4 Ways You Are Killing Video Games
This is how the players, the press and the publishers are all coming together and bringing about the death of video games. Dont worry, there is a fix. When I sat here, fingers poised over keyboard, I wanted to write about you. Yes, you. And how you are the cause of every problem that exists in the video game industry. Its your fault that the internet is full of hate. What right do you have to tell the makers of my chosen art form to tell them how to make their games? You are a consumer, not a creator. Shut up and make something for yourself. Then I stopped. During a bout of furious research, I found a GDC talk from Chris Hecker where he briefly tells us what you are not the problem; in fact, everyone is the problem. Hes right too. 4. Hayter Love
It all started here. Shortly after the announcement that both Metal Gear Solid: Ground Zeroes and The Phantom Pain are one and the same, it was revealed that the long time series stalwart and voice actor David Hayter would not be voicing the protagonist, Big Boss. Series director Hideo Kojima said that he wanted recreate the Metal Gear series. Its a new type of Metal Gear game and we want to have this reflected in the voice actor as well. This statement was much to the chagrin of the internet.
Dont get me wrong, I love David Hayter as much, maybe more, than the next man. I pride myself on being a walking Metal Gear wiki. I will defend the franchises ridiculous stupidity to my final breath. Hell, Hayter didnt watch The Watchmen, he wrote them. I even enjoyed the Scorpion King Yeah. To be honest, I am a little disappointed at the lack of Hayter in the next installment in the series. It will be weird, after all, questioning cries of Meryl? Metal Gear? And Liquid? are ingrained into my psyche. However, Metal Gear Solid, and its associated media, is the brainchild of its creator, the aforementioned Hideo. Whatever he decides to twist Metal Gear into, thats his prerogative.
But, of course, the internet did not like this too much. So among all the I IS GOING TO BOYCOTT METAL GEARZ, a Change.org petition was started. The petition, or partition, as the creator, Branden Gunn, at one point calls it, is after 15,000 signatures to try and get David Hayter back into Metal Gear Solid V to play Big Boss. At the time of writing, the petition has just shy of 13,000 scribbles on it, with reasons like the following attached to it.
Cause i wanna hear davids voice one more time =D- Lulu Hand-destruction
Because David Hayter- Arturo Pérez Avila
SAY NO TOE KEIFER SUTHERLAND- Say No To Keifer
Without David Hayter any potential for a successful product will go away.- Gregory Wojcik
Its that last one that really got me.
What gives the player of a game the right to turn around and say they know what is best for a product? That right is for Konami and Kojima alone. As a consumer, you are just that, a consumer. It would be ridiculous for you to turn around and say to me, Im not reading the rest of this article. The writer put Konami in front of Kojima. What a douche! Im going to commence a Kickstarter to get this guy off the internet." I am not going to turn up at your house whilst youre making your lunch and punch you square on the nose for replacing the extra strong cheddar with a french brie in your sandwich. Its your sandwich do as you please. I may show distaste after experiencing the final product, but that was your creative vision for your sandwich.
3. The Rise Of The Internet
Without sounding years my senior, its the fault of that-there internet. When I was a youngun, if you wanted to express your hatred for something, you had to write a strongly worded letter, maybe leave a voice message with Terry Wogan for Sunday afternoon television. Perhaps you could stand on your front porch with a loved one and shake your fist at the world that has wronged you. Now? Simply roll over, pull out your smartphone and mash badly spelt obscenities into your touch screen keyboard.
Remember when games were fun? When they just visualisations of your wildest fantasies? I used to swap cheat codes on the playground, talk about Zelda bosses in the middle of maths class, or lend a friend a cartridge because my ham shaped fists could not, for love nor money, get a certain star in Super Mario 64. As the internet has grown, so has the convention of the faceless culture. These days all I need is a email address and a witty pseudonym and I can spew hatred towards a person or group of persons.
As this industry grows, so does the antagonism. Do you remember the uncontrollable amount of bullying that BioWares Jennifer Hepler faced when she dared to suggest story-driven games could let players skip through combat sequences? What about when high level Street Fighter X Tekken player, Aris Bakhranians, defended the presence of sexual harassment in the fighting game scene because it was part of the culture and had more than just a handful of people coming to his defense?
Before I started digging, I was going to place the blame of the slow decline of intelligence in this industry square on the players, but it isnt. Those people who bitch and moan to the Nth degree, are part of the problem. Us, in the press and those in the game development and publishing communities are too at fault for the coming of what could be another crash in the video game monopoly. The most worrying part of all of this is the caustic attitude that the three strange bedfellows treat each other with. Dont forget there are exceptions to all of this.
