20 Best Video Game Stories Ever
The 20 best tales ever put to code.
For the longest time, telling a video game story was always an afterthought. That's because in a lot of cases it doesn't matter how good your writing is, if the gameplay between each story beat sucks, that's all people are going to focus on.
But when a game gets it right, there's nothing else like it in any other medium. A good game story perfectly blends narrative and gameplay together to make an experience you simply cannot get anywhere else.
As the medium has evolved over the decades, many, many games have tried their hand at telling compelling stories in various different ways through the lens of video games.
From branching paths, to cinematic experiences, to Avant Garde storytelling techniques that only work in the context of a video game, there are many ways to make a video game story truly great, and these 20 are the most successful ones so far.
20. Grim Fandango
The 90s were the golden age of Lucasarts point-and-click adventure games, where seemingly every single year you'd have a new PC game centering around some clueless clod being guided around by the player through puzzles that only make sense after a good hour of rigorously banging your head against a concrete wall.
But the best of these still remains the one and only Grim Fandango.
Centering around Manny Calavera, one of many travel agents for the afterlife, this story takes Manny through an epic adventure that spans several in-universe years as he travels from one end of the afterlife to the other in a desperate bid to make right a horrible mistake he made involving one of his clients, and maybe - just maybe - earn some redemption for the sins he committed when he was alive.
While the story can be tedious at points, where it shines is in its humor and heart. In both cases the game displays an emotional maturity that acts as the lynchpin to the game's theme of redemption.
19. God Of War 2018
God Of War's 2018 reimagining - despite initial ridicule for following the "bearded man with issues guides innocent kid across cruel world" archetype that was insanely prevalent at the time - was precisely what the franchise needed to survive in the modern day. Also helps that the story is insanely good on its own too.
Kratos, after destroying the Greek pantheon and somehow surviving - something he hadn't planned on - has left Greece to find out what to do with his life elsewhere. Over an untold amount of time, he found love again and settled down with his new family. But when his wife dies, Kratos and his son Atreus, whom he loves dearly but is kept from properly showing it from a mix of PTSD and fear of vulnerability, set out to find her home to spread out her ashes.
Unsurprisingly, this simple journey very quickly becomes anything but.
Kratos, as fun as his games always were, was never the most compelling protagonist. An issue that is more than fixed here, as every line he speaks, every conversation he has with Atreus as their bond grows, keeps you glued to the screen.
18. Portal 2
The original Portal was one of the most tightly designed games ever made, starting with a fun central idea and everything else built around it with the sole purpose of supporting that central idea. Though on the short side, Portal used the time it had to cement itself forever into pop culture.
So why am I talking about the second one? Easy, the second one has the better story.
While the first Portal was about introducing players to this strange world, Portal 2 focuses on expanding on that world while never ignoring what makes Portal so fun.
The jokes are funnier - with particular mention going to J. K. Simmons turning in a career highlight performance as Cave Johnson - the lore is deeper, but not distractingly so, and overall it's just a more engaging experience that the streamlined original just couldn't be.
Valve may take forever to get anything done, but games like Portal 2 are the reason why everyone is still waiting in vain hope for another entry.
17. Persona 4
It may have taken until 5 for the Persona series to really get its due, but Persona 4 was the first time people began perking up to what this series had to offer.
Like the other Persona games, what makes 4 so much fun are the characters you meet along your journey, but unlike the other games, the story doesn't completely take a back seat for them. Persona 4 is a murder mystery, set in the sleepy town of Inaba, where people are not only dying of unknown reasons at random, but are then being hung upside down from TV antennas. With the police being utterly useless, it's up to your character and the ragtag group of teenagers he meets along the way to find the truth.
Like any good mystery, Persona 4 throws twist after twist at you, pacing itself just right in order to pull the rug out from under you the second you think you have it all figured out. But like any GREAT mystery, the story gives you everything you need to figure out the true culprit on your own. This faith in the player is best showcased at the end when it gives you a list of EVERY named character in the game and asks you "okay, who did it?" And this is an RPG whose length goes into the triple digits, so that's a long ass list.
It may show its age in a lot of areas - particularly in its understanding (or lack thereof) of gender and sexuality - but when it all said and done, Persona 4 is still utter class.
16. Red Dead Redemption
Red Dead Redemption 2 is a fantastic story in its own right, but the original still comes out ahead in my book.
The original Red Dead Redemption tells the story of John Marston, a former outlaw who has been "volunteered" by the government to hunt down the members of his infamous old gang, with the prospect of being able to go home to his family acting as the carrot on the end of the stick to keep him motivated.
John must now grapple with trying to balance building a new life while also razing his old one to the ground, in the vain hope that maybe - just maybe - the government stooges holding his leash will actually keep their word.
