6 Amazing Video Games Almost Destroyed By Terrible Mechanics

Almost perfect. ALMOST.

Arkham Knight Batmobile
DC

Video games are a complicated business. Any given game has had tens-of-thousands of man hours put into its creation. From the concept to the box art, there’s a lot which needs to come together to create a masterpiece. That also means that there is a lot that can go wrong. And, like a stray nostril hair in a bowl of ice cream, it only takes one, small unpalatable aspect within something to turn you off the whole experience.

Some games fall into this trap, an otherwise excellent experience can be brought to a screeching halt while you are forced to piddle through some terribly designed or obnoxiously long section. Worse still, otherwise excellently executed games can fall short at the first hurdle and burden you with irritating controls that make what should be a pleasure an irredeemable chore.

In short, one terrible gameplay mechanic can cripple an amazing game and tear it down from the lofty status it probably deserved into mediocrity. With that in mind, let’s join hands together and explore the murky waters of games who had everything in the bag, and threw it a way with one, stupid, pointless, failed gameplay mechanic.

6. Castlevania Dawn Of Sorrow - Magic Seals

Castlevania Dawn of Sorrow
Nintendo

Castlevania: Dawn of Sorrow was the first Castlevania game released on the DS. It was also released fairly early in the fledgling handheld consoles run, far back in the sepia-tinged past of 2005. This meant it was the first Metroidvania game a lot of gamers ever got to play, but it also meant it was burdened with the responsibility to incorporate the DS touch screen mechanic gimmick in any way possible. In Dawn of Sorrow, this takes shape in the ‘Magic Seals’ gameplay mechanic.

The feature works thusly: upon defeating a boss, a symbol will briefly appear on screen. This is the ‘Magic Seal’. You are then required to draw that symbol from memory in order to seal the boss away. If you fail to draw it correctly, or even just draw it correctly but start from the wrong point on the screen, you fail to seal the boss. It then regenerates a load of heath and the fight continues. Better luck next time, I guess.

It’s a terrible idea because the task has nothing to do with your combat skill or anything going in within the fight at hand, and punishes you harshly for failure. It also completely interrupts the flow of the narrative and boss-fight induced tension for a few moments while you do the drawing mini-game. It’s a blatant, hashed out addition designed only to utilise the DS touchscreen hardware that the game really had no need for. All in all, an unfortunate and unnecessary addition to an otherwise excellent installment in Castlevania franchise.


5. Arkham Knight - The Batmobile

Rocksteady Batmobile Arkham Knight
Rocksteady

Arkham Knight is not a bad game. In fact, it’s great game. The combat is better than ever, it’s a visual delight and that ‘In From The Cold DLC’ is as solid as any moment in Arkham City. However, it falls short when compared with the first two entries in the Arkham franchise, partly for a weaker primary villain in Scarecrow, but mainly for the much maligned Batmobile sections.

As anyone who’s ever been trapped on a rollercoaster for eight non-stop hours will tell you, too much of a good thing is a bad thing. The Batmobile was pushed across all the game’s advertising, and when the game rolled around, sure enough, we were stuck in the biggest, blackest, middle-aged crisis inspired, bat-penis compensator far for longer than was fun. At first it wasn’t so bad, but the endless flow of basically the same mission, wiping out waves of drones, got tedious long before the game was done throwing them at you.

This is a case of the production team radically overestimating how much fun the Batmobile gameplay would be. The Jokermobile section towards the end was a cool little moment, but in hindsight, Arkham Knight's marred reputation almost exclusively comes down to the compulsory Batmobile sections.


4. Metroid Prime 2: Echoes - The Luck Based Boss Fight

Boost Guardian Metroid Prime 2
Nintendo

Who doesn’t love a healthy dose of RNG? Anybody?

Sure, I’m down for the odd random encounter in a game, or randomised drops, or whatever, but when it comes to boss fights? No. Boss fights should be a test of skill, not luck. Luck based bosses are so infuriating because if the RNG God is not on your side, you lose. It’s not your fault, there’s nothing you could have done to prevent it, but f*ck you anyway.

