20 Most Underrated Video Games Of The Generation (So Far)
Infinite Warfare was the best COD in years.
This generation has been good to games. Since the release of the Xbox One and PS4, hundreds of must-play releases have graced our consoles, and in only four years both Sony and Microsoft have managed to amass a rather impressive library of exclusives, keeping fans of both machines busy.
Indeed, with the amount of titles to choose from and games like The Witcher 3 boasting hundreds of hours of gameplay, new releases have demanded more from players than ever before. It's not only instalments in genres like RPGs that are huge time-sinks these days either, as every game is trying its best to be 'the one thing' players feel the need to jump into every day.
Overall, it should come as no surprise that in the few years since these new consoles have been on sale, more than a couple of excellent releases have slipped through the cracks.
Whether players didn't have the time to fit them into their hectic schedules or they were wrongly panned at release, some of this generation's most underrated games have been hiding under your nose this whole time...
20. Mass Effect Andromeda
Despite taking a beating when it first released and becoming the subject of countless memes overnight, the latest instalment into the Mass Effect series was nowhere near as bad as it was made out to be.
In fact, once it eventually got going and gave you the tools needed to explore its open worlds, Andromeda was pretty damn good.
Featuring the best combat of the franchise so far, the general minute-to-minute action was better than ever. When you were left to craft your own stories, finding side missions and interacting with characters on uncharted planets, it was easy to lose hours and whole nights to Andromeda's brand of sandbox gameplay.
And while the main story wasn't quite up to par with the other releases in the franchise, it was still enjoyable enough in its own right. Kicking off a brand new universe isn't easy, but the developers did a pretty decent job at creating a new mythology for fans to get stuck into.
Mass Effect: Andromeda is still a thoroughly enjoyable game at heart, and some dodgy animations shouldn't make you think it isn't.
19. The Order: 1886
Sony's first big flop of the generation, The Order: 1886 was derided by fans and critics alike for being more of a movie than a game upon its first release.
Because despite being stunningly beautiful and one of the most graphically impressive games you can find on console, the title's third-person shooting left much to be desired, adopting the same Gears of War cover-based model that ran its course years ago.
But even though the game was perhaps disappointing, it wasn't the complete write-off that it became known as.
The story itself showed a lot of potential (when it was actually focusing on the monsters and ghouls of Victorian England rather than the inter-office politics of the titular Order), and the gameplay was punchy enough to remain enjoyable for the game's short running time.
It's not the greatest game of the generation so far, but it's certainly not the 4/10 disaster that's it's known as, and pretty damn good if you can pick it up on the cheap.
18. Mafia III
Mafia III's biggest mistake was listening to the fans. With the first two games being criticised for having huge open worlds to explore but nothing to see outside of the main story, the third release dropped the linear focus on plot in favour of giving players a huge array of missions and the freedom to accomplish them in whichever way they saw fit.
Unfortunately, it swung the focus so far in the direction of open-world box ticking that the immersive storytelling that the series was known for was buried under a sea of repetitive activities that needed to be completed first.
Which was a shame, because when Mafia III was firing on all cylinders and focusing on its brilliantly engaging revenge narrative, it was amazing. Boasting high quality cutscenes and impressive voice acting across the board, the world of Lincoln Clay was an intoxicating one, but one that liked to give you a bit too much busywork.
Still, the activities you were doing were enjoyable in themselves, and the vivid backdrop of New Bordeaux more than kept them feeling fresh the longer the game went on.
17. Alien: Isolation
The Alien series has had a rather rocky relationship with video game fans over the years. With the only recent releases in the franchise being the middling Aliens vs. Predator and the disastrous Colonial Marines, the Sega-owned series had burned consumers one too many times.
Unfortunately, that meant most players outright ignored Alien: Isolation when it was announced.
Despite promising a return to the franchise's horror roots, nobody trusted Sega to deliver a good Alien game, which unfortunately meant that the developers behind Isolation were fighting an uphill battle from the get go.
As it turned out, their take on the long-running series was actually everything the franchise needed. A survival-horror inspired stealth game, Isolation was the type of faithful adaptation that Colonial Marines could only dream of being.
Capturing the retro-futuristic look of the original movie and sticking to that film's idea of having only one xenomorph terrorising a ship, Isolation was the game that fans had been craving for so long.
