8 Developers That Got Away With Selling You The Same Video Game Twice

Can you tell the difference?

Destiny 1 2
Bungie

When it comes to making sequels in popular entertainment, iterating on a given video game formula is a double-edged sword. On the one hand it's far easier than in film or literature as the audience will - assumedly - just want more excuses to use your various mechanics and characters in a new setting. If it ain't broke, just add more levels. Or something.

Though on the other... there has to be enough changed and altered to even justify that full price tag a second time - something that in many cases, results in a 'followup' that distances itself too much.

Gaming is littered with sequels that got everything wrong and tanked their franchises in the process. The likes of Mass Effect Andromeda and Tony Hawk's Pro Skater 5 all took their core components and repurposed them into complete messes, whereas the following titles kept everything the same... only to still leave a sour taste in the end.

It goes without saying that gamers are a hard bunch to please, but if we're coughing up the cash we'd like something substantial in return...


8. Prototype 2 (Radical Entertainment)

Prototype 2
Radical Entertainment

Essentially the video game equivalent of teenage angst made real, the original Prototype was a glorious explosion of visceral melee fatalities, vehicle-jacking, body-stealing and superpowers. Coming alongside a tie-in comic of the same name, it really felt like Radical Entertainment had a winner on their hands.

Then Prototype 2 happened.

Embodying the "If it ain't broke..." mentality to a tee, Prototype 2 was almost literally the exact same game as before. The same powers, climbing animations, feel of control and array of abilities - playing James Heller felt like a de-hooded version of the original's Alex Mercer, albeit without the amnesiac "Who am I, really?" plot drive.

Ultimately you could still drive a few hundred tendril-skewers through entire city blocks of police and civilians at once - and Prototype 2 still moved at a steady clip - it was just a huge shame there wasn't anything else of real substance. Needless to say, Prototype 3 remains a huge missed opportunity.


7. Star Wars The Force Unleashed II (LucasArts)

star wars force unleashed 2
EA

One for the glorified DLC pile, The Force Unleashed II came with more cinematic trappings than the likes of Prototype 2, yet its length was painfully short.

Atop that, you spent most of its runtime re-unlocking the same powers so you could dispatch enemies in much the same way as before. Physics stayed the same - which were always too overpowered when it came to the speed of Force-throwing a Stormtrooper in the first place - and Starkiller's batch of attacks barely changed.

Worst of all, the game's paltry handful of levels combined with powers that encouraged speed and group-based killing meant you could rattle through this full price title in an afternoon. Adding insult to injury was a tacked-on "Actually there's a clone of you!" ending where the original Starkiller got stabbed in the back, leaving fans with less a goodbye wave and more a middle finger to chew on.

The very idea of a Force Unleashed 3 was buried after Lucasfilm canned a ton of Star Wars Expanded Universe content in 2014, though with the narrative groundwork being so hacked to pieces as it stands, maybe that's for the best.


6. Just Cause 3 (Avalanche)

Just Cause 3 13
Avalanche Studios

Remember Just Cause 3? For as much as part two was a phenomenally fun archaic experience built on blowing up half of Panau, going into JC3 we were fully expecting a next-gen debut to take full advantage of the new consoles' firepower.

Sadly, at launch Just Cause 3 was a frame rate-addled mess; though this quickly put into stark contrast just how similar it felt to Just Cause 2. Thankfully we now had a wingsuit for Rico to launch himself out of planes and soar across the landscape, but aside from that and a handful of individual jet-boosting mines you could place wherever you like, it was business as usual.

The same busted driving physics, the same approach to combat scenarios and the same sandbox-feeling mission structures that fell on the wrong side of 'open ended'. Just Cause 3 would get exponentially better over time, but the fact remains: Its core feel was far too similar.


5. Crackdown 2 (Microsoft)

Crackdown 2
Microsoft

Speaking of wingsuits, how about you sell a game that being the only meaningful addition?

The first Crackdown was a phenomenal, easy to play superhero-powered experience. Yes, you can say its popularity boiled down to being the only standout first-party 360 exclusive, but when you were pinging cars off gangsters, hoovering up agility orbs and leaping tall buildings in a single bound, that all felt pretty damn special.

So special in fact, Crackdown 2 decided to release 99% of the first one all over again. With a wingsuit. And zombies.

