8 Notions That Help To Explain BioShock Infinite's Ending

massive spoilers. I will be talking entirely about the game's ending in detail, so if you haven't beaten the game yet, go off and do that then come back. We good? We're good. Bioshock Infinite seems to still be on everyone's lips and rightfully so. While there are still tons of great games to come out this year, it is not hard to imagine it walking away with tons of awards. But while we are on the subject of ends, Bioshock Infinite's left some people scratching their heads. Some are convinced it is the best ending in gaming history, others thinking that it is an empty twist, whereas others like it but don't understand some of its finer points. I must admit, I wasn't sure of the ending when I first saw it, but once I sat and thought about it, it is actually all very cleverly done. So allow me to clean a few things up for you if you were lost or just come and explore the fantastic ending with me once again...

8. Booker/Comstock

BioShock-Infinite-Explained-Quantum-Theory When this first happened, I was a little skeptical. It seemed like a somewhat forced twist: Booker DeWitt is actually Zachary Hale Comstock? That was until I sat back and thought about it and really it says something really quite interesting about fate. When Elizabeth shows you the many lighthouses towards the end of game, she explains that each one represents another reality. Each with their own "constant and variables". Every reality has a set of predetermined actions that it must abide by, while also having a set of actions that can change form reality to reality, but most importantly it all ends in the same place. For example, it doesn't matter if you kill Slate or not, your game will end in the same place. Elizabeth sums it up by saying, "We swim in different oceans, but land on the same shore" So each reality starts with a choice. Full of grief due to his time at the battle of Wounded Knee, Booker decides to absolve himself of his sins by getting baptism and accepting relgion. This is where the realities differ. In one Booker may decide to accept baptism, in which case he accepts relgion and becomes Comstock, or in another Booker may decide to reject Baptism, and he will go on to be the Booker we play through with. You all this knew this right? Well good, because it is going to inform everything else.


7. How Does Elizabeth Have The Ability To Make Tears?

8614252405_0c92a63137_b As previously established, Booker and Comstock are the same person who followed diffrenet paths but how does Elizabeth fit into all this? And how can she rip tears between each reality? For that, it is important to illustrate a point I think many might have missed. Booker and Comstock are exactly the same age. Comstock has become old, but most importantly sterile due to experimentation with the Lutuce twins. Comstock has become bent on the need for a heir to take over Columbia when he finally passes on. To achieve this, Comstock must go to a reality where he was never sterile and was able to have a child. This is where Booker comes in. With help from the Lutece twins, Comstock goes into Booker's reality and offers Booker a deal. He says that he will wipe away his amassed gambling debt in exchange for his daughter Anna. As Elizabeth states at the end of the game, this is one of the constants of each reality. Booker always gives Comstock the child. Although, another constant always has Booker trying to stop Comstock taking his child through the portal back into his own reality. During this scuffle, Comstock escapes with the child but not before the portal closes, severing the tip of Elizabeth's pinkie finger (once there, we presume Comstock changed her name to Elizabeth). This is what gives Elizabeth her powers. In a voxophone on Monument Island, Rosalind Letuce explains that, "It would seem the universe does not like its peas mixed with its porridge". Because Elizabeth's finger tip exists in one reality and her body in another, she partially exists in two realities, thus giving her the ability to not be contained to one and able to make tears.

6. The Lutece Twins Are The Same Person

I must admit, the Lutece twins were a mystery to me through my whole first playthrough. However, upon completing it again, it has become clear how their involvement is quite possibly one of the most important in the game's events. Both are the same person, just from different realities. Rosalind is from Comstock's reality and was the physicist who discovered the secret that makes Columbia float. When it became clear that tearing was a possibility, Rosalind discovered her 'brother' Robert, who is just a male version of her in Booker's reality. Once they had mastered the tear technology and Comstock had them retrieve Anna from Booker, the two joined up in the same reality. However, there was trouble in this multidimensional paradise. Comstock became increasingly paranoid that people would begin to find out that Elizabeth was not his. This is why Lady Comstock met her end. She had become increasingly jealous that she could not bear the child of the sterile Comstock and hated Elizabeth as she was not hers, assuming it to be the child of Rosalind Lutece. This made Comstock nervous, so he had his wife killed off and the blame falsely placed upon Daisy Fitzroy.(A nice irony that had Comstock create the Vox Populi) Comstock became anxious that the Lutece twins would talk too and it is revealed that Comstock had a try on their lives. This caused the twins to turn to Booker as a way of safety and putting things right. Worried about the safety of themselves and the world, as justified by the visions and reality of Elizabeth destroying New York, they brought Booker into Comstock's reality to stop him from ever existing thus stopping Columbia from ever existing.

5. There Have Been 122 Bookers Before You

bioshock-infinite-coins Which leads us to the revelation that the Booker we play is not the first Booker to have ever gone through this trial. Right at the beginning of the game, there is a very nifty little visual joke that actually explains this. Right after you gain the Possession vigor, the Lutece ask confront you asking if a coin flip will land heads or tails. Robert is seen wearing a chalk board with a tally. As the coin is flipped it always lands on heads. Rosalind marks the heads column and Robert then turns around to show lots of tallys for head and none for tails on his back. This is another example of a "constant" in a reality. The tally shows that this exact moment has happened multiple times before and the Luteces are keeping score. If you count them, there are 122 marking for heads, meaning that this Booker is the 123rd to attempt destroying Comstock. By opening tears to another reality, the twins have a near infinite supply of Bookers to bring into Comstock's reality. They believe that it is only a matter of time before enough variables line up and Booker finally destroys Comstock by allowing himself be killed by Elizabeth before he ever had the chance to be baptised. It just seems to happen on the 123rd time of asking.

