15 Best Horror Video Games Of The 2000s

The brightest jewels from the greatest era in gaming.

Horror will always remain fascinating, in the sense that the formula is so deceptively straightforward: just scare people senseless - how hard could that possibly be? Turn the lights down, toss in some zombies/demons/ghosts/pig-men (you really don't want to know where your food comes from sometimes) and voila! You've got yourself a bonafide Horror Classic. Except it isn't that easy, is it? You can't strip the genre down to the bare essentials and throw them into a cauldron for the perfect brew. No, it's the marriage between atmosphere and pace that really gives horror its legs. At the end of the day, monsters and madman are mere props that when used improperly, can sabotage the entire experience and reduce a menagerie of terror into a glorified house of horrors. Some games manage to strike that delicate balance, while others cross-pollinate to spectacular results; some are scarier than others, some are bloodier and some are just more fun. There's no genre with broader variations than horror, and there's no better showcase than the last decade.

15. Doom 3

Doom 3's flashlight-or-gun mechanics were silly beyond reason, but the tradeoff had the intended effect of making you plan your every move, as the clarity provided by a source of illumination was weighed against the likelihood of being caught off guard without a means of defence. Yes, you could try bashing heads in with a flashlight, but sooner or later your luck would run out, at which point you'd probably regret not dying in a more heroic fashion. On a purely logical level, the flashlight/gun swap didn't work at all (as if that needed to be said) but without it Doom 3 falls apart as a horror experience as the game leans far too heavily on jump scares to truly be effective. Still, there's plenty to love about Doom 3; the atmosphere and graphics were phenomenal for the time, the enemy design was brilliant and firing a BFG at a horde of demons was never anything short of a spectacle.

14. Siren: Blood Curse

Siren's 'sight-jacking' feature is so unique, inventive and downright cool that I wish I could it carry it around in my pocket to use whenever I like. With the press of a button, sight-jacking allows you to tune into an enemy's POV and borrow their eyes for a quick look around the environment; the idea being that you can map out a route through enemy patrols with the aid of split-screen. It's one thing to hide from somebody looking to rip out your throat, and quite another to actually see how close they are to spotting you as you crouch in a closet praying you're not too karmically overdrawn at the moment. Make no mistake, sight-jacking is more than just a gimmick, and your continued survival in Hanuda Village is dependent upon your ability to juggle several viewpoints to decide the best course of action. With its grungy visuals and J-horror aesthetic, Blood Curse stands apart from the crowd as a truly unique experience with a killer hook.

13. F.E.A.R.

F.E.A.R.'s not a 'scary' game so much as it's just a shooter bolted onto a horror frame - though that's not to say you won't break out in rash of goosebumps from time to time, as it's no easy task keeping your cool when a ghostly little girl with pyromaniacal tendencies tries to flash-fry you into a pile of ashes. It's funny, really. There's nothing more empowering than sprinting through a room and unloading in every direction until there's nothing left but a pile of debris and a carpet of corpses, but the instant Alma materialises in a blink of fire, whatever delusions of Neo-like omnipotence you might have entertained are melted away in seconds. It's a hell of a balancing act; giving players enough power to feel like Max Payne on steroids without neglecting to build up Alma as a credible enough threat so that the ability to sidestep bullets feels downright impotent in the face of a girl who can twist your sanity into pretzels, but Monolith Productions sure pulled it off.

12. Dead Rising

Dead Rising drops you into a colossal mall, crawling with droves of the undead and gives you the run of the place for three days. That's 72 hours of unadulterated zombie-killing mayhem with access to weapons of every shape, size and caliber, ranging from chainsaws, katanas and semi-automatics to guitars, bowling balls and plushies (I have no idea how those cute little things are supposed to kill anything, but it's funny). It's basically a playable Dawn Of The Dead, a concept so foolproof you have to wonder why nobody's tried it before. It's the kind of experience drinking games are made of (take a swig for every three zombies you slice up and you'll be plastered faster than you can say 'hair of the dog'), and with dozens upon dozens of time-specific missions spread across 72 hours, Dead Rising is eminently replayable. Blowing away hordes of flesh-mongering rotters with a Mega Buster? Good God, how was this not a thing before?