Together they gave us precisely ONE new way to traverse what was still the same city as the original with a few remodelled areas, and precisely ONE new 'type' of enemy to gun down.

Needless to say, Crackdown 2 was so half-baked and so ill-received it would take years for Microsoft to greenlight another instalment - though even that feels like it's being sent out to die, as once again there's very little to discern it being a numbered entry.


4. Left 4 Dead 2

left 4 dead 2
Valve

Look, I know. I know we all loved it - and man, Left 4 Dead remains one of the best zombie shooters of all time. But look back on it now and compare to that 2008 original: There is very little identifying the two.

In fact, looking back will immediately remind you of the overwhelmingly negative reception this had outside of how much fun it was to play. Coming just one year after the original and seeing a major plot resolution resigned to some pricey DLC, there was a prevailing feeling - outside of an initially disastrous showing at E3 - that this was nothing more than a cash-grab.

In reality, L4D 2 still played like a dream and gave an entire generation of gamers one of their most beloved online experiences of all time. But was it essentially Left 4 Dead with more bells n' whistles, DLC packs and a lack of meaningful changes? Sadly, yes.


3. Assassin's Creed Revelations

assassin's creed revelations
Ubisoft

Though Assassin's Creed would become known for churning out the same basic game over and over, at least Ubisoft's various teams would change up enough of the game to warrant a sequel. Black Flag's ship combat, Unity's gorgeous French setting complete with interiors (when it wasn't falling apart) - alongside new stories, characters or time periods every time, they easily justified the price.

That was the case for each game... bar Revelations (or Rogue, if we're classing that as a 'proper' instalment).

Coming at the close of the Ezio trilogy, Revelations was the first game made after Creative Director Patrice Desilets departed Ubisoft, leaving the remaining devs to essentially pick up the scraps for the next release. The result was something that still nailed its narrative with a solid cutscene depicting Altair and Ezio 'meeting' in the same place across two time periods, but fell down considerably when it came to combat, gameplay and narrative overall.

Case in point: The hookblade (described in the game as "a hook... with a blade!") - it immediately became the lamest weapon in the franchise. Used to climb certain gaps incrementally faster than before, it exemplified Revelations as the series' tipping point; a release that showed Ubi were going to pump these things out regardless, no matter how little necessity was present.


2. Far Cry 4 & Far Cry Primal

far cry 4
Ubisoft

Another from Ubisoft - and this is regrettably included as Far Cry 4 is still a fantastic game - the first game to capitalise on Far Cry 3's runaway success ostensibly opted to mirror it entirely.

Once again we opened with a 'quirky' madcap, monologuing villain, before segueing into much the same-feeling gameplay as before. The much-advertised Himalayan mountainside that propped up the game's marketing and looked to be enough of a departure from FC3's jungles was resigned to a corner of the map, whilst the rest of the base game didn't do anywhere near enough to differentiate.

Worse still, come time for Far Cry Primal, Ubisoft were quickly chastised for using the same map as Far Cry 4, albeit giving everything a Stone Age makeover.

Thankfully, Far Cry's gameplay remains stellar and one of the most quality-tested of all Ubisoft's output - it's just a shame we've now played the same thing three times in a row.


1. Destiny 2

Destiny 2
Bungie

From the menus to the general rollout of content across its entirety, Destiny 2 adds a story and some fancy new pieces of loot, but really, deep down, it's the same Destiny as it was post-Rise of Iron, remixed and put back out with a number '2' on the box.

I've done a full-on breakdown of everything Bungie's latest gets wrong over here, but sufficed to say: Once you've gotten through the threadbare story and unlocked every major part of the game, it immediately sets in just how much this is Destiny 1: Redux.

Instead of having a Sparrow vehicle right away, you'll unlock it after the story - though it doesn't do anything new. Instead of starting with the classes you previously spent hours unlocking, you'll again get them across the story. DLC vehicles like Pikes and tanks also sporadically appear on the four small world maps you can explore, and every last enemy (save for a handful of animations) are exactly the same.

Then there's the identical character creator that hasn't added any new items whatsoever, and menus from an overworld to the pause screen that you'd have to hold up side by side and squint to tell apart.

Destiny 2 is objectively a fantastic-playing product, but as a sequel... well, that's another story.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Destiny 2
 
Posted On: 
Gaming Editor
Gaming Editor

WhatCulture's Head of Gaming.