15 Worst Video Game Levels Of The 2000s

Seriously, what the hell was up with Max Payne's blood trail level?!

Is there anything quite like gamer rage? No other artform prods and pulls at your most primal reactions quite like losing a level at the last minute thanks to a mistimed jump, or a random boss getting the better of you just when you could've won, had you another second in the field. There's something incredibly universal in that feeling. A real fight-or-flight response that'll either make you hurl the pad in frustration or knuckle down, lick your digital wounds and try again - and again - until you emerge victorious. The final sensation of snatching victory from the constantly gnashing jaws of defeat is euphoric and something that, when a level's been designed in a way to make your win/loss ration fair the entire time, separates the finest games from the rest. Speaking of the rest, that's where these guys come in; unfair AI numbers baring down on you, bad level design, unresponsive gameplay mechanics and a whole lot more. It's easy to forget gaming's heritage is in coin-stealing difficulty of the arcade scene, and that sometimes boils down to a developer simply wanting to test your worth for the sake of it. So, time to test your gamer mettle - let us know how many of these abominations you overcame in the comments below.

15. Tailing The Resistance Member - Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots

MGS 4 remains the one entry in the franchise where Kojima went completely overboard on the cutscene-to-game ratio. There's eight hours of the damn things in total, which when you then reflect back on your game-time (a paltry four levels), is made far worse by realising an entire section was devoted to tailing a guy. Seriously, tailing missions in any form - from Assassin's Creed to GTA - just flat-out suck. Whilst the other two aforementioned franchises will give you a couple of HUD elements (like a detection meter or awareness circle around your target) to help you along, MGS 4 just threw you into the world, the informant you're after darting away into the distance, with zero help as to if you'd be spotted or not. Intended to be Kojima's tribute to French New Wave and film noir, its low lighting immediately makes Snake's trenchcoat'd exploits immediately iconic, but the thing went on for ages. You'd be dodging patrolling robotic sentries, guards, hiding under cars and ducking out the way of your target randomly turning around - all with zero checkpointing and an instant fail-state if you messed up. There's a good reason Ubisoft removed most of these levels in their later Assassin's Creed games, although MGS V couldn't resist having a couple - but at least you can finish if you're spotted.

14. Death Row - Grand Theft Auto: Vice City

Not know this one by name? How about this - "The one where you go get Lance from the Junk Yard". Remember now? Yes, Vice City would see Rockstar take GTA III's game engine and iterate on it in every way, fleshing out your interactions with the world, expanding weapons and animation sets - and seeing what they could do with general mission structures. However, they forgot to add any checkpoints along the way, which meant you had to trek across the city, fight your way through scores of enemy gangsters, escort Lance back to the car and hightail it to a safe house. All on one checkpoint. That meant if you carked it at any point, you were back to the start, no matter how far along in the mission you'd gotten - something that could genuinely break a person's mental faculties if it happened thanks to the enemies gunning down your ride on the home stretch.

13. Fighting The Blue Guys - Uncharted 2: Among Thieves

The second instalment in Naughty Dog's legendary Indiana Jones-challenging franchise is still one of the best action-adventures of all time... except for the ending battle in Shambhala. See, we could just about go with the whole 'ancient Spaniards come back from the dead' at the close of U1 (just), and the fact that the gigantic horned beast you fought halfway through U2 was someone in costume was an even bigger relief - but then having to accept some hulking blue-skinned Amazonian-looking warriors are baying for your blood? That was the hulked-up straw that broke the adventurer's back. Not only did their visual design and in-world existence feel totally dumb anyway, but you then had to face off against a huge number of them wielding explosive-tossing pouches and life-depleting projectiles. Drake's cut-to-ragdoll animation when you die is annoying enough, but the fact you're already embroiled in quite the 'WTF' reaction anyway, made it impossible to digest.

12. Splinter Cell: Chaos Theory - Bath House

It's about time Ubisoft took some focus off Assassin's Creed, admitted Watch Dogs is never going to work in a million years, and brought back the third corner to the stealth trifecta alongside Metal Gear Solid V and 2016's Hitman. What better time than now, being Hideo Kojima has departed and left MGS without a creative lead? Anyway, the trilogy original releases was the strongest the series had ever been, but over time didn't always accentuate the reason we were playing in the first place - the immaculate stealth mechanics. What was always present in the closing level or two of each game was made worse in the Bath House of Chaos Theory, where you were forced to take on a string of high-powered guards equipped with night-vision and rifles to take you down within seconds. The level itself was a winding series of tight corridors and hidden ventilation shafts, but as Splinter Cell is at its finest when you're forever moving forward, rather than worrying what's coming up behind or alongside, it ended up being an incredibly tense environment you just couldn't navigate effectively.

