8 Exact Moments Video Games Split Their Fanbase In Two

If it wasn't for those meddling kids.

Fortnite Kids Ruined Thumb
Epic Games

Being a video game fan isn't all it's cut out to be.

Thanks to the ever-shifting parameters of the gaming industry itself - which seems to reward homogeneity over individualistic projects - now more than ever, publishers are clawing back development costs through loot boxes and microtransaction NFT stinkiness.

It's tough to stand up and proclaim your love for a franchise and not feel that tinge of sweat running down your spine at the thought of how it could all come crashing down with just one wrong move.

Yet, we're also a passionate lot, and our love and hate ebbs and flows like the tide itself, meaning we're constantly buying first-class preorder tickets for the hype train and then actively sabotaging the tracks of others in equal measure. Sometimes you can pinpoint exactly when the mood began to shift, when the family unit divided and some just shook their head at where the series was going and gave it the old "hard pass"

These are such moments, and while some of these franchises went on to bigger and arguably better things, it was clear they'd lost their original audience along the way.

8. When You Realised The Massive Open World Was Almost Empty - Sea Of Thieves

Sea Of Thieves Music
Rare

When Sea of Thieves was announced, it was hard not to get excited at the prospect of swashing some buckles and making sure that poop deck was so damn clean and zesty lemon-fresh that it'd cure your scurvy, and indeed the trailers and promotional material for the title painted a picture filled with derring-do and adventuring on the high seas.

You'd travel to uncharted islands, battle undead minions as well as other foes, pillage loot from forgotten tombs, and best of all, come face to face with other rival ships and blast holes out of them in such a devastating manner you'd think your cannons fired nothing but parental divorces.

And yet.

When players finally (and I mean that quite literally seeing as the game was originally meant to come out in 2018) got their plastic hooks on the game it turned out that all that beautiful looking water was actually as shallow as a puddle, as aside from lumbering from island to iland and engaging in some pretty whiffy combat, some fans noted that there was basically nothing to do!

With the gameplay loop as transparent as some of the ghostly enemies you face in the game, it wasn't long before forums were awash with early adopters begging for more. Yet on the other side of the ocean, a band of perky pirates was having a great time, seeing the journey itself as the core entertainment, and managing a vessel as a crew as a key selling point for the title. For them it was about plotting a course, planning your angle of attack, and of course firing yourself out of a cannon onto the beach like a total badass.


7. When You Lost All Your Items The First Time - Death Stranding

death stranding
Kojima Productions

Now if we're being honest, if you're a fan of Hideo Kojima then you're pretty much sold on his brand of "yes I'm a little eccentric from time to time and thank you for commenting on my pork pie had made of actual pork pies", however with Death Stranding, even the renowned auteur game designer was faced with an audience utterly torn on some of his decisions.

And it all began with the first step, or to be more accurate, the first time you fudged said step and went arse over tit, slid down a mountain, lost all your packages, and then watched them get swept downstream and out of your life forever.

This, this was the moment where Death Standing showed you what it really was. It wasn't a convoluted, often hamfisted message about literally rebuilding society, it wasn't about whales being washed up on Princess Beaches, hell it wasn't even about weaponized piss thanks to Monster energy drink, it was all of these things AFTER it showed itself to be Post-Man-Pocalypse-Pat The Tripping Simulator.

All that guff about Strand gameplay being its own genre, all of the mad celebrity cameos and crazy marketing that got you hyped on the game, all of this couldn't be enjoyed if you couldn't get over the fact that you would be running, balancing and then tripping your way across the map as a glorified courier, and that was enough to cleave opinion on this title in two from the off.


6. When Abby Took Up Golfing - The Last Of Us Part II

The Last of Us Part 2 Ellie
Naughty Dog

!!MASSIVE SPOILERS FOLLOW!!

I think we all pretty much had the same look on our faces once "that moment" happened in The Last Of Us Part II. A look that was similar to one you'd pull after witnessing your dog be put down with a brick and then also having someone remind you that your grandparents might still be having sex. Yeah, disgust, confusion, and sadness all in one.

This was a moment that split the Last of Us fanbase in two, as here we had lost one of the central driving figures behind the entire experience. For some it was simply too much to get over and tapped out there and then, yet for others they commended Naughty Dog for their decision which seemed to follow the Game Of Thrones mantra of "never become too attached to characters".

By removing Joel from the equation they raised the stakes to unprecedented levels and inspired such a thirst for revenge that it drove the entire rest of the game.

Yet this fury was also an important vehicle for the devs to comment on the nature of revenge itself, as come the close of the game we come to realise that violence is cyclical and to break away completely one has to remove themselves from that mindset. It's a hard concept to convey, and especially through a medium that almost rewards revenge rampages, but they bloody well went for it, even if some of the fanbase felt the concept came in over par.


5. When The Trailer Dropped - Call Of Duty: Infinite Warfare

Call Of Duty Infinite Warfare Kit Harrington
Infinity Ward

Despite your thoughts on the franchise overall, you cannot deny the sheer power Call Of Duty wields in the mainstream. Each year a new title is slopped out into the mouths of all the little foul-mouthed birds who can't wait to gobble up more explosive set-pieces and hone their trash-talking skills, but that's not to say that the entire fanbase has been in unison across the franchise's tenure, hell it's not actually been in step for a long while now.

Back when Black Ops II moved the setting of the game into sci-fi territory the cracks began to show, as some fans embraced the new setting while others lashed out calling for a return to the series' roots. Therefore when Activision decided to double down on the futuristic fighting, it sparked a sort of civil war between COD fans, which culminated in the mass dislike bombing of Infinite Warfares reveal trailer, catapulting it to the top of YouTubes most disliked videos ever.

