8 Best Video Game Endings You Can't Get On A First Playthrough
Time to put in the work.
As the credits begin to roll and a symphonic score swells into existence, it's hard not to feel a little emotional at the end of a video game.
With the final boss defeated, the land once more at peace, and our journey finally over, we can finally rest easy knowing that our countless hours of hard work have paid off.
However, what's this? The game isn't over?
What do you mean there are still more endings to see and that they're significantly more upbeat than the ones we witnessed? Ah well, time to strap on the armour once more and get to questing!
It's actually pretty common for video games to hide 100% completion endings, alternate closing scenarios and even story chapters as DLC, but those that make it onto this list make you work so damn hard, there was no way you were going to see the best ending in a single playthrough.
8. Save The Entire Crew - Mass Effect 2
Is there anything more pulse racing, outside of betting on Octopus Knife Fights, than the moment that you commit to traveling through the relays into the Collector and Reaper HQ in Mass Effect 2?
The game warns you again and again throughout your long run that this is going to be a moment that will change everything, and that the tagline of being a suicide mission is not going to be taken lightly.
Bioware delivered fully in this area as well, annihilating crew members if the player hadn't maxed out their loyalty or completed certain quests, and it was very possible for everyone including yourself to be reduced to mere atoms.
Therefore it was pretty likely that players opted to go the safer route of taking their time to max out bonds and explore the galaxy, yet this too was a devious trap by the devs! If the player takes too long then other members of the crew who had been captured would already have gone through the painful conversion process into thralls for The Reapers.
Move too quickly, you die. Move too slowly. you die. Even if you made it through to landing you could make the wrong squad choices and see friends meet their untimely end! It's like The Dark Room was hosting this mission in that every single choice ended in death!
You'd have to have been a speedrunner completionist combo to get the 100% survival ending with this!
7. The Real Ending - Asura's Wrath
Now this one is cheating a little bit, but at the same time, I think the same can be said of Capcom for having the gall to pull this ridiculous stunt in the first place.
For those who have never played the outstanding expression of anger that is Asura's Wrath, the title is basically what would happen if you stuffed every anime villain alongside Mastadon's seminal Blood Mountain record into a blender and hit Frappé. There's a lot of screaming, intense power and a whole lot of headbanging in the form of you bouncing your foes off of the bloody moon and back.
Still, it was players who felt like they were headbutting a brick wall when Capcom announced that despite what the game itself was telling you, the "real ending" was actually going to be released as a DLC chapter. That's right they partitioned off the actual true ending of the game and charged you money for it.
Therefore it's quite possible that nobody playing the game at the time of launch achieved the best ending the first time around as it's likely they played it at a time before the bastard thing was even in the game!
Cheers mate. Get the impression that Capcom is the type of guy who always nips to the loo when it's his round.
6. High Honor Ending - Red Dead Redemption 2
Red Dead Redemption may indeed be something of a modern-day masterpiece when it comes to it's immersive gameplay, rich character development, and of course its attention to detail, but one thing that fans were a little chaffed from seemed to come from how the title handled it's ending.
Or should that be endings, because depending on your Honor rating come the close of the game, you might not even get access to the best ending despite making the more honorable choice. To better explain in the final mission you come to a fork in the road in which Arthur can choose to either take the money and run or help John Marston out, and by choosing the latter you'd think you'd earn the best ending right?
After all, you've forgone wealth in the pursuit of helping a man who pretty much just exists to rub you up the wrong way. However, if your Honor meter is low, an ensuing firefight will see Arthur bite the bullet quite literally as he's shot in the head!
Turns out that by having high honor you'd see the tense situation diffuse with Arthur finally left alone to die in peace, watching one final sunrise as he passes on. It's still a bleak ending, but it's a fitting one, capping off his story as he breaks a cycle of violence he was embedded in from the very start.
Still you'd have to have been a right saint of the West in order to have this ranking, and precognition to know it'd ever effect the story this greatly. Better get chopping that wood for camp friends!
5. SOL System Overload - Breath Of Fire: Dragon Quarter
Ok so. I'm not going to lie to you, researching the methods to unlock all of the hidden scenes and extra content in Breath Of Fire: Dragon Quarter might have been the most confusing thing I've ever had to do across my tenure at this company, as even now as I sit here typing this, I'm not entirely sure what the hell the devs were thinking with this SOL Mechanic.
On paper the Scenario Overlay idea seems like a sound one, allowing the player to revisit certain areas and, if they have a certain ranking (known in the game as a D-Ranking) which the game determines through the level, speed of completion and about a million other tiny details, allows them to see extra content and alternate dialogue which fleshes out plot points.
