8 Video Game Remasters We DEMANDED (Then Instantly Regretted)
Be careful what you wish for.
There once was a time in the video game industry that they word "Remaster" held the type of clout that could knock a goat out just by punching the air near it.
When accompanied with the prefix of a video game title that all had but forgotten, the announcement of a video game remaster could and indeed did send the collective gaming consciousness into a pleasure coma, as the act of cherry-picking a niche game, tweaking, and ironing out its flaws for the modern age was basically like a win-win for gamers.
However, as we all know, there are more than a handful of times where a remaster is anything but, with developers squirting out tepid gruel with minimal effort in an effort to exploit nostalgia and to tickle your wallet dry, which is horrifically damaging to not only our bank balances but also to the legacy of the IP in question. It's lead to many heated arguments down the pub with my younger colleagues as they strain to understand why I adore franchises that have just been dug up and wheeled out with the only new feature being "now with added stink lines!", and it makes you wish that you'd never begged developers to give your favorite title another day in the sun.
They say "be careful what you wish for" and in the cases of these eight games, they would be bloody right to be so apprehensive as we regretted asking for these remasters IMMEDIATELY.
8. Final Fantasy Crystal Chronicles
While not being as well received as some of the other mainline entries into the Final Fantasy franchise, Crystal Chronicles found a lot of favor with Gamecube fans upon its release back in 2004, mainly due to it's wonderfully cute art style and interesting approach to battling.
Therefore it was to the applause of many when it was announced that Crystal Chronicles would be making its way to non-Nintendo consoles in 2018 alongside a slew of updates, new dungeons, and the ability to take this title online with cross-play elements, which quite obviously was the main selling point here.
However, that applause soon turned to moans of frustration when it was also revealed that this cross-play feature also allowed mobile phone users to jump in on the action, which was akin to swapping out a crying babies' milk for a bottle filled with food bin squeezings.
The reason why this was so utterly terrible is that it placed a huge limitation on the online aspect of the remaster, as now everything was boiled down to the bare essentials to make sure it worked on phones, meaning that parties auto-disbanded after every single dungeon, and online chat was basically non-existent. Add into this the constant connection issues and the removal of local multiplayer as a workaround and you have a remaster that actually offered less than the original game.
Good going.
7. Grand Theft Auto Trilogy
*Sighs while looking out of a rain-covered window*
"What have you done to my boy?"
Seriously, what can be said about this remaster disaster that hasn't already been yelled about before seeing as this was the talking point around the entire industry when the supposed "definitive" editions of the original GTA trilogy were released in 2021. To call this remaster collection "a bit of a miss" is like saying that trying to slay a T-rex with sarcasm is "a little bit of a challenge" and yet that's entirely what Rockstar did when faced with the mounting vocal backlash in that they simply ate it up and carried on their merry way, not realizing the mass extinction of goodwill they were about to experience.
Endless complaints about textures and bugs pushed this collection into the mainstream and soon the refund requests were pouring in as support for some of the most requested titles for remastering bled out. In every single way, this was the worst way to experience these classics, and yet it was somehow about to get even worse.
Fans soon realized that Rockstar had delisted older versions of these games from digital storefronts, meaning that this new "definitive" edition was now the only way to play the trilogy. Rockstar had somehow mastered alchemy but used this power to turn a diamond into pure s**te which when you consider the legacy of the games in question, took some bloody effort.
6. Super Mario 3d All-Stars
Nintendo sure are a weird company, aren't they?
Despite positing through every piece of marketing that they are a family-friendly company that values the customer above everything else, they sure do have a weird way of rewarding that affection seeing as they repeatedly gouge their die-hard fanbase over and over with sub-par and half-baked releases.
I'm speaking of course about the curious case of the Super Mario 3D All-Stars pack, which is, quite possibly a collection of Nintendo games that have received the most requests for a remaster, and on the surface, it's a wonderful package, containing Super Mario 64, Sunshine and Galaxy which all got a coat of new paint and some quality of life fixes.
Or so we were lead to believe, as, alongside a bizarre FOMO-centric ad campaign that told fans that this package would be discontinued after a few months and that you had to BUY NOW DON'T ASK QUESTIONS, this package actually contained an inferior port of Mario 64. This version of the game actually removed a lot of glitches and skips that many speedrunners relied upon and thus instantly was lower in value for this rather sizeable community.
Add in a whole load of "absolutely nothing extra" for the other two games and you have a package that appears all smiles and Mario Sunshine on the surface, but it's a black hole of corporate greed that not even Galaxy could hope to survive.
5. PaRappa The Rapper: Remastered
When you first lay your eyes on the Parappa The Rapper Remaster you might not immediately be able to tell what's so utterly heinous about the experience.
The graphics look polished and sharp, the music is, as was in the original on another level for how comedic and catchy it is, and of course, the premise of a rapping dog looking to win the love of a Sunflower is just so out there that it almost demands your attention.
However, things become abundantly pungent the moment you actually start playing this game, or should that be attempting to play as this Rhythm action game contains precisely the one thing that all titles of the genre should go to the end of the earth to avoid.
The game has lag. SERIOUS AMOUNTS OF LAG.
