8 Convoluted Video Game Narratives NOBODY Understands

"Just go with it".

Killer 7
Capcom

While there might be some who sigh in despair over video games moving away from the pursuit of points and prizes to a more "cinematic" focus, you can't deny that when it comes to keeping players hooked, one of the easiest ways is a stonkingly good narrative.

Complex character arcs, intriguing plots and mysteries, double-crosses that leave you stunned, all of these can both knock the player on their ass and keep said rump glued to the sofa as they dive in further and further.

Yet, in the pursuit of player investment, some video game developers went a little too far, and by that, I mean that the narrative ended up disappearing up its own behind, leaving both gamer and characters wondering what the hell is even going on.

With betrayals around every corner, out of nowhere swerves you had no idea were coming, and good old fashioned plot holes created by too many changes and loops, these games definitely told one heck of a tale.

However, you need a tin hat and a whole lot of glue to patch things together into something even remotely coherent.

8. Final Fantasy 13-2

Final fantasy 13 2 XIII-2 caius ballad
Square Enix

Final Fantasy 15 infamously held a lot of its narrative in a two-hour movie that most fans didn't watch, and Final Fantasy 13 took an idea that was simple on paper and made it so arduous to understand, that many fans switched off long before the game became any good. And yet, it's Final Fantasy 13-2 that truly takes the cake when it came to convoluted plots.

The reason why it's so taxing on the mind is that it takes all of the Square-Enix twists and turns and then adds time travel to the mix, or should I say terrible time travel that doesn't even follow its own logic in most instances.

The plot in a very simplistic manner is that Lightning, the protagonist from the previous game has been all but erased from existence thanks to a time paradox, and now her sister and new boy Noel have to travel through time correcting mistakes like a Hot Topic Time Cop.

HOWEVER, what this means is that you're basing a game on fixing things that don't make sense, and therefore is it any wonder that the throughline of this game is so confusing??

You're literally playing through something which, as I've just mentioned, DOESN'T MAKE SENSE.


7. Rule Of Rose

Rule of Rose
Sony Computer Entertainment

Rule of Rose however does not give a single toss about any so-called "storytelling conventions".

This psychological horror game for the Ps2 may well be regarded as an undersung hero by many today thanks to its genuinely creepy atmosphere and setting, but it's plot is delivered in such a disconnected manner that trying to connect the dots may well become the thing that haunts your nightmares.

I felt like that one seen in Always Sunny with Charlie in the mailroom, endlessly trying to figure out who characters were as well as their motivations only for the game to then say, "oh that event hasn't actually happened yet and didn't happen to these characters EVEN THOUGH THEY WERE IN THE SCENE YOU JUST WATCHED" which then sent me back to the drawing board.

On top of this are all the details hidden in collectibles and even within the games manual, all of which need to be understood and re-evaluated constantly. It's draining work and leads to fans creating a website dedicated to piecing things together which still brings up arguments to this day!


6. Pathalogic

Pathologic Game
Ice-Pick Lodge

"What it's Pathologic?" you might ask, and I will immediately begin sweating bullets as I try to figure out which part of the game to even attempt to grasp onto first.

I guess you could begin by stating that the plot both does and very much does not make sense. Focusing on a remote town that is experiencing a rather nasty dose of Nurgles Blessings, it's your job to stop the spread of the plague while also uncovering its origins and why many of the townspeople seem so very, very odd.

The problem is that the game makes every step of the way as painful for you as possible, doling out woeful combat mechanics, quest related NPC's who die if you don't help them, and even positing the other playable characters in the world and having them live out their own questlines but making them choose the worst possible outcome for YOUR character each and every time.

Add on top of this dialogue that seems to have been plucked from a high school Shakespeare production AND the fact that characters lie to you all the time because they have their own ambitions and goals, and you'll be left reeling long before the game explicitly tells you it's a game and introduces you to the developers and you have a chat about how all of this is pointless.

Don't even fight it, just let your brain fall out of your ear.


5. Eternal Sonata

Eternal Sonata
Namco Bandai

God Bless Eternal Sonata because I honestly would have loved to have been in the pitch meeting when this absolute barnstormer of a barmy idea was dropped onto the table.

"So it's an anime adventure game with RPG elements and a cool combat mechanic where you have a limited time to wail on enemies as much as you want? Sounds brilliant!.....wait...sorry I must have misheard you. You want the characters to all be based on Frederick Chopin's music and that this adventure is actually his fever dream as he dies of Tuberculosis?....ok? WELL, AT LEAST IT'S UNIQUE!"

