20 PS4 Exclusives - Ranked From Worst To Best

The naughty dog, the overlong cutscene and the radioactive abomination.

playstation 4 ps4 games
Sony/Capcom/Insomniac

Can you believe the PS4 is now in its third year? By this time in the last generation we'd seen the 360 and PS3 sprout the likes of Gears of War, Crackdown, Metal Gear Solid 4 and the phenomenal Uncharted 2: Among Thieves, but for this generation it's been a slower build, with only 2015 and now 2016 providing a defining ramp-up in quality.

Thankfully we're now at a time where you can comfortably look at the PS4's output and champion it accordingly. Not only have Naughty Dog knocked it clean out the park and into the stratosphere with Uncharted 4, but there are a bevy of indie titles providing solid foundations for innovation and progression too.

It hasn't all gone well - but luckily as far as exclusives go, Sony have only licensed a handful of bad eggs - yet one thing remains; the PlayStation 4 of 2016 is one hell of a machine, both in terms of its library and hardware output.

Time to check out the best, the rest, and anything in between. Let me know your own best and worst games in the comments below!

--

20. Godzilla

Godzilla ps4
Bandai Namco

You have to start at the bottom, and by far the worst exclusive gracing the big blue machine is Godzilla, a turgid experience where the only appeal is in seeing everyone's favourite radioactive lizard smash the hell out of everything.

Literally, that's it.

Ambling forward and stomping on pieces of the environment is the order of the day, and save for the occasional boss battle against the likes of Mothra or King Ghidorah, the only lasting impression left behind is a question: How can it be this hard to make a truly brilliant Godzilla game?


19. The Order: 1886

the order 1886
Ready At Dawn

It's sad to recant just how naff The Order was, because it could've been so much more. A Gears of War-style cover shooter with a Knights of the Round Table-aesthetic and a smog-filled Victorian London in need of a good cleansing? Sign me right up.

Sadly, in action... there was none. Action, that is.

The Order certainly looked the part, but as for gameplay it was primarily one gigantic cutscene, complete with entire 'chapters' beginning and ending with your hands off the pad.

Stop n' pop gunplay was fun enough, but the grey and brown colour palette did little to encourage replayability, and the less said about the quick-time event boss battles, the better.


18. Killzone: Shadow Fall

Killzone shadow fall
Guerrilla Games

Speaking of grey and brown aesthetics, for their leap to PS4 hardware, Guerrilla Games amped up their own formerly bland visual punch for Killzone, introducing all sorts of technicolour levels and vibrant armour designs.

It was the best Killzone had been, but sadly that's a bar even the likes of Homefront could step over with ease. Yet again the shooting felt flat and weightless, the enemy animations crumpling like wet paper and the story was yet more "We invaded a planet and the people already there weren't happy, let's fight!" nonsense.

A launch title through and through, can we all join hands and cheer the fact that Guerilla have finally been allowed to make something else? Here's to Horizon: Zero Dawn coming before Christmas.


17. Knack

knack ps4
Sony

Knack gets to be this high in the list because honestly, honestly, he wasn't anywhere near as bad as the critics would have you believe.

Being a fine, tight little platformer, the buckethead's biggest fault was his character aesthetic and mismatched "I'm a big tough guy!" voice - oh, and the fact he could've been done on the PS2. Those particle effects weren't fooling anybody.

Still, Knack scuppered his chances with the younger demographic thanks to being too damn hard, but for the rest of us, this was a surprisingly challenging 3D platformer in a world completely starved of them (but not anymore).


16. Infamous: Second Son

infamous second son
Sucker Punch

Infamous is the perfect bridge between the negatively received exclusives and the awesome ones. It was just 'okay':

Its platforming? Solid. Characters? Likeable, but not loveable. Its level designs, powers and general feel of gameplay? All totally serviceable, but in a way that did nothing for Infamous as a franchise just teetering on the edge of being truly great.

Indeed, something has always felt that little bit 'off' over the years with Sucker Punch's baby. Whether it be that you take too much damage too quickly or the controls just aren't responsive enough to usher in Spider-Man 2-levels of exploration, Infamous is the highest of B-tier games, and Second Son was a formulaic execution of exactly that.


