8 Video Game Plot Twists That Were Hiding In Plain Sight

These details are SO obvious on a second playthrough.

batman arkham city
Rocksteady

Video games love trying to be smart.

Directors such as Hideo Kojima and David Cage practically made their names crafting dense, intellectual, surprising stories that didn't treat the player like an idiot, really authoring the game around storytelling and using that investment to deliver genuinely jaw-dropping twists and turns along the way.

Even better, because you spend way more time with characters in games than you do in movies and even TV, it makes it all the more surprising when the rug is pulled out from under you.

Of course, executing this successfully is an art form in and of itself. Having grand ambitions to deliver a huge twist is all well and good, but the potential for failure is huge, and if a player guesses where the plot is going too early, it can ruin the entire experience.

These shocks need to be earned, and that means putting in the legwork throughout the entire story, rather than hastily throwing something in at the end and hoping players don't realise it doesn't make any sense. Fortunately, when this is done properly, it results in plot twists that were actually subtly telegraphed way before they happened.


8. Naomi Hunter And Grey Fox Share The Same Last Name

Grey Fox
Konami

A franchise so packed with twists and turns it shows up twice on this list, the original Metal Gear Solid gave fans a taste of the kind of cinematic story video games could tell. Though the most famous reveal is the one concerning Liquid impersonating Master Miller, there are so many more that surround it, from Snake being set up by his own government to members of his team of advisors joining the mission with ulterior motives.

It's that last part that's the focus of this entry, as geneticist Naomi Hunter is revealed to hate Solid Snake for killing her adopted brother, Frank Jaeger - otherwise known as Grey Fox - during the events of the previous game. It's just one part of telling the player they can't trust anyone - even those that are apparently there to assist them - but the connection between Naomi Hunter and Frank Jeager is actually spelled out right from the get go.

Well, if you speak German anyway.

That's because 'Jaeger' translates from German to English as 'Hunter', revealing that both Frank and Naomi share a surname, and thus must be connected. That's probably about as subtle as Kojima has ever been with foreshadowing.


7. Jack Being Andrew Ryan's Son Is Teased In An Audio Diary - Bioshock

bioshock jack
2K

The original Bioshock is full of ridiculous plot twists, one of which reveals that player character Jack isn't just a random casualty of a plane accident who found himself in an even worse situation at the bottom of the ocean, but rather he's intrinsically linked to one of the game's major players, Andrew Ryan.

Ryan was the founder of Rapture, the underwater "utopia" the player finds themselves in, and Jack was his illegitimate son, artificially aged to do the bidding of Ryan's nemesis, Frank Fontaine. It's a reveal that comes late in the game, but it can actually be spoiled quite early on by the bathyspheres.

These contraptions are used to get around the city quickly, but when everything went to hell, Ryan locked them, and only his genetic code being registered can actually activate them. This security measure is actually discussed in an audio diary, where the security chief states: "Sisters, cousins — anyone in the ballpark, genetically, will be able to come and go as they see fit."

So, while this line of dialogue doesn't outright give away that Jack is Ryan's son, it does reveal that there's a connection between them - long before the story ever acknowledges it directly.


6. Roland's Death Is Literally Spelled Out At The Start - Borderlands 2

Borderlands 2
2K

Roland's death in Borderlands 2 offers a surprising emotional peak for a game that is otherwise primarily concerned with giving players ridiculous weapons of mass destruction and dropping as many knob gags into the story as possible. Handsome Jack shoots him in the back in a genuinely shocking moment towards the end of the game, but his untimely demise had actually been signposted long before that.

In fact, it's right there in giant letters the very first time you meet him.

During his introduction, Roland is sat on the bed of his cell as he talks to the player, and on the wall right behind him, in gigantic letters, are the words "YOU DIE" written in an ominous red.

At the time it's easy to ignore it as simply a bit of scene dressing to make his introduction more visually interesting; just a random, stylised addition that's on brand with everything else in the world of Borderlands. In hindsight though, this warning makes his ultimate fate extremely obvious.


5. Josh Dies No Matter What You Do - Until Dawn

Josh Until Dawn
Sony

Until Dawn's loving ode to the horror genre hides twists within twists, but perhaps the biggest is that Josh, who seemingly dies early on in the game, is the one who orchestrated a night of terror for his "friends".

Though you might have a sneaking suspicion that one of them might be in on it (as is slasher convention), the game attempts to throw you off the scent while simultaneously giving away the twist that Josh is responsible. At one point early on in the title, you encounter one of the game's branching choices: Josh and Ashley are hooked up to a Saw-like trap, and you have to choose who gets the chop.

However, no matter who you choose, it's Josh who ends up with his (later revealed to be fake) guts on display. If you choose him, you'd have no idea anything was off about the choice, and even if you didn't, you might have just chalked it up to a sick joke on behalf of whoever set this trap up in the first place to kill the person you thought you were saving.

It's later revealed that Josh didn't die, but simply rigged the trap to make it look like he did to sell the horror to everyone else. In fact, he never put any of them in any real danger (it was the wendigos doing all the actual murdering), he just used his own apparent demise to make them think they were being hunted.


