8 Video Game Endings That Had More Questions Than Answers

"It's not a lake, it's an ocean." Yeah... WHAT?!

Alan Wake
Remedy

Grinding your way through hours of gameplay is near always worth it to reach that gratifying, clarifying, and oh-so-satisfying ending. Whether it's figuring out the meaning of art itself or just simply getting to smash the face off the biggest and baddest boss imaginable, video game endings are designed to give a fitting finale to all the time and love we pour into them.

Or at least, so you'd think.

Sometimes, the time we're given on screen just isn't enough to figure out what the hell has been going on for the past 20+ hours, and you're left scratching your head at an ending that was supposed to provide the goods. Is it really worth playing all that Final Fantasy for characters to just fade out into the wind like a lost fart?

You tell me.

Ambiguous endings are both some of the most frustrating and perfect finales to our favourite series, and even though we may never be given definitive answers or know the truth - half the fun comes from watching people guess, nyway.

8. Life Is Strange

Life Is Strange
Square Enix

Square Enix's Life Is Strange is one of those games that sticks with you. Told episodically from the viewpoint of Max - a high school student who discovers she can turn back time after she saves a girl from getting shot - you're thrust into the heart of a dark murder mystery that threatens the very fabric of space and time itself. That, and surviving high school. Both are equally hard.

At the end of the game, you're faced with two distinct options: save Chloe, the wild child you've reconnected with and begun to love after rewinding to prevent her murder, or save your home town and everyone in it from instant destruction at the hands of a supernatural storm, conjured up from disrupting space and time with your rewind abilities. It's definitively the hardest choice you'll have to make, boiling down to saving the bay, or saving bae.

But what exactly happens once you've condemned a township or your love to destruction? If you save the bay, will the tornado come back since there's such a massive time jump? If you save Chloe, will she continue to be plagued by death? Why is one person's life so integral to how the universe functions? How exactly does Max live her life after losing her home or Chloe?

Life Is Strange doesn't really attempt to answer anything further than a simple wrap up to your choice - but dear god, is there so much more tugging at the edges.


7. Metal Gear Solid 5: The Phantom Pain

Metal gear solid 5 skulls parasite
Kojima Productions

The Metal Gear series has been weird and convoluted since its inception in 1987, throwing you at the heart of a cinematic stealth game that depicts a special forces operative tasked with saving the world from nuclear destruction at the hands of a Metal Gear weapon. The timeline is anything but linear, and littered with men who can control bees with mind power and bombs that turn into whales and flaming horses - was there really any doubt you'd be confused as f*ck by the end of this series, honestly?

Metal Gear Solid V: The Phantom Pain is the final entry in the franchise (because no one counts MG Survive), supposedly wrapping everything up neatly by positing itself as a prequel, and making the protagonist the original enemy of the first game - but only as he went through extensive plastic surgery to look like someone else.

It's a mess, and considering it's supposed to have brought everything full circle - there's still a whole lot left hanging due to cut footage and what's assumed to be a rushed ending.

How does Venom Snake, the man with a new face, really feel about his identity being written out? What happens to half the characters that have just disappeared from the canon? Why does science mean that a woman breathes through her skin and needs to be almost naked most of the time? What does any of this mean!?


6. Alan Wake

Alan Wake Standout
Remedy Entertainment

"It's not a lake, it's an ocean."

Alan Wake's mysterious last lines could really mean anything. Telling the tale of a novelist who has traveled to the small town of Bright Falls to overcome his difficulty with writer's block, Alan soon gets more than he bargained for when his wife disappears and the work he's written begins to come to life, puppeteered by a dark, shadowy force.

By the end of the game, Alan has discovered how to dispel the darkness, and realises that to free his wife from the evil forces he must swap places with her to maintain balance. Putting himself at the bottom of a lake, she climbs out freely - but what exactly has been taunting Mr. Wake for the entirety of the play through? And what do his mysterious final words mean?

We have no idea what this ocean could be, nor who the strange doppelganger referred to as Mr. Scratch is. And since Alan Wake runs like TV series with only one season completed (six episodes in the first game, and two in DLC), it's likely we never will, either. Poor Alan's going to have to get used to being stuck underwater for the forseeable future.


5. Mass Effect 3

mass effect 3 ending normandy
Bioware

We all know what people think about Mass Effect 3's ending. After years of buildup, with two amazing games as foundation points for what could have been one of video game's defining trilogies, and some seriously misguided patching that revealed a big old problem in how Mass Effect 3 was released: the general consensus is that it's very bad.

And whilst that might or might not be true depending on how desperately you want to cling on to Shepard's pride, the fact of the matter is we're left with so many open ended threads that it's hard to know what to think about it all really.

What exactly happens if you join organic and synthetic life? Do we just get green eyes and carry on as normal? Does choosing the destroy option render biotics void? Will we ever get to see a somewhat happy future, or is this all we're left with? Did Bioware know how angry this would make everyone?