In a game about rapping on beat, this is a cardinal sin, as now in order to beat the levels you've got to either anticipate the next string of inputs or wait until you're out of sync with the music in order to hammer home the bars, and because Parappa is synched with your inputs, he'll then rap his lines out of time throwing you off even further! Plus to add salt to the gunshot to the face that is this remaster there's no option to recalibrate the game.
It turned the little pooches saying from "I Gotta Believe!" to "I can't believe you've done this"
4. Silent Hill HD Collection
So we begin this entry with a question: "When is a remaster not a remaster?"
And the answer, as confusing as it might first sound, is "When it's the Silent Hill HD Collection", as despite being marketed as being a remaster of Silent Hill 2 and 3 (My kingdom for Silent Hill 1!) was actually a near one hundred percent remake of these two games.
Now I hear you cry "Why would Konami hire developers Hijinks to fully recreate two of the most well-loved horror video games of all time?" well my friend, the answer to THAT question is that Konami, in their infinite wisdom had commissioned a remaster of two games that they had lost the source code for. That's right, they didn't have the original framework to give to the new devs and so they pretty much had to make both titles from the ground up!
Is it any wonder then that the games feel so slightly off? Like it's some sort of uncanny valley of video gaming, where your actions lag behind your inputs, where enemy AI seems to have to load information before kicking into gear, and of course where there's no !*$% fog in a game so well-known for it that it's almost like it's a part of the central cast.
Yes, that's right, the thick fog that blankets Silent Hill was nowhere to be found in the original release of the HD Collection, meaning you could see all the nasty draw distance issues, pop-in, and of course enemies that now look like they've had their action canceled in the Sims and are just waiting around like absolute lemons.
Good stuff.
3. Crysis Remaster
Back in the day even uttering the word "Crysis" next to your PC would likely cause it to overheat, as there was nothing quite as hardware melting as Crytek's gorgeous FPS title at the time.
Hell the majority of games nowadays are only just getting up to par with the lighting and shading effects of this 2007 release!
Thanks to its immersive gameplay and because high-end PC players were able to loudly stroke themselves to climax over being able to run this beast, Crysis soon became the talk of the town, much to the chagrin of console players who had to settle for a "still pretty impressive" but noticeable downgraded port for the Xbox 360 and PS3.
Yet in 2020 it seemed that console players would finally be able to experience the full heft of Cryis' mighty bulge as it was announced that Xbox One, PS4, and Switch owners would be getting a remaster of the original. Rubbing their hands together in glee, console players pre-ordered the game in droves, only to be met with utter disappointment when the remaster dropped, for you see this wasn't a remaster of the PC version of the game, but the aforementioned downgrade of a port they received on the previous console generation!
The graphics were indeed polished but were still found lacking by many, and an entire level was cut from the experience as was also true of the original port making this the least requested remaster of the most requested game. Thankfully more graphical options and the "ascension" level were added back in but for many, even with these fixes it was still lagging far behind the PC original.
2. Halo: The Master Chief Colleciton
Four years. FOUR. YEARS.
That is how long it took (roughly) for a certain video game remaster collection to have stable online connectivity after its initial launch, and we're not talking about some small fry game from a dev house of just one person and an intern that takes way too long in the bathroom each day, we're talking about how it took four years for Halo: The Master Chief Collection to do what it should have been offering from day one.
The sheer mind-blowing irony of the true "Halo Killer" being Halo itself is beyond compare, as here in an effort to celebrate the works of Spartans all around the universe, Microsoft ended up unleashing a collection that was beyond bugged to the point that unofficial Halo 1 servers hosted by committed fans ran better than their output. Now to their credit, Microsoft did offer out some form of compensation to those affected by the online issues but did so in the form of a free Xbox Live subscription and a Halo avatar, seemingly unaware that these items basically remind the customer of the game their NOT PLAYING AND THE REASON AS TO WHY THEY'RE NOT PLAYING.
Still though at least all those months later you can finally appreciate the collection as it was meant to be, a glorious package that features updated graphics, quality of life tweaks, and even a neat feature to swap between the old graphics engine and the new at a click of a button. Still though that online mode for a long time might as well have come with a toxic waste warning for how irradiated it was.
1. Ape Escape: On The Loose
There is honestly so much to love about the Ape Escape franchise.
From its ridiculous premise of grabbing gibbons across time and space, to its horrendous voice acting on the UK PS1 original, to the fact that the soundtrack to the games slap so hard it will leave you with cheeks redder than a baboon's, Ape Escape is just a pure slice of fun that is so very much needed in gaming in this day and age.
And of course who can forget that the original game was built from the ground up with the Dualshock Analog Controller in mind, and used this new tech to implement gadgets and gameplay features that felt absolutely revolutionary at the time?
Well, apparently the minds behind Ape Escape: On The Loose did, because they decided to remaster the original game for the PSP which lest we forget, is a console with only one Analog thumbstick. Talk about slipping on a banana peel.
While the game itself was received fairly well, the lack of the second thumbstick was painfully apparent as now gadgets and certain moves had to be accessed through the face buttons, killing movement entirely in some cases and making the game infinitely harder than it was originally designed to be. To call your game "on the loose" while certifiably restricting player freedom seems rather ironic all things considered.