15 Best Hidden Gem Video Games Of The Decade

Control deserves your attention.

CONTROL GAME
Remedy

Compressing ten years' worth of video games into a single list is never easy. With cutting edge events like Call of Duty: Modern Warfare and Star Wars Jedi: Fallen Order seeing the decade out, it's easy to forget that groundbreaking titles such as Red Dead Redemption and Mass Effect 2 were there to usher it in.

What I mean by that is there have been a ridiculous amount of great titles released in that time, and the industry as a whole has shifted through so many revolutions (and arguably devolutions) over the past ten years that putting together the pieces and writing these lists is a daunting task.

With so many genre-defining projects dropping over that period being held up now it's coming to a close though, it shouldn't be forgotten that just as many great games slipped through the cracks.

These releases, for whatever reason, didn't get their time to shine and were largely ignored by audiences, and that is a total travesty. They're some of the best experiences the decade had to offer, and this is your last chance to rectify missing out on them.


15. Batman: Arkham Origins

Deathstroke Batman Arkham Origins
Warner Bros. Montreal

In the dying embers of the 2010s, Arkham Origins has enjoyed something of a small reappraisal, but it shouldn't be forgotten that for the majority of its life, this spin-off was treated as the unwanted afterbirth of a glorious superhero trilogy.

Crafted purely as a stop-gap between the final two "main" Arkham games, Origins' corporate reason to exist is no secret, but the devs at WB Montreal overcame those limitation to deliver a worthy follow-up that deviates from the core instalments in worthwhile ways.

Sure, there's a lot of familiarity present in the gameplay and setting, but the spin-off arguably boasts a better story than its more popular siblings, and certainly one which embraces the nastier, edgier elements of the Batman mythos.

In a way it's kind of like the New Vegas of the Batman series; an 'unnecessary' spin-off that was initially poorly received, but which has since been embraced by the die-hards as the cream of the crop.


14. Nier

nier 1
Square Enix

Nier: Automata released to rave reviews in 2017 and became a strange overnight success that surprised even the developers and publisher who made it. It was embraced for daring to be different, including some contemplative philosophical musings, and having one of the most subversive set of mechanics of the whole generation.

However, most of the unique elements that game was praised for were also present in the original Nier, which resulted in the five people who played and enjoyed that first effort looking on with smug resentment.

Nier isn't as technically accomplished as its follow up, but it still has the same charm in spades. It also tells an arguably more original story, with a far more tragic, melodramatic heart at the middle of it.

It's a genuine cult classic, and if you liked Automata, it's more than worth seeing the title that made that possible.


13. SOMA

SOMA game
Frictional Games

There have been plenty of great, narrative-driven first-person games over the past ten years, including the likes of Gone Home and Firewatch, and it's an absolute travesty SOMA is never placed on the same level as those genre-defining giants.

That's perhaps because it was wrongly pigeonholed as a horror game closer to Layers of Fear or the developer's previous title, Amnesia, though.

That genre heritage is still there, and you spend plenty of time crouch-walking around tables to avoid the petrifying gaze of horrifying mechanical beasties in SOMA, but it's the storytelling and world building that makes the game so damn appealing.

Uncovering the mysteries of this world, which takes the form of an underwater base housing the last remnants of the human race following an extinction event, is tantalising, and features twists far too juicy to spoil here.

Just play it.


12. Resistance 3

Resistance 3
Insomniac Games

It took them three attempts, but Insomniac finally fulfilled the potential of their post-apocalyptic alien shooter series Resistance with the final game. Though the first two releases weren't quite the Halo killer Sony probably wanted, they were still ambitious FPS games, with interesting stories and a damn good world to fight your way through.

The third game elevated everything though. The narrative was more emotional, characters more well-rounded, and the gunplay was tighter than ever. Throw in some spectacular set-pieces, and Resistance 3 was one of the best shooters of 2011, it was just too little too late.

At that point PS3 players had kind of given up on the franchise ever becoming the big smash hit it could have been, and with 2011 being a particularly stacked year, it ended up buried.

It's gained a following now though, and hopefully Sony will get around to remastering the entire series one day.


11. Donkey Kong Country - Tropical Freeze (Wii U)

Donkey Kong Tropical Freeze
Nintendo

Nintendo metaphorically Wii'd themselves with the successor to their ludicrously popular wand-waggling hardware, launching a 2012 sequel which confused their greatly expanded but less industry-attuned consumer base as much as it convinced them.