Whilst a little ambiguity and pessimism can work a treat, ME3 suffered at the hands of all options being essentially the same choice when boiled down to their core: and none of them were the universe-saving, world-defining Shepard-as-saviour fans wanted to see. Intentional or not, the true repercussions are never going to be uncovered unless we get another true Mass Effect game, which doesn't look likely after Andromeda.


4. Final Fantasty IX

final fantasy IX 9 final boss necron
Square Enix

Final Fantasy has had a mega run in its time. To get to ten games in a series, you've got to be doing something right - but both the ninth and tenth entries into the franchise suffered more than a little from fans not being entirely sure what they're watching at the close of the game, or what it means from there on out.

IX in particular has an interesting ending that raises all sorts of what-the-f*ckery, where instead of offering up one of the built up, engaging enemies that had been carefully curated throughout gameplay, the developers instead decided to just chuck in a random big baddie at the end to see what's good. Oh, okay then, no problem.

Necron is Final Fantasy IX's boss battle: but where the hell has he come from? Whilst fan theories have speculated he's the representation of death, or linked to Kuja, or is just secretly Soulcage because why not, the truth of the matter is that we have no idea where they sprung Necron from, or why they'd choose to do that in place of literally any other villain taking up the end mantle.

Just... why? I think is the main question here.


3. Five Nights At Freddy's

five nights at freddy's
Scott Cawthon

With five mainline games and a whole host of other spin-offs, tie-ins, and weird key rings to go alongside, Five Nights At Freddy's has become a power player in the survival horror genre whether people like it or not. Slowly revealing the lore of the universe one title at a time, it was FNaF 4 that promised to tie everything together with the opening of a mysterious box that appeared after completing the game.

Scott Cawthon, creator of the game, wrote on the game's Steam Page: "But then I released part 4, and somehow ... no one, not a single person, found the pieces. The story remains completely hidden... What's in the box? It's the pieces put together. But the bigger question is: would the community accept it that way? The fact that the pieces have remained elusive this time strikes me as incredible, and special, a fitting conclusion in some ways."

Annoying and secretive as ever, it turns out the code doesn't exist in the game to open the box, leaving all the connecting parts on what's really happening at the heart of Freddy's narrative locked to anyone completing the games. Brad Pitt screeching at the end of Se7en has never been more appropriate, to be honest.


2. Bloodborne

Bloodborne Moon Presence
From Software

The whole Souls-Borne series is a giant question mark, to be honest - from what little pieces of lore that can be uncovered through the convoluted narrative and strange, inhuman monsters, it still isn't really clear what the full story is in the world of all things weird.

Bloodborne is one of the main offenders for WTF moments though, forcing you to carefully consider all the items and terrains you come across along the way to discern exactly what's happening - your attempt to stop the blood-borne disease that is taking over residents of a gothic city - before turning into a baby squid, being picked up by a giant living doll, and cutting to black. Wait, what?

Forums have been dedicated to trying to figure out exactly what the heck is going on at any given time, with three interchangeable endings deemed 'good', 'bad', and 'true', each just as confusing as the last, without mention of the lore that remains as mysterious as ever. What are the true meanings of the bosses you fight? What are the messengers? What the hell just happened? Will the hunter's cycle continue? What does it mean to be an old one? Why are they squids?

Who knows...


1. The Last Of Us

Last Of Us Ellie Final Scene
Naughty Dog

One of the defining narratives of video gaming as a whole, The Last Of Us had some absolutely mammoth balls to end on the note that it did. After hours of playing as the pragmatic and straightforward Joel, a father who lost his daughter but found a new one in Ellie, you're faced with the inevitable. Ellie, the one girl immune to the Cordyceps pandemic who has travelled across the country to share her genes with scientists who can create a cure, has to die.

Only, Joel won't let that happen.

Lying to her face after murdering the surgeons in cold blood, Joel tells Ellie that she's not the only one immune, and that there is no cure for the disease ravaging humanity. Ellie chooses to believe him.

What in the hell happens after that? Are there more people immune to the illness? Will Joel and Ellie just go and live and humble life at the power plant, pretending nothing terrible is happening? How can Joel live with himself knowing he lied? Does Ellie know the truth, is she choosing ignorance?

It's the perfect ambiguous ending, laying questions thick in the air before cutting to black and throwing up the finger to anyone thinking you're playing as a good person. Whilst it's likely we'll get SOME answers in The Last Of Us 2, the sheer guts it took to give Joel and Ellie this climax is impossible to beat.


Watch Next


In this post: 
Alan Wake
 
First Posted On: 
Contributor
Contributor

Horror film junkie, burrito connoisseur, and serial cat stroker. WhatCulture's least favourite ginger.