The title has managed to garner a rather strong following in the years since its release, but the game could have been so much bigger had Sega not messed the franchise up so thoroughly in the first place.
16. Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare
Infinite Warfare's fate was sealed by fans long before it even come out.
Not only was the game doubling-down on the sci-fi setting at a time where players were growing increasingly tired of CoD's futuristic focus, but Activision's decision to exclusively include Modern Warfare Remastered as part of IW's Legacy Edition turned fans against the game in the months leading up to its release.
They should have given it a fair chance however, because it was actually the best Call of Duty title in years. An attempt to shake up the series' stale gameplay, IW gave players access to a wide variety of new weapons, the ability to fight in zero-g environments and even missions that solely took place from the cockpit of a spaceship.
The story itself was surprisingly excellent too, telling an epic sci-fi tale that managed to keep the focus squarely on the game's eclectic ensemble of characters. Being unafraid to put this squad of misfits in genuine danger - for the first time in years - Infinite Warfare's campaign was able to evoke an emotional response from its players, rather than simply being an excuse to string together bombastic set-pieces.
15. Deus Ex: Mankind Divided
Despite suffering from a limited scope following publisher Square Enix's decision to split the latest Deus Ex into two different games, Mankind Divided is still a worthy entry into the long-running series.
Once again adopting the player-driven philosophy of the previous RPGs, this time around the game dropped you into a world plagued by the divide between augmented humans and regular flesh-and-blood people.
It's not a new setting as far as sci-fi goes, but it was a surprisingly political and relevant backdrop for a game who's protagonist is a Batman-voiced super-solider with blades in his forearms.
Deus Ex doesn't just get a pass because of its story however, but because it succeeds so much in building upon the foundations set by its predecessor. There are no more awkward boss battles that dragged the previous game to a halt here, and this time around the game doesn't push one specific playstyle over the rest.
Over its four years in development the studio behind Mankind Divided listened to feedback and rolled with it, managing to create a damn good RPG in the process.
14. Wolfenstein: The New Order
Although Doom was praised for ushering in a grand return to the style of old-school first-person shooters back in 2016, Wolfenstein: The New Order had already accomplished the very same thing years prior.
Throwing out many of the restrictions that modern FPS games were known for such as regenerating health, a two-weapon carry limit and linear corridor shooting, The New Order proved that the old way of doing things was still alive and kicking.
But it wasn't just impressive because it marked a return to classic game design principles that were thought to have been long abandoned, as Wolfenstein had a surprisingly great story backing it up too.
The series has never been known for the quality of its storytelling, but the latest release managed to turn what had previously just been an excuse to shoot supernatural Nazis in the face into a compelling alternate-future tragedy.
13. Star Wars: Battlefront
Despite releasing without a single-player campaign and only a handful of multiplayer modes, Star Wars: Battlefront was still one of the most satisfying shooters of 2015.
Derided for taking a more accessible and 'arcade-y' approach to combat, Battlefront's pick-up-and-play mentality was actually one its biggest strengths.
DICE made it so easy to jump into a multiplayer game and just start having fun, and it meant that the title was always good for a few rounds of Walker Assault no matter what mood you were in. The approach might have resulted in a game that didn't have the depth or the longevity found in the likes of Battlefield or even Call of Duty, but it made for one that was instantly gratifying.
Plus, for Star Wars fans Battlefront was simply a dream come true. From the sounds of the blasters to the threads on Han Solo's jacket, it was clear that the developers loved everything about this series and were committed to bringing it to life.
12. The Evil Within
Although some fans of the Resident Evil franchise were turned off by the radical new direction of the seventh game, they need to look no further for a worthy successor to the series than The Evil Within.
Spearheaded by the same director as the best Resi games, Tango Gameworks' take on survival horror refined the intense third-person shooting the genre was known for while ramping up the gore and focusing on psychological elements that gave the title an added surreal edge.
There were a few technical problems that held the title back when it first launched, and the decision to adopt a letterboxd screen didn't sit well with some players, but in the intervening years patches have sorted out most of the complaints that marred the title back in 2014.
The Evil Within 2 is shaping up to be one of the biggest releases of the year, so there's never been a better time to go back and appreciate one of the best survival horror games of the generation so far.