As you might expect from a setting that is literally forming from a man's last thrashings against the night, the story of Eternal Sonata is wild and often nonsensical.

Now you could well argue that it doesn't need to make sense seeing as the emotional weight of this tale still hits hard, and I'll totally agree with you on that, but when you end the game on his characters still living past his death, now given agency to exist in a world made of music... you have to take a step back and say "what the f**k just happened"

Still, great game.


4. Resonance Of Fate

Resonance Of Fate
tri-ACE

It's a shame that while Resonance of Fate's combat and characters are soaring overhead, the plot is scraping its arse along the floor like a dirty dog.

Now put your hand up when I lose you; The game takes place in a city that has risen above a now polluted surface and is ruled over by those at the very top of the spire. These lazy, fat, rich idiots decide to build an AI that will help with population control, kind of like Logan's Run. The AI goes rogue, because of course it does, and it's your mission to battle through the city and unplug this glorified car battery.

So far so simple...ish right? Well now add in a church that worships the AI, child soldiers who are being grown to be resistant to the poisons, a facet of the AI that means people can't die before their allocated time, but yes they can, but the end boss can't die because he believes in a higher power beyond the AI, so the group just decide to....let him go....and go live in the poison....and DON'T DIE?

Yeah, it....doesn't make much sense no matter how many times you play through it.


3. Kingdom Hearts Franchise

kingdom hearts 3
Square Enix

I think we all knew that this was going to make it onto the list really didn't we? To be fair it's not without warrant as the now plentiful memes about Kingdom Hearts narrative are powerful strong! However I'm going to at once defend the game as I deride it, because Kingdom Hearts, as a story is not actually that complicated, however the way it tells this tale about darkness, hearts and friendship truly is.

This is because there are just too many damn Kingdom Hearts games and each of them so, so bloody long and when you've got a narrative which is as simple as "The Darkness Is Bad, Stop It However You Can" this means you have to add in turns, twists, and unnecessary characters by the boatload in order to pad things out.

This means the real confusion of these games come from how much there is to remember at any given point, even if most of this boils down to generic goals of good and evil.

Making matters worse is that in some games, narrative plot points and character bios are hidden as collectible Ansem reports meaning you could easily lose track of what plot you are given because Square Enix thought it best to make motivations optional. This is not a dumb series but it's delivery truly is at points.


2. Death Stranding

Death Stranding Sam Fragile
Kojima Productions

I think that if one were to look up Hideo Kojima in the dictionary they may well find THE definition of a "cheeky whippet" as this man is an absolute meme lord through and through.

From having a gas at fans with the reveal of Raiden as the central character over Solid Snake in Metal Gear Solid 2, to pretty much every interaction with Johnny the solider, he just loves having a laugh at his audience and shattering their preconceived notions of what a video game can be.

That being said, maybe someone should be hired to tell him "no" every once in a while because when it came to penning Death Stranding, having the reigns of studio meddling taken off really didn't help establish a coherent plot. In an effort to make a new genre of games, Kojima threw everything at a wall, then took that wall and threw that at another wall, and repeated the process until he stood amidst the rubble of countless ideas and said "wait what was I doing again?"

This is the only explanation as to why we got moments that didn't make sense even within the very loose confines of the game itself and go some way to explaining why in an interview with VG 24/7 that he said "Even now I don't understand the game".


1. Killer 7

Killer 7
Capcom

Trying to nail down a concrete timeline of events in this game is next to impossible, and this is by design, as the game actually operates on different levels of existence and meaning, jumping freely between them at any given moment and not even caring if the player joins it.

The basic plot, if you can call it that is that a new Terrorist organization called Heaven's Smile is attacking locations around the world in order to destabilize Western Authority and give power back to Japan, however, those leading the group are themselves being controlled by a Buddhist daemon.

Only 7 assassins with the power to see these invisible exploding terrorists will be able to stop the daemon.

Yet this story is the very most you can actually say is true, as everything else, from its characters who may or may not even be real, to the villains who spout esoteric monologues that lead absolutely nowhere, and the fact that the game tells you occasionally there's no point in fighting as light and darkness must be allowed to exist equally, there seem to be so many strings to chase that they end up knotting together and beating you to death.

I will say hand on heart that I have no idea what's going on throughout this, but I think, I THINK, that's kind of the point, that the machinations of social and political figures make little sense to those who can't see the bigger picture.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Killer 7
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.