn't help noting, the game launching with a full AAA price tag did it absolutely no favours where review scores were concerned.

Even though the online multiplayer is still an abject disaster after numerous patches, it's staggering that the game managed to land "mixed or average" reviews. Anything over 40 for this one just seems ridiculous, and one suspects critics went a little easy on it because it was a Switch launch title and the glow of a new platform hadn't yet worn off.


10. Star Wars Battlefront II (68)

Star wars battlefront 2 theed
EA

After 2015's Star Wars Battlefront scored a solid if undeniably underwhelming 73 with critics, EA assured fans that the follow-up would act as an apology of sorts.

Not only did EA sing the praises of a new cinematic campaign, but they insisted the game would come complete with a larger wealth of content from every Star Wars era, and better still, there wouldn't even be a season pass.

This all sounded great, but as with their Need for Speed: Payback, pesky micro-transactions ended up ruining a lot of the fun, proving so interwoven into the multiplayer progression system that removing them (temporarily) still left behind a slog of an online suite.

As for that promised single-player campaign? It lasted about four hours and was comprised mostly of multiplayer skirmishes lazily plugged in, while much like its predecessor, the multiplayer was intermittently fun if ultimately quite hollow and soulless.

Few could've expected Battlefront II to score less than its predecessor, but such is the extent of EA's patent greed, and thankfully the video game press collectively flipped them the bird in response.


9. Knack II (69)

Knack 2
SCE Japan Studio

Every console's launch has at least one infamous title that becomes the punch-line of jokes for the remainder of the system's shelf-life, and for the PS4, that game is Knack.

Though hardly a terrible platformer, it was rather on the uninspired side and proved jarringly challenging for a game fundamentally aimed at kids, resulting in it scoring just 54.

While Sony was saying all the right things about Knack II, namely that the difficulty had been curbed and it placed a greater emphasis on co-op multiplayer, was it really reasonable to expect anything more than a mild improvement over the original?

A 60 score seemed about right for this one, but you know what? Knack II is actually a legitimately solid platformer. Flawed, absolutely, and far too long for what it is, but the co-op elements work superbly, the gameplay is dynamic, and yes, it truly is worthy of a Metacritic score higher than Star Wars Battlefront II.

This is clearly a game made by people with passion, which is more than can be said for EA's big-budget "Star Wars casino". That it triumphed over Star Wars, albeit just barely, is one of the year's most mind-boggling - not to mention hilarious - video game stories.


8. Mass Effect: Andromeda (71)

Mass effect andromeda
Bioware

In terms of highly-anticipated entries into hugely acclaimed franchises falling flat on their faces, no game fell below expectations as spectacularly as Mass Effect: Andromeda, which was at least polite enough to offer up an EA Access trial a week ahead of release, allowing players to experience the mess for themselves.

Considering that the previous entries into the franchise scored anywhere from the mid-80s to the mid-90s, Andromeda scraping just 71 was a huge story that left the already-jaded fanbase at a total loss.

Launching with meme-worthy facial animations, an abundance of bugs, an underwhelming story and oddly repetitive gameplay, Andromeda failed to live up to the high standard set by its predecessors, causing EA to put the series "on ice".

Shortly after the game's release, reports emerged of its hurried, sloppy production, and while the series will definitely return one day, EA needs to think long and hard about how they reintroduce it to audiences (no microstransactions!).


7. Star Trek: Bridge Crew (75)

star trek bridge crew
Ubisoft

Though the idea of a Star Trek VR game was a dream come true to Trekkies the world over, Ubisoft didn't do a particularly great job of marketing Star Trek: Bridge Crew's awesome social potential, and like most VR games based on popular IPs, expectations were set sensibly low.

Would it have surprised anyone if the game scored a 50, while being deemed an "ambitious failure"? As it turned out, Bridge Crew is absolutely one of the best mainstream social VR games, serving as a thoroughly immersive love letter to Star Trek while being a total blast with strangers and pals alike.

Sure, the mission variety isn't amazing, but above all else it's a ton of fun and a decidedly sturdier multiplayer experience than most were surely anticipating.


6. Arms (77)

Arms Nintendo
Nintendo

Back when Nintendo first announced Arms for the Switch, it seemed like a daft gimmick destined to score mixed reviews from critics, because how often are games centred around motion controls actually fun for more than a few hours?

Arms may not be one of the Switch's very best games, but it sure proved its doubters wrong, serving up a surprisingly deep and challenging beat 'em up experience, with some of the best online multiplayer on Nintendo's nifty hybrid console.