11. Watch Dogs 2
Improving on virtually every flaw that made the original game such a mess a few years ago, 2016's Watch Dogs 2 was a huge step up in quality for the franchise.
Dropping much of the po-faced seriousness the series was known for in favour of a more comedic and zany approach to the world of hacking, this sequel attempted to win back players disappointed by the first release by going in an entirely different direction.
But despite radically improving on its core gameplay and story, Ubisoft had burned so many excited fans with the original title that most of them didn't give this second game a chance.
The sequel should have been the start of a new beginning for the series, but it only proved that the Watch Dogs hype was well and truly over.
10. Outlast
Although the Outlast series is slowly gaining more recognition as a modern horror masterpiece the longer time goes on, the original game released without any hype surrounding it back in 2013.
Adopting the same run-and-hide gameplay mechanics of countless indie horror titles on Steam, the game could have easily just been another run-of-the-mill cash-in on an increasingly popular genre.
But Outlast brought a surprising amount of variety and polish to the expected genre proceedings. Instead of being able to quickly identify how the game's scares were put together and having the suspense ruined through shoddy game design, the original title remained genuinely surprising for its entire run-time.
Rarely ever reusing scenarios or scares more than once, despite not having access to the same resources of a big triple A release, Outlast still felt like one. A lean and mean monster even four years down the line, the original instalment in the franchise is still one of the most impressive horror games of this generation.
9. Dishonored 2
The first of two games on this list developed by Arkane Studios, Dishonored 2 wasn't quite the breakout success story that many thought it was going to be. Which was weird, because at this point it's unclear what Dishonored has to do to become a mainstream hit.
Home to two of the best stealth games around, the series' focus on letting players go nuts and accomplish their objectives in any manner they see fit was pushed further than ever in this latest release.
Giving players not only access to a wide variety of different playstyles and supernatural abilities, the second game also let players choose from two completely different characters, which radically altered both the gameplay and story depending on who you chose.
There's no way to see everything Dishonored 2 has to offer on a first playthrough, but fortunately the quality of both the title's gameplay and writing means that once you see the credits roll for the first time, you'll be dying to jump back in all over again.
8. Dying Light
Nobody was expecting much from the new zombie game made by the guys responsible for the original Dead Island, but damn if Dying Light wasn't one of the best hidden gems of 2015.
Building on the open world zombie-killing the studio was known for by adding in an emphasis on parkour and a day/night cycle that changed the way the title played depending on the time of day, with Dying Light Techland made their first attempt at the genre look like nothing more than a glorified tech demo.
Plus, the developers have released some impressive expansions in the years since the title hit shelves that have only improved on the systems established in the core game, giving players even more of a reason to give Dying Light a shot.
7. Titanfall 2
Titanfall 2 had the odds stacked against it when it released last year. Not only was it coming off an Xbox One exclusive original game that came under fire for not releasing with enough content, but it was dropping between Battlefield 1 and CoD: Infinite Warfare, by far the two most anticipated shooters of the year.
Everyone except EA could see poor sales coming from a mile off, and even though Titanfall 2 was critically well received, it wasn't enough to stop it from being pushed out by those other two gigantic games.
Respawn Entertainment's sequel deserves your attention, as it's home to some of the most satisfying and addicting shooting mechanics this side of Destiny 2. With a focus on fast movement and quick reflexes, the title retained the great, twitchy feeling of Call of Duty while losing the repetitive, kill-die-repeat gameplay that the series suffers from.
Plus, this time around the sequel has a great single-player campaign to boot, building upon the lore that was established in the original release to create one of the most impressive recent solo FPS experiences not published by Bethesda.
6. Prey
Taking inspiration from the likes of classic horror shooters such as System Shock 2, this year's reboot of the Prey franchise was an imaginative and terrifying combination of old and new FPS game design.
Rewarding experimentation and exploration rather than pure first-person shooting reflexes, Arkane Studios' latest is a game that no two people will play through the same. Dropping you into an alien-infested space station and letting you figure the rest out for yourself, you have to have your wits about you if you want to survive long enough to make sense of what's going on.
The story might lose you as it starts revealing more and more of its secrets, but even that doesn't stop the game from being one of the most interesting narrative-driven shooters in recent memory.
