15 Biggest Video Game Lies You've Been Told This Decade
Is the industry more full of it than ever?
It's not until you've been exposed to the industry for a good chunk of time - enough to go through some of life's own trials and tribulations, hopefully maturing along the way - that you realise just how out of control a lot of its marketing can be.
Even after a game has 'gone gold' i.e. off to the printers, many publishing wings will take reviewers' comments out of context, completely re-appropriating any given sentiment to 'sucker you in' to buying their product.
Simply down to the cost and overall size of the industry right now (though looking back, these practices have always been prevalent), there's a moral-cleansing 'need' to shift units - one that feels as though it boils down to "Say whatever you need to, just move our game!"
Alas, this generation we've seen some of the biggest porkers in the history of the medium, many of which resulted in lawsuits, the death of franchises, the tarnation of once-beloved industry figures, or all three.
Honestly, if lies are porky pies, the games industry is a meat packing plant.
15. Mark Hamill Will Not Be Returning As Joker In Batman: Arkham Knight
Remember that incredibly momentous final scene in Arkham City, where - for one of only a handful of times in the character's history - Batman actually didn't save the day? Instead, thanks to Joker stabbing him - Bats dropped the phial for Joker's cure, leaving him to literally laugh himself to death.
El Fin.
In the run-up to Arkham Knight we were told repeatedly, over and over (and over) that Mark Hamill was not returning as the Clown Prince, and that the titular Knight himself was also "not an established character" from the Arkham series.
Except, he was. It was Jason Todd. Big ol' lie.
And Joker? Turns out Hamill had been fibbing for years too, as not only was Joker in the game, but thanks to Bruce Wayne's fractured psyche, he literally saw him everywhere, meaning we got more Joker than the last two games combined.
Both revelations were clearly meant to be surprises for the fans, but when you've led them on the wildest of "Guess who?" goose chases for months prior, revealing you've taken the easiest way out was one HELL of a letdown.
14. The Xbox One's Kinect Worked As Advertised
Microsoft have done their darndest to wash all memories of the horrendous Kinect away, yet it stands to reason that the only motivation behind Sony's meteoric lead in PS4s shipped over Xbox Ones, comes from the latter reveal being so laughably bad.
Case in point: Yusef Mehdi literally getting on stage and pretending to expand/contrast various application windows and viewing screens, just to show off the 'power of the Kinect'. Of course, all it takes is to watch the footage back and realise it doesn't line up with his actions, to come away thinking something was up.
Cut to launch day and hundreds of Xbox Ones couldn't recognise voices or hand gestures to save their lives. Thus, after a year of Microsoft insisting that the Kinect was an "integral part" of the 'Xbox One experience', they gutted the thing from their bundle deals, reorganised the dashboard, commissioned the Xbox One S and Xbox One X, and never looked back.
Ironically, of all people, it's now Microsoft who don't recognise the Kinect.
13. Every Pre-Launch Trailer For Aliens: Colonial Marines
One of the most prolific and talked-about downgrades in gaming history - which is impressive, because they only really started being a thing this generation.
Alas, check the above video for some side-by-side breakdowns, as it goes without saying that Gearbox's initial footage of Colonial Marines was lining up quite nicely. Moody lighting, derelict ships dripping in alien goo, bulky weapons and terrifying creatures?
Maybe this could actually be a truly great Aliens game?
Well...
Needless to say, the difference between marketing, trailers and release was so staggering, it resulted in a rather costly lawsuit between Gearbox and publishers, Sega - one which Gearbox barely escaped.
12. Crackdown 3 Would Run Using "The Power Of The Cloud"
Hey, you there - do you know what "powered by the Cloud" even means?
I don't mean 'in theory', because we all know that 'in theory', Microsoft had commissioned some stupidly expensive 'cloud farm' of servers that would apparently help render games alongside physical hardware, but just how in the blue hell does that ever get past the discussion stage?
I mean, were they going to stream in the backgrounds whilst the game handled characters and weapons? What happens if you have an internet shortage, or the connection goes even a little bit spotty?
Microsoft were remiss to comment on this after the first reveal, and sufficed to say in the years that followed, we heard next to nothing about whether or not Crackdown 3 even existed.
It was re-revealed at E3 2017... though it happened to look exactly the same as before.
So much for 'cloud processing' being anything more than hot air.
11. Almost Everything About The Ouya
There was a time - a real, tangible, actual point in time - when it felt like the Ouya could actually be a thing.
Hear me out.
So, you had a console that was completely mod-able out the box, welcoming of tinkerings from those with the know-how, had the complete works of every console in history ready to be loaded on, AND with such momentum, would surely get all the triple-A publishers on board too.
A perfect controller, minimal size, speedy processo- oh, what? Oh, it was all a lie, and this 'groundbreaking console' was just a mobile phone chip in a glass case? Creator Julie Uhrman actually managed to squander 8.5 million dollars on prototypes, half-baked 'exclusives' and terrible adverts?
