8 "Awesome" Video Game Mechanics We All HATED

Brilliant On Paper. Terrible In Practice.

death stranding bb
Kojima Productions

In order to stand out in the crowded sea of video games that are released on a nearly continual basis, developers often have to think outside the box when it comes to making their game catch you and by extension the attention of your wallet.

Therefore questions about said box quickly turn into, "well what if the box was only opened with motion controls?" "what if the box WAS motion controls?" "What if the box was actually a pre-order bonus that players unlocked with motion controls?"

And just like that, we've lost the point we were trying to make in the first place as do a tonne of video game mechanics that tried to be different but all ended up being seen with the same ire.

It's easy to make a great idea on paper that fails to materialize into greatness for the player, and even those that sound utterly "awesome" can lead to moments of frustration and backlash from the fanbase which is what we're talking about today.

8. The Persuasion Mini-Game - The Elder Scrolls IV: Oblivion

Elder Scrolls Oblivion Persuasion
Bethesda Softworks

If there's one thing I'm an absolute sucker for in video games, it's systems and mechanics that focus on talking your way out of problems as much as I end up finding myself talking my way into them.

Any game with a charm or charisma stat that has real influence on the gameplay will usually mean I lean heavily into that through my play sessions, wringing extra loot out of NPCs, sidelining boring quests with a turn of phrase, and even getting bosses to back the hell down when they see my razor-sharp wit.

And yet when it came to Oblivion, an otherwise absolute masterclass of a game, Bethesda managed to bungle their persuasion mini-game in such a way that it's still perfectly functional and oftentimes useful but is just so uncannily horrible to use over and over.

The idea behind the mechanic is sound, use a rotating wheel with different values in order to charm whoever it is you're speaking to, but the implementation and accompanying "panopticon of pain" seems to be the animator's attempt at conveying base emotions of pleasure and hatred, all make for an utterly ridiculous experience.

You're basically chatting absolute !*$% to them while hoping that your Trivial Pie-alogue of Persuasion matches up to what they like. There's no skill, there's no finesse, it's basically the same as the lockpicking mini-game but the lock is someone's face and it's not always happy with you pocking a metal rod up its nose.


7. The Majority Of The Batmobile Sections - Batman: Arkham Knight

Batman Arkham Knight Batmobile Drone Tanks
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Throughout Rocksteady's tenure with the Arkham series of video games, fans the world over threw adulation and praise at the devs for their attention to detail, amazing world-building, and of course the impeccable blend of hard-hitting action and supremely enjoyable stealth sections.

However there was always one aspect that the player base felt was almost being ignored by the creative team, that being the ability to pilot the sleek and deadly Batmobile on the streets of Gotham.

And then it happened.

Previews for Arkham Knight pushed the Batmobile heavily as being one of the key reasons to own this game, with a huge focus on vehicular combat as well as puzzle solving. It all sounded too good to be true, and unfortunately for many, that turned out to be the case when the game finally dropped, as these sections quickly became a drain on the experience.

Don't get me wrong, the mechanics of the Batmobile itself were wonderful and the heavy bottomed slide of the car felt wonderful to wrestle against, yet the Batmobile was used way too many times across the game to the point where it became a bit of an eye-roll when yet again Batman announced that he'd need his car for this specific mission.

Nearly every aspect of the game features the Batmobile in some capacity, with even the Riddler creating a whole slew of races to challenge players with, and as such it was a case of having way too much of a good thing thus souring many on the mechanic as a whole.


6. The Force Wall - Wipeout 3

Wipeout 3
Sony

Thanks to the likes of red shells, homing rockets, and even SWARMS OF BEES (Thanks Sonic), when it comes to racing games, there are many, many ways to claim pole position while causing other racers to curse your name as they drown in sticky honey, but when it came to the otherwise fantastic Wipeout 3, the devs dropped the ball hard when it came to its powerups, as here more often than not you'd be the one having the brakes put on.

I say this because, for some reason, the creative team decided that should you hit another racer with a powerup or weapon enough to damage it, instead of dropping onto the track and creating an obstacle for you, the racer would be temporarily flipped over to allow you to pass underneath. Sounds great on paper right? Well, the issue was that this mechanic had a ridiculously short window of opportunity, meaning that you'd most likely be halfway underneath before having the racer in question drop back on top of you!

This of course impacted your own racing skills somewhat because last time I checked it's much harder to make a three-point turn when you've got your rival flipping you off in front of your own windscreen. Worse still some of the powerups themselves were actively dangerous to use, with the Force Wall dropping a barrier ahead of you but causing all other racers who crashed into it to bounce backward, likely into you!

"Haha! Take that!" you would have yelled, before....you know...taking exactly the same punishment. Cheers.


5. Using R.O.B To "Help" You - Gyromite

Rob The Robot Gyromite
Nintendo

The NES era of video games was truly what the MCU would have deemed "the maddest timeline".

You had an explosion of video game content that washed the sour taste of Atari's ruinous taint, and because Nintendo was leading the charge it also came with a wave of weird and wonderful peripherals.

Including the one and only R.O.B or "Robotic Operating Buddy" who may well have been Nintendo's most insane product ever...well until the Virtual Boy....and the Nintendo Labo....and....just look it was pretty mad ok because it was a bloody robot who would help you play games.

Now you tell me that this isn't one of the best sounding mechanics for your video game hobby ever. An actual robot assistant.

