7 Video Games You Traded In After Playing Once

Broken, boring or one dimensional - even great games get traded in.

The cost of a new video-game is pretty tough to justify at times. At the good end of the scale, you have games that have enough replay value to last a lifetime (I must have played Dragon Age: Origins and its respective DLC at least 10 times in full by now) or which may have a great multiplayer that extends the shelf life almost indefinitely (see Call Of Duty, Battlefield and so on...) However the problem there are also some games that are only ever destined for one attempt, and sometimes even less than a full go. Whether it is through a lack of content, lazy design or frustrating mechanics some games are destined to be returned after a few short and frustrating hours. It doesn't help that games are marketed with so much bluster that it's impossible to tell ahead of release whether they're actually any good (and that's not to mention the impact of manipulated reviews) and with our continuously tightening wallets this is becoming a major problem. With trade-ins becoming the most prominent solution to this risk/reward system, I think it's time to take a look-back at previous games that have only lasted the one sitting before you gave up and attempted to get at least some of your money back.

Honourable Mention: Dark Souls

If you've followed video-game journalism in the slightest in the past 3 years you don't need me to tell you that this game is hard. In honesty, it's rip out your hair hard, and it rewards patience and observation in a world where the go to game is usually a hyper-speed modern military shooter. Which is admirable, but therein lies the problem. I've only managed to defeat the second boss since I bought the game at launch (way back in November 2o11. Other people I know spent the full £40 on release only to trade it in the next day after discovering the very steep difficulty curve was far too much, and that they were probably better suited to something less complex. Regardless of that trend, Dark Souls doesn't deserve to be on the main list, because it's a hugely rewarding game, and the satisfaction you get from beating a difficult section is hard to beat, even if it is all too rare. "Prepare To Die" indeed.

7. Peter Jackson's King Kong: The Official Game Of The Movie

I like Peter Jackson's movie, and I like the game that it spun off. The ability to sneak my way through tropical jungles, avoiding any dinosaur that wants to make me his next meal, only to fill them full of 1930s lead when I mess it all up is invigorating. And then in complete contrast you get to play as the mighty King Kong, destroying native villages before wrestling dinosaurs in an attempt to save Anne before eventually confronting the military in New York. The spectacle is something to behold, and it's wonderfully cathartic. So why is it here on the list you may ask? Well, King King is a game that exists solely for achievement hunters (I could have just filled this list with movie tie-ins to be fair). It's easy enough to complete in one sitting (8 hours, if not less) and every achievement is unlocked through natural progression of the campaign. There just isn't any skill required to get there, and while that is fun for the duration but it won't light a fire in your belly. I don't tend to replay games that I've reached the ever elusive 100% on €“ with the exception of games with very good multiplayer €“ as a rule because I'm gaining nothing of value. And after one play, you might as well launch it.

6. Dynasty Warriors

Some items on this list only concern individual games, but this is an example of a complete series proving to be meaningless after the initial play-through. For the uninitiated, the player takes control of a historical Chinese warrior/general from the Three Kingdoms era of China (in Samurai Warriors €“ also by the same company €“ it is the Warring States period) to gain control of China for his respective faction €“ Wei, Wu or Shu. In this case when I refer to playing once before trading in I mean the practice of completing each characters particular campaign to experience all of the content. Don't get me wrong, I've had some of the most fun with video-games playing Dynasty Warriors, and the sublime soundtrack combines traditional Chinese music with modern rock. Then there is a very impressive roster of characters (82 as of Dynasty Warriors 8) each with their own unique fighting styles and weapons, and finally is the simple vastness of it all. The battles feel big and dramatic while the actual time investment to complete the campaign is astounding. But once you complete the campaign, you just won't play it again, because the series doesn't have any particular replay value. So once the campaign is done, it might as well be traded just so it doesn't gather dust.

5. Gun

There exists an amazing open-world cowboy game filled with saloons, gambling, horse-riding and shootouts. Sadly for Activision, it's called Red Dead Redemption. Unfortunately for us, the game we're talking about here is Neversoft and Activision's Gun €“ the first non-Tony Hawk game the former company produced in 5 years. Which you can totally tell, thanks to the dated graphics (it was simultaneously a launch title for the Xbox 360 and a late release on the original Xbox), sticky controls and one of the most ridiculous final boss-fights in history (the hardest difficulty is nigh-on unplayable without your controller being covered in 4-leaf clovers). This game doesn't leave you wanting more. The Red Dead Redemption comparison is the most appropriate as everything Gun does, RDR does bigger and better, and the final problem with Gun is that without any multiplayer or additional content, it doesn't really need subsequent attempts.