4. Why Doesn't Booker Remember Anything?

But if Booker existed in a realty where his daughter was taken away by the Luteces and he saw her get taken through a portal aswell as interacting with Comstock, why doesn't he remember anything? This one is actually explained in the very first thing you ever see in the game. As the game opens we see the quote, "The mind of the subject will desperately struggle to create memories where none exist..." attributed to "Barriers to Trans-Dimensional Travel, R. Lutece, 1889" We see so many quotes thrown around to illustrate points in art that you could be forgiven for having glazed over this. I am sure many never cottoned on this was actually a fake quote drawn up by one of the Lutece twins ont he first play through.It explains that subjects who are brought into a reality in which they don't belong will create memories to fill in gaps in their logic. This may sound like a convenient excuse but this actual has basis in reality. During some attacks where pshycological damage takes place, subjects will forget the reailty and invent an easier to understand one. The mind is an entirely unreliable thing and when it doesn't understand something, it will fix its perception of reality to make sure it does.

3. It Is All In The Music

bioshock-infinite-january-2013-church While Gary Schyman's soundtrack is great and one I have been listening to while writing this, the choice of songs for the game is really quite interesting. The most important of these songs is "Will the Circle Be Unbroken?" which takes a double meaning in the game. A truly heart breaking song about the passing of loved ones and how a 'circle' becomes broken when they die and leave the earth to join heaven "in the sky". When thinking about Booker's story the song takes two meanings. You could see the "Will the Circle Be Unbroken?" as a literal refernece to the Lutece twins trying to change the perpetual cycle of Comstock and Booker's story. However it also has a more emotional meaning as it accurately describes the pains of Booker having had Anna taken from him and taken to a literal kingdom "in the sky". The song is used three times in the game to emphasise this very point. The game also features songs that simply should not have been in the 1912 setting. Each is used for relavent meanings than they might first appear. I will only reference one here but the inclusion of 'Girls Just Want To Have Fun' is pretty interesting. When you first arrive at Battleship Bay, you can hear a fairground rendition of the song. If you actually look at the lyrics for the song, two lines read:
Some boys take a beautiful girl And hide her away from the rest of the world
I would argue that if the ending had to be condensed to two lines, that would be pretty close. There are tons more little interesting meanings in the games tracklist but I will let you figure those out for yourself.

2. What Is The Epilogue About?

eliz If you get past all the credits, you will see a very small epilogue. At first glance it is quite an odd inclusion as nothing really happens in it but once you figure out the entirety of the story, you realise it means everything. In the epilogue we find ourselves in a Booker's room, a place we have been transported to several times through out the game. Only this time, Robert Lutece isn't knocking on the door to take Anna away. Instead all we hear is her crying in her next room. That is all. But that is the heart of the story right there. The whole story was about a father who had his daughter stolen from him and his journey to be reunited with her. Because Booker went back to a point before he ever became Comstock, he destroyed all the alternate realities where Comstock ever existed, thus allowing himself to be with Anna without the "constant" of Comstock taking her from him. It is a slight story beat but one that really conveys the emotional heart and meaning behind the game perfectly. Now, there is one more thing that I have added on to the next page, although for now, I am filing it under 'fan theory.'

1. Bioshock Could Be Another Reality

2013-03-28_00129 This is a theory that lots of people have been throwing around in forums and such, but for me there isn't any 'concrete' evidence that confirms it. Although, I have to admit the theory certainly holds water (pun intended). The theory goes that Rapture is just another reality behind one of the doors in the light house section. Behind all the doors could be any number of realties and stories of insane cities and the story of a man, a girl and a lighthouse. This is based on something Elizabeth saying that it each story always starts with a lighthouse, just like the first Bioshock game. The implication being that the story of the first Bioshock is the exact same story of Bioshock Infinite, just with different "variables" with Booker being Jack, Elizabeth being the Little Sisters, Songbird being the Big Daddies and Andrew Ryan being Comstock. The similarities are stark but I would argue, so are the differences. In Rapture, there is no one little sister, you aren't there to save them, Jack and Andrew Ryan are very different entities etc. However, it can't be disproven and if it does turn out to be true, it creates quite and interesting little paradigm for the series to work in. The idea of there being an entirely different realty behind each and every one of those lighthouses is an exciting prospect. It would open up the universe of Bioshock to multiple possibilities while also always keeping it defined. I hope that solves some issues for you if you were having trouble figuring out some of the logic and timeline of the game. Quite a lot of the the finer details of the story are explained int he voxophones that you find scattered around that you might have miss, so I won't begrudge you for having missed anything. Do you think there is anything I missed or am completely wrong about? Please let me know how dumb and blind I am in the comments section below.

Contributor
Contributor

Patrick Dane is someone who spends too much of his time looking at screens. Usually can be seen pretending he works as a film and game blogger, short film director, PA, 1st AD and scriptwriter. Known to frequent London screening rooms, expensive hotels, couches, Costa coffee and his bedroom. If found, could you please return to the internet.