8 Genius Ideas Wasted On Bad Video Games
These killer ideas deserved SO much better.
There's a clear reason why truly innovative video game mechanics are so few and far between - they're extremely tough to come up with, and even then, there's no guarantee they'll actually resonate with the general public.
And so, it's always frustrating to play a game that's ultimately a bit naff, only to appreciate that there is one shining golden nugget of innovation amid the dreck, albeit one which has basically been drowned out by said game's thunderous badness otherwise.
Sadly that's absolutely the case with these video games, each of which brought one truly brilliant, even ingenious idea or mechanic to the table, but it ended up stifled by the game's many creative deficiencies elsewhere.
From a terrible story to obnoxious characters, janky gameplay, and myriad technical issues, these games failed to foreground their best and most creative concepts, ensuring that they were largely slept on by the gaming masses.
And as such, these ideas have largely laid dormant in the gaming sphere ever since, even though it's clear that many of them could be implemented far more successfully by other developers producing great work. We can only hope...
8. The Deaf Experience - The Quiet Man
On paper, the Square Enix-published beat 'em up The Quiet Man had a ton of head-turning potential, with the game featuring a minimal soundscape in order to reflect the experiences of its deaf protagonist, Dane.
Only vague muffled sounds are audible throughout both the action-centric gameplay and live-action cutscenes, and the dialogue is left un-subtitled, leaving audiences to try and piece together the plot themselves through visual cues.
It's certainly an intriguing setup, and one which in better hands might've actually made for both an interesting mystery-action game and a creative step forward for representation in video games.
But even if you can forgive the deeply clunky combat, The Quiet Man's execution feels fundamentally flawed; Dane is shown regularly reading lips and communicating with other characters, so there's a bizarre disconnect between Dane's comprehension of what's going on and our considerably lesser grasp.
As such, you were more likely to be confused than compelled by the story, but even once a patch was released allowing players to replay the game with full audio and subtitles, it just confirmed how overpoweringly dull it all was.
The kernel of a great idea is definitely there, but not like this.
7. Joy Pills - We Happy Few
We Happy Few takes place in an alternate 1960s dystopia where the residents of Wellington Wells are hooked on a pacifying hallucinogenic drug, Joy, which leaves them blissfully unaware of what's really happening in the world.
And this is also the game's defining mechanic - you're free to pop Joy pills throughout, causing the stark dystopia to morph into a colourful, cheerful environment, where you have decidedly sunnier interactions with others.
Meanwhile deciding not to conform and weaning yourself off Joy will show the village as it is actually is - drab and depressing. You'll also be met with hostile responses from the locals and coppers alike, and suffer Joy withdrawal which will affect your health.
This is all conceptually terrific, so it's a shame that the game as a whole can't sustain interest for long.
The world is surprisingly bland and empty, the gameplay loop is too repetitive, and it's absolutely rife with bugs.
6. Modular Weapon Customisation - Homefront: The Revolution
Don't feel bad if you don't even remember that a second Homefront game quietly slid onto storefronts in 2016, because it was a big fat nothingburger - well, almost.
Though neither the story nor the characters made even the slightest dent and both its gunplay and stealth were mediocre-at-best, Homefront: The Revolution had one killer idea going for it - modular weapon customisation.
Because the occupying Korean People's Army (KPA) have fingerprint-locked guns, the resistance forces can't use them, and so you're instead forced to get crafty in order to amass an arsenal.
That is to say, the guns on offer are modular, allowing you to make functional changes on-the-fly in the heat of combat. A shotgun can quickly be modified to become automatic, and universal attachments can be added to basically any weapon.
This allowed players to make some truly wacky weapon combos, like a grenade launcher with a massive scope.
It's just a shame that the moment-to-moment gunplay didn't actually feel particularly good, because this freedom-loving approach to the player's loadout was absolutely first-rate.
5. Parkour Combat - Brink
Brink is one of gaming's all-time great missed opportunities, because dammit, the potential was definitely there.
Released in 2011, this multiplayer-centric first-person shooter was sold almost entirely on the eye-catching appeal of its parkour-infused combat, with players able to sprint around the map, vault onto platforms, and balletically leap back to the ground in fluid motion during shootouts.