11. Dead Space

It isn't until you go back and replay the original Dead Space that the full realisation of just how badly the series lost its way hits you in the face like a sledgehammer. By the time the third chapter rolled around, Dead Space just couldn't seem to decide if it was a horror game doing a crappy impression of an actioner, or an actioner doing a crappy impression of a horror game. Rewind back to the franchise's inaugural instalment though, and it's clear that Visceral Games set out to create a horror experience first and foremost. Sure, you can argue that much of the game's effectiveness in that regard relied heavily upon whether or not you were willing to put up with a jump scare every time you so much as turned a corner, but there was a genuine investment in conveying an oppressive sense of isolation. Safety was a fleeting notion at best on board the USG Ishimura, and every battle with the Necromorphs was a vicious tug of war between your nerves and reflexes - your chances of leaving the Ishimura in one piece plummeted with every stray shot, so unless you didn't mind losing 65% of your body mass in one swipe, you'd clamp down on your nerves and make with the strategic dismemberment.

10. Left 4 Dead 2

Oftentimes the real horror of playing Left 4 Dead 2 comes from being stuck with a group of players so hostile and aggressive that an actual worldwide pandemic is preferable to sticking it out another minute with a band of misanthropic teenagers who seem far more invested in bickering at each other than actually playing. Once you link up with the perfect group, though - that's where the fun begins. It's no exaggeration to say that you can sink thousands upon thousands of hours into Left 4 Dead 2 without ever really feeling like you've mined all you could out of the experience; it's THAT addictive. If you're unfamiliar with the series you may not understand how it's possible to lose entire afternoons replaying the same maps over and over until the sun goes down, but that's where The A.I. Director comes in - with randomized item and enemy placement, Left 4 Dead 2 is a kaleidoscope of terror and the game's ever-shifting landscape knocks monotony on its ass. And while Left 4 Dead 2 is far from being the scariest game of the seventh generation, there's no denying the shooter's effectiveness in provoking the occasional heart palpitation. Witch attack, anyone?

9. Manhunt

Sometime during my twenty-second decapitation, it dawned on me that I still had no clue what James Earl Cash was actually locked up for. I know that's such a laughably pointless thing to hang up on when you're painting a Jackson Pollock with a guy's brains, but given that Cash's first act of onscreen violence has him casually slipping a plastic bag over a dude's head, you can't help but wonder what kind of man he was before being thrown into the slammer. Cash kills with such ease and finesse that it wouldn't be much of a stretch to assume that the man's dry cleaning bills far exceed his rent. Which is an interesting thought to say the least, because in a genre populated by grizzled ex-cops, battle-hardened soldiers and crowbar-wielding physicists, it's easy to get used to the whole "lone hero against unfathomable evil" deal, but it's not too often that a horror game places you in the shoes of a man more fit for inclusion on the FBI's "most wanted". After all - you don't get the death penalty for parking tickets, do you? At the end of the day, Manhunt's about a bad man doing very bad things to very bad people; it's a grim game overflowing with blood, guts and gristle, wrapped up in a grainy visual style reminiscent of the nastiest 'video nasties' and some of the smoothest stealth gameplay you'll ever experience. Cash may be a bad man, but he's pretty damn good at what he does.

8. The Suffering

Whereas Manhunt left the exact nature of its protagonist's crimes unclear, The Suffering hits us point-blank with all the gory details. Torque was convicted for murdering his wife and children: he supposedly pummelled his woman to death with his bare hands before drowning one child and tossing the other out of a window. Yeesh... sounds like one sick puppy, huh? With a rap sheet like that, I don't know how the man can sleep at night, but a quick stop at the confessional might help take the sting off 3000 volts of electricity (Abbott Penitentiary's old fashioned that way). Or it would, if a horde of demonic beasts didn't put his appointment with the grim reaper on indefinite hold in one of the creepiest openings in video game history, hands down. And though The Suffering would unfortunately have difficulty maintaining the pervasive sense of dread the first few hours instilled, the brilliant enemy design went a long toward making up for the lack of pants-soiling terror with its sheer WTF factor. Every single creature you squared off against represented one of the many execution methods carried out on Carnate Island which, in the hands of a genius like Stan Winston, made for one hell of a nightmare.