Was the Wii U an add on? An upgrade? Or a brand new console? Nintendo themselves, returning to their typically PR inept days of the N64, struggled to clarify the situation. As a consequence, significantly fewer homes stashed the new kit under their TVs - meaning many of its best games went grossly underplayed.

One such title, rather appropriately corresponding with the Wii U's glacial uptake, was Donkey Kong Country: Tropical Freeze. Retro Studio's stellar simian sequel to the Wii's Donkey Kong Country Returns didn't simply echo the admittedly outmoded ape adventures of the SNES, but served up a slice of hyper-designed platforming perfection, bursting at the banana skin with the sort of invention and variation Nintendo's own 2D revivals hadn't quite managed to conjure.

And yet, mixed reviews (Gamespot slapped it with an insulting 6/10) and the Wii U's criminal inability to leave shop shelves saw the game sell just over 200,000 copies in total. Nintendo, knowing they had a secret smash hit treasured in their vaults, recycled Tropical Freeze onto the Switch in 2018.

Within five days, the game had already outsold its Japanese Wii U performance, proving you can't keep a good ape down.

[Words by Benjamin A. Richardson]


10. Assassin's Creed: Syndicate

Assassin's Creed Syndicate
Ubisoft

No matter what Ubisoft had up their sleeve to follow the utter embarrassment that was Assassin's Creed: Unity, it was always going to disappoint. After years of growing discontentment, Unity broke the AC series in half, with its bevy of glitches and launch problems making for a limp jump to the next generation.

That shadow extended to the next game, the Victorian London-set Syndicate, and made for one of the lowest selling instalments in the franchise's history. That was a travesty though, because the follow up was better in every single way.

Of course, it was the setting that was the real winner. Walking these streets and zip-lining to the top of iconic London buildings never gets old, and it was complimented by a story stacked with great characters and period-specific cameos.

It's a shame the location was a one-and-done affair, because it deserved way more time to shine.


9. Mad Max

mad max
Avalanche

Ever since I started writing for this website, I've championed Mad Max as one of the most underrated games of the generation.

The sandbox brawler could have been nothing more than a shoddy tie-in to cash in on the release of Mad Max: Fury Road (which came out a few months prior), but it was way, way more than that, and could easily rub shoulders with the best in the open world genre at the time.

Its death sentence came from releasing on the same day as Metal Gear Solid V, which completely overshadowed this risky purchase. That absolutely sucks though, because Mad Max was - and is - just as fun.

What made it so special and charming was the way it blended the surprisingly gorgeous sandbox with the core gameplay staples of post-apocalyptic living; everything is purposeful, the action is tight, and crafting your own Magnum Opus death-bringer car never gets old.


8. Singularity

Singularity game
Raven Software

Singularity is a bona-fide miracle. Activision execs aren't really in the game of green-lighting new ideas that won't net them Call of Duty money, so the fact the publisher released this intriguing time-warping shooter has always been an enigma.

It was pretty much guaranteed to be a one-and-done affair before it even came out, but that doesn't stop Singularity being worthy of your time.

The shooting itself was as tight as you'd expect from the publisher in charge of COD, yet it was awarded a distinct personality thanks to the Time Manipulation Device, which opened up a whole host of unique gameplay possibilities.

2005's Black was the overlooked shooter that defined the last decade, and Singularity will be the one everyone looks back on in disbelief that it wasn't bigger from the 2010s.


7. The Surge 2

The surge 2
Deck13

The Surge dropped in 2017 to lukewarm reception commercially and critically, and as a result the 2019 sequel wasn't anticipated as one of the biggest games of the year, even when reviews praised it as an improvement.

Still, I don't know what those critics handing out 7s across the board were smoking, because The Surge 2's blend of RPG goodness and intense, thrilling action made for one of the best games of the year.

It's a difficult title to sell, admittedly, as it doesn't appear all that too dissimilar to other games dominating its sub-genre, but one session with the title will make you a believer.

From the way you can impact the story to spectacular fights, there's so much to love about the sequel, and if you slept on the original, make sure you don't make the same mistake twice.


6. Max Payne 3

Max Payne 3
Rockstar

There are some people out there who think that Max Payne 3 shouldn't exist, and that it spits on the quality first two titles Remedy created.

Those people are wrong.

Rockstar took the reigns of the franchise following that second game and injected it with their own brand of detail-orientated design. The effort the studio usually puts into delivering massive, dense open worlds was filtered into a linear third-person shooter, and it resulted in one of the most tactile, visceral action games ever.

Though the deliberateness won't be for everyone, there's something so undeniably satisfying about accounting for Max's weight and position that makes pulling off those sick, gravity-defying slow-motion kills feel even better.

