8 Biggest Flaws In Red Dead Redemption 2

Game of the year? Probably, but was that HUGE epilogue really necessary?

Red Dead Redemption 2 Braithwaite Manor Burning
Rockstar

Although everybody knows Rockstar for being one of the biggest pioneers in the video game industry, there was a lot of apprehension surrounding whether Red Dead Redemption 2 could better its predecessor. Sceptics were critical of it being a prequel, while fans were gutted about having to play as a rugged blonde newcomer instead of their favourite scarred gunslinger.

However, not only did it surprise worried devotees by improving on its forerunner in every way, it also outclassed all the competition to become the immediate favourite contender for game of the year. Its story is one of the best the industry has ever seen, Arthur Morgan is an unforgettable protagonist who even eclipses John Marston, and the landscape is a magnificent achievement that has set the bar for the genre going forward.

While the long-anticipated epic is a bona-fide masterpiece though, there are still issues which stop the experience from being perfect. Although there’s never going to be a flawless work of creative genius, most of the issues in Red Dead Redemption 2 could have been avoided through abiding by a less-is-more philosophy, and fixing hinderances that have plagued Rockstar titles for more than a decade.

8. Bizarre Design Choices Make For An Inconsistent Experience

Red Dead Redemption 2 Compendium
Rockstar

The most echoed complaint about Red Dead Redemption 2 is its deliberately slow approach and obsession with realism. Critics have lambasted Rockstar for needlessly including too many animations, and for crafting a depressing life simulator that ignores the golden rule about video games needing to be fun.

However, the real issue isn’t with the developers being too extreme in their attempts to immerse you, it’s that there are a number of bizarre design choices which conflict with the game’s tone and approach. The biggest of which is that gunsmiths jeopardise their business by refusing to sell weapons you haven’t already picked up from deceased husbands whose faces you have spoiled with bullets.

It’s nonsensical that you can’t buy or rob any gun in the game at your leisure, and it also doesn’t make sense why being underweight rewards you with more stamina rather than less. No matter if you've stuffed your face with cookies or only feasted on your steed’s carrots, your stamina should always be low and quickly deplete.

In addition, the game’s log leaves a lot to be desired, and the ‘cinematic’ black bars are an irremovable intrusion that constantly break immersion by reminding you it’s all a video game.


7. The Wanted System Is Too Sensitive

Red Dead Redemption 2 Wanted System
Rockstar

Although having praised the wanted system for its immersive consequences when discussing what Red Dead Redemption 2 does better than every other open-world video game, it is is still plagued with problems. The biggest of which is that it can be more than a tad hyperactive and intrusive.

Now, it makes sense that a weasel would tattle on you to the law when having seen you rob a store or pettily murder someone because they didn’t acknowledge your ‘hello’. However, it’s more than a bit oversensitive when a bounty is put on you for having an accidental kerfuffle in the mud with some drunken fella who is equally to blame.

This results in plenty of instances where you’re trying to be good but your honour keeps depleting due to killing men shooting at you (who have worse aim than a stormtrooper). Murdering the law or bounty hunters in self-defence shouldn’t make you dishonourable, nor should gunning down an army of wild hicks chasing you for accidentally crushing one of their chickens with your steed.

Being pursued by the law for accidental ‘crimes’ was occasionally annoying in past games, but in Red Dead Redemption 2 the wanted system’s sensitivity can rob you of a satisfying experience by making you not honourable enough for later missions and the 'good' ending through no real fault of your own.


6. It's Too Easy To Make Money

Red Dead Redemption 2 Valentine Heist
Rockstar

Throughout the main story, Dutch Van Der Linde constantly wets your ear by yelling about just how much more money is needed to reach the paradise of Tahiti. The problem with this is that while the camp and its charismatic leader wallow in the self-pity of being paupers, you can be filthy rich and repeatedly put hundreds of dollars into the gang’s money box.

For a game so obsessed with realistic details intended to immerse you in its world, this feels like a huge oversight. Although suspension of disbelief is required for pretty much every narrative, it’s impossible to share the gang’s desperation when you have enough cash to go anywhere if Dutch would just ask.

Not only that, but there’s hardly anything to wisely spend your dough on besides cheap food and horse accessories. Being honourable gives you a huge discount on all in-game items, and you don’t need to purchase weapons as guns are unlocked by stealing them from homes and headless corpses.

To avoid having players stuck with a farcical amount of money that makes Dutch’s qualms about not having enough border on being a parody, merchants and fencers should have had a limited amount of cash when buying your unwanted goods. That and items should have been more expensive than two dollars.


5. A Lack Of Creativity With Missions

Red Dead Redemption 2
Rockstar

Aside from the early hours of the campaign and the odd time you're pestered to go fishing, most of the story’s missions play out identically. You and your companions ride while blabbering about the current climate, and then everything quickly goes to sh*t with you being forced to paint nature red with the blood of a hundred nameless minions.

While nearly every video game has a pattern each of its missions replicates, they are usually better at making it discreet. With Red Dead Redemption 2, the calm-before-the-storm routine is so obvious that it soon turns from comical to monotonous.

To avoid the repetition of players rolling their eyes as a simple stroll turns into another predictable war that Arthur miraculously always finds baffling, the main story needed more variety. That way each inevitable battle would have felt less like a forced convenience thanks to being a video game, and Arthur would have had less blood on his hands.