7. Condemned: Criminal Origins

What sticks in your mind the first time you play Condemned isn't the decrepit, rotting buildings which apparently house every frothing-at-the-mouth psychopath on the eastern seaboard, or even the aforementioned psychopaths themselves - they're a dime a dozen, those guys. No, what really sticks with you on your first trip through the seedy underbelly of Metro City is the sheer brutality of Criminal Origins' melee system - there's nothing showy, graceful or elegant about it, and neutralising enemies never feels like anything less than the total obliteration of flesh and bone. It's not a dance, it's a fight for survival, and the slightest misstep could result in you scooping your brains off the floor with a dustpan. Interspersed throughout the carnage are forensic sequences which, while not being as fleshed out as they probably could have been, do provide a change of pace as well as some genuinely scary moments, the most famous of which involves a body in a locker. Condemned isn't a perfect game by any means - the latter half in particular introduces some truly baffling plot elements (the sequel somehow manages to make those seem downright pedestrian by comparison though) - and while Bloodshot polished the core mechanics to a mirror sheen, the original provides a more consistently frightening experience overall. You can't go wrong with either game, though.

6. Resident Evil 4

I'm willing to bet that more than half of the fine folks reading this can regale the comments section with stories of running in terror from chainsaw-wielding madmen with sacks over their (no doubt deformed) heads, before being cornered and losing their composure/noggin/bowel control. It's okay, we're all in the same boat here. Resident Evil 4 is fascinating in the sense that while it no doubt changed the landscape of horror gaming forever with its reflex-based, over-the-shoulder gunplay, it also heralded the demise of traditional survival horror with countless imitators abandoning any pretence of scares in lieu of the kind of explosion-laden gameplay that would make the typical FPS seem understated by comparison. Still, there's a reason so many horror fanatics stand in awe of Resident Evil 4 even today - it's that rare kind of experience you only get every few years, the kind that makes even the most hardened gorehound shriek in blood-curdling terror as they're quickly surrounded by a horde of murderous villagers before realising there's not enough ammunition to split between them.

5. Fatal Frame II: Crimson Butterfly

You don't realise how much you've come to rely on guns and explosives as a means of defence against the paranormal, until you're cowering in fear of a creepy little ghost girl with the power to phase through walls at any given second. Or a spider-walking woman with a neck so shattered that the head attached to it swivels with the slightest twitch. Or a pair of twins who - never mind, you get the picture. Remaining calm when you're confronted by an enemy you can't just pump a few rounds into is no easy task, but when you're handed a camera and told that it's your only chance for survival, it starts feeling like somebody's having a laugh at your expense. But that's the brilliance of Fatal Frame; Tecmo managed to somehow build a genuinely frightening game around the central conceit of a spirit-banishing camera, an idea that sounds utterly ridiculous when spoken aloud. It all sounds so simple - enter the camera's viewfinder, point it in the spirit's general direction and try to get a decent shot. The closer the spirit, the greater the damage. Doesn't sound too bad, does it? Well, it's one thing to talk about it, and another to try it yourself without shaking.

4. Clive Barker's Undying

The setup for this one is simple: a group of siblings drag a dusty old occult book to a group of standing stones situated near their estate, and do about exactly what you'd expect of a pack of over-enthusiastic children with no concept of foresight or genre tropes: they curse their family to a slow and agonizing death by reciting ancient Latin from the crumbling tome. Kids. You can't leave 'em alone for two seconds without worrying they're going to damn the entire house into oblivion. Fast forward to 1923 and we're introduced to paranormal investigator Patrick Galloway as he links up with his old friend and last surviving member of the Covenant family, Jeremiah. Turns out that poor ol' Jeremiah's siblings have come back from the dead and made it their un-life's mission to haunt the man into an early grave, leaving you to put an end to the family curse. Released way back in 2001, Undying utilized a dual wield system which presented the perfect counterpoint to the slower-pace associated with many horror titles - with a pistol in one hand and a spell in the other, Undying's captivating narrative was shot through with bursts of action that made excellent use of the game's mix-and-match style of gunplay while spewing forth a legion of monstrous creatures that could only have ever spawned from the darkest corners of Clive Barker's brain. Undying is easily one of the most dazzlingly inventive games of all time, so it's doubly unfortunate that the potential series fell victim to a curse of another kind: crappy sales.