15. Axiom Verge

axiom verge
Thomas Happ

Right, onto the good stuff. Developed by one man coding powerhouse, Thomas Happ, he promptly recognised there hadn't been a truly brilliant Super Metroid-style game since Shadow Complex, and set about remedying that immediately.

Playing as scientist-turned-inter-dimensional explorer Trace, you wield the titular weapon and explore your surroundings in a 2D side-scrolling shooter. The world unfolds around you and Trace discovers that he's the linchpin in a war of two entities, the game injecting enough humour into proceedings to always prompt you to keep going.

Upgrades in both weapons and character abilities come thick and fast, and in terms of being a retro throwback, even the corner map and intentionally glitchy level tiles are laser-focussed nods to the cartridge-loading days of the 90s.

Don't be put off by its primitive aesthetic, Axiom Verge is one hell of a fun ride.


14. Grow Home

Grow Home BUD
Ubisoft

Y'know when I said there was a lack of 3D platformers? Yeah, Ubisoft noticed that too, and although they weren't about to gamble tens of thousands on a big budget release, Grow Home was made by one of their smaller studios instead.

Playing as BUD, gameplay maps the triggers to his hands, as you strategically climb and jump your way up a vertical landscape. Thick vines arc across the sky and carry you place to place, flowers can be clung onto and used as makeshift parachutes, and BUD himself is a clumsy sort that means momentum must be thought of at all times.

It's cute, it's unique, has just enough of a tactile feel to be addictive, and it'll scratch your 3D platformer itch like nothing outside of Ratchet & Clank.


13. Street Fighter V

street fighter v 5
Capcom

Dammit Street Fighter, even Adele couldn't sing loud enough about how much you could've had it all. From a total lack of decent single player content to tutorials and general progression that feels tacked on in favour of getting this out in time for the Capcom Pro Tour, SFV is lacking in almost every area.

However, like Destiny, its core is polished to a mirror sheen, and the fighting itself, the actual going one--on-one with anyone, is the best Street Fighter has ever been.

That means it's still the same cerebral showdowns of timing-based moves, storing up specials and watching animations before pulling off the perfect counter. Characters and graphical presentation is outstanding, and if you came for the multiplayer in the first place, you'll be more than satisfied.

Shame about the story, though.


12. Everybody's Gone To The Rapture

everybody's gone to the rapture
The Chinese Room

"Eww, story-focussed games" many will squirm and say. Well, yes, and especially with Everybody's Gone to the Rapture, it really is a narrative-heavy 'experience' rather than anything with any particular gameplay loop, but for the mood it creates and the phenomenally well told story within, The Chinese Room's latest deserves a mention.

Said story sees you playing an unknown wanderer through a village in Shropshire, England. The town's populace are nowhere to be seen and all that's left is to travel house to house, item to item figuring out exactly what happened.

The only character models in the game are spectral balls of light that form shapes resembling humanoid movement, but it's a testament to how cutscenes are delivered and just how well voiced the entire cast is, that from just the barest idea of 'this person was here, and this person was over there' staging, that incredibly emotional exchanges occur.

It's definitely not for everyone, but none of the best things in life are. Give it a shot if you fancy flexing your pretentious muscles, Everybody's Gone to the Rapture is gorgeous.


11. The Witness

The Witness.jpg
Jonathan Blow

Even if you're not a fan of things like Everybody's Gone to the Rapture or The Witness, it's a damn good thing that the console can cater to so many experiences anyway. The latter especially is the product of Braid's Jonathan Blow, who amassed a team of coders to bring his next mind-bending puzzler to life.

Centred entirely around the idea of getting a beam of light from one end of a given grid to another, the game starts introducing rules and thought processes to subsequent iterations of that same setup.

the witness
Thekla Inc.

Eventually you need only look at a particular symbol to know the rule the game is asking for, and when those rules start combining and feeding into the world you're exploring, The Witness truly reveals itself as one giant comment on how we take in information, repurpose it and spread it.