The problem is however that the game doesn't make these rankings apparent and also that there's no way to get a high enough ranking in order to see all these extra moments the first time around. Hell, you'll need to be on your third playthrough at least in order to see the final ending moment which centres around Ryu's self-sacrifice to the Dragons power in order to save his friend, and trust me while it's a touching moment the sheer amount of effort to get here is quite frankly insane.
4. Promise Ending - Fatal Frame 2
There are very few things that you can say in life as being dead certainties, but I can with full confidence say that utterly nobody got the Promise Ending for Fatal Frame 2 on their first run through this rather exceptional horror title and can do so for two pretty big reasons.
The first is because the Promise Ending, which sees our protagonist pair of sisters able to both complete a ritual to save a village they are trapped in but also get out the other side alive and kicking is only unlocked by completing the game on Nightmare difficulty, something which you literally don't even have access to the first time around.
The second is because this is an ending that was only included on the XBOX releases of the game which game many months after the original Japanese horror titled had launched. The ending was apparently included because all of the other final scenarios were too bloody bleak, which is pretty much the franchises biggest gimmick, nearly always having the worst ending actually be the cannon one.
Still, for original Xbox users, the best and most upbeat ending in the game was there to grab, if they could make it through this substantial challenge.
3. Dragon's Homecoming Ending - Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice
I can't think of a video game ending more frustratingly obtuse than the Dragon's Homecoming ending from the otherwise spellbinding Sekiro: Shadows Die Twice, and while I did eventually knock off this ending through sheer trial and error, it was at the expense of multiple playthroughs and quite possibly a piece of my soul.
FromSoftware has never been shy about delivering nuggets of storytelling gold through esoteric means, often requiring the player to have the knowledge of precisely where to be and what to do before even being aware of those parameters in the first place. They are a company that seems to build games in such a way so that they can sell walkthrough guides but then forget to actually make the guide when all is said and done.
In order to get the Dragon's Homecoming Ending which sees the power of the Immortals returns to the Divine Realm and away from the temptations of humans, you basically need to learn how to both consume tonnes of and then strangely abstain from eating rice.
I'm deadly serious.
While there are many other steps required for this ending, many players fall foul of not using a Divine Child of mystical origin as a bloody rice vendor so much that she falls asleep, and again forcing our little lord Kuro to make sweet rice balls for us to eat. Yet don't you dare eat the rice that was meant for Kuro otherwise you'll be trudging through the entire game once more.
If you tell me you got this ending the first time around without any help, I'm not calling you a liar...but I totally am.
2. The True Ending - Cave Story
Cave Story is such a delightful title that it's little wonder that the game has endured so long and is so beloved by both critics and fans alike. However, one factor that its cutesy aesthetics didn't inform players of immediately was that it can be crushingly hard in places. Like to the extent that even the chest stepping fetishists of Resident Evil Village would say "ok that's enough cheers"
Still, one thing that the game literally informed players of was the game's super-secret and best ending! In a charmingly obtuse move, the physical release of the game on the Switch came bundled with an instruction manual containing a cryptic word puzzle. It turns out that this passage of text actually reveals the walkthrough required to net the games best ending, and as you can imagine when looking at the steps which require you to go against all in-game logic, giving items to people you wouldn't think of and moving other characters to certain areas, that barely anyone would have figured this out on their first playthrough.
Luckily having the guide makes this all the easier for people nowadays, but unluckily it also is bone-shatteringly difficult.
1. Ending E - NieR Replicant
God Bless you Yoko Taro, you are such a strange creature that I'm not even sure if you're human at this point and not just an alien who floated in from the skies above and focused very specifically on making utterly insane video games.
As you might expect from the mind behind the likes of Drakengard and the almighty Neir: Automata, when it came to the reimagining of Neir Replicant, Yoko Taro and his team weren't exactly going to just squirt out a simple high-res update and call it a day.
Far from it in fact as in this version of the game we are presented with a new ending, Ending E, which is, and I'm not kidding here, the most ball-breakingly tough thing to unlock but at the same time one you will almost desperately want to seek out. Confused? Perfect, then you're in the right frame of mind for this.
Each time you complete the game, you'll unlock a rather dour ending but also the option to carry on playing with a pseudo-New Game Plus mode. Working your way through again sees you fight new bosses, experience new story beats and allows you to collect all 30 different weapons in the game.
With all of your arsenal fully loaded and pretty much everything in the game ticked off, you'd be forgiven for thinking that the final boss for Ending D was going to be all she wrote, especially seeing as the game makes you delete all of your save data! However, this itself isn't even the final, true, I'm serious this time ending!
Go through once more and you'll finally be able to see the best ending, AND restore your previous saved content to boot. I tell you now, this is one hell of a ride.