3. Resident Evil (2002)

Whereas the very idea of a remake is anathema to most moviegoers, video games seem to exist in some weird sort of Bizarro World where the slightest whisper of a shiny new coat of paint is met with streamers and champagne instead of gritted teeth and furious forum rants. But for every remake or remaster that's announced, there's still a mile-long list of games we'd like to check off (I'm still holding out hope for a Thief/Thief 2 remake). With a Resident Evil 2 update in the pipeline, it's only a matter of counting down the days until Nemesis gets a much-needed facelift as well. It's been a whopping 14 years since the original RE remake hit shelves, but it's truly amazing how well the game still holds up, graphics and gameplay-wise. Sure, characters still manoeuvre through corridors with all the grace of an M1 Abrams with a busted tread, but with so much gorgeous scenery to take in do you really mind the bumpy ride? Every hallway, stairwell and crevice positively oozes menace. The remake's power lies in it's ability to take everything you remember the first time around and manipulate it just enough so that it all feels new.

2. Silent Hill 2

I don't think there's a concept in all of gaming more terrifying than Silent Hill, which isn't really a town at all so much as it's what happens when your nightmares construct a prison bricked with your deepest fears on a foundation cemented with every torment you've ever suffered and throw you inside with nothing but your own cries to keep you company. And the worst part about Silent Hill? Most of the poor souls trapped inside came looking for catharsis. Take James Sunderland for instance; after receiving a letter from his dead wife, James travels to Silent Hill where he's hoping to find answers. What he's confronted with however, is a town hosting such deeply-rooted evil that it's capable of clawing into the minds of everyone inside and manifesting their darkest secrets in forms so grotesque it'll scare Freddy Krueger away. This is usually where a lesser game would be content to simply throw monster after monster at the screen and call it a job well done, but Silent Hill 2 stands the test of time because the narrative allowed for different levels of interpretation - James Sunderland's journey was as much about him coming to grips with his true nature as it was an exploration of grief. Even today, you can replay the game several times and come away with something new.

1. Eternal Darkness: Sanity's Requiem

Much has been made of Eternal Darkness' 'sanity effects' - which do their damnedest to take your unflagging stoicism in the face of all things nasty and pick off its limbs until there's nothing left but a quivering mass of blood and tears - but what really grabbed me the first time I chewed through the game was its brilliant narrative. It all starts when Alexandra Roivas is summoned to her grandfather's stately mansion by police in the dead of night (the old man was murdered in a particularly vicious attack, leaving body sans head). Determined to unearth the truth behind her grandfather's murder, Alex explores the mansion and discovers the book which fuelled the old man's obsession. And it's between the grimy covers of The Tome Of Eternal Darkness that the truth behind the murder, and indeed, the universe lies. Alexandra's investigation frames a web of terror spanning centuries; from ancient Persia to World War I, The Tome Of Eternal Darkness relates several gruesome tales of man's helplessness in the face of evils too great to even comprehend, much less kill. Each of the twelve characters contributes a new piece of the narrative puzzle, as well as several new elements and abilities which are in turn used by Alexandra in the present day as she uncovers more of the mansion's - as well as her family's - dark history. Eternal Darkness is a bleak, oppressive experience, made all the more horrifying by the screen-covering 'sanity effects' which only increase in intensity the longer you go on. But all the gimmicks in the world aren't going to help if the narrative itself doesn't have legs to carry the game forward, and Eternal Darkness is a tapestry of terror. There's a thread of unrelenting nihilism running through every chapter, and the few moments in which you're granted a temporary respite upon returning to the present day do little to dispel the notion that forces beyond our imagination are waiting beyond the veil of reality. What are your favourite horror games from the 2000s? No list is truly definitive, so be sure to share your own in the comments below!

Contributor

Carlos Jimenez hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.