8 Smart Video Games With Incredibly Dumb Twists
From Fallout 3 to Yakuza 0, which dumb twist spoiled an otherwise smart game the most?
What’s your favourite twist of all time? Mine was at the end of The Sixth Sense, when it was revealed gradually over the next two decades that M. Night Shyamalan was a garbage writer the whole time. Truly, a meta masterstroke.
That's films, though. Video games, in general, rely upon things that the player sees coming. The flaming orbs that the imps throw at you in Doom, for example. You need to see those coming, so you can move. If you walk into a room with a bunch of health and ammo pickups, you can see that there’s a boss coming. If you’re allowed to play for more than five minutes in a Hideo Kojima game, you know there’s 45 minutes of cutscenes coming. It’s how games build the comfy sense of familiarity that keeps us coming back, like hungry little cheese rats on the Sisyphean wheel of simulated progress.
So, when a game pulls something you don’t see coming, it’s usually a nice surprise. Wow, you think. This game has vision. It’s got moxy. It’s really going places, this game, and I want to be there when it does. I am a tiny guppy fish and this game is virtuosic angler, and I am powerless but to dangle on its mastercrafted hook of shocking revelations.
Here is a twist right now: Some games are bad at doing this. The following highly-clickable pages contain 8 games that were smart, right up until they went full dumb with a terrible twist.
8. Fallout 3 - He’s Literally Standing Next To Me
Here is a riddle:
Q. When is heroically sacrificing yourself by entering a fatally irradiated water purifier actually just a really stupid, pointless death that could have easily have been avoided if Fallout 3’s writers had communicated with each other at all during development?
A. When you have a huge slab of green beef-buddy standing right next you, who huffs up radiation like it’s the sweet fumes of a lightly toasted marshmallow, and is entirely capable of moseying into the purifier, flicking a switch, then lying down for a fifteen minute power nap, before leaving without even the lightest throat tickle.
In Bethesda’s defence, the free Broken Steel DLC did fix this issue. In Bethesda’s non-defence, hindsight has taught us that the themes and lore of Fallout mean about as much to them as customer loyalty. As in, not at all.
7. Metal Gear Solid 2 - Something Something Scissors
If you’ve already guessed that I’m going to write an entry about the reveal that Raiden is the protagonist, then congratulations. You’re wrong, by the way, but I figured you might need that congratulations to soften the blow of how very wrong you are. The Raiden reveal was a stroke of genius, inexorable from Metal Gear Solid 2’s wider themes and deconstruction of the very concept of sequels themselves, and some top quality commercial trolling besides. Lots of pages on the internet say this twist is bad. These pages should all be printed off and burnt to a crisp. Do not let them infect your mind.
The actual dumb twist in MGS2 is when Colonel Roy Campbell starts malfunctioning, hinting that Raiden was communicating with an AI the entire time. This ends up revealing the game’s trump card too early, fraying the edges of reality too violently, and causing the upcoming reveal regarding the Solid Snake Simulation to have much less weight. Kojima is a treasure, but his Matryoshka-like twists within twists can sometimes cause the minor ones to dull the major, and this was one such occasion.
6. Devil May Cry 5 - Questionable Wordplay
Devil May Cry 5 was a smart game. Not because it had a cerebral story or like, even vaguely interesting level design or anything, but because it knew exactly what fans wanted, and because its dozens of interweaving combos displayed a geode-like glittering complexity. People occasionally describe Platinum-style character action combat as ‘balletic’, but I feel DMC5 is more of a shameless, riotous barn dance of unselfconscious, comically-slick abandon, with some dope cowboy hats.
The game also mentioned romantic poet William Blake a lot. This is fine. The bad part was the reveal that Blakean fanfic demon ‘Urizen’ is Dante’s rival sibling Vergil, with a line to the effect of ‘He’s your reason for fighting’.
Urizen. Your reason. As a dedicated proponent of puns, I rank this somewhere below “Christmas cracker joke your dad found stuck to his shoe on New Year’s Eve and proceeded to pull out the aux cord just so he could read it to the whole party, but halfway through started choking on the mouthful of mini cheddars he was still eating.” From now on, all DMC stories should involve nothing but dance-offs between Vergil and Dante. Combat. Dance off. Combat. Dance off. There, fixed it.
5. Final Fantasy 8 - Plot Kompression
Many internet lists will tell you that Final Fantasy 10 contains the worst twist in the series, citing the revelation that the entire plot was a dream. This never actually happened, although bad translation is partly to blame here. A little digging online for writing by smarter and more dedicated fans than me will teach you that Tidus was actually a summon, similar to the Aeons. It’s, uh, complicated. Go look it up.