Easily the hardest puzzle game on PS4 and one of the most well designed of all time, if you like the sensation of a given conundrum snapping into place after hours of pondering, The Witness is for you.


10. Until Dawn

until dawn
Sony

Okay, let's switch gears - from brain matter-testers to exploding heads, torsos and everything else. Until Dawn's idea of casting you as an entire band of teenagers looking to hide out in the woods (as all teenagers are want to do at some point) was total genius - especially when one wrong decision spells permanent disaster.

Story pathways snake off and a present day recanting of the horrors you're witnessing by an unknown character only deepens the mystery of what's really going on.

Something of a cult success that nowhere near enough people played, Until Dawn is like old-school PS2 horror Obscure, mixed with David Cage's game design on a good day.


9. Invisible Inc.

Invisible Inc
Klei Entertainment

Variety is the spice of life, and when you've got one of the best developers in the industry bringing games to your console, it's also hugely inspiring.

As such, Klei Entertainment decided to mix XCOM/Fire Emblem's turn-based tactics gameplay with stealth, resulting in randomly generated interiors and spy-themed levels you'll slink through, square by square.

Guards can be taken out, cameras disabled, computers hacked and everything in between - if you've ever been the person to play something like Metal Gear Solid, Splinter Cell or Hitman and form a plan in your mind before executing on it, Invisible Inc. is the embodiment of that entire mindset.


8. Transistor

transistor game ps4
Supergiant Games

Another fantastic indie dev, SuperGiant games brought you 2011's Bastion, only to then take their gorgeous, hand-drawn animation style and spin a completely different, sci-fi tale instead.

Taking place in a utopian data-driven city gone awry (as they always do), you play as Red, an opera singer wielding a talking sword (yes really). It gets better from there though, as combat plays out like PS2 gem Alter Echo, seeing you plan multiple moves as time stands still, only to hit a button and watch them all play out.

Weapon upgrades come in the form of various mods combining to create unique abilities, and as the world's lore is also tucked away behind using said abilities, you're actively encouraged to experiment just to get the full picture. Genius.


7. Broforce

broforce game
Free Lives Games

Sometimes you just want to blow the living hell out of everything. DOOM more than realised this, and on the 2D plane, Broforce does to.

Playing as every last action hero or awesome pop figure you can imagine, your goal is simple: Explode, detonate and punch your way through enemy soldiers and vehicles. Simple as.

One bullet and you're dead, but for every time you respawn you'll get a new character with a different weapon and ability. The roster includes Arnold Schwarzenegger (Terminator and Commando variants), John McClane, Predator, Ellen Ripley, Macguyver, Robocop and a TON more, all given brilliant pixellated makeovers and name-changes to avoid any whiffs of copyright.

A love letter to action cinema, Broforce is the ethos of the Expendables x1000.


6. Firewatch

firewatch game
Camp Santo

The latest narrative adventure to make waves, Campo Santo (a supergroup developer comprised of members from Telltale's The Walking Dead, Mark of the Ninja and Double Fine) put out an experience all about isolation, connection and introspection.

You play Henry, a man who's taken a job in the middle of the Wyoming wilderness, simply to escape from his unfortunate life. You'll then make a connection with Delilah, a fellow 'fire-watcher' stationed across the valley. From here let's just say many things happen, but the crux of the game explores that human desire to either be around other people, or distance ourselves from them.

It asks many questions as to our fascination with the wider world, with media, with stories not our own, and how that shapes us as people. Naturally I'm staying very vague here, but as a goodhearted experience with a few twists and turns, and a thoroughly interpretative ending, Firewatch is one hell of an achievement.


5. Bloodborne

Bloodborne Weapons
FromSoftware

Who knows where Dark Souls creator Hidetaka Miyazaki is going to go from here, but Bloodborne was a fantastically solid statement of intent, showing he and his team at FromSoftware are more than capable of branching away from swords n' shields fantasy.

As such, Bloodborne is 'Souls by way of H.P. Lovecraft, it's steampunk by way of the Babadook. By taking the open-world stylings inherent to how we explore Soulsian worlds, Miyazaki drops you into the city of Yarnham, one rich with demons and monsters that need slaying, with a far larger story backing it all up.