Throw in a killer story that rivals any action flick, and Max Payne 3 shouldn't be slept on by any shooter fan.


5. Vanquish

Vanquish game
Platinum Games

In a lot of ways, Vanquish takes the polar opposite approach to Max Payne 3, and acts as the other side of the coin when it comes to the decade's best, most immediately thrilling shooters.

Unlike Rockstar's effort, which prioritised balancing weight with momentum and the immediate limitations of the play space, Vanquish was quick, responsive and arcadey, throwing you into large combat areas to live out your wildest anime dreams.

Especially at a time where the industry was obsessed with sticking you to a wall and having you pop your head out to shoot targets from a static position, Vanquish was a breath of fresh air. It didn't totally escape the trappings of the genre at the time, but it still provided a tantalising alternative, and resulted in an action game that still stands alone today, a whole generation later.


4. Hitman

Hitman 2
IO Interactive

Hitman has had a rough time commercially over the past decade. Absolution was an attempt to bring the series to a wider audience by 'streamlining' (which in video game terms always mean ripping out the things fans love) the stealth and free-form elements.

After that disappointment, Hitman Season 1 was conceived to ride the episodic hype at the time. Unfortunately, the new structure was treated with caution by fans, who assumed the release was going to be nothing more than an under-developed bunch of levels that wouldn't be worth it until every episode was out (and even then it had a lot to prove after Absolution).

However, the new schedule was actually a blessing in disguise. The developers were up to the challenge, and it meant each new level was packed with content and ways to play, designed to be revisited with different tactics over and over again.

While it might not have been delivered like the older instalments, Hitman embraced the core pillars that made those titles so enjoyable for a whole new generation, and made the best stealth game of the entire decade, until the sequel came around anyway.


3. The Evil Within 2

Evil Within 2
Bethesda

At the start of 2019, every video game fan and critic hailed Resident Evil 2 as bringing the survival horror genre back from the brink. That always felt weird to me, because The Evil Within 2 did that exact same thing years prior and nobody noticed.

The original game was a rough-around-the-edges charmer, but this sequel raised the bar in every way. It was spookier, the story was better, the gunplay tighter and enemies nastier. Even better, it introduced a semi open-world structure that somehow complimented the horror elements and made the experience even scarier.

The best thing you can say about The Evil Within 2, though, is that it actively makes the original a better game in hindsight. The plot points it picks up, the motifs it repeats and enemies that return are all deepened and granted greater significance, and it's generally just a great survival horror experience.


2. Control

CONTROL GAME
Remedy

Control is the most recent game on this list, and it absolutely sucks that it's already well and truly cemented itself as a 'hidden gem', and not the genuine smash hit it could have been.

Whether it was the marketing or a general disinterest from the audience is yet to be seen, but Remedy's latest shooter hasn't broken out of its little niche corner of the industry, which is a travesty considering it has some of the slickest combat mechanics of the entire generation.

Once you nab all the powers in Control, fighting enemies feels almost godly. Hovering around areas, telekinetically picking up chunks of the environment and launching them into a huddle of goons while picking the remainder off with an alien, shape-shifting gun makes for one of those gameplay loops that should get old after eight hours, but never stops feeling so damn satisfying.

That's only one part of the (overall excellent) puzzle though. It's the setting that really shines, as the mysteries of The Oldest House pose fascinating questions, and that signature Remedy charm runs throughout the veins of this creepy building.

Games in 2019 had a major personality problem, and Control stuck two fingers up to that and embraced the weirdness.


1. Splinter Cell: Blacklist

Splinter Cell Blacklist
Ubisoft

There hasn't been a new Splinter Cell game in over six years, which stings doubly because the last instalment, Blacklist, was such a confident step in a new direction for the series.

Coming towards the tail-end of the last generation, Blacklist followed up the controversial Conviction, attempting to blend that title's action-orientated approach to 'stealth' with the classical, methodical approach of the original Xbox trilogy.

Though franchises suffering an identity crisis had tried and failed to find a harmonious balance before (looking at you, Resident Evil 6), Ubisoft's effort surprisingly paid off. If you wanted a more active, aggressive approach, the level design accommodated for that, while also providing the ability to take it slow and ghost your way through areas.

The focus was always on player choice, and it made for an inventive stealth game at a time where the genre was sadly no longer in vogue. If Ubi picks the franchise up, it should build on these foundations - but let's face it, it'll end up being another open world game, won't it?


Watch Next


In this post: 
control
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.