So, that in mind, Final Fantasy 8 takes the crown for the series’ dumbest twist, when it’s revealed that all the central characters actually grew up together at the same orphanage, but forgot because they have a bad case of monster-brain. Obviously, amnesia is a bit tired as a device, but the real problem here is how it shrinks the story’s scope. The potential richness offered by six individual backstories is all smushed together into a single, chokingly plot-driven revelation, and the scale of the whole thing is fed through a narrative can crusher as a result.
4. Doom Eternal - Literally Any Storytelling Whatsoever
Doom 2016 shocked the world by slapping the words ‘boomer shooter’ right out of everyone’s cynical mouth holes, and spooning in a decadent ramekin of frenetically-whisked murder soufflé. Doom 2016 was shown a piece of cover, once, and asked which end of it was for hitting demons with.
Doom 2016 also had very little in the way of story interruptions, and displayed a fourth wall breaking, Verhoeven-esque glee in winkingly facilitating the player’s own impatient bloodlust. That’s not to say the game didn’t have lore, or worldbuilding, and interesting lore and worldbuilding at that, but the plot was left refreshingly optional.
Doom Eternal, however, pulled perhaps the biggest storytelling twist of 2020, by assuming that anyone actually cared about the story in a Doom game. A shocker, for sure, although not an especially welcome one. I’ve warmed up considerably to most of the changes that Eternal made. It’s an incredibly confident, smart game, made better by the designers' refusal to sit on their laurels. They had a successful formula already, and they stuffed it to the gills with extras, just because they wanted it to be even better. Any exposition longer than a metal vinyl’s tracklist is painfully superfluous, though.
3. Mass Effect 3 - No Time To Explain
Is this low hanging fruit? Absolutely. Low hanging fruit is still delicious though, and after you’re done, you can throw the seeds at the chumps still climbing the tree. So, let me take a break from shoving these delicious, easily-obtained grapes in my mouth to say that Mass Effect 3’s hologram child was hot garbo juice.
“How should a series only tangentially about byzantine sci-fi explanations and mostly about friendship end?” someone asked. “With a byzantine sci-fi monologue!” someone stupid replied. And then someone even stupider agreed.
Very little of Mass Effect’s depth or appeal ever arose from the larger philosophical questions about the purpose of its universe. Nearly everything good about the series was about the personal struggles of its fantastic characters, and the political tension between its many species. This twist acknowledges precisely none of that.
Now, Citadel was a great DLC, and went a long way towards fixing things. Really though, this will never be OK until Shepard is joined by Luigi in Haunted Mansion get-up, ready to suck the catalyst into a hoover bag filled with dog hair.
2. Fire Emblem: Three Houses - Edgelord Is An Edgelord
Hey, so, you know Edelgard? The character we’ve given several monologues about gaining power and not really feeling the whole ‘church’ thing, and also slathered with proto-fascist imagery at all opportunities? She’s uh, she’s sort of planning something.
Yeah. Thanks, Three Houses. I sort of got that.
To Three Houses' credit, the game is quite successful in presenting different sides of a conflict without defining any one side as especially evil. Unfortunately, it does this by cutting out important reveals, depending on which side you ally with. Edelgard’s breakup with the church stays consistent, but the circumstances around it don’t. This is all further complicated by Three Houses' frustratingly incomplete story arcs that only give you the whole picture after you’ve pieced together divergent timelines that contradict each other.
Ultimately, the story ends up being a bit of a mess no matter which route you choose. It’s still a great RPG despite this, though, and after all this, Edelgard’s route is still the best. Fight me.
1. Yakuza 0 - Hey Mister, That’s My Sister
In nearly all the ways that count, Yakuza 0 is a masterclass in video game storytelling. The life sim/brawler/RPG hybrid exhibits a butler-like dedication to making the player happy at all times, but the butler is also a clown, and also, a master storyteller, and also, your dad. The game has so much unshakeable confidence in its ability to keep the player emotionally invested, that it isn’t afraid to gleefully headbutt the boundaries of realism in its mission to keep the player smiling. Ultimately, it realises that characters that never have fun aren’t really full characters.
Not that it isn’t afraid to get exceptionally dark, with a central arc including human trafficking, racism, and sex slavery. Just as it's fully unpacking these ideas though, it drops another reveal.
The reveal that Makoto Makimura is Tachibana’s sister is squeezed in between several equally huge plot revelations, and given basically no time to breathe as a result. While Yakuza 0 and ‘restraint’ aren’t exactly words you’d find together often, I feel this one could have been parcelled out a little more elegantly.