4. Clive Barker's Jericho

By far the most repetitive game being discussed here, Clive Barker's Jericho is a gritty linear FPS centred on an occult black ops squad trying to stop God's first creation from destroying the world. Convoluted may just be the appropriate word for the plot €“ written by none other than Clive Barker. If you think you recognise that name I suggest you go watch a little film called Hellraiser. As such I suggest that if you really like Clive Barker then you owe it to yourself to definitely give this game one play, but beyond that quick trade-in is on the cards because the game isn't particularly groundbreaking. When I said "repetitive" I mean that every enemy encounter in the game is defending against subsequent waves of enemies interspersed with boss battles that add a single gimmick in order for you to damage them. Thank you Clive Barker for this experience, but now it needs to go.

3. Lego Marvel Super Heroes - And The Whole LEGO Series In General

When a games sole purpose is to be fun you know you're onto a good thing. Despite the age rating being 7+ for the most part, the LEGO games are so enjoyable that you can play them at any age and still get something out of it. Inevitably the latest incarnation is Marvel Superheroes and even more inevitably it's a blast. Flying through New York as Spider-Woman or beating up thugs as Taskmaster are just two of dozens of things I never thought I'd get to do in a video-game but LEGO and Telltale Games made it a reality. The problem is that the novelty of these events wears thin incredibly quickly. The simple puzzles are often character specific or very repetitive (who isn't sick of fetch quests by now?) and getting anything like half of the collectibles requires so many replays of the same section that even the slightest whiff of ADHD will mean you don't make it past one play. If you have the time and the patience, the game (like all entries in the series) is very easy to 100%, and once you've reached this intangible goal, what else is there to do? Admittedly you do get your money's worth as the games are long, but the downside is that the trade-in price will be much lower than purchase, especially if you commit to the 100%.

2. Assassin's Creed

This, without a doubt is the most subjective entry on the list. I love the Assassin's Creed series: I love the settings; I love the game-play; I love the overarching pseudo-sci-fi plot. So my question here is why doesn't it love me back? The problem with the series is that once you've completed the main story there isn't really anything left to do except gather the leftover collectibles, and this practice of artificially padding out a game annoys me. Admittedly, later instalments in the franchise have helped themselves with the actually innovative multiplayer and procedurally generated content, but it isn't just my cup of tea. Patience is a virtue I lack as a gamer, and maybe that's why I can't get on board with the multiplayer but it just isn't my thing. After one go I become quite disenfranchised with the experience, and so far I've traded in every entry after I've completed the campaign. At least the convenience is that because you can grind through the game in a weekend, the trade-in value will be closer to the original price.

1. Duke Nukem Forever

Buying this on release day is one of my biggest regrets*. Fuelled by nostalgia I was prepared to invest a sizeable amount of my time and effort in an experience 15 years in the making. And an experience it was. A shoddy one. Critically panned by everyone, the game dropped in price to pennies within days. It had multiplayer but after the abysmal single-player campaign I just couldn't be bothered wasting more time on it. And neither should anyone else. The developers even cared enough to design some additional content €“ including an additional single-player campaign Getting a few pennies back on it is completely worth it, if only for the cathartic release of sending the Duke back where he came from. *At least it led me to not purchase Aliens: Colonial Marines on release. Instead I picked up the limited edition for £3 the other day - and brand new I might add. I think to justify criticism you need to have experienced it yourself so as to have a fair opinion, which is probably the only reason Aliens isn't on this list.

Contributor
Contributor

I’ve been a film fan for as long as I can remember, with one of my earliest memories watching my dad’s copy of Star Wars one rainy afternoon in the mid-nineties. Then the 21st century happened, and my interests developed from there – mainly including comics and video-games, and recently an introduction into WWE. It’s a good time for popular culture. Follow me on Twitter: @TW0_ST3P or on Facebook: facebook.com/Tw0st3p