Red Dead Redemption very quickly earned acclaim for its masterful storytelling, acting as a realistic portrayal of life on the American frontier while still being really fun to play.
John Marston is one of the best protagonists in video game history, a tragic figure who wants to leave his past behind and become a better man, but constantly has the choke chain pulled back on him by the entire world. Culminating in an ending that will leave you emotionally drained but wholly satisfied.
15. Mass Effect 2
Bioware's flagship franchise may not have had the best first outing, especially in hindsight, but Mass Effect 2 was what put the series on the map, and for good reason.
After (momentarily) thwarting the eldritch monsters known as The Reapers in the first game, the second game begins with The Reapers getting payback by blasting Shepard into deep space where they then burn up in a nearby planet's orbit.
Two years later, Shepard wakes up, having been put back together by the human supremacist group Cerberus, who want to help Shepard stop The Reapers. And considering that the rest of the galaxy would prefer to believe that The Reapers don't exist, beggars can't be choosers. Shepard must now put together a team of specialists to go on a suicide mission to stop The Reapers' latest scheme.
And it IS a suicide mission. You can get everyone through the final mission alive, but doing so requires doing a lot of optional content that the game doesn't outright tell you about, so first time players will most likely get to see some of the best written characters in gaming history die brutal, horrible deaths.
With amazing dialogue, brilliant character writing, and one of the finest examples of a game holding the players' feet to the fire this author can think of, Mass Effect 2 stands head and shoulders above the rest of the series.
14. Final Fantasy 9
There are multiple Final Fantasy games I could have put on this list, but frankly when the creator of the entire series comes down from on high and names one game as his personal favorite of the bunch, it narrows down the decision somewhat.
And really, I can't blame him in the slightest for loving Final Fantasy 9 so much, as it is one of the best games in the entire series, and the best story in the entire franchise.
The story begins with a bunch of thieves planning to kidnap a princess and ends with those same thieves and that same princess fighting against an interdimensional conspiracy to wipe out the human race. Typical stuff for a JRPG, but what makes it work is the cast.
Zidane is the best Final Fantasy protagonist by a country mile - a hilarious, optimistic, dashing rogue - but the other characters are just as charming and compelling to follow. And for such a cartoony looking game, 9 features some of the darkest twists and turns that the series has had to date.
13. Shadow Of The Colossus
The PS2 era is considered by many to be the last era of true experimentation by large companies in the video game industry, where for a brief, beautiful moment, risky projects getting a lot of money thrown at them was the norm rather than the exception. And one of the crown jewels of that era is, without question, Shadow Of The Colossus.
When a man named Wander loses his lover, Mono, he is told by a mysterious and totally-100%-trustworthy-we-promise spirit that he can bring her back by slaying 16 great beasts known as the Colossi. What results is a series of the best boss fights in gaming history as Wander gives up everything about himself to bring back the one person who gave his life meaning.
Shadow Of The Colossus is a genuine tragedy, a genre that games very rarely get right, being an industry where audience satisfaction is literally built into the bone marrow. But Shadow Of The Colossus (as well as a few other entries further down the line) show that this genre can absolutely work for video games if placed in the hands of a narrative master.
12. TellTale's The Walking Dead Season 1
TellTale's reputation ending in irreparably total disaster is one of the things that keeps this once legendary series from cracking the top ten, but I couldn't in good conscience leave it off completely.
The first few seasons of The Walking Dead game - helped by the insane popularity of the TV show at the time - still stand as one of the greatest gaming stories ever written, with memorable characters and a realistic depiction of a world that's fallen apart. What's always made TWD's depiction of post-apocalypse so raw is that it knows that it takes a LOT to make a society completely go away.
People, by and large, will only turn to things like, say, cannibalism if there genuinely is no other option. Otherwise they will hold on as much as they can to what they've known to work all their lives. Which of course makes the moment where everything truly falls apart all the more harrowing because then you get to see how the truly desperate behave.
And as Lee and Clementine's journey continues down bloodier and bloodier paths, where every choice feels like the end of the world, you will be glued to the screen every step of the way.
11. Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic
When Bioware approached Lucasarts for permission to make their own Star Wars game, they were allowed on the condition that they find a way to not contradict the events of the prequel films, which were still coming out at the time.
Their solution was to set the story of Star Wars: Knights Of The Old Republic so far back in the past that there's no way anything they could introduce could ever interfere with the current story. And thus KOTOR was allowed to be as insane and creative as they possibly could.
While still recognizably the same galaxy we've come to know and love, KOTOR's world is notably more ancient than the modern galaxy-wide civilization we see in the prequels. But the problems of the Jedi are eternal, as the old republic is nearly brought to extinction by a Sith lord named Lord Revan. Not that that's relevant to you, a totally random grunt working for the Jedi Bastila Shan. Nope, no way that has anything to do with you.