11. The Spiked Column - God Of War

Speaking of games that take their weakest components and make a stupidly hard level out of them, the original God of War inspired all sorts of Kratos rage-faces as we attempted its godawful spiked column-climb in Hades. In theory it wasn't that hard - simply climb directly up, edging forwards and holding steady to avoid various clumps of spikes. Simple. Except it wasn't. Firstly, the viewpoint was so hamstrung you could barely see more than a centimetre above, the radius on when the game decided you'd made contact was more random than Fallout 4's game engine, Kratos' animations weren't remotely tactile or responsive and instead looked more like he was doing star-jumps than taking hold, and one wrong move plummeted you right back down to the ground again. Oh, and the columns themselves were constantly rotating, so left became right as soon as you went from one segment to the next. How lovely.

10. Rescuing Civilians Off Boats - Spider-Man 2

Answers on a postcard if random interactions in open-world games count as 'levels', but the boat rescue segments of Spider-Man 2 almost ruined the otherwise flawless Spidey experience. Up to this point we'd become quite adept at dropping in out the sky, snagging hapless construction workers or childrens' balloons and disappearing again - which was why it felt so off to then venture out to sea. Why? Because even touching the water sent you back to land, with some very repetitious dialogue accompanying you as Parker pulled himself out the brink. Collision detection on the people you were grabbing wasn't the best, and as the whole of Spidey's swing mechanic was built on momentum, you'd most likely overshoot the vessel altogether and plop straight into the New York Harbour, resulting in a cut to black and another hilarious quip as the Web-Head mentions he'd "Rather not go swimming today" or whatever. Thankfully, the very idea of an open-world Spider-Man game was fantastic enough to sell itself, as we certainly didn't go back to replay any of these abominations.

9. Blood Trails - Max Payne

So you've put together one of the most satisfying third-person shooters in recent memory, and you're struggling for ideas on how to provide variation on blasting thousands of thugs in the face... Well, how about... right, a nightmare where you walk across a tight-rope made of blood, in the dark, as your infant child screams in the distance, getting louder if you fall off? Genius, yeah? Portrays the horrors of Max's tortured psyche and shows he's just one wrong foot away from descending into total madness, right? Wrong. Max controlled about as well as a sentient stack of ham when you started trying to do anything precise, and if you already thought the occasional platforming/walk-along-this-thin-plank-of-wood segments of the standard levels were bad, this was just excruciatingly dumb.

8. Escorting Anyone, Anywhere, For Any Amount Of Time

Have you ever completed an escort mission and thought "That was actually a really enjoyable use of my time"? Of course not, as the more common response is to grind your teeth and speak only in consonants, the A.I. you were supposed to be protecting either getting blown to pieces, running off or getting stuck in the environment. Yes, for all the different mission designs or quest setups developers have perfected over the years, the escort mission has forever remained under the banner of impossible. The 2000s got the worst of it too, with Metal Gear Solid 2's Emma Emmerich needing to be led everywhere by the hand, Resident Evil 4's Ashley Graham getting mauled if you left her alone for a second, and Dead Rising's moronic A.I. attempting to stave off a zombie horde with a CD case, rather than walk towards the door of freedom you were waiting next to. Thankfully - and let this spate of downtime go on for a lifetime - I can't think of one escort mission from the last few years, hopefully indicating that the industry has learned from its many, many missteps, and can continue giving us what we want - which is absolutely anything else.

7. Escaping The Water Slums - Jak II: Renegade

Hands down, I'll fly Jak II's flag as the best open-world game since GTA III, but man, the mission where you've got to retrieve the Seal of Mar - only to then go up against an infinitely-spawning amount of soldiers - remains one of the hardest sequences Naughty Dog have ever put together across all their games. Respawning enemies are a big game design no-go, but a ton of old games used to do it as a way of forcing an intense situation, your character finding the resolve to battle through and escape their predicament, rather than staying to fight everything. In Jak II, the Krimzon Guard wouldn't only be blasting you with pinpoint accuracy from all directions at once (locking you in reaction animations that looped until you died), but they'd be swarming the skies in Hellcat Cruisers, preventing a vehicular escape unless you could bob n' weave your way through. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xLG69D912vQ Combine the lot and you've got a third-person shooter that didn't have a cover mechanic or even an aiming button, meaning you just had to dodge-roll and jump your way to freedom, hoping the game's code didn't trigger too many automatic enemy hits along the way.