You'll get torn down (the studio's difficulty curve isn't any less devastating), you'll rank up and you'll specialise in a ton of fancy, cobbled together weapons. In the end though it's the world that you'll drink in, and for that Bloodborne will forever be one of the PS4's finest achievements.


4. Hotline Miami & Hotline Miami 2: Wrong Number

Hotline Miami
Dennaton Games

Large open worlds are one thing, but simple controls and fun excuses to act on them is where the purest of gameplay experiences lie. To that end, Hotline Miami is quite possibly the most fun you can ever have when gameplay perfectly matches impeccable audio design.

Creators Jonatan Sderstrm and Dennis Wedin hand-picked all the game's synthwave songs, to which the second title, Wrong Number, has the best collection of tracks this side of GTA: Vice City. Gameplay is a top-down ultra violent twin-stick shooter, challenging you to wipe out all sorts of locations filled with enemies in the fastest, most blood-soaked ways possible, but you'll do all of it in time with the beat.

hotline miami 2
Dennaton Games

Blast a guy's head off, grab his knife, fling that at an oncoming goon before unloading another round into the guy who thought he had you by surprise. The entire time the music is just thumping away in the background, challenging you to get better, to be more in time, to kill faster and score higher.

Hotline is a stupidly fun rush, and although many critics lambasted the sequel for being too hard, its difficulty curve simply continues where the first left off. Master the original and then leap straight into the next. Perfect.


3. The Last Of Us: Remastered

The Last Of Us Zombies
Naughty Dog

As gaming's 'Citizen Kane' moment, The Last of Us truly proved Naughty Dog are the finest developers working right now. Their tech is just on another level for one, and even on PS3, TLoU's graphics are outstanding.

Putting you in the shoes of father Joel and asking you to take care of Ellie (the girl with the only cure for the zombie-like infestation ravishing the globe), you could've predicted the "And they became best friends" arc a mile off.

What nobody predicted however, was the ending. A plot twist so severe and so human in its execution, that it divides all who experience it. At the heart is the question of who's more important: Your loved ones, or the millions around you, but the execution of this idea by piloting Joel through one of the most harrowing final levels of all time is just sublime.

The Last of Us hits harder than anything else I've ever played, and the sheer balls of its final shot before the credits kick in is the stuff gaming history is made of.


2. Ratchet & Clank

ratchet and clank
Insomniac

It's hard to go from such gushing praise of what's clearly a very mature title to Ratchet & Clank, but occasionally you just want a game to be a game, y'know?

Sometimes you don't need grand arcs, character development and discussions online about what a line of dialogue truly means. Sometimes, you just wanna smash through waves of enemies with a wrench, collect hundreds of shiny bolts and get a gun that fires discoballs every few minutes.

Sometimes, you just need a 3D platformer like Ratchet & Clank to rekindle your childhood, reminding you of a time when the genre was everywhere, and that underneath all the cinematic grandeur that comes with blockbuster action adventures, solid mechanics and loveable characters can stand toe-to-toe all the same.


1. Uncharted 4: A Thief's End

uncharted 4
Naughty Dog

All those lovely words for Ratchet & Clank and I still went back to Uncharted? Well, yes, hell yes, because what Naughty Dog have done with the character of Nathan Drake isn't something I ever thought possible. They grounded him, made him human, made him more relatable than you thought before, and crazier than ever - they reframed all three past Uncharteds as flights of fancy; youthfully exuberant adventures we've all done as part of growing up, perhaps now yearning to do so one last time after settling down.

By making Drake the man first and the adventurer second, you look at the near-death experiences he just barely scrapes through under a whole new light. A Thief's End does all this before introducing Nate's brother from years gone by and asking you to then go on one more adventure, too - and you feel the weight of that situation through every subsequent step.

Uncharted 4 might not be the landmark success The Last of Us was in terms of holding up one version of morality and forcing you to live with it, but it is the natural evolution of the blockbuster action flick - one with brains, brawn, and a ludicrous amount of heart.

What's the best and worst PS4 exclusive so far? Let us know in the comments!


In this post: 
PS4
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.