8 Terrifying Video Game Moments That Are Laughably Outdated Now

How did anyone ever take Slender Man seriously?!

Slender Man
Dark Horror Games

Thanks to being a uniquely interactive medium, video games and horror have always gone hand-in-hand. Even when they lacked the technology to effectively do so developers have always tried to scare players silly, even back in the NES days, and over the years have amassed quite an impressive library of classic horror moments that have haunted the nightmares of gamers both young and old.

Unlike movies or books - who's scares can remain legitimately terrifying for years - the ever-changing nature of the video game industry means that something that was considered bone-chillingly horrifying as little as a few years ago is tame (or even hilarious) now.

With technology improving at a rapid rate, the ability for game developers to create scary scenarios is constantly getting better, but it's resulted in their previous attempts being embarrassingly dated in hindsight.

In fact, if you look back on some of gaming's most iconic scares you'll wonder how they could have ever frightened a toddler - never mind a grown player. Between dated graphics, jarring camerawork and terrible voice acting, today these moments have everything going against them, but at the time you could only watch them from between your fingers.

8. Resident Evil 3's 'Random' Nemesis Encounters

One of the defining differences between Resident Evil 3 and the previous games in the franchise was that players were always being stalked by the deadly Nemesis. A biohazard engineered to bring down the game's heroes, the monstrosity constantly showed up at seemingly random moments throughout the title to terrorise the player.

The thing is, while the idea of having an omnipresent villain constantly attempt to thwart the protagonists is pretty scary, the design of the Nemesis was anything but. This leather-clad hunk always felt out of place in the Resident Evil universe, and was a clear symptom of the developers trying too hard to make something cary by committee, rather than just letting it happen naturally.

Consequently, it's only the anticipation of the Nemesis showing up that ever managed to be sort of scary, because once you knew when he'd show up he became more of a garish nuisance than anything else.


7. FEAR 2: Project Origin's Phantom Sexual Assault

When the Fear series was at its peak, you couldn't escape from seeing creepy pictures of the game's main antagonist, Alma, online. Looking pretty much identical to every black-haired little girl that littered horror movies in the 2000s, the villain constantly tormented players throughout the game by warping reality and infecting the minds of the main characters.

The ending of the second release tried to ramp this creep factor up even higher though, inter-cutting a scene where protagonist Beckett has to execute a demon version of one of his men with brief clips of Alma sexually assaulting him.

Once you finally shoot the guy, she fizzles away for a brief fake out, only to return nursing a pregnant belly a few seconds later. Putting your hand on her stomach, the camera pans up to her distorted face before cutting to black.

In theory the scene is insanely disturbing, and back in 2009 it sort of was. Everything about it just feels awkward now though; Alma writhing half naked on top of the player comes out of nowhere, while her digital disintegration completely sucks any remaining horror out the scene entirely.


6. Dead Rising's Psychopaths

Although Dead Rising always erred on the side of horror comedy than trying to purely terrify its players, the original game actually made an effort to be pretty spooky at times, especially with its enemy designs.

Consequently, while the title's psychopaths - deranged individuals who acted as boss fights around the map - were imaginatively wacky, their oddball designs were still intended to be pretty creepy at the time.

However while some of them retain their horror factor today, other memorable ones like Pennywise's two-bit cousin Adam the clown don't hold up quite so well.

Adam's off-kilter voice and manic laugh used to be enough to haunt players' dreams, but now it just makes the character's dodgy animations look even more hilarious. Aiming a weapon at the psychopath and watching him bounce around the screen is one of the funniest things in the game, made even more humorous by how hard the game is trying to push him as a genuine threat.


5. Doom 3's Game Engine Gimmick Is The Spookiest Thing About It

Moving away from its bombastic roots, Doom 3 instead opted for a gameplay approach that owed more to survival horror games than it did previous releases in the franchise.

