8 Controversial Video Games The Industry Was FORCED To Change

Does a fine of $50,000 make you more or less interested?

POSTAL 2
Running With Scissors

It's common knowledge that video games don't always come out the way they were first imagined. Whether it's minor storyline tweaks to suit a broader audience or a graphical overhaul with the latest technology, sometimes the worlds we're meant to see just aren't what we get.

There are some games out there, however, that are so downright dangerous, the industry had to pull rank and call when developers have gone too far. They decide for our own good that no one wants the experience on offer, no matter how enticing gameplay might sound or how beautiful visuals might be, avoiding controversy and burying the evidence deep underneath releases with far tamer subject matters.

This can totally work out, or it can be a severe overreach on what's upsetting to the mass populous. "Won't someone think of the children!?" feeling like the overriding sentiment.

Either way, who are we to be told what to do? Whilst these titles may never see the light of day how they were intended - if they even made it out at all - we can still take a look at what might have been.

8. Weird Dreams

Weird Dreams Amiga Trucchi E Codici Videogame
Rainbird Software

Often forgotten as a relic of the Commodore 64 age, Weird Dreams is a title that never really made a lasting impression, initially releasing in 1988 to some mixed reviews. The game features a man named Steve who begins to have the titular Weird Dreams, as unbeknownst to him, the woman he loves is actually a demon called Zelloripus trying to works its way into his mind.

Easy enough mistake to make, we've all been there.

Since his psychiatrist can't figure out the problem, he's sent to a neurosurgeon, put under anaesthetic and operated on, resulting in one last weird-ass dream that you then play through. Dying in the dream results in dying in real life, but the game wasn't always designed that way.

Weird Dreams was supposed to punish the player's death by revealing you wake up in your own surgery and have to endure a brain operation, whilst fully capable of seeing and feeling everything going on. Coming at a time when people were genuinely quite scared of being awake during medical procedures, as well as just being a generally horrifying premise to begin with, the ending was altered to being simple death instead.

It's not a big change, but we might as well start off light here before the next entries...


7. Thrill Kill

thrill kill
Midway

Whilst technically unreleased, leaks of the game have been playable for some time - rendering this one a bizarrely censored title that feels like overkill considering what else is on the market.

Thrill Kill was supposed to be the most controversial game of all time, combining BDSM, dismemberment, loads of gosh dang cursing, and all the genre staples of exploitation into one big fighting mashup, but EA decided to pull the project before it could ever hit shelves to avoid bringing out a 'senselessly violent' game. Then they released Dead Space 2 off the back of it being the most offensive game ever that your mom definitely hates. Make your mind up, guys.

With move types like 'Bitch Slap' and 'Swallow This', the game gained notoriety quickly, and was eagerly shared around when former employees released it despite EA putting a hold on proceedings. Turns out, Thrill Kill is a prime example of the industry not getting it right, since most that played the title complained it really wasn't worth the hype, and they weren't particularly blown away by the Mortal Kombat-aping release, despite its infamous status.

Oh well, at least you can happily clobber people's heads in with a severed leg knowing EA aren't seeing any profits from it.


6. Six Days In Fallujah

Six Days In Fallujah
Atomic Studios

Apparently created as an attempt to offer the most realistic military depiction in gaming, Six Days In Fallujah was originally supposed to replicate the experiences of U.S. Marines as authentically as possible, but whilst various marines were on hand to help design the game, they were deployed to the Second Battle Of Fallujah during the Iraq War. Atomic Games, seeing a potential opportunity, thought this would be a great idea to capitalise on.

It was not a great idea to capitalise on.

Whilst many games have portrayed incidents of war throughout history, none have gone so far as to actually release a game based on a war that was still fresh in peoples' memories - never mind one that was still unfolding. Six Days In Fallujah was regarded as heavily controversial, and a major misstep for a studio that could easily have looked at what they were doing and actually took a moment to consider if they reeeally wanted to stir that pot.

The game unsurprisingly wasn't released despite being finished, as Konami pulled out due to the controversy surrounding its new direction, and in the end, we never got a release date. It's probably for the best.


5. Active Shooter (Standoff)

Active Shooter / Standoff
Revived Games

It's really not hard to understand why this title was shelved a few days before release. How it even got that far into the system is a mystery in itself, since it's a game that simulates a school shootout in some sort of strange parody.

And no, you aren't a SWAT team member honing in to neutralise a threat, or a school attendee running through protocol - not that either of those would make it any better - but you're the one wielding the actual gun on school premises.