The motion controls actually work pretty well (though you can easily turn them off if not), it crackles visually and has far more to it than just being another gimmicky Nintendo motion control game like, say, 1-2 Switch (which, to the surprise of nobody, scored a mediocre 58).


5. Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle (85)

Mario rabbids kingdom battle
Ubisoft/Nintendo

Much like Arms, a lot of people - press and fans alike - had seemingly made their mind up on Mario + Rabbids Kingdom Battle the moment its existence was leaked online.

And that's totally understandable, because on paper, why would a Ubisoft cross-over game starring Mario be anything more than a lazy cash-grab?

And then the reviews dropped, and it turned out that Kingdom Battle's "XCOM with Mario" label fit better than just about anyone expected. Visually dazzling, surprisingly challenging and unexpectedly lengthy, this clearly wasn't just thrown together in a few months by the dregs of Ubisoft's dev teams, and was absolutely deserving of all its shock praise.


4. Resident Evil 7: Biohazard (86)

Resident Evil 7 Gun
Capcom

Prior to the release of Resident Evil 7, Capcom's survival horror franchise had been on the back foot following the critically and commercially disappointing reception to the sixth game, which scored just 67 upon initial release.

While just about everyone was expecting RE7 to be an improvement, it wouldn't have been remotely surprising if the game's new first-person style was met with some pushback, as well as the potential for it to be too short, fail to fully exploit its PSVR support, or just not feel like a Resident Evil game.

As it turned out, RE7 was by far the best Resident Evil game since the fourth, with critics praising it for its macabre story, unexpected dark humour, entertaining villains and fantastic VR support.

Seriously, if you haven't played this game in VR yet, get yourself some adult diapers and give it a go. It is a terrifying experience like nothing else available for PSVR right now.

Even played "flat", though, RE7 is a highly entertaining rejuvenation of the stagnant series, creating a firm formula for the inevitable eighth game in a year or two.


3. Sonic Mania (86)

Sonic mania green hill
Sega

Beloved though Sonic the Hedgehog is, there's a reason why he isn't held in quite the same esteem as, say, Mario: his games are nowhere near as good.

The Sonic series is one of the most infuriatingly inconsistent AAA franchises in gaming history, almost never scoring consistent 80+ scores across platforms, such that often, only the hardcore Sonic fans need apply (see the widely-panned recent release Sonic Forces).

2017 did see the release of one excellent Sonic game against the odds, however, with Sonic Mania serving as a visually faithful, ingeniously conceived return to the series' 8-bit roots.

While it isn't the most unique or original Sonic game, straight-up "borrowing" from the better earlier games, it performs a minor miracle in getting even casual players excited about Sonic again for the first time in years. Who could've seen that coming?


2. Injustice 2 (87)

injustice 2
NetherRealm

The original DC-themed Injustice: Gods Among Us scored a solid 81 back in 2013, and when Injustice 2 neared release, it seemed like it would probably score around the same: maybe a point or two different either side.

As it turned out, however, Injustice 2 wasn't just a terrific improvement over the original, it's arguably the best beat 'em up of the generation so far. The cinematic story mode is legitimately involving and shames practically every recent fighting game "campaign" (looking at you, Tekken 7), the combat has become more varied in complex, the graphics are (mostly) fantastic, it's overflowing with content, and even the micro-transaction nonsense isn't overly intrusive.

While other hit beat 'em up franchises are busy serving up piecemeal releases (looking at you, Street Fighter) and coasting on their more sizeable, loyal fanbases, Injustice 2 swings for the fences and largely succeeds. If you've been sleeping on it, the gaming drought of early 2018 is a great time to get involved.


1. Nier: Automata (88)

NieR Automata World
Square-Enix

And finally, we have one of the best-reviewed and most talked-about games of 2017, Nier: Automata. While the game was always going to spark a lot of discussion, expectations for most fans were cautious optimism after the original Nier scored a middling 67.

As it turned out, Automata was a towering improvement of a sequel, serving up one of the year's most fascinating narratives, wrapped inside a wildly entertaining, diverse action RPG that saw director Yoko Taro once again challenging the limits of what games can do.

While the original Nier was a poor seller, Automata's reviews have no doubt helped it cross 2 million sales worldwide. Can the inevitable third Nier score even higher? As ever, time will tell.

Which video game Metacritic scores surprised you the most this past year? Shout them out in the comments!


Contributor
Contributor

Stay at home dad who spends as much time teaching his kids the merits of Martin Scorsese as possible (against the missus' wishes). General video game, TV and film nut. Occasional sports fan. Full time loon.