Joking aside, the twists and turns in this game have become legendary among both RPG and Star Wars fans as being some of the best storytelling in both. Combine that with crackling dialogue between some of the best characters in Star Wars history, and you get one for the history books.
10. Bioshock
Speaking of legendary twist, Bioshock has one of the best of the bunch.
When a man named Jack survives a mysterious plane crash in the middle of the ocean, he finds himself transported via lighthouse elevator to an underwater Randian nightmare city called Rapture. A city that seems like it already wouldn't have been the best place to live for multiple reasons, even if it wasn't in the process of burning to the goddamn ground.
Jack must traverse this living nightmare of a city, while along the way learning that his coming here might not have been the astronomically bad luck he thinks it was.
The story takes you through all of Rapture, doing battle with the horrors around every corner, and being constantly confronted with the choice to either save what good remains, or take it all for yourself. Games with moral choice systems often get bogged down in the infinite possibilities of their premise, but Bioshock keeps the choices simple enough to close any moral loopholes, but also poignant enough to be meaningful.
9. Metal Gear Solid 4
The hardest part of putting a Metal Gear Solid game on this list is picking just one to place over all of the others. Metal Gear games practically revolutionized what it means to be a story heavy experience in gaming, and they've been keeping up that trend since the 80s, so which one wins out over the others?
So while I could have chosen true violence and picked Metal Gear: Survive just to watch the world burn, I instead decided on the true ending of the series - Metal Gear Solid 4: Guns Of The Patriots.
MGS 4 may require a lot of backstory from the previous games in order to really know the intricate details of what's going on, but it always remembers to tell a good story that mostly stands on its own. The lore details make the game better, but they're not vital. And if you have played the previous games, this game's ending will have you weeping like a baby all the way to the end credits.
The cutscenes may be long as hell but you'll barely notice as MGS 4's story of war, PSTD, intergenerational trauma, and how one lives with dignity keeps you glued to the screen the whole way through.
8. Dragon Age: Origins
Dragon Age: Origins has the distinction of having one of the longest development times in gaming history, definitely in the top 3 in the triple A gaming sphere, at 8 years of development time, starting at the turn of the century and releasing in 2008. Now obviously with such a long time before making it to shelves, Origins was destined to either be legendarily good, or one of the worst things ever. There is no in between.
Fortunately we live in the universe where everything worked out for the best, as Dragon Age: Origins isn't just one of the best RPGs ever made, but one of the best stories ever told in gaming.
The basic premise of Origins is taking a Tolkien-esque fantasy world and asking a few "questions" about the setup. Such as: what if being the Big Damn Hero in this world carried with it some unfortunate drawbacks? What if humans and elves not only didn't get along but REALLY didn't get along? What if the powerful wizard had their own ulterior motives for helping you? Etcetera, etcetera.
What results is a world that feels uniquely alive from other stereotypical fantasy worlds, and a story that twists and turns in ways unexpected, even to veterans of so-called "dark fantasy".
7. Nier: Automata
Yoko Taro is one of those auteur creators that, for the longest time, the only people who knew about him were the kind of super-hipsters who make 3 hour long YouTube videos about inane topic that you can't stop watching for some reason. But the man finally got his due when he made the critical darling, Nier: Automata.
Nier Automata takes place so far into the future from the previous games that you don't need to know jack all about them (and considering how many people played Yoko Taro's other games, that's definitely a good thing) and centers on a pair of androids, 2B and 9S, who are tasked with exploring the ruins of planet Earth by their android masters. Little do they know that this mission will take them on an existential nightmare of a journey through the meaning of existence and humanity as they are confronted at every turn by dark mirrors of everything they are.
Nier: Automata loves one and only one thing and that is taking the audience for a damn ride. And that refers both to the fun as hell gameplay by acclaimed studio Platinum games and the story that twists and turns in every way you expect and at least 12 ways you don't.
6. The Last Of Us
Is it the obvious choice? Yes, yes it is. But some things are obvious because they're true.
The Last Of Us is easily one of the most influential games made in the last several decades, its release back in 2013 marking a fundamental shift in not just how Naughty Dog made games, but in how game stories would be told.
The story of Joel and Ellie traversing a post-apocalyptic America to find a cure for the zombie-like plague that caused said apocalypse is one that has forever marked itself onto the minds of an entire generation of gamers for its harrowing, bleak, but still beautiful tale of what the human race will do to protect its own when faced with the absolute worst conditions possible.
To call the story emotional would be to compete for the understatement of the year, and while I personally have problems with the ending, this is a game that's about the journey, and that journey is unrivaled to this day.
5. Disco Elysium
Where to begin with Disco Elysium? This isometric RPG has a repetition that massively precedes it, becoming one of the most beloved video games ever made since its 2019 launch.
And it’s easy to see why. From its dystopian setting of Revachol to the stunning cast of character littering the city’s streets, Disco has one of the richest worlds in the industry.
