8 Things Nobody Wants To Admit About Battlefield 1
It's like Star Wars Battlefront all over again.
The release of Battlefield 1 has been a resounding success. Coming out of the gate riding a wave of hype thanks to its brilliantly retro World War 1 setting, EA's flagship shooter has managed to gain scores of new fans where its competitors have been rapidly shedding them.
But Battlefield 1 isn't a perfect title, and hell, in many regards it's a pretty substantial step back from Battlefield 4. See, while the World War 1 setting has certainly shaken things up for the franchise, DICE hasn't entirely embraced the theme wholeheartedly, and unfortunately the game shares a little too much DNA with the virtually content-free Star Wars Battlefront.
Lacking key features fans have come to expect, altering series-standard staples for seemingly no reason and having a progression system that's not only lacking when compared to other shooters on the market, but previous entries in its own series, it's clear that there's a wealth of ways DICE can improve on Battlefield 1's solid foundation going forward.
Yet they won't, because the universal acclaim the game is receiving is happily overlooking the title's biggest shortcomings. The World War 1 setting itself is being bandied around as a get-out-of-jail-free card, excusing the lack of new environments, weapons and new gameplay mechanics because "there's just not much to work with".
So let's get this straight: World War 1 will give DICE enough content to mine for years, and it's time to drop the excuses and admit where Battlefield 1 went wrong.
8. The Severe Lack Of Customisation
While it's not quite Star Wars Battlefront bad (I feel like I'm going to have to use this disclaimer a lot in this article), the amount of character and weapon customisation in Battlefield 1 is entirely lacking when compared to previous games in the series.
Especially Battlefield 4, where you had the option to chop and change between an incredible amount of different camos and skins for your weapons and characters, there's nothing you can do to add a bit of personality to the soldiers in DICE's latest game.
Not only that, but what little aesthetic customisation there is has to be painstakingly grinded out through the new Battlepack mechanic. Unlike the previous game where you'd be rewarded with new weapon attachments, skins, camos and XP boosts with every new level, Battlepacks are randomly rewarded in Battlefield 1, and only offer whatever is on available in that week's specific revision.
It's a feature almost as frustrating as Overwatch's loot boxes - but at least in that game, the legendary skins actually lived up to their name.
7. There's No Trench Warfare
One of the biggest disappointments in DICE's latest release is the severe lack of combat engagements in WW1 trenches. The frantic rush through these tight, nightmarish corridors could have provided brilliant choke-points in many of the game's mutiplayer maps, yet they're strangely absent in every mode other than Operations.
And even then, although Operations almost gets it right, the horrors of trench warfare are always pushed aside in favour of the same old skirmishes you could find in any other Battlefield game released in the past ten years.
Hell, even in the campaign, which attempts to be a more faithful depiction of the first World War, there's only about two instances where you're actually fighting as part of a large assault or making your way through No Man's Land.
I get that executing this type of warfare would have been difficult to pull off (and even more difficult to make fun), but if you're going to choose WW1 as a setting, then you've got to find a way to make it work somehow.
6. All Of The Vehicles Are Boring (Except Zeppelins)
Another aspect gutted from previous games is the diversity of vehicles at your disposal, both in multiplayer matches and the main campaign. Sure, you've got your standard planes and tanks, but only a smattering of different variations to choose from inside these vehicle types.
Again, you could argue that there wasn't exactly a vast amount of vehicles to choose from when creating a World War 1 game, but even then, DICE could have given each faction a slightly altered version of a heavy tank, instead of just making one universal across the whole game.
Plus, it doesn't help that actually commandeering these vehicles is just as monotonous as ever. The ability to drive and shoot tanks remains virtually unchanged since Battlefield 4, only now you have less choice when it comes how you can use these behemoths to cause maximum chaos in the heat of a battle.
5. Gadgets Have Been Virtually Unchanged
By far the laziest element of DICE's World War 1 update comes in the form of the different gadgets that can be equipped by every class. During the run up to release, fans were wondering how the high-tech items found in modern Battlefields would be adapted to fit a more rudimentary time period, and when the final game hit it turned out that, for the most part, they wouldn't be at all.