Yet before you think that this showcased all of the fans getting on the same side to dunk on the publisher, Former President and CEO of Activision Eric Hirshberg commented that preorders were up and that the like ratio on the trailer was also the highest it had ever been, meaning that while some fans were trying to make their voices heard, others were simply speaking the only language that Activision cared about ake with the money from their wallets.


4. When Your O.G. Pokemon Got Ditched - Pokemon Sword And Shield

Pokémon Sword and Shield
Youtube

I'm pretty sure that if you went up to a random person over the age of 20 and said: "Catch 'Em Catch 'Em Gotta Catch 'Em All" that they would probably instantly respond with "Pokemon", well unless they were from Chelsea and then they'd correct your use of "Em" to "Them" then beat you with their top hat as you're making them late for their caviar and oil dinner.

Still, I digress, Pokemon is a very embedded concept is what I'm trying to get at, and as such nearly every Poke fan worth their salt knows that they have but one goal in life and that is to bloody well "Catch 'Em All"

Except there's just one problem, there sure are a lot of the little fuckers around.

This was clearly a problem for GameFreak who knew that adding in more and more pocket monsters was only going to lead to burst seams on our comfy shorts down the line, and so it was down to Pokemon Sword and Shield to take one for the team and become the first title in the mainline series to remove creatures from the roster.

As you can imagine this went down like a lead balloon splitting the fanbase as if Scyther had had a pop at them. Some understood the need for limitation, that it would allow the series to grow, and were focused on the other plus points of the title. Yet others just couldn't get over how some of their original lineups was nowhere to be seen.


3. When You Tried To Do... Anything - Deadly Premonition

Deadly premonition
Access Games

I don't think I've ever experienced a "marmite" game more "marmite-y" than Deadly Premonition, as wherever you look across the gaming industry you'll find those claiming this to be near perfection, and others decrying it as a game that they wouldn't even use to prop up a wobbly table as they're worried said table would feel insulted by having to step on such garbage.

Now cards on the table, I'm in the former camp as I utterly adore this game; it's weird, it's obtuse, it's sometimes entirely self-aware and others so straight-laced it could join the army, and I cannot get enough of the oddity that is Deadly Premonition. However, I completely understand why others hate it, because at every turn the game fights against what you want to do by telling you "ok but here's how we're going to do it today"

For starters, the moment you try an auto-aim with York only to be directed to your enemies arse is jarring to the point that it feels broken, and the dialogue is so off-kilter it makes you think that aliens who only had access to cave drawings to base human exchanges on wrote this.

Then you've got the driving sections that feel like trying to guide a brick on ice across vistas so bland that bare drywall would give them a run for their money, and best of all you can't even break the speed limit because that would be rude.

Deadly Premonition is a meme of a game, for better or worse, and you are either on board for the ride of your life, or running out of gas and hoofing it the f**k outta there.


2. When The Kids (And Money) Arrived - Fortnite

Fortnite Battle Royale
Epic Games

So this is going to make me sound like the King of All Hipsters here, but sometimes, when it comes to video games, popularity is something that can absolutely ruin the experience.

Well, to be more specific, it's the after-effects of popularity such as the developers trading in on the IP and over saturating the market with merch or losing sight of what the original intention of the project was as it now chases the demands of its ballooning audience, but it all stems from that initial piercing of the mainstream that draws in a deluge of new players to the title.

And for many, the exact moment where the now monolithic Fortnite died, was when the kids arrived.

And to be honest who could blame them? With it's Free-To-Play model, colorful aesthetics, and immediately enjoyable gameplay loop, it ticks all the right boxes. However as soon as the age demographic lowered to cater to these perpetually energetic and overhyped players, many were left feeling like the old man yelling at the clouds.

With aggressively cringey "yo yo my fellow kids" marketing, a drive to be weird for the sake of being weird, and all the pop culture tie ins money could buy, Fortnite became a vehicle that was less the cheeky whippet of the Battle Royale genre and more the over-sugared puppy that chases anything shiny and shits on the rug every now and again.

Kids. They ruin everything.


1. When You Tried To Talk - Fallout 4

Fallout 4
Bethesda

One of the biggest parts of the Fallout video game experience, aside from dressing like you've eaten nothing but magnets by strapping any bit of metal you can find onto your irradiated body, is being able to walk out into the various Wastelands and play as any type of character you can imagine thanks to the in-depth choice and dialogue systems on offer.

You could play as a suave, smooth-talking lad about town, or a character who uses brains over brawn to solve their problems, or the exact opposite and play as a character who is so stupid that most other NPC's take pity on you when conversing and just give you the stuff to make you go away. Or, as in the case of Fallout 4, you could not do any of the above and just take a gamble on the prescribed dialogue options you were given and just try and make the best of things.

Yes Fallout 4 is the best looking of all the current titles, yes it's gunplay is arguably much the best it's been in the entire franchise and yes Preston Garvey is as annoying as a permanently itchy bum crack, these are things we can all agree on, but the way this game approaches dialogue choices? STINKY.

I don't want to hazard a guess of what my character might say when picking the "sarcastic" option, I want to actually dictate how they go about making and breaking relationships. This one move by Bethesda killed a tonne of fan support and it's not hard to see why. They were telling you in some small part how to play, and that just ain't Rainbow Rhythms my friend.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Fortnite
 
Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Jules Gill hasn't written a bio just yet, but if they had... it would appear here.