And yet, as anyone who's ever had the pleasure of R.O.B's "help" will be able to tell you, this product and the games he was attached to were utterly abysmal.

Gyromite best exemplifies the problems here, as in this title you were a professor trying to move through levels to collect dynamite that would explode if you ran out of time. Blocking your way were color-coded pillars that R.O.B could help you shift by pushing the corresponding buttons. However, the act of getting him to move at all was a chore, making you pause the game to go into a pseudo-select screen to tell R.O.B what to do.

And then you'd wait upwards of a minute per action for him to press one button.

One button. In a minute. In a game with a time limit. Do I need to expand more on why this was actual hell? Thought not.


4. Unlocking Cars Based On Rankings - R4: Ridge Racer Type 4

R4 Ridge Racer
Namco

Now here's an idea that seemed absolutely perfect when chatting about it in the planning stages but became as confusing to wrap your head around as the title of the game it was attached to.

R4: Ridge Racer Type 4... does that mean that the game is actually called Ridge Racer Type 4: Ridge Racer Type 4?

In "R to the power 4" you'd unlock cars for your collection based on the position in which you finished the tournament, meaning that if you placed first across all the races you'd get a first-place-esque prize of the fastest car and the most cash. All sounds grand, right? Well, what if I were to tell you that sometimes better and more desirable cars were actually rewarded for coming in second or third? That means that you're going to need to race the events again but this time purposely throw the races in order to land where you need to on the scoreboard.

Match-fixing. As a mechanic in a video game. I've officially seen it all.

Plus you have to feel sorry for those questing for 100% as they'd have to do this multiple times on each even to complete their collection and unlock the final car of the game!


3. Calming BB - Death Stranding

death stranding bb
Kojima Productions

To say that Death Stranding is a game full of half-baked ideas is like saying that I expect to be a little bit chilly when these energy price hikes kick in in winter, aka a bit of an understatement.

In fact, trying to look at Death Strandings' list of unique and odd mechanics is like trying to read Homer's Odyssey but all you've got to go on is paraphrases and key quotes written over an old groceries list for how weird some of them seem. "holding buttons to balance?" "multiplayer in the form of bridge building?" "Weaponising your own piss thanks to Monster energy drink?" "Avocados?"

That last one is just was just surprising to me as I thought we had some in the fridge.

I digress, which is actually what Death Stranding does a lot, introducing new mechanics on the fly that often lead absolutely nowhere near essential storyline missions, but one that unfortunately was tied directly into the experience was the monitoring of BB your little Bridge Baby, or as it's known amongst many gamers "Baby Mario Version 2"

On paper, the idea of calming down a frightened child once you've taken a serious spill or encountered a horrific enemy should only serve to heighten the tension of the moment. You've just lost your packages, your baby is crying it's all gone wrong.

Except.

You've just lost all your packages, your baby is crying, it's all gone wrong. What about that is actually fun to go through? None of it. And unsurprisingly it wasn't fun to have to use the motion controls to calm BB down for the fiftieth time by which point the quirky method had officially outstayed its welcome.


2. Don't Forget To Take Your Joy! - We Happy Few

We Happy Few
Compulsion Games

I don't think I've ever been as disspointed with a video game than with the version of We Happy Few that hit storefronts back in 2016, as before it got all its tweaks, fixes, and admittedly brilliant DLC expansions, this was a game that promised so much and yet delivered so little.

Its concept was a stone-cold killer, of a society held in a perpetual state of drug-addled repression and backed up with brutality. It told of a town divided by those who took their Joy Pills to forget and "downers" those who rejected the fantasy to live out in the wastes. As such a lot of expectations were built up around the process of taking Joy in order to fit in with the other pill junkies and how these mechanics would affect gameplay.

Would you be caught short at a desperate moment and be chased out of town? Would you have to scavenge for them in order to stave off a beatdown? Well, the answer on paper was a definite "yes" but in practice was a resounding "no". For you see while Joy dosage was important to get through certain gates and bypass Doctors, that was the exent of it's implementation, and the sheer abundancy of the pill meant it was never hard to acquire.

What was once an amazing piece of world-building just became a chore with all of the tension of the situation dissipating almost entirely. Hell, you could complete the game without taking Joy once outside of the story beats, that's how little it was used.


1. The Renbu System - Dynasty Warriors 6

Dynasty Warriors 6
Koei Tecmo

So imagine you're in the headquarters of Koei Tecmo and all of a sudden one of the devs of the Dynasty Warriors franchise bursts through the door. They're all sweaty and panting nervously, a look of sheer unadulterated excitement in their eyes and as they shakily stagger towards you they whisper feverishly in your ear.

"but what if we did infinite combos?"

Now that might not mean much to an outsider but to a DW fan or as we call ourselves Muso-mmeliers (for we drink the Muso like fine wine) this concept is enough to make my Dong Zhou turn into Dong Woah. Infinite combos in a game about pushing beatdowns like a drug dealer is pretty much the actual dream, so many, myself included were hyped to the Xtreme Legends when the "Renbu System" was announced for Dynasty Warriors 6.

However, this soon became possibly the most hated mechanic in the entire series thanks to its implementation, which saw nearly every character share a base moveset that had to hit a certain hit chain to unlock new and more exciting moves. This, when coupled with the fact that enemies only appeared in small clumps often meant that you'd be using basic strikes for far longer than our patience would tolerate, thus turning what were once warriors of legend into Sunday Leage dads after a few pints of go-go juice aka a burpy mess of piss weak punches.


Watch Next


Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.