And on top of that, she once decried over and over to an audience of millions that the system was "nothing special"?
Yup, this deserved to be discontinued in 2015, but you really have to feel for all those 63,416 backers...
10. Halo 5 Will Let You "Hunt The Truth" Behind Master Chief Vs. Spartan Locke
Onto something that was just straight-up miscommunication, as though the coding wing of 343 Industries sent but the barest of memos to their advertising department, you could tell nobody knew how to stop the resultant juggernaut that bolted from the gates.
This miscommunication is my inference, as you literally had a final product that had next to nothing in common with what was advertised.
What Microsoft and 343 DID talk about - or rather, alluded to - was a 'hidden story' of why newcomer Spartan Locke was hunting down Master Chief. In parallel marketing campaigns we saw Locke get the better of Chief, or vice versa - they even had a hashtag and plenty of forums debating fan theories.
What could possibly be this hugely personal reason behind Chief making his first notable enemy, and who would emerge victorious?
Well... erm, nothing.
Turns out at one point the Chief asks to chase down a lead on Cortana, his superiors say "We'd rather you didn't", Locke is dispatched to chase him down, they tussle for literally about two minutes, make up and are friends for the rest of the game.
Hunt the truth? The truth is, you should never trust Halo marketing ever again.
9. Peter Molyneux & The Godus Project
You could call Peter Molyneux's career a 'fall from grace', though if you go back into the annals of gaming history, you only find more and more examples of when he spewed nothing but utter toss.
His latest steaming pile of nothingness came in the form of Godus; a game tied to a mobile app called Curiosity, where whoever tapped away enough to get to the centre would become a 'God' in the full game.
How did it work? F**K knows, because clearly nothing had been thought through. Winner Bryan Henderson was simply flown to the studios of 22cans and allowed to play a broken alpha build, with the resulting series of actions being nothing short of insulting for both Henderson, and the game's 17,184 Kickstarter backers.
You can read one of the most hands-down brutal dressings-down of a video game developer in our medium's history here, where Molyneux was taken to task over the state of the game, where the money went, how he even thought it was supposed to work, and everything in between.
8. Microsoft: "Everything Is Hardwired, We Can't Change Our Policies"
The tail-end of 2013 was literally a series of Microsoft attempting to throw curveballs, only for Sony to slam them straight out the ballpark.
One of the biggest was the genuinely baffling approach the former had to DRM (Digital Rights Management) in light of their Xbox One reveal. The initial controversy stemmed from Microsoft wanting to enact a "family policy" where a collection of Xbox accounts could be green-lit to all gain access to the same games, regardless of purchase.
So far, so good.
Next, they attempted to enforce a policy surrounding the purchasing/trading of 'license fees' (necessary to play games), even if you wanted to just lend a game to a friend.
Why, you ask? Because Microsoft was determined to convince you this was the future, they even had spokesman Major Nelson talking about how the console was built "from the ground up" to have these features, and it wasn't as simple as "flipping a switch" to revert them.
Though, literally a week later, when the world's media collectively screamed "ARE YOU F'ING SERIOUS?!", do you know what they did?
Flicked a switch.
7. Destiny's World Will Be So Expansive, "Every Gun Will Tell A Story"
Thanks to a fantastically revealing exposé from Kotaku as to the reality of making Destiny, we now know the game was completely gutted mere months before release.
Still, it didn't stop Bungie and Activision selling a lie to the general public, talking about how the game was so expansive, "every gun will have a story", even using footage from cutscenes that included characters nowhere seen in the final product.
Destiny even opens with a character saying they "Don't have time to explain why I don't have time to explain", being evermore on-the-nose once you realise just what fresh hell the development team went through.
That doesn't change the reality of just how much content wasn't present in the base game of Destiny though, as it would take a string of DLC packs and a solid year's worth of patches and community feedback to just barely make Bungie's latest a respectable investment.
6. Watch Dogs' Immense Graphical Downgrade
If you were to point to one specific game that started this generation off on the wrong foot, it's Watch Dogs.
Initially delayed just after the launch of the new systems (which many people bought, specifically to play the game in the first place), when Ubisoft's latest finally launched in 2014, there was an immediate, demonstrable downgrade in graphical quality.
Not only that, but many areas appeared to be unfinished, had blurry textures, or just otherwise failed to look sufficiently 'next-gen'. Ubisoft insisted that the game had to look a certain way, and there was no downgrade - only for PC users to take one look at the game's files and note there were a number of graphical shaders turned off.
Said shaders restored the game to how it was supposed to look, leaving Ubi to respond by saying these changes were necessary to get the game running whatsoever.
That leaves to conclusions:
1. So they showed off a version of the game with said shaders turned on, knowing the game wouldn't render this way in the end, or
2. Well, actually, it was toss. PC modders got Watch Dogs up and running just nicely, the only possible explanation being that the game was downgraded for feature and performance parity across consoles and PC.