The story has a simple but amazing premise: you wake up one morning controlling a man in the throes of the world’s worst hangover. The hotel room is trashed, you’re in your underpants, and you have no memory of who you are or why you’re here. It quickly turns out you’re a detective solving a murder case in the neighbourhood, which you have to wing your way through when your partner Kim arrives to aid the investigation.
This is just the tip of a massive iceberg though, as Disco Elysium uses this set up to explore political ideology, interrogate a warring set of characters you need to keep happy via dialogue choices, and dive into a deep and complex history propping up the tumultuous world you’re occupying.
Throw in sharp, funny writing that characterises the literal voices in your character’s head vying for attention - and some truly heartbreaking plot revelations - and you have not only one of the richest video game stories, but one of the richest pieces of fiction in recent memory.
4. Silent Hill 2
Yeah you all knew this game was gonna be here somewhere, and why wouldn't it be? Sure, thanks to Konami being the actual worst, this series is an absolute joke nowadays, but back in the PS2 era, Silent Hill was the gold standard for horror games, and Silent Hill 2 in particular stood out from the rest of the series as one of the greatest tales ever woven in video game history.
The story of James Sunderland wandering the haunted streets of the eponymous town as he searches for his once thought dead wife who says she's waiting for him there in their "special place" has wormed its way into the hearts and psyches of an entire generation of gamers and horror fans alike.
Silent Hill has taken many different forms across the many games in the series, but 2 has the most multi-layered interpretation of it, showing it as the worst therapy session you've ever had. Where your choices are to either face your demons and overcome them, or be swallowed by them until there's nothing left behind.
How James fares when he enters the town is up to the player. But no matter which ending you get, this game will reach into your chest, grab your heartstrings, and tear them out of your chest cavity and then stomp on them.
3. Fire Emblem: Three Houses
Three Houses is the story of Byleth, an adventurer/mercenary who pulls a job that goes just a bit too well, and as a result, finds herself in a teaching position at a hoity toity military academy for the sons and daughters of nobles in the country of Fodlan.
As she quickly discovers, however, this school is not teaching the kinds of frivolity one would expect from a finishing school for rich brats. But is instead preparing them for an inevitable succession war for the throne. A war that Byleth will end up getting dragged into as well, and must choose a side. The side she chooses will determine who lives, who dies, and who gets to shape Fodlan's future.
What makes the story so interesting is how VASTLY different each side of it is, encountering different characters, settings, and ideas. But every one remains the same in the end, with you having to kill multiple characters that the game spent several hours getting you to fall in love with. There is absolutely no shame in playing this multiple times to do every route - the game encourages it, in fact. Just be prepared to have your heart broken in pretty much every single way.
2. Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs
Frankly Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs belongs this high just for being one of, if not the darkest story in gaming history. At least the canonical ending of Silent Hill 2 has James end in a place of genuine healing and the little girl getting out relatively okay, so at least some good came of what happened. Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs though? Yeah, no.
But I'm getting ahead of myself. Amnesia: A Machine For Pigs is about a man named Mandus, who wakes up in his house with no memory of the past several years. All he knows is that his two young sons are in danger, and a strange voice on the phone telling him that he needs to turn on this great machine resting beneath his mansion in order to save them. As he descends into the machine, Mandus learns terrible truth after terrible truth, most of which are obvious to the player, but in the context of the game, the obviousness of the twists actually make them worse in a way.
Machine For Pigs has NOTHING good to say about the human condition. It is bleak as all hell, but its bleakness is beautiful, in its way, owing mostly to the music by Jessica Curry and the brilliant writing, particularly the final monologue that sums up everything the game has to say about the human race, the world at large, and the futility of fighting against the march of time, no matter how steep the cliff it may be marching toward is.
1. Undertale
Are you mad? Of course you are. Most people get mad when confronted with the truth.
You just kinda had to be there to truly understand the immediate and craterous impact Undertale had on the gaming industry and community when it first dropped. There have been thesis papers, video essays, and god only knows how many Tumblr blogs detailing it, but to truly understand requires actual experience. I was there, man. And the punchline is that it was 100% warranted, because Undertale really is that damn good.
The story is the perfect example of appearing simple at the outset but gaining cavernous depth as you continue on and replay it multiple times, with hundreds of random events that can occur with each playthrough, and multiple different ways the story can end.
The characters have permanently seared themselves into popular culture with their iconic designs and fluid story arcs influences at every turn by the player. And the story is one of the most mind bending experiences I have ever had, with the game holding your feet to the fire at every turn, with some choices even forever corrupting your game to the point where you can NEVER get the best ending.
Undertale is the greatest story ever written in gaming. Who knows whether or not Deltarune will be able to match it. Stranger things have happened, but I sincerely doubt it.