Unfortunately, the title was the latest in a long line of causalities that have suffered at the hands of Bethesda's restrictive review policy. With no reviews out there at launch, nobody knew just how great Prey was.
5. XCOM 2
A sequel to 2012's sleeper-hit revival of the cult-classic series, XCOM 2 spent years perfecting the already fantastic turn-based tactical gameplay of its predecessor.
In charge of a resistance force pushing back an overwhelming alien threat, the sequel gave players the option of waging guerrilla warfare and full-on assaults on the enemy in its solid single-player campaign.
Boasting a much faster and more tactical hit-and-run style of gameplay than the original release, XCOM 2 still retained the depth and complexity that made that game such a cult hit in the first place.
Likewise, an approach to making the maps partly procedurally generated meant that players were constantly kept on their toes, never able to rely on the same tactics twice to get them through ever-changing levels and online bouts.
The niche appeal of turn-based tactics games meant that the title didn't blow up the mainstream as much as it should have, but it's provided countless hours of entertainment for the people who gave it a chance.
4. Mad Max
Mad Max managed to make the open world genre feel fresh again when it released in 2015. However, even though it was coming off the hype of Fury Road which came out in theatres only a few months prior, Avalanche Studios' attempt at the post-apocalyptic franchise released to little fanfare.
The reasons as to why are manifold, but it probably didn't help that although WB as a publisher had proven with games like the Arkham series and Shadow of Mordor that they can make great releases based on licensed properties, there was still an air of distrust around movie-to-game adaptations going into Mad Max.
Also it released on the same day as a little title called Metal Gear Solid V, which stole away eyes that may have otherwise been on Avalanche's brilliant sandbox game.
Still, it's one of the best entries into the open world genre in recent memory, shedding all of the fat that often bogs those titles down while delivering the definitive Mad Max gaming experience in the process.
If this game doesn't receive a sequel then it'll be one of the biggest mistakes of the generation.
3. Until Dawn
With Until Dawn, developers at Supermassive established themselves as the new kings of story games on Playstation.
Putting you in control of a bunch of teenagers trapped in a ski lodge on the anniversary of a tragic accident, the game revels in the tropes of horror cinema but in a way that has a clear affection for the genre.
Spinning a fascinating mystery plot that spirals off into radically different directions based on the choices you make throughout the title, there are a surprising amount of ways to play through Until Dawn that aren't just boiled down to deciding who lives and who dies.
Acting as a greatest hits run through of all your favourite horror movies in one expansive package, the cinematic title is a loving ode to a genre that rarely ever gets any big-budget love on consoles, and has quickly become one of Sony's most beloved properties because of it.
2. Hitman
While its weird episodic release schedule made many players think that the latest entry in the Hitman series was going to be a low-effort experiment rather than a fully-fledged sequel, that perception couldn't have been further from the truth.
In fact, the latest incarnation of Hitman is the best the series has been in years. Returning to the philosophy of older releases like Blood Money rather than following in the linear footsteps of Absolution, each episode of the latest game dropped players into a massive sandbox and let them loose to take out their targets in whatever wacky ways they could come up with.
And in many ways, the decision to split the game up into episodes actually benefited the release in the long run. Developers knew fans would be playing and replaying these isolated levels for potentially months before a new episode dropped, meaning there needed to be enough variety and content to keep players coming back for more.
What that resulted in is now the game can be bought as a full package is some of the strongest and most replayable sandboxes in the whole of the Hitman franchise, and easily one of the best stealth games of the generation.
1. Rainbow Six: Siege
At a time where multiplayer shooters were trying to be as big and as expansive as they could be, Ubisoft's Rainbow Six: Siege was committed to moving in the opposite direction.
Shunning huge battlefields for intimate 5v5 matches where each player has only one life per round, the intense shooter offered a more tactical alternative to other games on the market.
Unfortunately after releases like Titanfall and Star Wars: Battlefront, players were rightly wary of multiplayer-only games, meaning that Siege was treated rather harshly when it first hit shelves.
It didn't help either that in classic Ubisoft fashion the game was incredibly buggy at launch, with lag and crashes making the title unplayable for some during the first couple of weeks.
It's since improved massively however, and currently Siege is one of the most interesting multiplayer experiences you can get your hands on. There's nothing that comes close to it on console, and the constant stream of free updates has ensured that there's always a new reason to jump back in.