Which was it? We'll never know, because Ubi never commented on the state of the game again.
5. MGS V Will Be The "Missing Link" - Will Explain Big Boss' Downfall
Now, the true story behind what happened over at Konami towers during MGS V's development is out there, and relatively well-known, however, the ructions between Hideo Kojima and Konami didn't happen until long into development - long after the crux of what MGS V 'is' had got out.
Which is to say, MGS V was supposed to be the 'missing chapter' between MGS: Peace Walker and the original Metal Gear on the MSX. Aiming to show just what happened to the the otherwise heroic Big Boss in between games, we'd assumedly get shown some pivotal event that twisted his mind into a nuclear weapon-possessing madman.
Except, well... we got nothing of the sort.
The Phantom Pain just up and did away with the thrust of its marketing, instead spinning a pointless yarn about how there were 'always two Big Bosses', and how you were a clone helping the 'real' version from the later games.
After the credits, we were no further forward, and if not for MGS V's genuinely outstanding gameplay, this would've face-planted the floor entirely.
4. The Completely Basic 'Play Now' Console Guarantee
Why do we play on consoles? Like, over time, why do the majority of people choose to game on what's meant to be a 'plug n' play' system?
Convenience, right?
Any gamer born before the 2010s will remember how much the general gaming populace would decry PC gamers and laugh at their pathetically elongated install times. "Why would I bother playing on PC? I'll be waiting the rest of the day to play!" they'd say.
Well... that is now the reality of console gaming, though you'll seldom hear it talked about from the big publishers and developers of the world. Instead, they're more than happy to churn out half-broken games in need of 'day one patches', stupidly long installations or any number of bolted-on extras.
This generation - far more than any before - we were promised faster, 'instant on' access to our libraries, yet day in, day out, we're forced to wade through any number of pop-ups and loading bars to do so.
3. You'll Be Able To Find Other Players In No Man's Sky
Who knew, that in the end, No Man's Sky would be remembered for a galaxy-sized lie, rather than a fully interactive galaxy of possibilities?
Yes, there were naysayers all along, but nowhere near enough of them, as Creative Director Sean Murray continued to tell whopper after whopper. It came to a head... literally on day one, as two different players managed to travel to the same spot with the intent of meeting up (something Sean Murray said you could do), only for nothing to happen.
Thus, this monumental mixup was only the beginning. It emerged that not only was there no way for the game's servers to sync two different experiences in real time, but our character models didn't even exist.
Factional warfare, space dogfights, downed spaceships and other multiplayer interactions - none were in the final game. If it was anything else, or if No Man's Sky had been advertised as the ambitious indie project it always was, the genuine anger surrounding post-release might have abated, but - as I'm sure you well remember - it was quite the opposite.
2. Mass Effect 3 "Will Not Be An A, B or C Ending"
There's embellishing and over-exaggerating, and then there's the absolute maelstrom of miss-marketed faeces that was the run-up and release of Mass Effect 3.
The outcry was so bad, so OTT and so unprecedented, it first, got EA labelled Worst Company in the World by Consumerist (thanks to fan poll) and second, caused possibly the biggest investigation on behalf of any fanbase, to highlight every last lie that was told.
Here are just some choice highlights, taken from key Bioware personnel, all pre-launch:
“There are many different endings. We wouldn’t do it any other way. How could you go through all three campaigns playing as your Shepard and then be forced into a bespoke ending that everyone gets? But I can’t say any more than that…” - Mike Gamble
“I’m always leery of saying there are 'optimal' endings, because I think one of the things we do try to do is make different endings that are optimal for different people “ - Mac Walters
“You'll get answers to everything. That was one of the key things. Regardless of how we did everything, we had to say, yes, we're going to provide some answers to these people.” - Mike Gamble
Never before had quite so much outrage been quite so justified.
1. Microsoft Literally Buying Positive Coverage For The Xbox One
It really does make you wonder: Did Microsoft know they'd dropped a clanger of a press conference, far before the rest of the world reminded them?
It certainly feels that way in retrospect, as once one Youtuber blew the whistle on the partnership between Microsoft and Machinima, tons more started coming out the woodwork. An excerpt from the 'tantalising offer' that was sent to many of Machinima's Youtubers (who are supposed to be equal-opportunities reviewers or trusted sources, no less) details how Machinima were actively able to offer more money to their personalities, if they said nice things about Xbox products.
One of the fees came down to an extra dollar per 1000 views, though you need only look at the average Youtube viewcount to see just how much money was being handed back and forth.
A truly manipulative way to 'infiltrate' the world of Youtube and its 'influencers', the end result being viewers getting Xbox Ones and certain respective games 'recommended' with less than honest intentions.
--
What was the biggest gaming lie you were told since 2010? Let us know in the comments!