From stealthy knocking out goons to carrying out simple errands with your merry men, more variety would have made the game less predictable and confrontations truly feel unavoidable.


4. Key Missions Are Optional And Easy To Miss

1361104

There’s so many missions in Red Dead Redemption 2 that you have to complete, and then there are a dozen more that are entirely optional. While this mostly isn’t an issue, it does make you afraid of leaving camp and advancing the plot in case you missed any crucial dialogue or requests from your pals.

The biggest problem with certain missions being optional is that they are crucial to the story, yet appear to be hidden. Collecting debts for Strauss is easy enough, with them being marked on the map as huge dollar signs, but it’s left to chance whether you find the letter from Mary Linton sitting on your bedside table.

Players who aren’t attentive as others could easily fail to notice the letter, robbing them of one of the key components to making Arthur one of gaming’s most tragic protagonists. The same applies to the side quests with Charlotte the widow and Edith Downes, as Rockstar never tell you that high honour is required to experience two of the game's most unforgettable strangers.

Instead of being quests that you can easily miss by accident, the interactions with Mary and other characters crucial to Arthur’s redemption should have been mandatory. That way everyone would get an equally rich experience that isn’t dependent on extreme observation and the patience to finally pick up a letter up stuck between cigarettes and hair pomade.


3. There's No Incentive To Be Bad

Red Dead Redemption 2 Micah And Arthur
Rockstar

The honour system in Red Dead Redemption 2 is initially an interesting mechanic that constantly reminds you of its existence. Saying ‘howdy’ to folks and rescuing damsels makes you honourable, while robbing campers, punching lasses and shooting barbers, unsurprisingly, makes you a total b*stard.

However, other than it being fun to put a bullet through the skulls of cowboys who rudely tell you to sod off, there is no incentive to be a wicked man. You don’t need to rob trains or innocent folk as you’ll always have too much money from completing missions, and there are no in-game benefits for being a cretin like there are for being a boy scout.

In addition, the excellent story pushes you to be a good boy by offering more missions and compelling character arc. Meanwhile, if you choose to be a baddie worse than even Micah, you're punished with fewer levels and a barely altered tale of redemption that doesn’t fit your actions.

Rockstar could have avoided this by making it apparent in chapter 6 that a decision between good and bad needed to be made. That way the story and characters could have adapted to your choice, and unique missions could have been made available for each path chosen, giving you an incentive to be bad as well as to replay the campaign.


2. Clunky Combat That Lacks Challenge

Red Dead Redemption 2 Browning Gun
Rockstar Games

Similar to nearly every mission replicating the same structure, the clunky and mindless combat is responsible for making Red Dead Redemption 2 frequently repetitive and tiresome. It doesn’t matter if you’re a novice or a pro gamer who pretends to have bedded everybody’s mum, the act of gunning down hundreds of bandits is a ridiculously easy chore that could be done with your eyes stapled shut.

While the A.I. can be smart, with gang members flanking you and hicks showing off their idiocy by running at you with knives in a gun fight, the auto-aim ruins everything. Rather than wasting your time with the returning dead eye system, it’s much easier to simply snap in and out of cover as you automatically lock onto enemies and still receive satisfying killcams.

However, although the combat is mostly too easy, with Rockstar still refusing to provide difficulty options, there are occasions it frustrates due to heavy handling and clunky cover mechanics. Exiting cover is always a pain due to how much Arthur sticks to objects, and occasionally the game refuses to let you pull the trigger despite having a perfect shot with nothing in the way.

Combat has never been the strongest component of any Rockstar game not called Max Payne, yet it’s baffling that their releases continue to suffer from outdated gameplay that everybody was moaning about back in 2011 with L.A. Noire.

Warning: The next point features heavy spoilers so only read on if you have completed the epilogue!


1. John Marston

Red Dead Redemption 2 John Marston Sadie Adler
Rockstar Games

During the entirety of the 50-60-hour main story, you become attached to rapscallion Arthur Morgan as he undergoes one of the most powerful soul cleansings in video game history. Unfortunately this dramatic and emotional story is then usurped by an epilogue which ends on a pathetic whimper as the focus switches to John Marston in order to set up Red Dead Redemption.

Compared to Arthur, John is an uninteresting Neanderthal that additionally pales in comparison to campmates Sadie and Charles. As if that wasn’t bad enough, the majority of time spent with him is doing chores, being nagged at by the missus and carrying out forgettable bounties that are, ultimately, superfluous.

John Marston hogging the limelight at the end despite already having an entire game devoted to him makes Arthur feel less important as he's barely mentioned, and all his quirks are passed onto the scarred gunslinger you’re stuck with. The death of the game’s biggest scoundrel also fails to be satisfying thanks to the amount of time that has passed, and because it plays out like a pretentious effort to ‘poetically’ mirror Jack’s revenge with Edgar Ross.

For the majority that didn’t play Red Dead Redemption, the epilogue is a padded bore that ruins the emotional impact of the main story’s finale. It makes you no longer want to explore after the credits have rolled, and it doesn’t give newcomers any desire to experience what happened next.

Agree? Disagree? Sound off about all things Red Dead in the comments below!


Contributor

Callum Smith hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.