While a couple of new gadgets were added, most of them were just the same ones fans have been playing with for years now. The Support class still gets two different types of mortar and a timed explosive, while Medics get a grenade launcher that now works on a delay, rather than detonating on impact - it's the same old stuff we've seen before with the most uninspired WW1 make-under.
It's not the biggest deal, of course, but certainly feels like a lazy step-back. There was chance for some real variety here, but it seems that the same embracing of the theme that gave us War Pigeons wasn't there when the team was tinkering with the series' long-stagnant classes.
4. There's Zero Weapon Variety
The decision to get rid of the ability to add attachments to weapons in Battlefield 1 was almost entirely made to hide the fact that each class only has three or four different guns at their disposal.
While you can look at the customisation screen for every class and see a huge armoury of guns and gadgets, most of these are simply variations of the same few, differentiated by what you can add such as grips and optics.
As a result, you only have an illusion of choice when you're picking your loadout, and it means that once you've found a favourite gun you're probably going to stick with it for the majority of your playtime - simply because you don't have any alternatives.
And sure, fans of the game have been playing the old "but it was World War 1, how many guns could there even have been?" card, but that's no excuse. There were plenty of weapons used during the conflict, and taking into account DICE's penchant for including "experimental weaponry", then there should have been a much more diverse array of guns available in Battlefield 1.
3. Levolution Was Better Than Dynamic Weather
Battlefield 4's levolution mechanic made every map feel alive. Whether it was the skyscraper falling in Siege of Shanghai or the cruiseliner crashing into the beach on Paracel Storm, these huge events could completely change how teams approached every level.
Dynamic weather in Battlefield 1 on the other hand more often than not just acts as a mild annoyance for five minutes in every match. Instead of feeling genuinely dynamic or random, weather changes in Battlefield 1 seem to come in one or two varieties: sandstorms or fog.
Both of these additions are included in order to get you to manoeuvre around the environment differently, but it seems like a step back from the levolution mechanic rather than a leap forward. Had the weather felt properly dynamic, or worked in the background alongside something like a day-night cycle, then playing on a map could have felt genuinely different every time you loaded up the game.
As it stands, seeing a map like Sinai Desert coming up next fills you with nothing but dread for the inevitable sandstorm that's undoubtedly going to ruin your time.
2. Saving Key Armies For DLC Is Pretty Shady
We've all come to expect some pretty dodgy DLC practices in recent years, but initially it seemed as though Battlefield 1 wasn't going to be too big of an offender. Sure, it had a ridiculously overpriced Season Pass that was being sold without letting anyone know what was actually in the damn thing, but at least they weren't selling in-game Battlepacks for real life money.
Well, as of the recent update, now they are, which combined with other revelations, has made me reconsider DICE's DLC approach entirely. With information coming through that the developers are planning to include new factions in the game alongside new maps based on their countries, you've got to wonder why the likes of France were left out in the first place.
It's just not cool: keeping back core armies that everyone with even the slightest knowledge of WW1 would expect to see is such a cheap way to get players to pony up for the season pass in advance.
Sure, it was great of the developers to shine a light on some of the more obscure battalions that took part in The Great War 100 years ago, but these should have been in there alongside the likes of France from the get-go, not replacing them so that we'll have to pay up later.
1. The Campaign Isn't Actually That Great
Battlefield 1's campaign isn't very good. Sure, the mini-narratives that DICE has crafted over the course of its five War Stories are full of excellent characters, brutally violent moments and more World War 1 poignancy than you can throw a bayonet at, but the actual gameplay in between these story bits is so disappointing.
Because each chapter is essentially made up of a few basic combat scenarios woven together in a disjointed and slap-dash way, there's nothing new here that shooters haven't been doing for years, and the rudimentary and lazy design of the actual missions themselves don't have a patch on the CoD-chasing single-player of Battlefield 4.
It's a shame, because the stories themselves are actually well told, it's just that the repetitive and uninspired gameplay detracts massively from their impact. You'll slog through lazily slapped together chapters like the one that has you armouring up and carrying around a minigun through the Italian countryside (so much for Battlefield 1 allegedly going against the whole "one man army" thing), just so you can get to the actual good bits - which are, strangely, the bits you don't actually get to play.
Again, the narratives themselves are top-notch, it just might have been better if they were individual cinematic movies rather than part of a divided up main campaign.
--
Where do you stand on Battlefield 1? Let us know in the comments!