6. Hidden Valley/At The Gates - Hitman 2: Silent Assassin

The Hitman games always felt like a heaving mass of A.I. programming and player experimentation just barely holding together - a notion that broke every now and then when missions would go awry for no reason, character animations would freak out, or in the case of both these two Japanese-themed levels, the size of the environment resulted in endless "You've been detected!" prompts. IO Interactive would go on to iterate on how the various NPCs could detect you around the areas, but in Silent Assassin it seemed to be based on proximity, speed of movement and what you were wearing. Factor that into navigating a multi-floor fortress, and that meant navigating enemies in tiny corridors that would skewer you with swords even when you'd walked past them, could detect bodies no matter where they were stashed, would hide and disguise themselves above you - and all-round just made keeping a low profile impossible. The detection system in these old Hitman titles was always pretty broken, but these two levels in particular highlighted that it was always teetering on a knife's edge between "Okay, carry on" and full-on base-wide "HERE'S HERE. KILL HIM NOW" at any second.

5. Burnt Rubber - Gears Of War

It's always a bit of a crapshoot, the idea of having a vehicle sequence in amongst an experience geared towards another style entirely. It seems everyone saw the lightning Halo managed to capture in a bottle back in 2001 and thought "We can do that too!", leading to levels like this, where you're left controlling a lumbering four-wheeler as a never-ending swarm of death-dealing Kryll descend on you and your crew. Burnt Rubber is another victim of the 'It just needed one checkpoint' crew, as although controlling the vehicle itself is weighty and responsive enough, the fact that you've got to ward off the flying bat-like beasts with a forever-draining spotlight just means there'll be times where you're left to the mercy of their inevitable onslaught regardless. The stretch of road you've got to get down is pretty lengthy too, meaning if you've mistimed the spotlight attack and lost a chunk of your health, you might as well just try again anyway. There's something exponentially more annoying about a level that feels as though it 'shouldn't belong' thanks to a contrasting genre twist, and Gears' attempt to branch out was one of the worst.

4. "Get On That Turret!" (Every Turret Sequence)

Although they still pop up every now and then (to hell with Mass Effect 3's awful battle on Palaven, for one), the heyday of turret sequences came across the back-end of the 2000s. Sure we'd seen light gun shooters and other stationary blasters over the years, but it felt as though the success of Call of Duty's explosion-happy set-pieces encouraged every developer to crowbar one of their own in. Dead Space's meteor section was one of the absolute worst - sticking out like a sore thumb compared to the rest of that game's slow, explorative horror beats. These levels always feel forced, and honestly, does anyone out there really like them? You're bolted to a place, forced to just spray n'pray whilst holding down one button, forever taking damage because there's nowhere to go and nothing to prevent it. Terrible.

3. Aloha Ice Jam - SSX Tricky

What level did you play most on SSX Tricky? It was Garibaldi, wasn't it? Maybe Elysium Alps if you were feeling adventurous. The one you didn't go back back to - any more than the main progression demanded anyway, was the impossible-to-master Aloha Ice Jam. Starting with a tight corner and a slippery patch of ice (a great combo for a game built on speed) you'd end up restarting the race multiple times to even get a decent position off the starting line. From there it was a hodgepodge of big air jumps and landing zones that required your momentum be pushing in a certain direction, or you were inevitably flung off into the background or another obstacle in the environment Considering how sublime the majority of the levels already were in the first SSX - which Tricky revamped or added to in various ways - some of the more complex ones simply didn't need additional items or obstacles to pad them out, with Ice Jam being the worst offender.

2. Any And All Sewer Levels

What is it about designers that makes them think we gamers want to traipse around endless sewer tunnels and stinky vent shafts? Not even Bane in The Dark Knight Rises could make a sewer hideout look appealing, and in their various game iterations it's worse, forcing us to hop, skip, jump and swing through the same grey n' green sewage-lined tunnels every time. Again with the entries on this list that cover multiple games, the 2000s saw something of a trend spring out of the platformers of the 90s, with everyone from Oblivion to Enter The Matrix plunging you into the poop-filled depths at some point. 2015's The Order: 1886 proved that drab landscapes haven't completely gone away, but with Bethesda's excellent work in revamping their wasteland in Fallout 4, perhaps there's hope for everyone to follow suit.

1. Supply Lines - Grand Theft Auto: San Andreas

Want a testament to just how much awful game design we once put up with for the sake of a genre finding its feet? Look not further than Supply Lines, arguably the worst mission Rockstar have ever designed, and one that sounds funny on paper, yet was an absolute nightmare in reality. If you didn't already recognise it from the name alone, it's 'the mission with the tiny planes', where you're tasked with flying a toy RC plane around the city - your fuel constantly depleting - as rival gang members try to blast you out the sky. As I said, fun on paper, but the reality was a handling model for the plane itself that was impossibly twitchy to get used to, an ineffectual targeting model that meant you had to line up your shots perfectly (all while watching your health get shaved off by forever-accurate enemies), and a time limit that could reset the whole thing right near the end anyway. It was agony, and the pinnacle of Rockstar pushing GTA III's tech to literal heights it was clearly never meant for. What's the flat-out worst level of the 2000s? Let us know in the comments, and create an account if you'd like to write for the site!

In this post: 
GTA
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.