Steam got so riled up about the project they not only banned the game from sales through their platform but instated a controversial games policy in its wake. In response, the game changed its title to 'Standoff', relocated itself to a shopfront, and got itself back onto the server - but has managed only a measly amount of sales in the wake of its boneheaded decision to trivialise an actual horrific problem going on in the world today.

That this happened in just 2018 is somewhat more shocking that anything else. With everything from the developer's PayPal accounts suspended to their website hosting revoked, it's at least an example of the consequences of pulling such a stunt in the industry today.


4. CarnEvil

carnevil junior
Midway Games

Another from Midway games that attempted to cash in on being 'the most controversial game ever', or at least shocking enough to send audiences into a spin, CarnEvil was a rail-shooter release that sees you attempt to survive a haunted fairground risen from under the earth. It's pretty much all fun and games and a neat little arcade horror game to work through - all apart from one boss level that got some punters clutching at their pearls.

It's nothing to think of in modern media, but the Freak Show level revealed a giant baby rising up to attack the player. Considering you've got to shoot it to death to win the level, that upset some people. Nobody tell them about Catherine. Or Who's Your Daddy.

The software settings allowed for the monstrosity to be swapped out with a Teddy Bear affectionately named Deaddy, and the blood and gore meters to be toned down for those that got upset at being faced with zombified human offspring. Considering it was 1998, there's something to be given for it being a different time - but still, it was literally a giant deformed monster-baby stitched together like Frankenstein. Hardly a cherub.


3. Mother 3's Western Release

Mother 3
Nintendo

Considering this one was actually released and has been yearned for by western audiences for over 15 years now, it's somewhat of a surprise that Nintendo hasn't capitalised on the popularity of Mother 3. Earthbound, technically the second in the Mother series and known as Mother 2 in Japan, is the only game of the trilogy to get an official release on Western shores - but exactly why we haven't received the follow up is an issue still being debated today.

Nintendo believes that the driving force of bereavement in the game would ruffle up players if it were to be translated and marketed outside of Japan, with a comment from Game Informer's editor revealing it was actually in progress before coming to a stop:

"It was full steam ahead for a while but upon re-evaluation there were aspects of the game that weren't going to go without controversy."

Anything from hallucinogenic drug trips that recount child abuse, to getting kicked and shocked as you play as an animal, to designs for characters that might not be as #woke in today's climate could be reason for that.

Either way, Nintendo does not want us playing Mother 3 outside of its original region.


2. Postal 2

Postal 2
Running With Scissors

Now, this one ties in more specifically to New Zealand's game industry than anywhere else, since Postal 2 has been outright banned since its release in 2003.

This isn't particularly special since it's been banned in Australia and Malaysia too - but neither of those countries went quite so far as New Zealand did in ensuring it didn't get into the hands of the public.

Postal 2 posits you as a man out to complete mundane tasks - the catch being you can do so as explicitly and violently as you like. The game features plenty of controversial content; namely a lot of violence and urination, and combines about every offensive feature you can manage into one neat little disc. It isn't a nice game, and considering New Zealand is a nice country, there was only one course of action they felt was appropriate to take.

To counteract anyone interested in its gameplay cited as “Gross, abhorrent content" featuring "High Impact Violence, Animal Cruelty, Homophobia, Racism, and Ethnic Stereotypes”, they implemented a fine of $50,000 and up to ten years in prison.

Even if you think you could handle this game, just don't f*ck with the kiwis.


1. Grand Theft Auto 3

Grand Theft Auto 3
Rockstar

Coming only mere weeks after the events of 9/11, Rockstar decided it would be best to make some changes to their game set to take place in the same city, purely to avoid any coincidental references to the attack that left New York reeling. Delaying the game by three weeks, the GTA we got was reportedly only about 1% different to the game that was originally created, with changes to the cop cars, flight paths of planes, and one mission with reference to terrorists.

Whilst Rockstar were open with what had to be altered in light of the attack, people still speculate on potential theories as to other coding changes happening behind the scenes. Whether it’s lost tunnels or multiplayer modes, there’s plenty that fans get stuck into - but nothing more than the awkward Dodo plane that flies with clipped wings.

It’s incredibly difficult to handle and can only be flown for short periods, predominantly as Rockstar argued they were making a ‘driving and shooting game’, but the tragedy of 9/11 is still pointed at as the reasoning for pushing the dodo out of gameplay, or at least heavily dissuading players from engaging with it.

Either way, the developers had their hand pushed to create a game that wouldn’t touch upon the weeks prior and made nuanced changes - managing to get out an excellent, adapted version that remains one of the best of its kind.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Postal 2
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Horror film junkie, burrito connoisseur, and serial cat stroker. WhatCulture's least favourite ginger.