Enter: The Boost Guardian from Metroid Prime 2: Echoes. The creature has an infuriating attack where it curls up and boosts around the tiny arena like sonic the hedgehog in a pinball machine. It’s completely impossible to predict where it will redirect to next, meaning you just have to spam jump and hope it doesn’t crash into you. To make matters worse, you’re constantly taking damage from being in the Dark World, and only way to regain health is if you’re lucky enough for the boss to smash through one of the pillars around the room, which drop health refills.

To summarise, you not only have to get lucky by not being hit by the completely random, hyper speed attack, but you also have to hope that the same attack destroys one of the pillars or you’ll die to the Dark World anyway. The luck factor makes it the bane of every Prime 2 speedrun and casual playthrough alike.


3. Skyward Sword - Pointless Motion Controls

legend of zelda Skyward sword
Nintendo

Once more, the Nintendo hardware curse strikes an unwitting game down to the dust. When it came to Skyward Sword, the highly anticipated Zelda game that followed Twilight Princess, Nintendo was drunk on the success of the Wii. I had one, you had one, your granny had one, and we’d all learned long before Nintendo did that the motion control gimmick wasn’t really going anywhere.

But, hyped up on their own juicy, arm-flailing technology, Nintendo went with an ambitious motion control combat system for Zelda: Skyward Sword. Here’s how it works: 1) Try and follow the game’s instructions to control Link with precise motions. 2) Fail at doing that. 3) Manically wave your arms around like a 19-year old white girl at her first rave. 4) Repeat for every fight over the next twenty hours.

Nowadays, Skyward Sword is remembered as ‘that motion controlled one’, rather than for its stunning graphics, brilliant dungeon design (some of the best in the series in fact), and rich, franchise building lore. It’s a brilliant game, but that just doesn’t matter when doing literally anything is a tedious endeavour in of itself.


2. Until Dawn - Quick Time Events

Until Dawn Jumpscare
Supermassive Games

Much like any tool of man, quick time events are not inherently good or evil, but when used with malicious intent can cause untold pain and devastation to all who encounter them. Until Dawn is a great concept, with the ‘hours until dawn’, episodic structure and character driven narrative crafting an engaging gameplay experience. However, it fumbles the ball when it comes to the ubiquitous quick time events.

An often maligned video game mechanic, the quick time event requires a specific button press shortly after the appearance of an on screen prompt. They almost always suck, with a notable exception being the eye-popping introduction to God of War 3, but they rarely suck worse than in Until Dawn.

Not only is a huge amount of gameplay dependant on you’re QTE success (in fact, an experiment by Kotaku put the game’s length at only 5 hours if you fail every one), but they are used so regularly that they begin to lessen the impact of the action on screen.

The result is, rather than paying attention, you’re sitting there awaiting the inevitable QTE to be sure you don’t accidently smoke a character by missing it. It takes you out of the game world, rather than propelling you into it, and in a game as reliant on creating a connection between you and the characters as Until Dawn, that’s a pretty big problem.


1. The Witcher 3 - Weapon Degredation

The witcher 3 geralt
CD Projekt

Realism in games is a funny old thing. If gamers wanted real life they’d leave their mum’s basement, clean the crust of dorito shards and mountain dew from their bodies and venture, pasty and blinking, into the harsh sunlight of the real world.

However, too little realism and we’re left with no way to dive into a believable, immersive world. Drawing the line is difficult, but all things considered, The Witcher 3 did a fantastic job.

With than in mind however, one area that strays just a bit too close to irritatingly real rather than fun is the weapon degradation system. It does nothing other than provide an infuriating halt to the flow of the narrative and gameplay to have to take a time out from what you want to be doing to head to a town and stump up an insane amount of cash to have your weapons and armour repaired.

Weapon degradation is obnoxious in any game, and even the otherwise excellent Zelda: Breath of the Wild fell into the same trap. It’s a mechanic that blights two of the best video games in the history of the medium, and pretty much every other game it touches.


Contributor

Writer, editor and presenter for WhatCulture, also a resident musician at NU. I know I'm not as funny as I think I am, please stop pointing it out...