This was governed by Brink's Smooth Movement Across Random Terrain System - or SMART for short, which with the press of a single button would attempt to anticipate the player's next move and seamlessly execute it without complex button presses.
And honestly, it was both a neat idea and one that proved pretty damn fun in practise. It's just a shame that Brink's art style, story, and characters didn't amount to a hill of beans, and the community was immediately hobbled by persistent bugs and lag during the launch period.
Given the prevalence of the hero shooter today, Brink can't help but feel a bit ahead of its time, even if it was clearly also too rough around the edges for prime time.
4. Leveling Up Body Parts - Hybrid Heaven
Time for a mega deep cut now, with the profoundly Marmite experience - love it or hate it - that is Hybrid Heaven.
Released on the N64 in 1999, this utterly bewildering genre-bending outing from Konami was basically a garish yet occasionally creative car crash of RPG and action-adventure game.
This is a game whose real-time combat system allowed you to perform wrestling moves on your alien enemies, because why the hell not? But what truly distinguishes it from its genre rivals? Its enticingly peculiar leveling system.
Hybrid Heaven had separate progression for your legs, arms, and head, meaning they level up at different rates depending on how much each limb is used during combat. The more you use a body part, the more awesome moves you'll unlock for it.
This system added a unique air of strategy to battles, yet for all the game's eccentricity, Hybrid Heaven's repetitive environments, low enemy variety, and clunky movement still made it an absolute slog to get through.
3. Memory Remixing - Remember Me
The ironically monikered Remember Me came and went in a blip in 2013, with most dismissing it for its jumbled story and uninvolving gameplay - that is, save for the game's ingenious Memory Remix sequences.
Protagonist Nilin possesses the ability to enter a person's memories and alter their perception of past events.
These set-pieces, of which there precious few throughout the game, are the easy highlight - effectively interactive cinematic puzzles in which you need to reconfigure memories for your benefit.
Sadly these segments too often take a backseat to generic combat and platforming, effectively feeling like a prototype for another type of game entirely.
Developer Dontnod of course went on to bigger and better things with the Life is Strange series, but it's a shame they've never returned to the Memory Remix concept in a new title, because it's the only part of this game you're actually likely to remember today.
2. Cloud-Based Destruction - Crackdown 3
Oh, Crackdown 3. You never really stood a chance, did you?
When Microsoft's open-world shooter sequel was first announced, its multiplayer mode was revealed to be employing innovative cloud computing technology to augment its city-wide destruction mechanics.
This would allow for an unprecedented level of detail compared to any game being rendered on a single home system.
Microsoft even boldly claimed that this real-time cloud-driven rendering would provide 20x the power of a single Xbox One.
But with the game's extensive delays came increasing skepticism about the viability of the cloud tech, especially with Microsoft being suspiciously quiet about it in the lead up to Crackdown 3's release.
And indeed, while the concept of farming out intensive environmental destruction certainly seemed interesting, the final game's destruction capabilities were scaled way back compared to the stunning early gameplay footage.
To compound the disappointment, Crackdown 3 suffered from a snoozily generic gameplay loop and boring open world, enough that even the presence of Terry Crews couldn't liven it up.
Cloud-based destruction quickly died a death as a concept, and it's probably because Crackdown 3 showed the industry how challenging it was to implement.
1. Voice-Activated Survival Horror - Lifeline
PS2 survival horror game Lifeline was nothing if not a brave, perhaps foolish attempt to do something radically different.
Set onboard a space hotel as it becomes overrun with monsters, the player is tasked with guiding protagonist Rio to safety through voice commands administered via the PS2's microphone.
You never control Rio directly whatsoever, but rather tell her where to move, and how to both solve puzzles and attack enemies, while also being able to speak with her in a limited capacity.
It was certainly an ambitious setup for a game released in 2003, when console voice chat was still very much in its infancy, which may also explain why the game doesn't fully work.
For starters, the voice recognition software is painfully creaky, where any accent outside of received pronunciation is basically deemed too "exotic" to produce reliable results.
But for its time this was a huge swing, even if the maddeningly unwieldy voice recognition likely makes it too frustrating for most to see through to the end.
It's easy to see how such a game would fare better with the more sophisticated technology of today, but 20 years ago we just weren't quite there yet.