4. Clayface Is Pretending To Be The Joker - Batman: Arkham City

Clayface Arkham City
Warner Bros. Interactive Entertainment

Another classic case of mistaken identity, the bulk of Arkham City focuses on the Joker and Batman suffering from a disease caused by The Clown Prince of Clown's self-induced monster mutation in the original game.

However, the former's apparent renewed health after a blood transfusion is revealed to have been nothing more than a lie to prompt Batman to find a proper cure. In the final act, his true appearance is revealed, and he's shown to be completely decrepit, barely able to stand and completely ravished by the disease.

So who was the seemingly healthy Joker you'd been interacting with before then? Well, it's revealed that Clayface has been acting on his behalf, impersonating the old puddin' in order to not give the game away.

If you were paying attention during any prior interaction with the man formerly known as Joker, you would have figured out this twist straight away. By using Bats' detective vision you can see a person's skeleton and vital signs, but all the way through the game the Joker has no skeleton.

This isn't simply a glitch or an error, but confirmation that what you're actually looking at is the boneless body of Clayface. Hell, the series even draws attention to this fact in the original game, where once again Clayface has no skeleton in detective mode.


3. Alice Is An Android - Detroit: Become Human

Detroit Become Human Alice
Sony Interactive Entertainment

For the most part, Detroit: Become Human is about as subtle as a sledgehammer. While the plot itself is still enjoyable, it wears such obvious symbolism and foreshadowing on its sleeve. All with the exception of one key twist: the fact that the young girl android Kara is protecting is also a machine.

The revelation that this girl, Alice, isn't human comes right before the climax, but the team at Quantic Dream included so many hints towards her true nature before then that, upon replaying the game, it becomes just as signposted as anything else.

For one, when you find a picture of Alice's family in her room, it shows her, her father and mother, but the child's features are slightly off, especially her hair. The suggestion is that the real Alice is in the photo, and not the machine her dad bought to replace her.

On top of this is the fact that advertisements for android children (and their affordability) are mentioned a few too many times, and some characters refer to Alice as "it", all hinting towards the reveal that she isn't human.


2. Venom Snake Is A Big Boss Body Double - Metal Gear Solid V

Metal gear solid V ishmael
Konami

The one thing the entirety of Metal Gear Solid V's fragmented plot is building towards is the reveal that the man you think you are, that is, the legendary soldier Big Boss, isn't who you've been playing as for the past 50 hours.

The final cutscene shows that, despite having his face and taking his place in the public eye, you've been nothing more than a pawn for the real Big Boss, who has been accomplishing his own dastardly deeds behind the scenes while all eyes were on you.

It's supposed to be this grand reveal that makes everything else in the narrative click into place, but there were so many hints in there beforehand that the most die-hard fans actually figured out the twist before the game itself had even released.

Because, with all the information at your disposal, it's pretty easy to figure out that there are two Big Bosses. For one, there's two characters (including the player character) voiced by Kiefer Sutherland, one of which drops quips and informs you how essential it is to heal yourself during battle (which the real Big Boss would know after MGS3).

That's vague enough, but the real kicker is how many times the people you interact with don't recognise you, despite the fact that you're one of the most famous war heroes in the world.

And all this isn't even to mention the fact that he's not even called 'Big Boss', but rather 'Venom Snake'...


1. Kratos' Wife Has Been Guiding Him The Whole Time - God Of War

God of War Kratos Tree
Sony

In one of the loveliest video game plot twists of the generation - one which serves to add emotional heft to the rest of the experience that came before it rather than deliver a shocking anime betrayal - one of the final tidbits before God of War's narrative closes out reveals that both the player and Kratos have been unknowingly guided by a familiar figure the whole time.

Though Kratos' wife, Faye, dies before the title even begins, she actually marked out the entire journey for him and son Atreus to go on before her demise. I don't mean that figuratively either, like she knew in advance that they were destined to go on this mythological quest, but rather that their path to success throughout the world was literally guided by her own hand.

As a lot of adventure games are want to do, God of War features a visual signifier to let you know which part of the landscape is traversable and where you can climb. This comes in the form of a gold paint that highlights parts of the environment you can interact with. Unlike other games though, here there's a reason for the gold signifier: it's been placed there by Faye to guide Atreus and Kratos.

As the title's director Corey Barlog put it: "She was there every step of the way. She walked that path before they ever did.”


Watch Next


Contributor

Josh has over 11 years of experience as a published writer, having worked nine of those years as a full-time content producer at WhatCulture. In that period he has created hundreds of articles, videos and podcast episodes for multiple WhatCulture channels, specialising in gaming, horror and film & TV. He now primarily works as a senior content producer and presenter on WhatCulture Gaming where he co-hosts the WhatCulture Gaming Podcast, a top 3 UK most listened to gaming podcast that he co-created in 2018. Over the years he has reviewed several high-profile gaming releases, covered industry events with on-site reporting, opined on breaking news, and even kicked off his interviewing career by chatting to childhood hero, Tommy Wiseau.