More of a showcase for the Id engine than anything else, in an attempt to show off the game's graphical capabilities the opening hour of the sequel focused on players stalking expertly-rendered corridors while encountering small groups of zombie-like enemies.

It was quite atmospheric at the time, with the lighting in particular often creating silhouettes that sparked your imagination and made you wary of whatever was lurking around the next corner.

However, looking back on the sequel it's clear that the game was only actually scary because the dynamic lighting system could make spooky shadows. The demons themselves lack the visual punch of anything found in Silent Hill or Resident Evil, and with the title's pioneering graphical capabilities being the norm now, the introduction of Doom just plays like any other boring corridor shooter.


4. Everything About Slender Man

slender man
Blue Isle Studios

Back in the early days of the 2010s, Slender was one of the big games that helped reignite the horror genre. Becoming a YouTube phenomenon, the short indie game took the streaming world by storm, with everyone wanting to know why so many popular personalities were getting so caught up in the Slender buzz.

You can see why everyone was so terrified at the time, too. Taking off before horror walking simulators saturated the market, Slender took advantage of its simplicity to create a horror experience that could be picked up by anyone, whether they were a gamer or not.

Detached from its original context though, Slender is painfully basic. Heavily relying on creepy noises and the fear of the unknown, the game is a one-trick pony when it comes to scares, with the actual design of the Slender Man himself completely falling flat when the character is in full view.

In hindsight the title was little more than a YouTube screamer, and today proves to be even less effective than some of those.


3. Silent Hill 4's Big Head Mode

After three games, the Silent Hill series needed to pull something out the bag to scare players going into the fourth game. Keeping with the tradition of making its monsters manifestations of the protagonist's guilt and fears, a later level featured the oversized mangled head of one of main character Henry's neighbours, Eileen.

While many players thought it was one of the creepiest moments in the game at the time though, in hindsight it's by far one of the strangest monsters in the whole Silent Hill franchise.

Sillier than it is scary, the decision to focus on the oversized head is puzzling enough now, but it's the zig-zagging eyes freaking out that absolutely make the scene hilarious all these years later.

Clearly somebody at Capcom didn't get the memo that back in the day big head modes were goofy cheats players punched in to get a few quick laughs, not what should have been considered scary enough to put in a Silent Hill game.


2. Eternal Darkness's Blood-Soaked Bathtub

Eternal Darkness was one of the most innovative survival horror games of its time. Introducing a sanity meter that added unique and terrifying elements to the gameplay the more players let it fill up, it's a travesty that more games didn't riff on its distinctive brand of horror following its release.

Unfortunately though, not everything was as inspired as that one mechanic, and the game still relied heavily on the regular jump scares you'd expect from a horror title. The one that always pops up in particular though is the bathroom scene, with the player opening a door to uncover a dead body lying in a bathtub filled with blood.

While shocking at the time, the scene is more noteworthy now for its early 2000s music video style of editing. Featuring flashy cuts rather than just letting the moment speak for itself, the jump scare is far too stylised to be effective. It can still give you a jolt if you don't know what's coming, but the bright lights and loud noises hide the fact that there's nothing happening that's even remotely creepy.


1. Resident Evil's First Zombie

Introducing the main enemies for the whole game, the first encounter with one of the undead shamblers haunting the Spencer Mansion in Resident Evil needed to set the tone for the entire franchise going forward. Fortunately, by indulging in a slow build the developers at Capcom were able to create one of the defining moments in video game history, scaring the pants off everyone who picked the game up back in 1996.

Now though, it's difficult to see how anyone could have been scared by the original Resident Evil. Not only does the campy voice acting and horrible FMV introduction completely skew the tone before it even drops you into the game proper, but the janky first shot of a zombie lacks any sort of real punch.

In the title's defence, the censored version that just has the ghoul looking over his shoulder is a little spookier, but the original uncut scene where the zombie drops a half-eaten head is so entrenched in the B-Movie tone that it breaks the tension completely.


In this post: 
Slender Man
 
Posted On: 
Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.