2. The Overall Problem
The majority of people who play video games always seem to be hard done-by. They're never, ever happy, and they seem to be able to happily wallow in a stinky pit of acrimony. Players get mad at publishers because publishers give us nothing but the same crap year in year out. Every year I am expected to go out and buy another copy of FIFA, followed by an Assassins Creed entry in October and a Call Of Duty in November. They push us into buying season passes for stuff we never are going to play then metaphorically slap us with on disc downloadable content.
THEN, in the next generation of consoles, they have the audacity to lock us out of pre-owned games with the ability of technological advancements. We are expected to dish out a hard days earnings on a game but be unable to play it because of some stupid issue with digital rights management. The press as well. All of the media outlets, both on the internet and in print, dont serve their readership but are owned and controlled by the PR companies and their advertisers.
However, the players are not the only ones to hate the people that support their hobby. The press and the publishers share a similar amount of antipathy towards the players. Gamers are always in a bottomless pit of wanting and whatever happens to be spoon fed to them, a not insignificant amount of the them are vocally abhorrent.
This sequel is rubbish, its too similar to the last game. This sequel is rubbish, they changed too much. That review score is too high, the reviewer must have been payed off. That review score is too low, they must not be a real gamer and not have finished it on super hard ninja difficulty. This website has ZERO integrity, they thrive on click baiting BS articles and have no respect for the reader now let me click this news article called BREAKING: Kaz Hirai bashes the Wii U!
1. The Fall To Pieces
When publishers attempt to right these so called wrongs, they get it pushed back in their face. When a bad case of sequelitis sets in, publishers will put out a, say, Mirrors Edge. A damn fine game which nobody brought. Players wanted Banjo Kazooie back and got given Nuts And Bolts. Not good enough. Another Battlefield is coming out this year but it just looks the damn same. RUBBISH. What is a video game publisher supposed to do? They are in an eternal catch 22. Put out something new and face low sales and lost cash. Put out the same old shooter, make all the money, but face abuse from the gaming public. And in many cases, as you have probably read on news sites, they get laid off.
The video gaming press doesnt get off lightly either. This is something I know from experience. The world most beautifully written editorial could be pushed down by some sensationalist headline and a cosplay gallery. Its another catch 22. We know what the readers pay attention to based on hard numbers like unique visitors and click through advertising however, the press still gets hated for posting those sorts of headlines instead of deep intellectualism despite people still clicking on them. Websites end up becoming places focusing on the more lucrative pieces over focusing on that which will best serve or inform readers. I mean look at the headline for this piece. I bet 90% of your are only reading these words because of the title of this. But the margins for error are slimmer than ever before, just ask anyone that has ever for the infamous Ziff Davis.
Just like the developers, if you dont make money, youll end up selling editorials on street corners to feed the family and pay the mortgage.
Contrary to popular opinion, the relationship between the press and the publishers is not all hunky dory either. If coverage drops off message the emails and phone calls could stop completely. PR companies will lie about what parts of games will be fixed for release, or if a person will be available for interview at an event. Some complain when a comment on a rumour is not sought, but then stall for ages to give one. On the flip side, Ive known reviewers to review games that they downloaded from not entirely legit sources online so their words can hit the net first. And, of course, theres no shortage of writers willing to view everything a publisher does in the worst possible light, making out-of-context remarks into headlines or run with scintillating scuttlebutt, no matter how flimsy or far removed from reality it actually is.
So what we have is the three pillars of the video game industry who are suspicious of each other in equal spades. No one pillar can extend the other any respect or patience. Because of it we will fall to pieces; creatively at least. Publishers will only push out the same title with a different subtitle every year because that is all that sells. Journalists will feed the world sensationalism because people will read nothing else. Gamers will end up buying those repeated games so they be engaged the hateful conversation online.
In the current state of the business, with recession hitting, technology speeding forward and the internet being a consummate pain the in backside there is no easy fix.
Thankfully, I still have some suggestions for a fix...
The Fix
There are three real options really to stop this hatred tearing apart video games as we know them. The first is to wait until the industrys financial fortunes improve, alleviating the pressures on the press and the makers of video games and, hopefully, giving people the afforded luxury of breathing room. Although, given the number of AAA-naysayers, lets assume this improvement is not imminent. Second, is the option that Chris Heck gives in the above video.
Players: Request and purchase true variety. True variety is not a turret mission in an FPS. You are the body of the industry, and you need to feed your body a variety of healthy foods. Press: Provide sorely needed context, and hold Players and Developers accountable for this appetite for sameness. You are the conscience of the industry. Developers: The statement, We make the games we want to play may be true and great, but then can you please want to play a wider variety of games so youll make them in turn? Or third, and my preferred option, give each other little space. A little empathy. A little benefit of doubt. You cant say who should extend that courtesy first and you cant fault those who wait on making that move, but it needs to happen to stop the art form I love from folding in on itself.