5 Truly Insane Video Game Theories (That Are Clearly True)

Turning Far Cry 3 on its head.

Far Cry 3 Vaas
Ubisoft

Video games owe a lot to their stories.

Often the most overlooked part of the experience, a cinematic story is sometimes skipped to get down to the action, and a more emergent narrative can be overlooked entirely. And while some games can go to great lengths to explain or further mystify their worlds and stories, they will always leave room for players' imaginations to go wild. Be it finding plausible ways to fill in major plot holes or working out the exact origins of something as minor as a health-pickup, the internet has been throwing around theories about their favourite games for as long as the medium has existed.

Some theories feel ridiculous enough to be worth nothing more than a chuckle, and some are so slight and meticulous that you wonder why the author isn't working for a major intelligence agency.

But there is that are kind of gaming theory; the kind that seems to make just so much sense that the developers must have had the exact same idea in mind...

5. Portal 2 - Chell Is Cave And Caroline's Daughter

Portal 2 Chell
Valve

Portal 1 & 2 are generally regarded as two of the greatest video games ever made. Quite the feat for what started off as a miniscule production designed by less than 20 people. A large amount of Portal’s appeal and fan following however, stems not from it’s signature portal based gameplay, but from its host of unique and colourful characters.

It’s surprising then, that Portal’s least fleshed out character is its protagonist, Chell. Portal’s mysteriously mute hero, she has been given hardly any concrete backstory in the world of Portal. At least, not officially. Enter this theory, one supposing that Chell is none other than the Daughter of Aperture Science founder Cave Johnson and Caroline, more famously known as the basis for GLaDOS’ AI.

With evidence including Chell’s name being found on an Aperture ‘bring your kid to work day’ science project, GLaDOS’ strangely maternal instincts towards Chell, and Cave and Caroline’s sketchy-but-believably intimate relationship.

One theory of many to be found in the Portal series, and perhaps the one with the most evidence in favour of it’s believability, it would go far in fleshing out Portal’s unfortunately least interesting character.


4. Super Smash Bros. - All The Characters Are Toys

smash bros master hand
Nintendo

While Super Smash Bros has been enjoyed by millions, becoming an iconic fighting game franchise, nobody has ever thought to question exactly why these characters can all interact.

Until this theory rolled along, that is.

The reason being, as theorised and speculated by fans, is that the various characters forming the roster of SSB are actually a collection of toys owned by an imaginative child. A theory supported by the fact that the series’ main antagonist (and apparent an architect) is the aptly named ‘Master Hand’, and that all instalments to date have included collections of the game’s fighters in plastic toy form.

Far from unbelievable, this is one cute little theory that adds some unnecessary-but-appreciated context to the game, and makes Snake throwing an honest-to-god hand grenade at Luigi feel that bit less ridiculous.


3. Bloodborne - You're Drinking Menstrual Blood

Bloodborne menstrual blood fan theory
FromSoftware

One of Bloodborne's most commonly encountered blood-stuffs are the health-restoring ‘Blood Vials’. Down on HP? Just chug an entire bottle of blood (Yum!).

However, fans have put together a compelling argument that the blood in those vials… is actually menstrual blood. This theory, far from just being a crude joke, is supported by far too much evidence to simply be a coincidence.

For example:

Special Blood Vials in the game are all given by females, the two that do not are old and pregnant, respectively. Additionally, the healing church refers to the women they home as ‘vessels of blood’, and the game constantly references and alludes to ‘cycles’ and ‘the moon’. The list of bloody strange coincidences goes on.

A tad more nauseating than most, Bloodborne's menstruation theory is a prime example of how snooping into a game's mythology can sometimes lead to findings you’d rather not know at all.


2. Max Payne 3 - Anders Is A Product Of Max's Mind

Max payne 3 ghost anders detling easter egg
Rockstar

One of the most criminally underrated games of the last generation, Max Payne 3 was a tragic story of addiction, downward spirals and second chances. All fun and games, of course.

Amid all the doom and gloom, however, MP3 does have its fair share of comedy spruced throughout, and a recurring comic relief is found in Anders Detling. An easily-missed character appearing in three levels of MP3, Anders is an ever-jovial ex-cop and Father who has moved to Brazil to help the children of the favela.

But in the most heart-rending theory on this list, Anders isn’t just a comic relief cameo, but a supposed invention of Max’s mind; a reflection of the man he could have become if his Wife and Daughter weren’t murdered so many years ago.

Max is a lot of things, but a stable mind isn’t one of them. Add to this his excessive alcohol and painkiller consumption, and it isn’t at all a stretch to believe that Max, in his darkest adventure thus far, was willing to take a peek behind the curtain of tragedy and into a happier, kinder world.


1. Far Cry 3 - Hoyt Always Knew 'Foster' Was Jason

Far Cry 3 Jason Brody
Ubisoft

Far Cry 3 is a game rife with plot-related gaps in its timeline, and consequentially, questions of what exactly was fact, and what was fiction. As such, the game has spawned a host of theories and ideas regarding the more sketchy parts of FC3’s story.

A notable one of which revolves around primary antagonist Hoyt Volker being able to see through Jason’s disguise as the privateer ‘Foster’ during the game’s climax. After one of the most tense poker games in gaming history, Hoyt reveals he has known ‘Foster’ was the infamous escaped prisoner Jason Brody this entire time. It was certainly a shocking moment, but the question remains; ‘How could Hoyt possibly know Jason’s identity?’ Was it a slip of Jason’s poker face? Were Hoyt and the real Foster close? Is Hoyt a telepath!? Well, No. The real answer is far simpler.

If you recall the opening of FC3, you’d remember an off-screen voice telling the (criminally underused) secondary villain Vaas to stop harassing the hostages, Jason and Grant. That voice was none other than Hoyt Volker, who had therefore personally supervised Jason’s imprisonment from the very start of the game.


In this post: 
Far Cry 3
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Writer, film fan, lover of Spider-Man, defender of Max Payne 3 and STILL not quite over Steve Irwin. See me try to be funny on twitter @NokesyPokesy